Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About strange myths that permeate MN about other countries and cultures

181 replies

Wetsummers · 23/07/2022 07:43

Does anyone else know what I mean - in particular about ‘Africa.’ I’m not claiming to be an expert on African culture or social norms but I’m pretty sure the ‘African tribes’ often referred to on here are a myth.

See also the insistence that we start children at school too early. Pretty sure most 4/5 year olds are in some form of education / kindergarten or whatever.

And you can’t open a thread on sleep without someone confidently stating the Japanese all co sleep.

OP posts:
Anothernamechangeplease · 23/07/2022 10:05

I have never seen any comments about African tribes so hard to comment.

You may be right about most 4/5 year olds being in some form of education.

It is a fact that co-sleeping is the norm in Japan, so I'm not really sure what point you're trying to make there - it isn't a myth.

Hardbackwriter · 23/07/2022 10:03

According to MN, All children in 'Europe' are very well behaved and eat anything they're given. The UK is the only place with noisy or rude children. We're also the only place in Europe where convenience food is eaten; in other places it is presumably only in their supermarkets for decoration. People know all this is true because they saw it that time they went to France on holiday.

The 'African tribe' thing is usually on threads where people are trying to shame women who use childcare (or sometimes where they're trying to shame parents who sleep train). They go on about how in 'African tribes' no one would dream of being separated from their babies, they breastfeed until 7, etc etc etc. Sometimes to amuse myself I ask which tribe they mean - perhaps they mean the Beng of Cote D'Ivoire, where babies are left with different teenage babysitters while their mothers work and where one of the most highly prized traits in a baby, considered a sign of good mothering, is a baby who is happy to be cared for by anyone?

LuxembourglivinginDenmark · 23/07/2022 10:02

Schulte · 23/07/2022 09:44

Nope. German and Austrian kindergarten, the Hungarian equivalent etc - they have absolutely nothing in common with English reception classes. They are basically childcare settings. They’re also not compulsory, you can keep your child at home until they start school at age 6 if you want.

The same in Denmark. You start school the year you turn 6. Anything before is considered childcare settings and not compulsory.

marcopront · 23/07/2022 10:00

marcopront · 23/07/2022 09:59

Can you link to one of these threads which mention African tribes?
I don't remember seeing one.

Sorry cross posted

marcopront · 23/07/2022 09:59

Can you link to one of these threads which mention African tribes?
I don't remember seeing one.

Wetsummers · 23/07/2022 09:58

MN search is really poor now but look at this thread.

It is from fourteen years ago, but it’s still a thing.

My point is that talking about ‘African tribes’ and the parenting they do as if you have a PHD on the subject is nonsense.

For one thing, not all Africans live in tribes

For another, is anyone actually an expert on these tribes?

OP posts:
Peregrina · 23/07/2022 09:57

I had a Scottish maiden name and now an English married name, and I had and have to spell both all the time, because there are alternative spellings.

Sigh, I accidentally gave my daughter names with a variety of spellings.

MattoMatto · 23/07/2022 09:54

SavoirFlair · 23/07/2022 08:29

Of course they “exist” - as do Norwegians over 35, hot countries, and anything else cited in this thread.

what the OP is referring to is how “African tribes” are used as an example of how a society manages a thing, yet the person has absolutely no source or reference point to back up this citation. Its a lazy shorthand to try and make a point. It’s just a projection that “African tribes” somehow manage to do a thing, therefore we should all do it also.

HTH

Op suggests African tribes are a ‘myth’. I took it the same way pps have. Also confused about where all these tribe discussions are taking place as I don’t think I’ve seen one!

Also fully agree with the hot countries / air con one.

Onlyforcake · 23/07/2022 09:54

My (married) surname is English and an actual English word BUT still requires spelling out or correcting pronunciation in England and the uk ..but thankfully less so that my previous non English surname. It is a source of irritation.

Wetsummers · 23/07/2022 09:53

And the African tribes tends to come up on discussions about attachment parenting. African tribes are all (apparently) doing it right. It’s never specified which ‘tribes’, are they from Zimbabwe, Egypt, Sierra Leone? We will never know.

OP posts:
SeaToSki · 23/07/2022 09:52

Apparently everyone in America risks being shot every time they put a toe outside of their house. Also all 330 million of them think and act the same way and so should be just lumped together when making assumptions.

Wetsummers · 23/07/2022 09:52

Indeed @Oobydo , but the myth prevails that everywhere but the uk (and America) has children running around in the fjords or alps or whatever for at least seven years.

OP posts:
Oobydo · 23/07/2022 09:49

Schulte · 23/07/2022 09:44

Nope. German and Austrian kindergarten, the Hungarian equivalent etc - they have absolutely nothing in common with English reception classes. They are basically childcare settings. They’re also not compulsory, you can keep your child at home until they start school at age 6 if you want.

But in theory can't people keep their children home in the UK until 5 when it's compulsory? It's only a year difference. People on here often act like it is compulsory that we send children to hard core school at 3 and all other countries no children go to anything similar before 7. When really its not a huge difference when you're looking at types of school/nursery/childcare and ages.

KittenKong · 23/07/2022 09:48

TrashyPanda · 23/07/2022 09:37

I’m nearly 60 with a non-English name.
i can only remember one time when I did not have to spell it.
it does get a bit wearing.

I’m Scottish and have a very normal surname.

I had to spell it all the time - in Scotland.. less so in England. Now my married surname is a monster and spelled phonetically (as it’s translated) and it’s always mangled (it’s rare where it’s from so I can’t complain). I always threaten to double barrel (but it would fit in a credit card!)

PlattyJubes · 23/07/2022 09:47

@TrashyPanda - I know exactly what you mean. I have a French surname and have to spell it every single time. I remember being in France and my amazement when they didn't ask me to spell it and, even more amazingly, that they wrote it down correctly.

Don't underestimate how boring it gets having to spell your surname EVERY single time (and one of the reasons I didn't saddle my DC with it - although no one on MN ever believes this).

Schulte · 23/07/2022 09:44

garlictwist · 23/07/2022 07:50

Yes, in most European countries children are in school at 4 or younger, they just don't call it school. They are still in an educational setting and in many cases learning to read and write. It's a myth that Norwegians are 35 before they learn to read etc.

Nope. German and Austrian kindergarten, the Hungarian equivalent etc - they have absolutely nothing in common with English reception classes. They are basically childcare settings. They’re also not compulsory, you can keep your child at home until they start school at age 6 if you want.

MereDintofPandiculation · 23/07/2022 09:44

I have an English name spelt in the conventional way and still have to spell it. Then there’s Catherine/Katherine/Kathryn Amelia/Emelia/Emilia etc

needtostopnamechanging · 23/07/2022 09:39

I have a fairly standard English name with as far as I know , no alternative spellings , and have had to spell it multiple times in my life

TrashyPanda · 23/07/2022 09:37

GiveMyHeadPeaceffs · 23/07/2022 08:29

That anyone with a non English name will be utterly tormented by having to spell it for the rest of their lives Hmm. I've also seen so posters making assumptions on how to pronounce certain names (specifically Irish/Gaelic names) who obviously don't know how to pronounce them.

I’m nearly 60 with a non-English name.
i can only remember one time when I did not have to spell it.
it does get a bit wearing.

NotDavidTennant · 23/07/2022 09:34

What is this "African tribes" thing people are alluding too? I've never seen "African tribes" mentioned on here but perhaps I'm not on the right threads to see it. Can someone explain?

Pooet · 23/07/2022 09:29

Mn opinion. Nasty old Middle East. Africa sweet people not their fault they aren't as clever than us. But because they are thick they forget about MENA with NA being by far the most brutal with slavery, women's rights and homesexuality laws. Its pointless debating with these folk because they have never travelled or worked or done anything with their lives.

CharlieAndTooManyCharacters · 23/07/2022 08:34

There are many different ethnic groups in Africa, including many who live in ways that fit the ‘African tribe’ stereotype in various ways. But anyone claiming anything on the basis that ‘African tribes’ do it, is usually just pedalling stereotypes. Anyone with knowledge would name the group and region they’re actually talking about - because there are huge cultural differences.

also that’s a stereotype about countries. Africa is a huge continent. 🤦🏻‍♀️

SavoirFlair · 23/07/2022 08:29

VladmirsPoutine · 23/07/2022 08:16

I'm confused. African tribes do exist.

Of course they “exist” - as do Norwegians over 35, hot countries, and anything else cited in this thread.

what the OP is referring to is how “African tribes” are used as an example of how a society manages a thing, yet the person has absolutely no source or reference point to back up this citation. Its a lazy shorthand to try and make a point. It’s just a projection that “African tribes” somehow manage to do a thing, therefore we should all do it also.

HTH

GiveMyHeadPeaceffs · 23/07/2022 08:29

That anyone with a non English name will be utterly tormented by having to spell it for the rest of their lives Hmm. I've also seen so posters making assumptions on how to pronounce certain names (specifically Irish/Gaelic names) who obviously don't know how to pronounce them.

VladmirsPoutine · 23/07/2022 08:16

I'm confused. African tribes do exist.