Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
RamblingEclectic · 01/07/2022 14:25

The idea that one formula like pronoun declarations will make things easier or more comfortable for everyone is a big assumption.

I've noticed an awful lot of colleagues opting for they/them/theirs though, many of whom I know for a fact aren't gender neutral. I can't work out if they're trying to avoid gender stereotyping or if it's just a subtle way of taking the piss.

I've noticed 'pronouns: any' seems to be gaining popularity in some spaces. For some it's likely a piss take, but like with those who prefer no title, it can be viewed as neutral/don't care or don't want to pin any colours visibly to the mast for a variety of reasons.

I think of pronoun declarations like titles. For some, it's just a standard of politeness. For others, they don't care. For still others, it causes discomfort from slight annoyance to strong anxiety, before getting into how it's read or could result in different treatment. There isn't much of a reason to do it only one way other than lazy corporate thinking.

Lola4321 · 01/07/2022 14:21

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Lola4321 · 01/07/2022 14:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Babdoc · 01/07/2022 13:20

99+% of people certainly don’t have a “gender identity”! What does that even mean, apart from accepting a pile of sexist stereotypes? People have a sex, which was determined at conception and is immutable. A very tiny % of people wish they were the opposite sex, for a variety of reasons that include gender dysphoria, internalised homophobia, autogynephilia, etc, but that doesn’t mean the rest of the population has to participate in their beliefs.

babyjellyfish · 01/07/2022 12:57

99%+ of people have a gender identity that aligns with their sex.

Do they?

I have no idea what this means. I don't have an identity which matches having a vagina. I'm pretty sure there's no such thing.

FlippityFlapperty · 01/07/2022 12:54

The notion that pronouns refer to a person's "gender identity" instead of their biological sex is ridiculous. We can virtually always distinguish men from women. On the rare occasions that someone looks like a man when they are a woman or vice versa, their name ‘David’ or ‘Claire’ usually clears it up. We are then talking about an utterly tiny minority of people who might be frequently mistaken for the wrong sex. To avoid embarrassing them, they can easily write Ms / Mr as part of their email signature. No fuss, no nod to gender ideology, no need for the him / her / they / ze nonsense.

FlippityFlapperty · 01/07/2022 12:38

I used to put pronouns but have since educated myself more on exactly what sort of alarming ideology they now stand for. Not a chance I’d use them now.

My answer is that I don’t agree with the gender ideology framework that is producing the question ‘what are your pronouns?’. 99%+ of people have a gender identity that aligns with their sex. Most of the time it is perfectly possible to guess. If a person is frequently experiencing people guessing wrong, then they can put she/her, but what is that doing that Ms didn’t, other than pleasing people who make a massive fuss out of Ms being about marital status? If the aim is to stop the embarrassment of misgendering, isn’t she/her drawing more attention to it than a simple Mr / Ms?

It is not psychologically normal to refuse to identify with your own body and want to cut off your breasts / penis or adopt the stereotypical traits of the opposite sex rather than simply accept that you are your body. Gender dysmorphia is being treated not as a psychological disorder but as a perfectly normal thing affecting us all, so much so that even our business emails need to declare if we want to be treated as a man or woman. If people want to put she/her after their names, fine. However, corporate policy that all employees must do so is something I can’t agree with. It’s not ‘expressing solidarity’, it is normalising an increasingly odd ideological movement that believes that you can choose your sex, totally immute the old one and demand that nobody ever mentions the biological reality in case it upsets you.

Oblomov22 · 01/07/2022 12:15

thread

Here is the thread I was referring to earlier. A woman was at a conference and wanted to know how to politely decline to use such pronouns.

I like the varied responses. My favourite was :

" Actually I don't find declaring my pronouns necessary. Please just use my name".

I like that. This pronoun bullshit really gets my goat.

HeadOnShoulders · 01/07/2022 00:49

beautyisthefaceisee · 30/06/2022 20:21

Nice gaslighting there. I'm not confused. You're just wrong and ignorant.

Do you regularly go around being rude to people because they dont fit into what you approve of?

You never mentioned "mental". You said "easy". Suggesting that what is easier for you is a priority. Are you regularly nasty to other vulnerable groups because thats "easier"? Perhaps you comment loudly on peoples weight, abilities, looks? etc? No? Why is that different?

No, you're the one gaslighting and pretending something is rude and nasty when it isn't.

I never said I don't approve of trans people, because I neither approve or disapprove of them. Frankly I couldn't give a shit if a man wants to wear lipstick or a woman wants to grow an beard and burp. I absolutely have no truck, doesn't affect me in any way, and of that floats their boat so be it.

What I won't do though, is buy into their delusion. If a man wears a dress he's still a man. If a man perceives himself as a woman he's still a man. If a man wears makeup, takes hrt and thpeakth with an affected lisp, he's still a man.

I wouldn't just walk over to him and tell him that, because obviously he doesn't like being a man, and I have no reason to rub his face in it. Same as I wouldnt tell a fat person they're fat. That's just gratuitously being hurtful.

But pronouns aren't about that. They're about me doing mental gymnastics and buying in to the other person's delusion. A preferred pronoun expects me to modify my own speech and police my own thought processes when even thinking about someone else. And I refuse to do that.

Pronouns are a natural part of speech, as is using male pronouns for men. So when I talk about a man I refuse to be dictated to about having to use specific words when mentioning them. Even if he thinks he's a she.

Matt Walsh said it best. Can you have preferred adjectives? That when you say my name you have to preface it with handsome?

If a man sees himself ad a woman, that's his perception. And in his mind he can do whatever he wants. But if I see him as a man, I'm not going to change that just to please him.

maddening · 30/06/2022 21:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No one wants to stop you, it is a free world 'chum', you can put what ever the fuck you like in YOUR email.

It is the compulsion to use it when you do not subscribe to that ideology. It is no different to requiring everyone to sign off emails with " praise be to god" and if they don't comply they are vilified. It is compelled speech to be required to use it.

OP - search Jordon Peterson and compelled speech, he explains it very well.

SolasAnla · 30/06/2022 20:59

Ponderingwindow · 30/06/2022 20:44

Not wanting to declare my own pronouns doesn’t mean I won’t try to respect another person’s name or pronoun change in most situations.

We all follow social conventions to have polite exchanges in all sorts of scenarios. You change the subject when your uncle brings up politics at Christmas dinner instead of getting into an argument. You tell someone you are fine even when you are having the worst day of your life because the exchange wasn’t really an invitation for a conversation.

unless I am offering evidence or testifying in court, I am typically prepared to try to edit my language to the same degree I edit my language in other scenarios. I am well aware that the courts want to impose this on people which I find incredibly disturbing.

The UK Courts want to force a witness to amend their sworn statement.

A UK judge told a woman, the victim of a violent assault that her justice was reduced as she refused to show "respect" to the male who attacked her.

landantan · 30/06/2022 20:46

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 30/06/2022 18:55

Oh, and perhaps it's because I've got a lot on, but I have often deep dived into some subject or other, established an opinion, and then forgotten most of what I read/my reasoning behind that opinion. Like throwing away the working when doing a maths problem once I've got the answer.

Yes this is exactly what has happened here.

It took me a while to get my head around the whole gender / sex thing as I naively viewed them as the same. Only after reading more information did I get that gender is more the social construct. It's all a work in progress as it can be difficult to understand points unless they are clearly spelled out. Sometimes I find people talking about issues such as this / trans talk in a way like everyone is up to speed. Just talking on my own behalf, I am not.

OP posts:
Eviandoll · 30/06/2022 20:44

@Naunet...actually when I trained as a typist back in 1985 that was considered to correct form at the time and remained so for a good many years afterwards, even though women were given the right to use credit over ten years previously so I'm not sure how you link the two ?

Ponderingwindow · 30/06/2022 20:44

Not wanting to declare my own pronouns doesn’t mean I won’t try to respect another person’s name or pronoun change in most situations.

We all follow social conventions to have polite exchanges in all sorts of scenarios. You change the subject when your uncle brings up politics at Christmas dinner instead of getting into an argument. You tell someone you are fine even when you are having the worst day of your life because the exchange wasn’t really an invitation for a conversation.

unless I am offering evidence or testifying in court, I am typically prepared to try to edit my language to the same degree I edit my language in other scenarios. I am well aware that the courts want to impose this on people which I find incredibly disturbing.

landantan · 30/06/2022 20:38

Theblondestoftheblonde · 30/06/2022 19:44

Haven’t RTFT but Sex Matters have a guide to resisting this bullshit

sex-matters.org/posts/updates/pronouns/

Ah! I think this is how I came across the initial information about this. There was a journalist that had done an article in the newspaper.

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 30/06/2022 20:37

landantan · 30/06/2022 20:32

@beautyisthefaceisee

Nothing disingenuous going on here.

I genuinely know that I do not agree with pronouns.

I genuinely struggle to articulate the reasons why and was asking for help on the matter.

You might know you don't agree with it.

But there's no way that someone who uses the phrase "chipping away at women" doesn't know why.

You have achieved what you set out to though, as I'm sure you knew you would.

landantan · 30/06/2022 20:32

@beautyisthefaceisee

Nothing disingenuous going on here.

I genuinely know that I do not agree with pronouns.

I genuinely struggle to articulate the reasons why and was asking for help on the matter.

OP posts:
SolasAnla · 30/06/2022 20:29

beautyisthefaceisee · 30/06/2022 20:01

That I can agree with.

I don't agree with people being forced to , as people might not want to give them for several reasons.

I however disagree with people refusing to respect other peoples and or posting disingenously like OP.

You don't agree with people being forced to announce a pronoun.

Yet you do agree with people being forced to accept a pronoun being forced on them.

Dominuse · 30/06/2022 20:28

Greensleeves · 30/06/2022 15:40

  1. some women feel that they should not be obliged to out themselves as female, in a society where sex discrimination is still very much a thing

  2. some trans people aren't ready to out themselves yet either, and insisting on pronouns forces the issue

  3. some GC people feel that making "these are my pronouns" mainstream panders to transgender ideology which is harmful to/in conflict with women's rights.

This. It draws attention to women and has been shown to widen gaps not narrow them - outing people who don’t want to be outed. Just no

AlisonDonut · 30/06/2022 20:26

beautyisthefaceisee · 30/06/2022 19:14

Which bit are you struggling with?

You said 'I actually have slightly more respect for those on here who come out and say it'.

And I asked 'say what'.

What is 'it' in the context of that sentence?

babyjellyfish · 30/06/2022 20:23

beautyisthefaceisee · 30/06/2022 20:01

That I can agree with.

I don't agree with people being forced to , as people might not want to give them for several reasons.

I however disagree with people refusing to respect other peoples and or posting disingenously like OP.

I think the pronoun thing is coercive.

We're conditioned to believe that not referring to a male person as "she" if that is what they want is unkind or disrespectful, so we do it because we want to be kind and respectful.

Next thing you know, the International Olympic Committee is saying "everyone agrees that trans women are women" to justify Laurel Hubbard being allowed to take the place of a young female athlete at the Olympics, the Labour front bench are all saying trans women are women and belong in our single sex spaces, and the Lib Dems are saying if you don't believe trans women are women, don't vote for us.

I don't want to be unkind or disrespectful towards anyone. But I also don't want to pretend I think trans women are women when I don't. And I feel like I have to choose between one or the other, because using the pronouns will be interpreted as a sign that I believe.

On the other hand, not using them could mean I get posts deleted on Mumsnet, my account blocked on Twitter, or even disciplinary action at work. So it's not really a free choice, is it?

Frankly I resent being put in this position.

Fuck pronouns.

beautyisthefaceisee · 30/06/2022 20:21

HeadOnShoulders · 30/06/2022 20:09

@beautyisthefaceisee

Im not sure what's causing your confusion.

If someone tells me they're a woman, when they're clearly a man, I'm not going to do mental gymnastics and start thinking of them as a woman. Because that would indeed be mental.

And 'respecting their identity' is just a word salad. Which is a nicer way of saying utter bollocks.

Nice gaslighting there. I'm not confused. You're just wrong and ignorant.

Do you regularly go around being rude to people because they dont fit into what you approve of?

You never mentioned "mental". You said "easy". Suggesting that what is easier for you is a priority. Are you regularly nasty to other vulnerable groups because thats "easier"? Perhaps you comment loudly on peoples weight, abilities, looks? etc? No? Why is that different?

LovinglifeAF · 30/06/2022 20:18

Hiphopopotamus · 30/06/2022 15:44

So you think you’re against something but you’d like someone to tell you why? And it’s supposed to be the trans inclusive community that are brainwashing? 🙄

Its supposed to just be a way to support trans people. If only trans people use preferred pronouns in their signatures to avoid being misgendered, it singles them out as being trans. If we all do it as standard it takes away the stigma. It’s a simple thing we can do to make peoples lives easier.

It’s not down to me to do something I don’t feel comfortable with to make others feel better about themselves. If trans people feel they stand out by declaring their pronouns that’s for them to manage their feelings on, it’s nothing to do with me.

OP I’ve not been asked yet this by my work but if it comes I’ll just ignore it and then say “not for me thanks” if it persists

FlirtsWithRhinos · 30/06/2022 20:15

DarlingDarwin · 30/06/2022 19:43

To those of you saying you don’t want to “out” yourself as women and face sexism, I do understand your point. But doesn’t your name generally “out” you anyway? And that would be in your email/signature?

It's cumulative. Having the pronouns stated as well as the name makes it a bigger part of what people include in their mental model of you.

Kind of like the difference between wearing a football team's hat, and wearing the hat, the scarf, the t shirt, the facepaint and banner round your shoulders.

Research shows that women do worse in maths tests when they focus on the fact they are women. Clearly they must have known that already, but making it a focus still has a negative effect. If reinforcing the knowledge that a known woman is a woman affects people to think differently about their own selves, how do think it affects other people?

Popcorn77 · 30/06/2022 20:14

MrsTerryPratchett · 30/06/2022 15:43

And studies have shown that drawing your own and other's attention to your sex makes you worse at certain tasks and makes other people treat you differently.

Sexism is a thing.

Yes it is not that I cannot see why it can be a positive but personally I had prior to this removed any reference to my gender from my email signature. I feel much more comfortable with that as I do not think my gender is at all relevant to my work. I also do not see that anyone needs to use my pronouns when they know my name. I very much dislike any reference to my gender and am highly aware of it for my kids - i am training myself to never say “boys will be boys, girls let do X… etc” so it feels very counter intuitive to now be asked to state my pro noun. I hate that I feel I am doing something unsupportive in refusing to, but I also feel very very uncomfortable being asked to state them. Its hard.