Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 30/06/2022 18:53

Speak for yourself and leave out the 'we', chum. She/her here and there's bugfuck all you transphobes can do to stop me.

We're not trying to stop you, we're saying that we, personally, don't want to. The only people attempting to compel speech (or text I suppose) is the people declaring pronouns.

I work with international teams. Unless we go on a video call, I sometimes don't know if I'm corresponding with a man or a woman, and it doesn't matter at all. Similarly, if they, using English as a second language, use he for me, then I couldn't care less, because I have built resilience.

Frankly, I think building personal resilience is a much better use of your time than demanding everyone panders to your pronoun demands and being upset when they don't.

SolasAnla · 30/06/2022 18:46

For me in a work situation it is about delegated authority.

Take Halifax a retail bank owned by shareholders, who bought the stock for income via dividends and capital appreciation by a rise in the share prices.
They appoint directors to run the business. Who in turn employ other staff who are given delegated authority to act on the shareholders behalf.

The shareholders expect that the decisions will be based around the core function, attracting service users who will be charged a fee for services and/or who will deposit money which can be loaned out at a higher interest rate and attracting borrowers who will pay service fees and high interest.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4578817-halifax

So Andy has been employed to reply to communicate on behalf of the bank

Andy reads this:

"It does nothing of the sort, Lee. There’s no ambiguity about the name “Gemma”;I t’s a female person’s name. In other words, it’s pathetic virtue signalling and is seen as such by almost everyone who has responded to the initial tweet. Why are you trying to alienate people?"

And Andy uses "we" deciding that Andy has been authorised by the shareholders to make a official announcement:

"We strive for inclusion, equality and quite simply, in doing what’s right. If you disagree with our values, you’re welcome to close your account. ^AndyM"

Andy works for the shareholders and has no idea how much money could be involved.

If given a choice between a profitable customer and a pronoun badge (which the shareholders have to pay for), which will the shareholders choose?

The reality is given a choice between a profitable customer and saving the cost of an salary employee (pronoun badge or not), which will the shareholders choose?

I suspect that if Andy stopped for a momnent and asked if the CEO would push that option out to a vote at the AGM, Andy would may not have pressed post.

Now if I bother to look at the board of directors, (who signed off on the pronoun ideology and who delegated authority to Andy), how many of each has penis badge v has vulva badge would be needed?

JanesLittleGirl · 30/06/2022 18:37

Why might I not want to add my pronouns? Because it's a crock of shit is why. Imagine the following email:

From: HR Director
To: All Staff
Subject: Head of Bollocks

Hi Folks,

I'm pleased to announce that Malcolm Plonker has been appointed as Head of Bollocks. She will be responsible for all the shit that gets in the way of getting the job done.

Kind regards,
A Totally-Woke (she/him)
HR Director

You would just assume that She was a typo. A sensible email would repeat Malcolm in the second sentence.

brookstar · 30/06/2022 18:36

It is extremely unprofessional to make declarations about your personal ideologies in a business communication, which is what including your made up choice of 'pronouns' would be doing.

Unless you work at a university where it appears to be expected.... as long as they're the right personal ideologies of course 😞

ThreeRingCircus · 30/06/2022 18:36

Because I think that gender identity is a belief system no different to religion. I don't have a gender identity in the same way that I don't follow a religion. If people choose to add pronouns to their emails that's their decision but I would refuse if my organisation tried to force me.

A PP summed it up perfectly for me when they mentioned that it forces people that may be struggling to identify before they are ready to and it also feeds into sex based discrimination at a time when females are still paid less than males.

CecilyP · 30/06/2022 18:33

But if it's someone's preference to give their "title" then they should be allowed to.

Yes it’s fine but we’re all on first name terms these days so we’ll reply Dear Chris rather than Dear Mrs Notaman.

bellinisurge · 30/06/2022 18:32

Luckily my work has said it's up to you. It acknowledged a range of views (probably someone mentioned Forstater case to HR) and said blah blah respectful of other's views blah blah

Hallyup89 · 30/06/2022 18:28

I'd love to know what would happen if I put he/him next to my obviously female name.

I suspect I'd be treated worse than if I just left them to presume I was female.

I don't think pronouns help anyone but men, and even then I'd argue they're irrelevant for most.

StillWeRise · 30/06/2022 18:21

it's completely performative and meaningless

I've had many conversations with younger people (25-35) about (absent) non binary people, who were known to us all, and whose sex was known to us all.
Despite their best efforts, these young allies frequently misgendered the absent person and used the pronouns appropriate to their sex. In the English language pronouns are powerfully and unconsciously linked to sex, even when they are trying and 'well meaning' they can't do it. Further evidence is that when talking about an unknown or hypothetical person, native English speakers find it easy to use 'they' (as in, 'if anybody knows where my keys are can they let me know please)

In a professional context I was part of a hilarious discussion where people were attempting to discuss a non binary person and their interaction with various agencies (also designated 'they') ...so it went...'well, they said that they couldn't do that because they wouldn't be there then, but then they said oh no, that will be OK so they decided to change it and then they said ....'
and the whole conversation became impossible until people started using sex based pronouns. It was very funny.

In brief, it's all a load of bollocks.

MagpiePi · 30/06/2022 18:17

Cyclebabble · 30/06/2022 17:06

I can see that using pronouns has some merit in making people feel included- it means we do not misgender people and we refer to them in a way they are comfortable with. So far so good. However, the problems start to come when this starts to become expected and what is voluntary actually becomes compulsory. For example we have undertaken a number of training courses recently where the starting point is tell us about yourself which includes pronouns. To not join in, looks really awkward. In short it has crept to being quasi compulsory.

Yesterday my business changed its diversity policy. It now states that transgender people are free to use the gender specific toilet with which they currently identify. So a genetic male can now use the ladies toilet. I thought this was against the law? However this is now our HR policy which also states that non compliance will lead to disciplinary action. In my business, way before you get to disciplinary you would have significant issues with a powerful internal lobby that would effectively ostracise you. So if you want to keep your job, you keep quiet. Unions and usual HR protections operate poorly in this space and I have seen this in practice.

Your company are on very shaky ground with declaring all toilets are now mixed sex if all they have done is changed the nameplates on the doors.

Are they complying with 'The Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992 Cl 20(c)?
...sanitary conveniences shall not be suitable unless--
"(c)separate rooms containing conveniences are provided for men and women except where and so far as each convenience is in a separate room the door of which is capable of being secured from inside."
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1992/3004/regulation/20/made

Have they done any risk assessments - what would happen if somebody was attacked, would they be happy with legal action? Also, have they assessed the impact on women from certain religions that would be effectively unable to use the facilities as they cannot mix with the opposite sex. How is that inclusive?

Piglet89 · 30/06/2022 18:16

@BellePeppa a new colleague has referred to me as “she” twice in meetings in my presence.

it’s pretty rude. Not because of trans stuff but because it makes me want to say “Who’s “she”: the cat’s mother?” She knows my name: just use it.

Snugglepumpkin · 30/06/2022 18:15

It is extremely unprofessional to make declarations about your personal ideologies in a business communication, which is what including your made up choice of 'pronouns' would be doing.

Would your company insist people include whether they were pro or anti Brexit?
Or their opinion on BLM?
Should pro-Ana people put that in their emails or should people include whether they are pro or anti Life in the abortion debate?

It also excludes gender critical women who may feel that an email has come from a hostile source who are announcing that they put mens feelings before womens rights.

The right NOT to believe in the pick your own 'pronouns' crowd has been upheld in a court of law.

For those who may not have a good level of English, or those who have English as a second/third etc... language, it causes confusion for no good reason.

DdraigGoch · 30/06/2022 18:14

0blio · 30/06/2022 17:07

Why not just have an email signature that says:

Alex Smith
Job title
Please note: I am female

No need for gender nonsense at all.

What's wrong with:

Alex Smith (Ms)

Much more concise.

What's wrong with "Alex Smith"?

The contents of your underwear are no one else's business. It's well documented that when many people know they're dealing with a woman they make assumptions about her capabilities. Much better to leave them in the dark, then they can't discriminate.

starfishmummy · 30/06/2022 18:13

I know the done thing in the Stone Age was to sign yourself as Chris Notaman (Mrs./Miss) but revealing your marital status is completely inappropriate.

But if it's someone's preference to give their "title" then they should be allowed to.

LadyApplejack · 30/06/2022 18:12

AmaryIlis · 30/06/2022 17:54

Basically it's utterly pointless unless you have an ambiguous name, or unless you've decided you want to be known as they or it.

I wish I understood the logic of people who put he/him. We can all work out for ourselves that someone who likes to be known as he probably also prefers him. And if we can't work it out, why don't they also kindly enlighten us on whether they want us to use his?

Ha, totally. The name "Ken" is usually the main clue. At my work they actually do add "his" as well, just to spell it out for any thickies 🙄

SweetSenorita · 30/06/2022 18:08

MrsTerryPratchett · 30/06/2022 15:51

I always think about two workers from an organisation I frequently use. One is female, bog standard email signature. She is helpful, kind and will go very far out of her way to assist the really vulnerable people we work with. The other is a young man. Pronouns, Pride flag, BLM and other stuff in his signature. Never returns phone calls and has been the cause of issues with the vulnerable people (including those very people from his email signature).

Virtue signaling versus actually helping.

Exactly. Watch the wheels, not the indicator ......

Crocsandshocks · 30/06/2022 18:02

If a pronoun badge falls in the woods and there is nobody there to read it, did it say anything at all?

😂

UnimpeachableBravery · 30/06/2022 18:00

So either you are an idiot who needs to be told what to think, or this was a deliberately goady post

GerryAtrick · 30/06/2022 17:57

Tell your boss you would rather they concentrate on whatever the business does and make as much money as possible so that you can have a decent payrise.

Also ask them if they want to be 'allies' to L blah blah blah, does that mean they are enemies of straight people?

AmaryIlis · 30/06/2022 17:54

Basically it's utterly pointless unless you have an ambiguous name, or unless you've decided you want to be known as they or it.

I wish I understood the logic of people who put he/him. We can all work out for ourselves that someone who likes to be known as he probably also prefers him. And if we can't work it out, why don't they also kindly enlighten us on whether they want us to use his?

oakleaffy · 30/06/2022 17:54

zurala · 30/06/2022 16:32

Why not just have an email signature that says:

Alex Smith
Job title
Please note: I am female

No need for gender nonsense at all.

Agreed, if someone has a name which could be either male or female , like 'Alex' , one could just use Mr, Miss or Mrs or even ''Ms''

Crocsandshocks · 30/06/2022 17:52

Because you don't lead with your gender.

You may as well be putting your star sign or hair colour as far as I'm concerned

CecilyP · 30/06/2022 17:51

Speak for yourself and leave out the 'we', chum. She/her here and there's bugfuck all you transphobes can do to stop me.

You refer to yourself in the third person?

oakleaffy · 30/06/2022 17:51

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/06/2022 15:48

I don't do it because (a) it's obvious from my name that I am female (b) I don't think it matters either way in a work context (c) if people do get it wrong I don't care (happens occasionally with foreigners) and (d) I don't agree with the whole trans thing. I mean if someone else wants to put they etc, I will respect that and use their preferred terms but I don't think there's any need for us all to get involved.

I have a very obviously Female name {To Europeans} but to Afghans, no! Several times over messages I was addressed as ''Dear Mr ''
I didn't put them right.
Didn't feel the need.
It reminds me of infant school to put pronouns everywhere..If people misgender my dog, I don't care.
Generally, when facing someone, it's pretty easy to tell if they are a female or a male., so daft to need their 'Pronoun', just use their name.

User354354 · 30/06/2022 17:49

Baffled that you need someone to tell you why you are against something.

If you are genuinely opposed, then it's your right to be. But surely you must know why you are not happy with it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread