Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving away. AIBU that family should come and see us?

236 replies

ChoccyWoccyHoHa · 21/08/2022 16:46

Myself, dh and my elderly dad are moving away very soon. Myself and dh are nearly 60 and retired. My dad is in his 80s and will be living in assisted living accommodation not far from our new house. Our dream is to pursue our own hobbies and interests in a location we love.

We will be moving away from our son, his wife and their children. Our grandchildren are 3 and 10 months. Although we're excited to start the next chapter of our lives in a quieter, more rural place, I'm worried we're going to miss out on family. Everytime we talk about ds and family coming up to stay with us they're very non commital. I've offered for gc to stay without ds and dil but they're not keen. It will be a 3/4 hour journey for them, taking into account their youngest doesn't travel well and will need to stop on route.

We've been living about 20/25 mins away from them and see each other fairly regularly. We have been looking after their eldest one afternoon a week while they work but obviously that will be changing. We plan to come and stay near them so we can see them so it isn't all on them. But I know they struggle. Ds has got various health issues, dil had pnd badly and their ds is being assessed for special needs. They moved house themselves quite recently. Both ds and dil also work. So maybe the timing isn't great for them, I know their day to day life can be hard but we need to think about our own lives and happiness.

But AIBU to think that they should make an effort to see us when we move? Are we doing the right thing with this move when effectively we could be cutting ourselves off from them unintentionally?

OP posts:
viques · 21/08/2022 20:02

JenniferBarkley · 21/08/2022 19:52

In a perfect world it would turn out that the OP is moving close to the other DiL and that her MIL is moving close to the OPs son.

(dances away through the meadow with bluebirds flying overhead )

Christmasiscominghohoho · 21/08/2022 20:02

Did your offer of having the GC extend to picking them up and dropping them back too?

otherwise it’s a useless offer.

NoAprilFool · 21/08/2022 19:57

My in laws live a similar distance away (my family are further) and constantly guilt trip is about not visiting more often. My daughter gets dreadfully car sick and the journey is mostly on windy roads. It’s bloody miserable for us all.
We’re quite happy FaceTiming most of the time with 1 visit a year.

i don’t think you’re selfish to move, but it sounds tricky for them to visit so please don’t lay a guilt trip on them.

Chuckiegg · 21/08/2022 19:55

My in-laws used to go to their caravan every weekend and couldn't understand why we didn't go all the time to relax and enjoy the countryside as it was only an hour away.
The reality was that their grandchildren had homework/parties/rugby/activities every weekend and also needed some downtime at home after busy weeks.

nexus63 · 21/08/2022 19:55

YABU you might have to accept that you will only see your gc if you travel to them, i understand why you are moving and your reasons you want a life and your hobbies away from the rat run as you put it, but moving has to come at a cost, if i was your son i would be annoyed at you for even expecting them to visit, they have work, health issues and 2 children and one of them possibly has problems. what happens if you or your husband die, are you going to be happy staying so far away on your own. i visit my dad once a year, i am not good at travelling and it is a 5 hour journey and two trains to get there. i hope you are happy in your new home and don't regret it later on down the line.

WarmSausageTea · 21/08/2022 19:54

YABVU.

DP and I moved from 150 miles from where most of our family and friends were/are, and we fully accepted that we the onus was on us to make more than 50% of the effort to meet up.

As it turned out, family and friends come and see us at least as often as we go to London, but that was absolutely not our expectation.

Whatever your reasons, you chose to move, so you should be prepared to make more of the effort required to keep up contact. If people choose not to make the effort to visit you, that’s their prerogative.

JenniferBarkley · 21/08/2022 19:52

It's either a reverse or both MIL and DIL are on MN.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4484541-Inlaws-abandoning-us-to-move-away

Winter2020 · 21/08/2022 19:51

Just to be clear Holiday Lodge/caravan on a site Not Second Home - as in second residential house destroying communities.

Winter2020 · 21/08/2022 19:49

The reason people think it is a reverse is because they can't believe you would expect this family to travel to see you regularly under the circumstances so they think it must actually be written by the daughter in law.

Too far and too much travelling and upheaval for a weekend so maybe they will come to stay with you for a summer holiday sometimes or stay near by and meet up with you.

You can absolutely live wherever you choose but your physical distance will mean a regular meet up with this family is not possible.

Are you not worried about what life will be like for the remaining partner if you or your partner passed away? Will you have enough support in the new area as a widow or would you want to move back? If you would want to move back would you be moving your now very elderly father or leaving him there?

If it was affordable would you consider a holiday lodge in the new area - you and your partner could pursue your hobbies and enjoy the outdoors but have home to come back to and come back for Christmas and maybe over winter. I appreciate with rising bills this would be a luxury few could afford.

ILoveYoga · 21/08/2022 19:49

Unfortunately, you’ll need to realise that this is a long trip with children and while both parents are working. Not to mention what type of accommodation you have for them (added cost and hassle if they have to stay in a hotel). Then the children will have activities and parties at weekends as they get older. You may realistically need to think about visiting them more than they visit you as really it is easier for you to travel to them.

did you think about this when choosing to move that far away? We’re looking at our next chapter too but are looking no more than an hour away from where we are now (30 minutes train from London) with main line train not more than 20 minutes drive from new home specifically so our adult children (and eventual grandchildren) will not have much difficulty coming to visit and we can get to them to visit or meet up easily.

weaselish · 21/08/2022 19:47

Wow it's not a reverse? YANBU to move but YABU to expect it not to damage your relationship with your son, dil and grandchildren. There is no way I'd be travelling 3/4 hours each way to go visit, leaving on a Friday night, back Sunday night with young kids, working etc. No chance. Maybe at Christmas!
You're retired - you do the travelling if you want to see them! Weekends are so so short and kids have clubs, parties etc. Go ahead but don't expect many visits.

3luckystars · 21/08/2022 19:39

You are retired. Have you forgotten what it’s like to be working and having a young family?
the timetable is full!!! Every day, just keeping the show on the road.

you are retired, and the ones moving away. I think you have just not taken in how much they have in their plates.

there must be somewhere nearer that is still ‘rural’ if you want to move away from the city, but still keep in touch with your grandchild.

Montii · 21/08/2022 19:39

You aren’t selfish to want to move.

You are selfish to expect your DS and DIL to visit you more than once a year.

If my in law’s moved a 3-4 hour drive away there is no way I’d be visiting more than once or twice a year. That sort of a trip with small children is a massive pain in the butt and I wouldn’t want to waste my annual leave making the trip more than once or twice a year.

SparklyLeprechaun · 21/08/2022 19:39

You are perfectly entitled to move away for your own wellbeing, and you don't owe your children childcare. But your move comes with the drawback that you'll see your son and grandchildren once a year, at Christmas (maybe twice a year at a push), unless you're prepared to travel more. Realistically, that's how often working parents with young children can travel that sort of distance.

Outlyingtrout · 21/08/2022 19:37

You are moving 4 hours away from your son and his family, when you know they face significant difficulties and challenges that you could offer support for, in order to prioritise your hobbies. You are perfectly entitled to do whatever you want but it's astounding that you would expect your son to go to such lengths to visit you when you've made it very clear to him that he is not a priority for you, and neither are your grandchildren. Maybe he is taking stock and is reassessing the relationship. We have a sort-of-similar situation with one of my DH's parents which has caused a lot of pain over the years. DH's way of coping with what he experienced as (another) rejection has been to mentally detach from the relationship so that he doesn't feel overinvested and vulnerable to being further hurt.

I can't imagine in a million years moving so far away from my children or grandchildren. It's such an alien concept to me. Especially knowing that they are struggling and I could be helping them. Would be interesting to know how much help you had when your family was young. Anecdotally I know lots of friends with young kids whose own parents are unwilling to help out or be particularly involved, despite having had tons of help and lots of involvement from grandparents when my friends were children.

JimmyShoo · 21/08/2022 19:35

The reality is it’s highly unlikely you will see much of your son and his family.

C152 · 21/08/2022 19:35

Sorry, I obviously read that wrong. I thought you meant you moved three quarters of an hour away. If you actually meant it's a 3-4 hour trip then I would maybe expect to see them once or twice a year. Not out of malice on anyone's part; just that's a very long trip with young kids and they have lives without you. As they both work, weekends may be their only real 'down' time or proper family time and as much as they may enjoy your company or wherever you move to, the travel itself is a chore.

C152 · 21/08/2022 19:32

YABU to expect them to "make more of an effort" to see you when you have decided to move away, knowing they have young children, which does make travelling more awkward; more so once they start school. However, there's nothing wrong with wanting retirement your way and moving to a place where you will be happy. I also don't feel travel of less than an hour is that far, although it becomes more difficult if they have to get to you by public transport. I would think it reasonable for them to see you once every couple of months.

If you will be happy long-term with the move, then you're doing the right thing. You have to expect that your relationship with your child and grandchildren may change, although that isn't necessarily a bad thing; just something different to get used to.

JazzHandsYeah · 21/08/2022 19:30

You’re perfectly entitled to move wherever you want. But you are unreasonable to expect your son and family to make 7-8 hr round trips with small children in tow on top of working full time.

catandcoffee · 21/08/2022 19:30

you only get one life to live...go for it.

But you should not expect your son and family to travel to you.

SammySueTwo · 21/08/2022 19:29

A close friend’s parents moved a 4 hour drive away into a one bed flat up north from 5 bed detached house. Not purely for financial reasons.
Friend has not seen them in 4 years and I don’t think they have met their grand daughter. They won’t leave the new home to meet half way or anything.
both friend and her siblings think their parents don’t have any interest in seeing them at all and the relationship has completely broken down.

ButyouwereuptoyouroldtricksinChaptersFourFiveandSix · 21/08/2022 19:28

YABU. Not for prioritising yourselves, but by simultaneously expecting your son and dil to not prioritise themselves. Working and having a family is already intense and leaves little free time as it is. To be upset that they won’t commit to forfeiting the little time they find to take a stressful trip isn’t fair. Maybe they will when they can manage it, maybe they won’t be able to, but I think that’s okay. As the ones who are retired now and the ones who have moved away it’s fair for you to be the ones to visit unless they say they’re happy to take a trip.

Endofanera22 · 21/08/2022 19:27

Is this for real? Of course YABVU

Hercisback · 21/08/2022 19:26

Nice rural peaceful places aren't located 3-4 hours from everywhere or even each other. There are many many places like this up and down the UK. You have chosen to move away, it's no one else's responsibility to come and see you.
It's not a trip I would make very often. It appears an almost deliberate snub towards the family you do live near to move away just as they have children.

ladymaiasaura · 21/08/2022 19:25

When I was young both sets of grandparents lived a similar distance away from me (because my parents had moved away, not because they did). I saw them maybe once or twice a year. I never thought much of it. It’s just how things were. Now we live 30 and 60 mins from my parents and in laws respectively. We see them often (although it’s getting trickier as kids get older and have school, weekend activities etc). The bond my kids have with them is lovely. They are so close to both sets of grandparents and it makes me a little sad that I never had that. I would be so upset if either set of grandparents decided to move away and my kids lost that.

You won’t maintain a close relationship with your grandkids if you are an 8 hour round trip away. So only move if that’s something you are willing to sacrifice.