Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think even P/T work with small kids is impossible??

256 replies

LowryLowry · 14/05/2022 09:42

I have an almost 1 year old and an almost 3 year old and have been a SAHM for the last couple of years. I've been vaguely looking out for p/t jobs and have been offered an interview for one which is 21hrs per week. Good job, in the field I want, with prospects. I've been trying to work out logistics and it just seems impossible. There'd be a 1hr commute each way. So, say I worked three days a week, 8-4, and DH dropped them off and I picked them up, that still just seems like an insanely long day for them. Then I'd literally just be picking them up, chucking some food into them and putting them to bed, then repeating for another two days. Is this just the norm? Then there's the probability of them being ill, DH going on work trips (not a regular thing, but reasonably frequent) Is it worth it?? I love spending time with my kids, but find the monotony and physical exhaustion quite hard at times. I feel a bit lost and would love to have 2 or 3 days a week to do something just for me. To not feel reliant on DH. To not feel like my career will never recover. To use my brain! But it just feels like the world of work isn't set up for people with kids, and that even working p/t would add a massive amount of stress to our lives. Anyone have any thoughts / advice / wisdom?

OP posts:
NorthernLights5 · 14/05/2022 17:49

I will add to my previous post that neither my partner or I stopped working at any point so we were able to negotiate a 4 on, 4 off pattern opposite each other, both working 12 hour shifts (due to the nature of our work we sometimes have to stay a bit extra). We don't see each other as much as we'd like but whilst the children are young it suits us and our annual leave is very precious. We couldn't afford childcare for 3 children and the children have the advantage of having a parent look after them at all times.

Would this be an option? It may become an option once you've established yourself in a role.

NorthernLights5 · 14/05/2022 18:00

I've also never known any of the working parents I know to have their relationship with their children consist of "chucking food at them" then putting them to bed. In fact they often do more activities and are more focussed because they value their time with them.

NumberCurtains · 14/05/2022 18:02

It can be tricky to deal with the multiple bouts of illness at this age without either a very flexible employer and family/friends nearby who are happy to help out along with a partner who is committed to sharing the load. It would be much better if employers were forced to offer more flexibility though.

It is doable. Not easy but doable. Literally millions of us do it. Some of us work or study full time with small children. It's 100 per cent worth the struggle. For your financial and emotional independence, your career and personal development, your future prospects, for relationship equality, as an example for your children and for a gazillion other reasons.

It may be worth reflecting on why you don't like the idea of your children being in childcare 8-4. What are your specific concerns? Will you miss them, will they miss you? Do you think they will find it tiring? Is it some other reason? Is it just plain old sexist mum guilt? Do you think there could be any benefits for sending them to nursery for these hours so you can work (e.g. socialisation, more earning power for your family, increased financial security, your partner having to be more involved - could make him a better dad/his relationship with his children stronger etc)?

I

Tamzo85 · 14/05/2022 18:46

I think it’s often overlooked on these posts when talking about “earning potential” that quite often two people trying to slog it out and earn more around each other’s schedules and the schedule of children can actually have the opposite effect. If my husband had of been doing half childcare I doubt he would have progressed as far in his career as he did or been able to concentrate singlemindedly on that side of things and our earnings would have been much smaller. It doesn’t usually follow that two part time jobs pay more than one full time one - when that one has the potential to increase exponentially.

Then when you end up with a greater income you can actually afford something to make parenting a little less stressful like a housekeeper to help that side of things, and a nanny on some days so you don’t have to wake up and can have lie ins then be the best parent you can be because your rested. Or have a few days for a me time hobby like riding or whatever your hobby is - you may even find one.

But that could never happen with two full time workers who can’t give their all to career unless they neglect their children and can’t give their all to children because of career - and on top of that will have to pay for childcare they struggle to afford, when if they had of concentrated on one of the careers and split their efforts - they may actually be able to afford care in the home so that their children could be looked after in their own hom while they did something more stinulating that wasn’t just the drudgery of some office job.

MissusMaisel · 14/05/2022 19:17

Tamzo85 · 14/05/2022 16:25

@Booboobibles

It’a no way to live and sounds like hell. Plus it must be so horrible for the kids.

This times 1000. Constantly rushed of your feet and involving the kids in the whirlwind of hurrying too and fro from this minder to that. Not for me.

How sneery and judgemental. And absolute horseshit.

Villagewaspbyke · 14/05/2022 19:18

Tamzo85 · 14/05/2022 18:46

I think it’s often overlooked on these posts when talking about “earning potential” that quite often two people trying to slog it out and earn more around each other’s schedules and the schedule of children can actually have the opposite effect. If my husband had of been doing half childcare I doubt he would have progressed as far in his career as he did or been able to concentrate singlemindedly on that side of things and our earnings would have been much smaller. It doesn’t usually follow that two part time jobs pay more than one full time one - when that one has the potential to increase exponentially.

Then when you end up with a greater income you can actually afford something to make parenting a little less stressful like a housekeeper to help that side of things, and a nanny on some days so you don’t have to wake up and can have lie ins then be the best parent you can be because your rested. Or have a few days for a me time hobby like riding or whatever your hobby is - you may even find one.

But that could never happen with two full time workers who can’t give their all to career unless they neglect their children and can’t give their all to children because of career - and on top of that will have to pay for childcare they struggle to afford, when if they had of concentrated on one of the careers and split their efforts - they may actually be able to afford care in the home so that their children could be looked after in their own hom while they did something more stinulating that wasn’t just the drudgery of some office job.

sounds a bit like letting men away without doing their share while sacrificing women’s career and financial future though. I am a high earner and worked with a lot of male high earners. Quite a few of the men have spouses who don’t work but I have only ever come across one woman with a non working spouse.

Funnily enough, my female colleagues just had to get on with managing childcare and home with work demands. Many of the men however, didn’t seem to manage it. I wonder what would happen if we didn’t tolerate that? Whether their jobs would still be too important for them to do their share (despite their female colleagues managing fine)?

Villagewaspbyke · 14/05/2022 19:20

Also why do we judge men who don’t look after their children so favourably if they are working when women are considered neglectful if they do the same?

notanothertakeaway · 14/05/2022 19:23

Tamzo85 · 14/05/2022 10:58

@Mumwantingtogetitright

I suppose the thing about making it a binary choice is that then everyone knows where they stand and what their schedule will be. Just my opinion but when you kind of have one foot in career and one as a SAHM and then DH is supposed to cut hours here or there or to organise time off work to do more babysitting - that way of life involves a lot of organising and leads to disagreement and stress.

Maybe some can make it work, idk, I just know I would find it hard as kids throw you curveballs and when one person knows they will be the main one to deal with that it’s a little easier imo - otherwise you get into the situation of both people seeing who can organise time off etc. - it adds a lot of stress. I suppose it depends on the personalities involved but I can’t imagine living like that, it sounds like endless stress.

@Tamzo85

It's not "babysitting" when it's your own child

SoggyPaper · 14/05/2022 19:49

Villagewaspbyke · 14/05/2022 19:20

Also why do we judge men who don’t look after their children so favourably if they are working when women are considered neglectful if they do the same?

Because the bar for men is subterranean. And far too many women seem
desperate to keep it that way. In fact, they think women are unreasonable for expecting anything of men at all.

It’s beyond depressing.

Tamzo85 · 14/05/2022 20:34

Villagewaspbyke · 14/05/2022 19:18

sounds a bit like letting men away without doing their share while sacrificing women’s career and financial future though. I am a high earner and worked with a lot of male high earners. Quite a few of the men have spouses who don’t work but I have only ever come across one woman with a non working spouse.

Funnily enough, my female colleagues just had to get on with managing childcare and home with work demands. Many of the men however, didn’t seem to manage it. I wonder what would happen if we didn’t tolerate that? Whether their jobs would still be too important for them to do their share (despite their female colleagues managing fine)?

@Villagewaspbyke

Ot may sound like that to you, but it’s definetly not what I meant - There is no “sacrificing womens financial future” when my husbands financial future and theirs are the same.

The point is you say those women just “get on with managing home and work demands” - well when you have a split division you don’t have to just manage or slog it out, it’s much easier, that’s the whole point. It’s easier for the husband (or I guess wife if the roles are reversed though I’ve never seen it with high earners) when he is home and at work because he doesn’t have other stresses and it’s easier for the wife because she doesn’t have other stresses AND can use that extra money to get actual day in day out help with the children at home to make her life easier, instead of having to use up that help when she’s at work and then have no time for herself between work and kids.

Also the thing you overlook is there is no sacrifice if you don’t really want the whole career thing anyway - in fact it’s a boon to have a relationship which brings out the best in both and you get the benifets of a career without the boredom of actually having to have one and you can give your kids your best with time left over. So there really is no “we” who tolerate this begrudgingly who are going to stop doing so, because plenty of people think there’s absolutely nothing wrong with it at all - and for us it’s the right thing to do and something good.

Team work makes the dream work after all.

Tamzo85 · 14/05/2022 20:43

Villagewaspbyke · 14/05/2022 19:20

Also why do we judge men who don’t look after their children so favourably if they are working when women are considered neglectful if they do the same?

@Villagewaspbyke

I don’t think any working parent is neglectful if the other parent does the lions share of the day to day stuff, regardless of sex. I’ve just never seen it work in reverse that’s all, maybe it can, though probably a lower proportion of men are cut out for it.

If a man wants to take on that role and a woman is happy with that, good for them, sincerely. From what I’ve seen though less men want to do it and less women want that full time carer role from a man while they work full time (also complicated if planning on having babies over the course of a few years) - so you have less men wanting to do the main parenting role and less women wanting men like that - so that means that the chances the two who do want to live that female earner and male carer life will find each other and be compatible are somewhat slim. Most higher earning women seem to want similar in a man, whereas men not so much.

Pinkyxx · 14/05/2022 20:46

I became a single mum when my daughter was 2 and continued to work full time. I've worked full time my entire adult life, with the exception of 9 months maternity leave. My daughter was in childcare 5 days a week from age 10 months, longer hours than you mention and I certainly don't believe our life consisted of me chucking some food at her and putting her to bed.

YABU - it's perfectly doable, millions of parents do it, millions of single parents do it.

Meadmaiden · 14/05/2022 20:58

Yabu. I have small children and work long hours. It's possible, and lots of mother's do it. I do think you are overly dramatising a little.

It is tiring, but my children benefit from the socialisation and activities in childcare and seeing their mother set a good example by being financially independent. I benefit from adult interaction, and having a career.

Classicblunder · 14/05/2022 21:24

@Tamzo85 I would definitely progress faster in my career if my DH was a SAHD and vice versa. But not to the tune of each other's full salary and especially not when you take into account that two earners are more tax efficient and get two pensions.

I am sure there exist couples where one has huge earning potential and the other does not but I have to say that I don't know any - most couples I know earn about the same

gymNamaste · 14/05/2022 22:06

I do think the commute is too much, is it such a place you can ask to WFH predominantly? That would give you a much better work life balance.

I personally think kids need to be at home until 2. I'm sure there are studies supporting this that pre-two childcare isn't beneficial but post two it is. Of course I understand that some families need to work, but childcare is such a massive bill I'm surprised how many mums go back to work after mat leave. But I totally get you on the wanting to an adult time and engage your brain. I adore my kids but i do find it quite boring playing at home, and going out is great but exhausting managing the behaviour, roads, especially with two.

Hastingsontheup · 14/05/2022 22:30

Quite a few of the men have spouses who don’t work but I have only ever come across one woman with a non working spouse.

I work with 3 women whose husbands either dom't work or do very very part time.

surreygirl1987 · 14/05/2022 23:14

You are being overdramatic. It is hard, yes - but not impossible. My husband and I both work full time and we have a 1 year old and a 3 year old. They go to nursery while we go to work. They do 8am-6pm (they used to do 7:30am-6pm). Yes they are long days, but they love it, are so well looked after, and are doing so well there. It works for us. We don't have any family nearby to help.

addictedtotheflats · 14/05/2022 23:17

I thought this was normal. My 3 year old goes 7-6 two days a week increasing to 3 days from september. He loves it and has been going since 10 months. I arrange my shifts so hes in nursery on my days of occasionally. I know, terrible 😄

DixonD · 14/05/2022 23:33

It’s much harder, I’ve found, once they start school to work, even part time. I only work 14 hours a week but it sometimes clashes with school stuff and it’s such a pain. Also. Having the time to do everything. It was so much easier to work (I worked 16 hours before they started school, so fewer now) when they were still under school age. I had family doing childcare though.

NorthernLights5 · 14/05/2022 23:59

There is no “sacrificing womens financial future” when my husbands financial future and theirs are the same.
it’s a boon to have a relationship which brings out the best in both and you get the benifets of a career without the boredom of actually having to have one and you can give your kids your best with time left over. If he decides to leave it is no longer your career or financial future though, is it? You have to start your career whilst he has benefited from you being at home. Or if he becomes too ill to work you're left with either benefits or a likely very low income. I wouldn't feel secure without my own income. You also have few options to leave if you want to or he becomes abusive, for example. Also, many women don't find the idea of having a career "boring".

Schoolchoicesucks · 15/05/2022 00:13

Tamzo85 · 14/05/2022 18:46

I think it’s often overlooked on these posts when talking about “earning potential” that quite often two people trying to slog it out and earn more around each other’s schedules and the schedule of children can actually have the opposite effect. If my husband had of been doing half childcare I doubt he would have progressed as far in his career as he did or been able to concentrate singlemindedly on that side of things and our earnings would have been much smaller. It doesn’t usually follow that two part time jobs pay more than one full time one - when that one has the potential to increase exponentially.

Then when you end up with a greater income you can actually afford something to make parenting a little less stressful like a housekeeper to help that side of things, and a nanny on some days so you don’t have to wake up and can have lie ins then be the best parent you can be because your rested. Or have a few days for a me time hobby like riding or whatever your hobby is - you may even find one.

But that could never happen with two full time workers who can’t give their all to career unless they neglect their children and can’t give their all to children because of career - and on top of that will have to pay for childcare they struggle to afford, when if they had of concentrated on one of the careers and split their efforts - they may actually be able to afford care in the home so that their children could be looked after in their own hom while they did something more stinulating that wasn’t just the drudgery of some office job.

I don't neccessarily disagree with you, that total commitment to one person's career can allow them to earn more than 2 who are both juggling. Though it's clearly not relevant for all careers. But how do you decide which one puts the grind and hours and stress into a high-flying career and who stays home with the nappies and household chores and a maybe promise that one of you will end up with time for hobbies? Neither choice really appeal to me.

Okaaaay · 15/05/2022 00:32

Very normal. None of my friends are SAHM - all work PT/FT and all have 2/3 young children. I work FT with two under 6. My youngest goes to nursery 8.30-5.45 four days a week. It is brutal and I wouldn’t recommend FT but 21 hours would be doable. Any chance of one day from home? Even better as 6 hours of travel on top is chunky. Ask for what you need to make it work (when they have offered the role).

SoggyPaper · 15/05/2022 06:30

NorthernLights5 · 14/05/2022 23:59

There is no “sacrificing womens financial future” when my husbands financial future and theirs are the same.
it’s a boon to have a relationship which brings out the best in both and you get the benifets of a career without the boredom of actually having to have one and you can give your kids your best with time left over. If he decides to leave it is no longer your career or financial future though, is it? You have to start your career whilst he has benefited from you being at home. Or if he becomes too ill to work you're left with either benefits or a likely very low income. I wouldn't feel secure without my own income. You also have few options to leave if you want to or he becomes abusive, for example. Also, many women don't find the idea of having a career "boring".

Oh don’t be silly. Women are property of their husbands! They’re not independent people!

Don’t want to encourage them to question the shit behaviour of men by not being utterly financially dependent on them. They need to get in the kitchen and feel happy they have a husband who never does any housework.

🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

Marvellousmadness · 15/05/2022 06:31

Of course is is tough
But we all do it

Mumwantingtogetitright · 15/05/2022 07:15

I think it's a bit of a myth that people (usually men!) with sah partners are able to progress much more quickly than people who have woh partners, and it certainly isn't the case that the majority end up earning double what they would have earned anyway. I often see that claim made by SAHPs on MN, but I don't think I know a single successful WOH partner of a SAHP who would credit their success to having a SAHP at home in the same way. If they have worked their way up to the top, they understand that there is so much more to it than simple presenteeism, not least because they're almost certainly surrounded in work by other people who have progressed equally quickly without having had a SAHP to pick up the slack.

I know a lot of people in very senior roles. A lot of them are married to ambitious people with very successful careers of their own. Having a SAHP certainly isn't a prerequisite to success.

If you are a SAHP, you really don't have to justify your existence by pretending that you are somehow responsible for your partner's earning potential. What they earn is far more likely to be the result of their own unique skill set and the personal traits that they bring to the role, rather than the fact that they never had to leave a meeting early to collect little Johnny from school because he's ill. As an employer, I know that talented staff are hard to find and I will bend over backwards to accommodate the needs of a really good member of staff because I know that it's worth it. I have never promoted anyone simply because they work long hours or because they're always available. Tbh, the people who are in the office all hours tend to be seen as inefficient and bad at managing their time as they are rarely more productive.

It is probably true to say that, as a sahp, you may have made the journey to the top easier or less stressful for your spouse/partner, because they will not have had to think about domestic stuff, just as you haven't had to think about earning money. It is a stretch too far though to pretend that you have practically earned their money for them. I am often shocked by the SAHPs on here who are so quick to belittle their partners' success and claim all of the credit.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread