Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Remind Everyone That Self ID Was A Tory Policy?

233 replies

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2022 19:31

I've seen so many posts over the past few years with people urging us to vote Tory because at least the Conservatives know what a woman is.🙄

This is nonsense for the following reasons:

  1. The Tories introduced Self ID under Theresa May's GRA Reform and Penny Mordaunt championed it.
  2. Tory MPs have reported women to the police for retweeting AHF posts and tweets by JKR.
  3. Trans contagion amongst teens happened under the Tory government.
  4. Trans women in women's spaces such as hospitals and prisons and Girl Guides happened under the Tory government.
  5. Rape in hospital that isn't considered "rape" because there was no man present? Tory government.
  6. It's a Trojan Horse. Bridgend Tories won the seat with a small majority. Their Tory MP, once safely in his seat announced that he was trans and intended to become a woman. I am gutted for any GC/feminist voters who held their nose and voted Conservative only to end up with Jamie Wallace.
  7. In the latest leadership race, Penny TWAW Mordaunt nearly became our new prime minister. Few (if any)Tories gave a fuck about her well documented TWAW stance.
  8. 1 week after Starmer refused to answer "what is a woman?", PM Boris Johnson did the same. This was not publicised to anywhere near the same extent.

So some Tories know what a woman is.
Some Tories don't.
Most don't give a shit about women or their rights either way, they're just happy to use us in their culture wars.🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
ImWell · 11/08/2022 16:50

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 16:47

I'd rather watch paint dry tbh, but cheers for the condescension.

So you don’t understand the subject, refuse to read posts by someone who does, and yet are trying to tell others that they are wrong.

Have you considered joining Labour, you’d feel right at home.

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 16:47

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:45

I'm not fully versed on all the legal details of transgender discrimination law

Obviously. FOJN is much more informed, so maybe read her excellent posts and if you can't answer her questions, think about them.

I'd rather watch paint dry tbh, but cheers for the condescension.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:45

I'm not fully versed on all the legal details of transgender discrimination law

Obviously. FOJN is much more informed, so maybe read her excellent posts and if you can't answer her questions, think about them.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 16:43

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 16:42

Who is 'you lot' in this sentence? My priority as a voter is about meaningful policies that affect people's day to day lives. Extreme hypotheticals or very specific edge cases like the one linked to are far less important to me then the bread and butter issues of people heating their homes, feeding their families, finding employment etc. I

'm not fully versed on all the legal details of transgender discrimination law, but I find it baffling that some women on here think the Tory party stance on trans rights means they are a better option for women as a whole - that's absolutely bonkers and they need to get a grip.

These are not extreme hypotheticals or edge cases, they are real cases that have happened. “You lot” means people like you who think that women should not be allowed single-sex provisions, and who post disingenuously about what the laws on the matter say.

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 16:42

ImWell · 11/08/2022 16:38

Of course it involves discrimination. Sensible, lawful, caring, absolutely correct discrimination. There was already a trans-friendly service there, why do you think it reasonable that women weren’t allowed a female-only one?

It’s not enough for you lot that you get equal provision, is it, the whole aim is actually to humiliate women, and take away what is theirs.

Who is 'you lot' in this sentence? My priority as a voter is about meaningful policies that affect people's day to day lives. Extreme hypotheticals or very specific edge cases like the one linked to are far less important to me then the bread and butter issues of people heating their homes, feeding their families, finding employment etc. I

'm not fully versed on all the legal details of transgender discrimination law, but I find it baffling that some women on here think the Tory party stance on trans rights means they are a better option for women as a whole - that's absolutely bonkers and they need to get a grip.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:40

thedancingbear · 11/08/2022 16:38

Well, personally, I would rather there were zero rape crises centres and other essential services for women, provided each of them was clear that, were it to exist, they would not assist trans people.

am I doing this right?

No, mate.

thedancingbear · 11/08/2022 16:38

Well, personally, I would rather there were zero rape crises centres and other essential services for women, provided each of them was clear that, were it to exist, they would not assist trans people.

am I doing this right?

ImWell · 11/08/2022 16:38

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 16:10

Because it could constitute discrimination against a trans woman to blanketly exclude all of them from a service? Each case is different and needs nuance. And also - how would such a thing be policed?

If a post-op trans woman who has her documents updated to female is outed while part of a therapy group, should she be ejected? Realistically trans people make up a tiny proportion of the population, while services for victims of sexual violence are being decimated due to lack of funding. The funding and accessibility of these services is far more of a priority for me as a voter than the thorny legalese around the inclusion of a tiny minority of the population.

Of course it involves discrimination. Sensible, lawful, caring, absolutely correct discrimination. There was already a trans-friendly service there, why do you think it reasonable that women weren’t allowed a female-only one?

It’s not enough for you lot that you get equal provision, is it, the whole aim is actually to humiliate women, and take away what is theirs.

FOJN · 11/08/2022 16:33

Because it could constitute discrimination against a trans woman to blanketly exclude all of them from a service? Each case is different and needs nuance. And also - how would such a thing be policed?

You are wrong.

It is lawful to exclude a transwoman, with or without a GRC, if the action is a proportionate means to achieving a legitimate aim. In Sarah's situation the service became less effective by allowing TW to attend the women's support group and given that alternative provision was made for TW the RCC would have had no problem lawfully excluding TW from the women's group. The service (women's support group) became less effective because the people is was set up to serve (women) self excluded.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:30

In the last 12 years of Tory government many services supporting survivors of sexual violence have been closed due to lack of funding. What's more important to you - voting a party that opposes self id, but refuses to fund the services, or voting for a party that supports self id but will fund the service?

If it's a party that won't allow women to set up single sex rape crisis centres even in addition to mixed sex ones, I'm not in favour. If you don't believe women deserve sex-based rights - if you don't think female people exist as a cohesive socio-political class with needs unique to them - then I don't want to live under your party.

FOJN · 11/08/2022 16:27

Now maybe you could answer a question from me. In the last 12 years of Tory government many services supporting survivors of sexual violence have been closed due to lack of funding. What's more important to you - voting a party that opposes self id, but refuses to fund the services, or voting for a party that supports self id but will fund the service? Because for me it's a no-brainer.

I might agree with you if the parties which supported self ID were absolutely explicit that they would protect single sex services and spaces, and in certain situations make them mandatory as long as there was also provision for trans people. As it is many of those parties would also like to amend the EA2010 to change the PC of sex to gender which means that there would be no single sex services. Under those circumstances I'd prioritise first principles; you need to be able to clearly define who or what is being afforded protection by the EA; women have no meaningful rights if the category woman also includes men.

I think I've been more than civil to you despite the fact that I find your attitude to female rape survivors absolutely dispicable and you didn't answer my question, you just fudged it.You still haven't read the details of the case, the RCC does not dispute that a support group for TW was available.

thedancingbear · 11/08/2022 16:24

ImWell · 10/08/2022 22:47

I know literally no-one who worries about paying for fuel, but a great many women who fear their fundamental rights are under threat.

This is delusional

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:18

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 16:10

Because it could constitute discrimination against a trans woman to blanketly exclude all of them from a service? Each case is different and needs nuance. And also - how would such a thing be policed?

If a post-op trans woman who has her documents updated to female is outed while part of a therapy group, should she be ejected? Realistically trans people make up a tiny proportion of the population, while services for victims of sexual violence are being decimated due to lack of funding. The funding and accessibility of these services is far more of a priority for me as a voter than the thorny legalese around the inclusion of a tiny minority of the population.

How is it discrimination if services are also available for TW?

Why don't you accept additional options as a solutions? Why must you take options away?

Denying female only spaces discriminates against women who cannot tolerate a mixed sex crisis space. They may have cultural beliefs (observant Muslim or Jewish women, for example) or trauma or a disability that prevent it. Many of them will go without the service rather than be denied a female counsellor or space.

Why is that OK?

This isn't about support at all. It's about using all female spaces, even ones designed for those traumatised by male violence, as validation for the idea that a female gender - which nobody can define - is the same as bodily female sex. No matter what the cost to female people.

DobbyHasASock · 11/08/2022 16:17

The rape crisis centre in question already had a group for men, trans and women.
A man joined the women's so she had to self exclude.
She politely asked to set up a female only group.
Was told no.
Leaving her without services.
Discrimination doesn't apply because tw are men and men would be equally excluded from a women's space.
Post op also not relevant here as the tw in question presented as male.complete with facial hair.
But post op doesn't give you the right to traumatise rape.victims.

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 16:16

FOJN · 11/08/2022 16:09

The link I was provided indicated a woman wanted to sue a survivors group for allowing a trans woman to attend, and that is what I responding to - they've made clear they include trans women, so it's up to any women whether or not they wish to join or not.

You didn't read the details did you?

There was a separate support group for TW but they chose to attend the women's groups whilst looking indistinguishable from a man.

Would you think it was OK for men to attend the women's group? If not why not? Can you think of any reason why women might find a single sex group more therapeutic?

If a TW and a man are indistinguishable from each other are women bigots for being unable to see magical gender essence?

The centre may as well have not been closed from Sarah's perspective, she self excluded because she didn't find a woman's group with an obvious male in it a healing place.

Your refusal to answer the questions I've asked makes it clear you know the situation is indefensible.

I would be very interested to hear the trans woman's account of how things went down - there's certain elements of that account that I'm rather sceptical of. There are scenarios where alternative groups should be suggested and a trans woman might well be excluded, and I don't have a problem with that, and it's perfectly legal.

Now maybe you could answer a question from me. In the last 12 years of Tory government many services supporting survivors of sexual violence have been closed due to lack of funding. What's more important to you - voting a party that opposes self id, but refuses to fund the services, or voting for a party that supports self id but will fund the service? Because for me it's a no-brainer.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:13

To put it yet another way: why are third spaces, ADDITIONAL spaces, to offer MORE options, not acceptable? Why must it always be that the female spaces are compromised? Why must this option for women be REMOVED?

If it really is only about a safe place to wee or to get trauma services? Why isn't an additional, gender-neutral space enough? Why must it be women's spaces or nothing?

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 16:10

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:06

I mean, why is "we should allow TW-inclusive services" a fine statement to make, while "we should allow female-only services" is an unhelpful blanket statement that doesn't incorporate the right nuance?

Because it could constitute discrimination against a trans woman to blanketly exclude all of them from a service? Each case is different and needs nuance. And also - how would such a thing be policed?

If a post-op trans woman who has her documents updated to female is outed while part of a therapy group, should she be ejected? Realistically trans people make up a tiny proportion of the population, while services for victims of sexual violence are being decimated due to lack of funding. The funding and accessibility of these services is far more of a priority for me as a voter than the thorny legalese around the inclusion of a tiny minority of the population.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:09

PronounssheRa · 11/08/2022 16:08

That's a rhetorical question, right? 😉

Haha!

No. It's a very serious one and I'd like an answer.

FOJN · 11/08/2022 16:09

The link I was provided indicated a woman wanted to sue a survivors group for allowing a trans woman to attend, and that is what I responding to - they've made clear they include trans women, so it's up to any women whether or not they wish to join or not.

You didn't read the details did you?

There was a separate support group for TW but they chose to attend the women's groups whilst looking indistinguishable from a man.

Would you think it was OK for men to attend the women's group? If not why not? Can you think of any reason why women might find a single sex group more therapeutic?

If a TW and a man are indistinguishable from each other are women bigots for being unable to see magical gender essence?

The centre may as well have not been closed from Sarah's perspective, she self excluded because she didn't find a woman's group with an obvious male in it a healing place.

Your refusal to answer the questions I've asked makes it clear you know the situation is indefensible.

PronounssheRa · 11/08/2022 16:08

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:06

I mean, why is "we should allow TW-inclusive services" a fine statement to make, while "we should allow female-only services" is an unhelpful blanket statement that doesn't incorporate the right nuance?

That's a rhetorical question, right? 😉

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:06

I mean, why is "we should allow TW-inclusive services" a fine statement to make, while "we should allow female-only services" is an unhelpful blanket statement that doesn't incorporate the right nuance?

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:01

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 15:55

I think it's a nuanced area which blanket statements aren't helpful on. There will be some situations where a trans woman should be included and others were an alternative service is best. The link I was provided indicated a woman wanted to sue a survivors group for allowing a trans woman to attend, and that is what I responding to - they've made clear they include trans women, so it's up to any women whether or not they wish to join or not.

Why can't you answer the question?

Should women be allowed to set up single sex rape crisis centres for those who can't tolerate mixed sex ones? Should they be forced to accept male people on pain of losing the funding?

Or as FOJN said: Do you think it's OK for a TW who presents as entirely male to attend a woman's sexual assault survivors group when provision has already been made, within the same service, for TW?

Do you think the TW is seeking support or validation?

Is that a reasonable thing to do to women?

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 15:55

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 15:52

But that's not what you're being asked. You're being asked whether women should be allowed to run single sex rape crisis centres without having their funding pulled for it.

Should they?

I think it's a nuanced area which blanket statements aren't helpful on. There will be some situations where a trans woman should be included and others were an alternative service is best. The link I was provided indicated a woman wanted to sue a survivors group for allowing a trans woman to attend, and that is what I responding to - they've made clear they include trans women, so it's up to any women whether or not they wish to join or not.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 15:52

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 15:40

I think if service providers wish to include trans rape survivors in therapy groups that's their prerogative, and far better that the service exists than gets axed, as many many of these services have under the Tories (which is what some suggesting is preferable to 'block self id')

But that's not what you're being asked. You're being asked whether women should be allowed to run single sex rape crisis centres without having their funding pulled for it.

Should they?

FOJN · 11/08/2022 15:52

I think if service providers wish to include trans rape survivors in therapy groups that's their prerogative, and far better that the service exists than gets axed, as many many of these services have under the Tories (which is what some suggesting is preferable to 'block self id')

You didn't answer my question so I'll ask it again.

Do you think it's OK for a TW who presents as entirely male to attend a woman's sexual assault survivors group when provision has already been made, within the same service, for TW?

Do you think the TW is seeking support or validation?

Is that a reasonable thing to do to women?

Why won't you answer these types of questions?