Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £6,000 a year energy bills are completely unsustainable

307 replies

Butterflyfluff · 22/08/2022 08:27

Following on from this thread but quite unbelievably the projected figure has gone from £4,200 to £6,000 now.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4607670-to-think-that-very-few-people-can-manage-ps4200-energy-bills?page=40

Where will this all end?

OP posts:
Getoff · 22/08/2022 14:21

LuluBlakey1 · 22/08/2022 10:28

No it won't. Ever. It never does.

The current wholesale price of electricity is about 25p. The most recent wind farm contract auctions were fixing prices at between 4 and 5p. As far as I know there will continue to be new contracts awarded every year going through to 2030, so although we already have a lot of wind, there's a lot to come.

www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-record-low-price-for-uk-offshore-wind-is-four-times-cheaper-than-gas/

About a year ago, I read about a project to build solar in morocco and send the electricity to the UK. They wanted the government to give them a price of 5p to make it viable. I guess it must look viable now. (Just googled, looks like that project is going ahead, the price will be 4.8p.)

octopus.energy/press/octopus-energy-backs-mega-solar-farm-in-morocco-to-power-7-million-heat-pumps-with-cheap-green-power/

Walkden · 22/08/2022 14:04

"They would be in breach of international law because they would be taxing companies on profits generated elsewhere"

Yes but only in a limited and specific way and according to her previously published perfectly acceptable because of parliamentary privilege!

theworldhas · 22/08/2022 14:03

Compared with Liz Truss' brilliant idea to get GPs to write prescriptions for energy bills.

she’s a lunatic, but she’s going to provide some great lols.

Kanfuzed123 · 22/08/2022 13:58

FourTeaFallOut · 22/08/2022 10:32

There's no incentive to work if even putting in fulltime hours, you can't afford the basics for survival ie food and heating

I've seen people write this a few times. I'm not entirely sure what it means. If working full time only pays for the basic then working anything less ...won't pay for the basics. That's a pretty big incentive.

Meh I do sort of get it, you know you graft and you graft, break your back for maybe a small step up in work, and maybe a few extra K a year but now we are paying more tax than ever and the price of everything has skyrocketed, all that work was in essence for nothing as you’re worse off. I’d say it’s just morale crushing than anything.

Getoff · 22/08/2022 13:52

christmas2022 · 22/08/2022 09:54

How is it a cap if it's potentially going from £1200 to 6k - surely a cap is capped not continuously increased??!

The cap is not their to protect consumers against rising wholesale prices, it's only job is to prevent the energy companies making excessive profits. If the wholes price of electricity and gas goes up, then the cap must go up.

Kanfuzed123 · 22/08/2022 13:52

dreamingbohemian · 22/08/2022 08:36

I mean clearly it's just impossible

The question is whether the government will do something now, or wait until it's already here and there's massive chaos and then throw together some half-assed plan that mostly only benefits their base (as always)

Most likely door #2

onthefencesitter · 22/08/2022 13:51

Bearsan · 22/08/2022 13:36

I suspect behind closed doors the government are saying things like
"What are they all complaining about? Why don't they just winter in the Caribbean like normal people and stop moaning?"

It's all getting a bit
"Let them eat cake"
And we all know how that panned out <hopeful>

no they are secretly thinking it might save the NHS a bit of money if the sick and old froze to death. Or that if old people and poor people could not afford their houses,they could buy them at a bargain.

Bearsan · 22/08/2022 13:36

I suspect behind closed doors the government are saying things like
"What are they all complaining about? Why don't they just winter in the Caribbean like normal people and stop moaning?"

It's all getting a bit
"Let them eat cake"
And we all know how that panned out <hopeful>

PEDRO12 · 22/08/2022 13:30

Butterflyfluff · 22/08/2022 13:25

I’m not sure how some businesses, especially in hospitality and beauty, will survive.

They are going to be in a perfect storm of


  • Rising and uncapped energy costs

  • Rising cost of serving debt

  • Lower consumer demand

They won't survive, leisure, tourism, hospitality, retail. Depending on how severe things get even the banking sector might struggle once people start to struggle to pay mortgages on a widespread level come the 2nd half of 2023 and most people are being hit with either higher mortgage costs or higher energy, or maybe both.

PEDRO12 · 22/08/2022 13:28

sally037 · 22/08/2022 12:31

People hoping the government will step in don't understand Tory ideology, particularly this incarnation of the Tory party. There aren't many one nation types or those with left leaning instincts within it anymore. Most of those with any sense of morality were purged for opposing the no deal Brexit we have.

They are wedded to the idea that the market will decide and that energy firms need to be able to set their own price and ensure profits. I honestly think that if they had their way they would scrap Ofgem and remove the price cap altogether.

The problem is that we have to wait a couple of years until the general election.

Whilst I do agree with you about this Tory party I think this situation is different than even a normal recession, it reminds me more of a depressionary situation to be honest.

The Tories won't want to intervene majorly but I think they are aware that large chunks of the economy is going to be gone (much like covid).

I think they will take a similar line to the covid crisis, that they will want to save as much of the economy as possible, especially as a great number of strong business will fail once the demand is gone due to peoples spending power contracting severely.

Basically them doing nothing of note will condemn Tories to a 15-20 year wait in the wilderness like the 07-08 crisis did for Labour.

Butterflyfluff · 22/08/2022 13:26

^ servicing debt

OP posts:
daisychain01 · 22/08/2022 13:25

Catfordthefifth · 22/08/2022 10:33

In a lot of cases, you could work part time and get top up benefits.... Why wouldn't you? Youd be no worse off.

There are millions of highly skilled workers in UK who won't consider giving up their well-paid full time job, to go on benefits "because why bother being full time". That's a ridiculous generalisation based on zero facts.

Butterflyfluff · 22/08/2022 13:25

BarbaraofSeville · 22/08/2022 09:25

The unsustainable part will be most felt when more and more people are spending very little money on non essentials such as restaurants, cinemas (one chain already in the process of going bust), travel, days out etc etc and the knock on effect on people involved in these sectors, which are already struggling due to being hit hardest by covid and many restaurant chains being propped up by a decade of cheap debt that's now being taken away due to rising interest rates.

I’m not sure how some businesses, especially in hospitality and beauty, will survive.

They are going to be in a perfect storm of


  • Rising and uncapped energy costs

  • Rising cost of serving debt

  • Lower consumer demand

OP posts:
Heidi1976 · 22/08/2022 13:18

Shouldbeworkingnotreadingtalk · 22/08/2022 10:46

I think the trouble is that if you have a smart meter they won't need to take you to court ... they will just "flick a switch" and you won't have ANY electricity... you will be on a pre payment meter. the only way your'll get it back on is to apply some money to your account. The first £10 or so will go towards your arrears ... so for the electricity companies they win either way ...

Ahh yes I saw an article about that just after I posted. It says though in order to do that you would need a whole new gen of smart meter, which I definitely wouldn't be daft enough to apply for! It's just sickening that this is going on at all.

SpinCityBlues · 22/08/2022 13:03

BarbaraofSeville · 22/08/2022 09:57

The cap is set based on the wholesale price, plus costs and a limited amount of profit. It's the wholesale price that has increased, hence the increase in the price cap.

Sorry if this has already been asked and answered, but how is the standing charge set?

SpinCityBlues · 22/08/2022 12:55

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 22/08/2022 09:33

I don't suppose she intends it to get anywhere near being implemented, like most of the shit the pair of them have been coming out with during this leadership campaign, but even in that context it still sounds fucking deranged.

I applaud you for your restraint.

balkanscot · 22/08/2022 12:50

What I don’t get is the proposed discount on energy bills if you used energy off peak in terms living in flats/tenements. I simply cannot program my washing machine to run at 23:00 or later, it’s just not on in terms of good neighbourly relations (I live in a Georgian tenement flat in Scotland). ☹️

Cheeselog · 22/08/2022 12:43

The government need to provide more support for sure. It’s unacceptable that any person will be unable to afford to use heating or cook. And there should be a special energy allowance/benefit for people who need to use more for medical/disability reasons like there is for the elderly.

But if MN is anything to go by, so many people are using far too much energy. We cannot expect to go around in T-shirts in winter, use a tumble dryer multiple times a day, leave computers and consoles running 24/7 etc and not pay handsomely for that privilege.

sally037 · 22/08/2022 12:31

People hoping the government will step in don't understand Tory ideology, particularly this incarnation of the Tory party. There aren't many one nation types or those with left leaning instincts within it anymore. Most of those with any sense of morality were purged for opposing the no deal Brexit we have.

They are wedded to the idea that the market will decide and that energy firms need to be able to set their own price and ensure profits. I honestly think that if they had their way they would scrap Ofgem and remove the price cap altogether.

The problem is that we have to wait a couple of years until the general election.

Allywill · 22/08/2022 12:26

The government themselves can’t afford the bills at that level. By that I mean they won’t be able to pay the bills of public buildings and offices. Businesses that rely heavily on fuel like large scale food manufacturing and pretty much anything that employs large conveyor systems to move products around will be looking at a quadrupling or more of their bills. Small scale businesses will go bankrupt. It is this that will drive government to act, not joe bloggs struggling to pay their domestic bill.

ThatsGoingToHurt · 22/08/2022 12:23

I agree that Something Must Be Done. Not because the Tories care about poor people but because there will be an election in 2024. Once the middle classes and older people (who both tend to vote Tory more) start complaining they will take notice as it will lose them votes.

GreenClock · 22/08/2022 12:12

I really do think that Something Will Be Done.

Not because this current Westminster shower gives a fig, but because it’s an issue that’s affecting the middle classes and they have become vocal.

If “just” poor people were struggling, this topic would barely be making headlines beyond the left wing press and Martin Lewis. But the chattering classes are impacted and they’re … well … chattering about it!

There will be an election in 2024 and middle class votes will be needed by the Conservatives. This cohort must not be allowed to feel poor.

carefullycourageous · 22/08/2022 12:11

Keepingupappearance · 22/08/2022 11:34

I think this government has truly totally and utterly ceased to function. There is effectively no prime minister at the moment.

the regulator has clearly failed.

even once there is a leader - they will have to be seen to do something - but even if they wanted to do something good these issues can’t be resolved over night and certainly not by winter

it is an abject failure of the political and regulatory process

It is not a 'failure' it is a Tory party choice that we are in this situation. The Tories have chosen to both allow and exacerbate the multiple crises (energy, inflation, health) crises we now face.

Eeksteek · 22/08/2022 12:04

AlexandriasWindmill · 22/08/2022 10:29

As I posted on another thread, it's shortsighted from an economic pov. The Tories' friends in big business rely upon their workforces. There's no incentive to work if even putting in fulltime hours, you can't afford the basics for survival ie food and heating.
They'll keep squeezing as long as people continue to work to produce their profits. But as PP said, sectors dependent on disposable income will disappear. The entire economy will stagnate. Because it's not only households that will struggle with bills, so will small businesses.
As for Truss, the fact they're even considering her shows they don't understand why Boris had to leave. They also don't care about keeping the UK together because there's no reason at all for the devolved nations to want to stay with such a morally and economically bankrupt batch of politicians.

I think they want workers back in the office. Well, I know they do. Look at JRM and his snide post it’s. But I think people who work from home might be a bit too happy and comfortable. Stressed people will throw money at their leisure time, because ‘they deserve to enjoy their time off and it’s worth it’. Happy people, being more productive at work but also able to be around more for their families and keep on top of their household chores through the week might contentedly stop spending billions of pounds to add value to their downtime or time saving gadgets and gimmicks and stop lining Tory pockets. People who work at home eat and drink at home, not in coffee shops, supermarkets and cafes. They cook at home, not grab takeaway and prepped food on the way back. They don’t spend as much on childcare, transport, office wardrobes and grooming when there at home more and judged more what they produce than how they present. They aren’t having after work drinks. They spend money on their homes, but they stay in them a lot more. They even have time to go to local independent shops and businesses, instead of frantically ordering from Amazon or getting everything at once from Tesco’s.

I realise this is a rose tinted view of working from home, but for a lot of middle income people, I think it’s a fair summary. There’s a reason workers love working from home and JRM hates it.

Best find another way to squeeze them, then.

I also wonder if this isn’t Russia flexing its economic muscles. Obviously, Putin doesn’t feel he can chance war with the entire world (or I hope not!) and he’s got some weird thing about Ukraine anyway, but maybe it’s just an excuse to remind the world that Russia controls a lot of energy, which is a lot of power and I wonder if Putin felt people might be forgetting that in their dealings with him. Not Boris, of course, because he doesn’t care about anything but having his name over the door and his personal comfort, but the rest of the West.

BorgQueen · 22/08/2022 11:59

If electricity does, as predicted, go up to 92p per kwh come April, the economy is fucked, let alone gas prices. Average electric bills of £4k? Businesses won’t survive either.
I’m seething at my fix of 57p kwh / £2000 a year but at least we can afford it.

As an aside, DH is contracting in a pie factory, they leave the numerous gas ovens running 24/7, even when not producing, instead of having them on timers to fire up 2hrs before use, he reckons they are wasting over a million £££s a year of gas and that is ONE factory. He asked them if they wanted him to do an energy audit to save them money, the answer was no. They are making so much money they don’t care, however the waste of energy is unforgivable. They also installed a false ceiling with energy saving led lights throughout, only trouble is, the old lights under that ceiling are still running because nobody knows where the main breakers are! He could save them a fortune (and earn a nice consultancy fee) but they aren’t interested.