Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To eat one meal a day

89 replies

Lemonite · 10/07/2022 18:03

Trying to lose the last 10lbs to get to my goal weight.

It's the most stubborn 10lbs in the bloody world. I track every calorie, I drink only water, exercise a lot, no snacking between meals or takeaways, no treats, no booze, essentially no fun whatsoever!

But it's not budging. And that's at 1300-1400kcals a day, consistently. But the past 2 months I've not lost a gram.

So - that must be my maintenance kcals. Would it be unreasonable to eat one meal a day (dinner) of around 800-1000kcals to just get this 10lbs shifted? Would it mess with my metabolism?!

Any tips I'd appreciate!

OP posts:
FinallyHere · 11/07/2022 07:18

What % are you targeting? Low visceral fat is great health wise. 23% fat is really quite low for women.

Ideal body fat percentage for women
Category
Percentage
Athletes
14-20%
Fitness
21-24%
Acceptable
25-31%
Obesity
>32%

Lemonite · 11/07/2022 07:13

@FinallyHere thanks very much!

Luckily my gym have started smart health checks, this is actually what prompted me to lose more fat.

My muscle mass is okay, 75% of total weight, but my weight isn't far off overweight BMI wise and my body fat is 23%. Very low visceral fat though. I definitely look 'soft' and the flab around my middle is the worst.

Thanks for the link! Still no budge on the scale this morning. Yesterday I walked 21k steps, 10k run, 20 min weights workout and ate 1100 kcal. Off to the gym now.

Maybe this is just what it takes to tone up? I know they say it's dedication and hard work.

OP posts:
FinallyHere · 10/07/2022 20:52

My bmi is still high ish (towards upper limit of healthy

If you work out every day and consider a gentle 5k as a day off, then your body composition may indeed be that of an athlete. BMI is recognised as not being reliable for athletes.

Might your gym have a set of 'smart' scales that can give you a reading for body composition and percentage body fat? Boditrax, InBody etc are the brands I have come across. There are bound to be many others.

A personal BMI and body fat percentage may give you a better idea of the right target.

LowCarb is often used in conjunction with Intermittent fasting. Once your body is running on fat, and if your body has sufficient fat reserves, eating one meal a day can work really well.

Hope you find this interesting

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Art-Science-Low-Carbohydrate-Performance/dp/0983490716/ref=mpssa111?crid=25L54NIWNPA10&keywords=volek+and+phinney&qid=1657482699&sprefix=volek+and+phinney%2Caps%2C127&sr=8-1

BoJoGoGo · 10/07/2022 19:58

My DS did this the year before last as he wanted to lose some weight. I thought he was bonkers at the time but he lost the weight mega quickly and two years later hasn’t gained it back.

Ownedbymycats · 10/07/2022 19:57

My blood sugar drops and I can't cope on 9ne meal. Divide the calories up as others are suggesting.

Dreams25 · 10/07/2022 19:30

Along with Jason Fung look up Gin Stephens. Many who follow her IF approach do One Meal a day, but many others do a variety of other fasting approaches. A clean fast is essential...so nothing other than plain/sparkling water, black tea or coffee. People see huge health benefits and weight loss is just an added bonus. I'm doing it for the past 2 months and absolutely loving it. My mood and energy are way better and I've lost inches...and I tried every diet under the sun and nothing worked. I was hugely sceptical at first but there's a lot of science backing it up.

Carpy88999 · 10/07/2022 19:28

Lemonite · 10/07/2022 19:14

On paper, I couldn't agree more. I really thought the last weight would come off slowly but surely! My bmi is still high ish (towards upper limit of healthy).

I eat between 110-140g of protein a day at the moment - I'll look at where I can increase? I've tried measuring to track progress but I'm rubbish at getting the tape the same place so it changes by an inch or so in the same measuring session so I gave up!

Yikes I couldn't ditch the scales. I'd be too worried about my weight creeping up. Admit I definitely need to put a rest day in. I did try to, but then I convinced myself a gentle 5k run is so short it doesn't really count as proper exercise, so out I go...

Thank you for the replies really appreciate the thoughts/advice

This sounds like the beginning of a problem tbh. Something isn't adding up if you're doing all that exercise on 1400 calories a day either.

tootiredtobother · 10/07/2022 19:27

if you can fast overnight for 14 hours then that allows your good gut bacteria to deal with food, so much better for you, then obvs avoid sugar and i cut down on carbs as that's the way my body lets me lose weight

elessar · 10/07/2022 19:19

MuttsNutts · 10/07/2022 18:44

Jesus…are women still putting themselves through this shit?

i remember starving myself in a similar fashion in my teens/twenties along with 90% of other women I knew. Didn’t make me any happier, just dissatisfied when my unrealistic demands on myself and my body weren’t met and I ‘failed’ to hit the magic number on the scales.

Only when I broke the cycle did I become happy with myself.

It's depressing.

I spent years yo-yo dieting, convinced that once I was thin I would be happy. Never sustainable. I'd achieve my 'goal weight' and then relax a bit and put the weight right back on.

OP - why do you have a goal weight and what do you hope to achieve by reaching it? Are you prepared to spend the rest of your life restricting your diet and denying yourself enjoyment from food? Is it worth it?

The most freeing thing for me (after a lot of therapy) was coming to the realisation that thin doesn't = better. Now I eat what I want and because I'm no longer restricting and obsessing over food I maintain my weight and I eat when I'm hungry - sometimes that does mean only eating one meal a day but it's not because I'm denying myself food! No I'm not as slim as I always strived to be, but I'm 1000x happier.

Steelesauce · 10/07/2022 19:14

When I stall, I have a weekend off and eat whatever the hell I want. Might even have a whole week off. Can guarantee I'll gain upto 4lb but drop the gain plus a lb or 2 once I'm back on it. Its like the start of a diet all over again.

Lemonite · 10/07/2022 19:14

gamerchick · 10/07/2022 18:52

You're not eating enough for the level of activity you're doing OP.

Ditch the scales, up your protien and use a tape measure and seriously, stick a rest day in there somewhere.

On paper, I couldn't agree more. I really thought the last weight would come off slowly but surely! My bmi is still high ish (towards upper limit of healthy).

I eat between 110-140g of protein a day at the moment - I'll look at where I can increase? I've tried measuring to track progress but I'm rubbish at getting the tape the same place so it changes by an inch or so in the same measuring session so I gave up!

Yikes I couldn't ditch the scales. I'd be too worried about my weight creeping up. Admit I definitely need to put a rest day in. I did try to, but then I convinced myself a gentle 5k run is so short it doesn't really count as proper exercise, so out I go...

Thank you for the replies really appreciate the thoughts/advice

OP posts:
Georgyporky · 10/07/2022 19:11

I'm wondering who set your goal weight, & on what basis ?

Strip off, stand in front of a mirror.

I'm guessing that you look good if there's a mere 10 lbs between you & some arbitrary perfection.

We're all different shapes & sizes - e.g I had a mum-tum as a skinny 10year-old !

Dreikanter · 10/07/2022 19:09

Jalepenojello · 10/07/2022 18:23

intermittent fasting. Look at 5:2. 5 days a week TDE and 2 days a week at 500-800 calories. Give it a few weeks. It’s really frustrating, I get it

I was going to suggest this too - years ago when I did 5:2 (or hardcore 4:3) the advice when you’re plateauing was to ensure you up your calories to your TDEE on the non fasting days.

I couldn’t quite get down to 500 calories on fasting days (was more like 700) but it still worked.

gamerchick · 10/07/2022 18:52

You're not eating enough for the level of activity you're doing OP.

Ditch the scales, up your protien and use a tape measure and seriously, stick a rest day in there somewhere.

alexdgr8 · 10/07/2022 18:47

it is not good for your stomach to go for long periods without food, can cause excess acid.
there may be other problems too.
not good for keeping stable blood sugar levels.
avoid such extreme measures.

Proudboomer · 10/07/2022 18:45

I went low carb and lost 3 stone in 6 months. I eat two meals a day of breakfast and diner. High protein , high fat ( good fats not the bad ones) and plenty of green leafy stuff. I find on that diet I don’t need to count calories as everything is pretty low cal so I eat as I want of these and don’t feel hungry.

MuttsNutts · 10/07/2022 18:44

Jesus…are women still putting themselves through this shit?

i remember starving myself in a similar fashion in my teens/twenties along with 90% of other women I knew. Didn’t make me any happier, just dissatisfied when my unrealistic demands on myself and my body weren’t met and I ‘failed’ to hit the magic number on the scales.

Only when I broke the cycle did I become happy with myself.

Windypants21 · 10/07/2022 18:42

Is it possible you're not eating enough ? Your body will stop shedding weight if you aren't consuming enough particularly with all the exercise ? Are you aiming for a weight but not taking into account the added weight of the muscle you have acquired through weights ? Jason Fung is excellent though.

Superduperwooper · 10/07/2022 18:39

Agree with the others. What is the point of following a restrictive diet you cannot maintain just to reach an arbitrary number on the scales. Which you will then never maintain because it requires just restriction to maintain it.

The end does not justify the means here surely.

doadeer · 10/07/2022 18:35

What's the point if you have to live on so little to maintain this?

pigsDOfly · 10/07/2022 18:30

Can't you have a meal of salad, vegetables or home made vegetable soup for lunch rather than eating absolutely nothing all day?

It's a very unhealthy way of losing weight and as pp said you'll be tired and hungry all the time.

What are you going to do once you've lost that 10lb, in order to keep it off? You can't spend the rest of your life eating one meal a day in order to maintain the weight loss.

MrsGamgee · 10/07/2022 18:25

It's the OMAD diet (one meal a day), it worked well for me to kick start weight loss again. I couldn't do it for life as I really missed having a lunch, but short term to get to your goal weight and then if you can maintain eating more calories then why not.

I am doing it now and find I really crave lots of lovely salad and veg. I would make sure you take a multivitamin everyday if you don't already.

Jalepenojello · 10/07/2022 18:23

intermittent fasting. Look at 5:2. 5 days a week TDE and 2 days a week at 500-800 calories. Give it a few weeks. It’s really frustrating, I get it

Flyonthewall01 · 10/07/2022 18:20

I do this. Drink a couple cups of tea to stave off any hunger pangs whilst at work then just have a regular evening meal when I get home. I don’t feel hungry as the meal is substantial and fills me up without having to cut any nice food groups out like carbs

Lemonite · 10/07/2022 18:20

Siameasy · 10/07/2022 18:13

Google the diet doctor, Dr Jason Fung, he has lots of info about intermittent fasting

I will do, thank you!

OP posts: