Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a real apology? Reposting for traffic

159 replies

danny735 · 16/05/2022 17:05

My DH was at the FA Cup final yesterday. Football is a huge hobby for him and he's had a season ticket for his club since he was a child.

We had a DD, 8 months old and he hasn't been able to go as much since she arrived. He's a good dad and he's very hands on but I will say he seems to be struggling since she was born. He doesn't stay in control of his emotions (whereas before DD he was my rock and showed high emotional intelligence).

He's been lashing out a lot but more than that hasn't showed the ability to take responsibility for his actions. He tends to externalise blame. We are in couples therapy already. I understand that he needs outlets and he was very much looking forward to the match yesterday. I've been unwell this weekend with a bad cold and DD is teething. I assured him he should still go, it was just a cold and whilst I felt a bit miserable I was able to look after DD. I left him through it throughout the day - just sending occasional pictures or videos of DD like I normally would. He left the house at 12:30 and was home at 9:30. I asked him to bring me a bar of chocolate. He messaged to say he was walking up from the station (an 8 minute walk) but didn't get home for another 20 minutes. I said "What took you so long?" He immediately flared up, swore at me and told me to "fuck off and go away" as well as another below the belt comment.

This morning he externalised blame - apparently his reaction/ swearing was because I asked him "What took you so long?" when he was still on the doorstep. He will apologise in one breath and externalise blame in the next which makes it quite difficult to accept the apology. He will then say "I should only have to apologise once". He didn't give any thought to the fact that I might have been exhausted from looking after a teething baby all day while feeling unwell. He didn't ask how I was feeling - he started swearing so I went to bed. When I suggested this morning that he had been taking his disappointment that his team lost out on me - he hotly disagreed. I was trying to understand his behaviour/ reaction but he just seems to take it as a slight.

What upsets me the most was the contempt in his voice / body language last night. Is it unreasonable to expect a meaningful apology?

OP posts:
pinthehammer · 16/05/2022 18:41

thecatsthecats · 16/05/2022 18:40

My husband and I both have a bit of a problem with "externalising blame" as you say it. It's come about for good reasons related to our childhoods.

Knowing this about each other, what we don't do is badger each other for apologies. We understand that certain times and circumstances we might overreact, and give the other person even a few minutes to cool off.

Then the apology comes naturally, whilst demanding it just exacerbates the situation. We also try to allow ourselves to be blamed when it IS our fault or neither of us behaved perfectly.

Did your therapist give you advice on how to handle this behaviour, and did you listen? Or did you just treat it as an explanation of why he is wrong and you are right?

This is a great post.

nearlyspringyay · 16/05/2022 18:40

You sound like you've swallows a counsellors handbook op, and could be seen as controlling at best.

thecatsthecats · 16/05/2022 18:40

My husband and I both have a bit of a problem with "externalising blame" as you say it. It's come about for good reasons related to our childhoods.

Knowing this about each other, what we don't do is badger each other for apologies. We understand that certain times and circumstances we might overreact, and give the other person even a few minutes to cool off.

Then the apology comes naturally, whilst demanding it just exacerbates the situation. We also try to allow ourselves to be blamed when it IS our fault or neither of us behaved perfectly.

Did your therapist give you advice on how to handle this behaviour, and did you listen? Or did you just treat it as an explanation of why he is wrong and you are right?

LetHimHaveIt · 16/05/2022 18:32

I can't be doing with all this 'externalising blame'/'biggest cheerleader'/'apologising meaningfully' bollocks. It's painfully cringeworthy.

pinthehammer · 16/05/2022 18:31

VeryTrying22 · 16/05/2022 18:04

There was a post on here last week about a schools bullying policy and questioning the term ‘provocative victim’ that’s what the OP is here. Pushing and pushing then playing victim when her DH gets annoyed about it.

messaging all day with pictures and videos, snapping rudely when he dared to arrive 12 minutes late back, with her bloody chocolate too.

I agree with this tbh. He was 12 minutes later than you thought he would be, and you decided to say that to him before he was even through the door when his team had just lost.

He shouldn't have shouted or sworn at you. But FFS let the man get in the door. Most people would be immediately annoyed by you at that I'd think. He was probably already gutted from the game.

It sounds like you were trying to provoke an argument with him at a bad time.

Reviewer123456 · 16/05/2022 18:30

Sending photos and videos whilst he out and then questioning why
he is 12 mins late, I would be telling you where to go as well.
Could he not just have have some enjoyment?

Brefugee · 16/05/2022 18:29

Have you ever been his biggest cheerleader?
Yes, he was wrong to swear but did you have to start on him as soon as he got in? Agree with others that he was gutted and you were ill. You both need to move on. Or call it a day

PriestessofPing · 16/05/2022 18:26

Inklingpot · 16/05/2022 18:11

Very much this.

I think the fact the OP posted the exact same thread yesterday in Relationships, and has posted it again in AIBU makes me think she just wants to be told that yes she’s right and her DH is a big meany.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/relationships/4549781-externalising-blame

The prominent use of that irritating phrase also makes me think she’s trying to legitimise having a go at her DH for very little reason by couching it in counselling speak.

Yes but she says in her post title she’s reposting it for traffic and she only got one response on that post so presumably was looking for a wider range of views.

DoItAfraid · 16/05/2022 18:25

I think your DH spoke to you very rudely and for that he should apologise.

However

  • you speak a lot about not having friends/ family near you and him being “your rock”. That is quite a lot of presssure to put on someone. Is there anything you can do to develop a network or an interest of your own?
  • your use of “counselling speak”/phrases would really annoy me I am sorry.
  • it is annoying to be jumped on with complaints the minute you get in.
ladydimitrescu · 16/05/2022 18:24

You're both wrong. He shouldn't be swearing at you, but you shouldn't be pouncing on him about taking too long to walk up the road. I'd be annoyed at that.

Wouldyabeguilty · 16/05/2022 18:15

Sorry but you sound like a pain in the hole. He is out at a match and you are sending him pics of the child and then because he didn't Usain Bolt it up the road home with your chocolate you are asking him what took him so long? Controlling and overbearing. Give him a bloody break.

TigerLilyTail · 16/05/2022 18:14

Can I just say that if your mental health isn't good, then MN is really the last place you should post for support. It's pretty brutal here!

I would suggest going for therapy on your own and figure out what you want in life because I think you deserve better than this.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 16/05/2022 18:14

I think if he's been amazing for 6 years and throughout pregnancy and now it's 8 months in to being parents and you're both snapping and under pressure. Is dd sleeping through the night? who's doing night feeds/wake ups?

Inklingpot · 16/05/2022 18:11

VeryTrying22 · 16/05/2022 18:04

There was a post on here last week about a schools bullying policy and questioning the term ‘provocative victim’ that’s what the OP is here. Pushing and pushing then playing victim when her DH gets annoyed about it.

messaging all day with pictures and videos, snapping rudely when he dared to arrive 12 minutes late back, with her bloody chocolate too.

Very much this.

I think the fact the OP posted the exact same thread yesterday in Relationships, and has posted it again in AIBU makes me think she just wants to be told that yes she’s right and her DH is a big meany.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/relationships/4549781-externalising-blame

The prominent use of that irritating phrase also makes me think she’s trying to legitimise having a go at her DH for very little reason by couching it in counselling speak.

VeryTrying22 · 16/05/2022 18:04

There was a post on here last week about a schools bullying policy and questioning the term ‘provocative victim’ that’s what the OP is here. Pushing and pushing then playing victim when her DH gets annoyed about it.

messaging all day with pictures and videos, snapping rudely when he dared to arrive 12 minutes late back, with her bloody chocolate too.

DashboardConfessional · 16/05/2022 18:04

I'm pretty sure that a dad asking a mum who has been out to a friend's for the day "What took her so long" (as the first sentence) would be seen by most as controlling.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 16/05/2022 18:03

I don't think i deserve to be swore at under any circumstances. I was unwell with a teething baby and I made sure I left him alone all day.

But in your OP, you fully admit that you didn't leave him alone as you kept texting him photos and videos of your daughter.

I appreciate you felt unwell and the baby was teething, but I do think, unless there's an emergency, if someone out for the day, you should just leave them to it. When people text like that, IME it comes across as a bit controlling - kind of like you don't want them to spend a whole day without thinking of you/being reminded of how unwell you are.

Jalepenojello · 16/05/2022 18:02

I’d instantly be annoyed if I stepped through the door and that was my welcome over a 12 minute delay. It would really piss me off. Almost as though you acted a martyr and merrily sent him off to enjoy his hobby while you sat at home ill, with a teething baby, just waiting to punish him for his free time when he returned. Maybe that’s really not the case but I see it a lot.

His response seems aggressive though and he should have apologised for that. I hope you get free time too OP.

danny735 · 16/05/2022 18:02

TadLlama · 16/05/2022 17:54

If you think he's having a breakdown then help him. Don't badger him for a "real apology".

The problem is my Mh is even more at risk and as my last post shows - he has much more support and outlets than me but is jumping down my throat - a lot.

OP posts:
DashboardConfessional · 16/05/2022 18:01

fluffycereal · 16/05/2022 18:00

So what? It doesn't excuse his behaviour.

Well, don't minimise the behaviour of interrogating your partner as to what they did with their extra 12 minutes before they step in the door as "asking a question"!

fluffycereal · 16/05/2022 18:01

My MH is suffering so much. I'm starting to lose hope.

As soon as you recognise his behaviour for what it is you can break free and work on yourself. He has done this to you, remember that. Your MH is suffering because your biggest supporter has turned into your abuser since your child was born.

danny735 · 16/05/2022 18:00

StrangeCondition · 16/05/2022 17:52

But you didn't leave him alone all day, you said you were sending him pictures and videos of your daughter - do you really need to do that when he's out?

She was in her jersey and laughing. It wasn't overboard - it was very cute and he's usually very receptive to this

OP posts:
fluffycereal · 16/05/2022 18:00

DashboardConfessional · 16/05/2022 17:55

I'm sickened at the amount of posters suggesting this is your fault for asking him a question.

"What took you so long?" is not just a question, is it?

So what? It doesn't excuse his behaviour.

danny735 · 16/05/2022 17:59

Sadly, because he was previously incredibly supportive, emotionally intelligent and my biggest cheerleader, I agreed to live in London (where I have no family and no longer any friends).

I don't think he's abusive. He was supportive for 6 years. But in that time -
I set up a business, worked overtime relentlessly so we could afford to buy in zone 4 London (where he grew up - I have no family here). His job is 9-6, relatively low pressure and doesn't offer opportunities for progression.

My maternity leave was cut short because my mat cover quit.

I'm back to work PT. I have no time for hobbies.I have no family here and no friends left - they moved back
Home during the pandemic.

I really thought I had chosen an amazing dad for my DD. But at the moment I don't recognise him.

We literally discussed apologising meaningfully in therapy last week but nothing has changed.

I don't want to give up on my family but it's dawning on me that I can't change him. My MH is suffering so much. I'm starting to lose hope.

OP posts:
DashboardConfessional · 16/05/2022 17:55

I'm sickened at the amount of posters suggesting this is your fault for asking him a question.

"What took you so long?" is not just a question, is it?