Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think even P/T work with small kids is impossible??

256 replies

LowryLowry · 14/05/2022 09:42

I have an almost 1 year old and an almost 3 year old and have been a SAHM for the last couple of years. I've been vaguely looking out for p/t jobs and have been offered an interview for one which is 21hrs per week. Good job, in the field I want, with prospects. I've been trying to work out logistics and it just seems impossible. There'd be a 1hr commute each way. So, say I worked three days a week, 8-4, and DH dropped them off and I picked them up, that still just seems like an insanely long day for them. Then I'd literally just be picking them up, chucking some food into them and putting them to bed, then repeating for another two days. Is this just the norm? Then there's the probability of them being ill, DH going on work trips (not a regular thing, but reasonably frequent) Is it worth it?? I love spending time with my kids, but find the monotony and physical exhaustion quite hard at times. I feel a bit lost and would love to have 2 or 3 days a week to do something just for me. To not feel reliant on DH. To not feel like my career will never recover. To use my brain! But it just feels like the world of work isn't set up for people with kids, and that even working p/t would add a massive amount of stress to our lives. Anyone have any thoughts / advice / wisdom?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ImaniMumsnet · 15/05/2022 17:55

Hi all, we are closing this thread while we take a look behind the scenes.

Dreamylemon · 15/05/2022 17:35

It's hard working with small children.

I did 7- 4.30 with an hour commute each way 3 days week when my children were younger. It was actually easier when they were in nursery than when they started school.

They were mega clingy babies/ toddlers but they benefited loads from nursery. I have kept my career and security and I'm so glad I did. There were times I wanted to give up ( non sleeping babies and stressful job) but I would be kicking myself if I had.

Frankola · 15/05/2022 17:16

Millions of parents do exactly this.

I work FULL TIME 😮with kids...shock horror.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 15/05/2022 17:14

brookstar · 15/05/2022 17:09

Tamzo65

Why do you feel the need to be so judgemental about women who have successful careers ? Why are you assuming that the children of two career parents are unhappy? You sound so patronising

I think she just sounds ignorant tbh of what life is actually like for most people. It's like she has bought into a particular view of how relationships and families work and she can't see beyond it.

brookstar · 15/05/2022 17:09

Tamzo65

Why do you feel the need to be so judgemental about women who have successful careers ? Why are you assuming that the children of two career parents are unhappy? You sound so patronising

LadyWhistledownsPen · 15/05/2022 16:59

I do 21hrs a week Tues-Thurs. My kids are in nursery 7:30-5:00. I get about 1hr 45 mins with them before bedtime. It's not great but then they spend Fri-Mon all-day with me. Plus I have to work, I don't have the option to be a SAHM.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 15/05/2022 16:38

Tamzo85 · 15/05/2022 16:19

@Mumwantingtogetitright

I accept it can happen but I think it’s rarer for it to be happy and to last happy. But it can happen if two people are both those highly motivated organised types with a lot of energy needed for all the ferrying to and fro and such. And that if those same people are incredibly good at getting along in stressful times and being ok with re organising around each other’s and the children schedules and this being their way of life. Then I accept that they can be happily married. I can’t imagine it, but I can accept other people may feel that way.

What I can’t accept is that children are really happy doing long days in care or nursery - as some have said 5 days a week 8 to 6. Forget the eventual outcomes - I don’t believe children are happy that way or that it’s best for them and I don’t care what anyone says, I never will. Just my opinion.
And because of that I could never be as happy knowing it.

So don’t take offense but not really, no. I accept they can turn out alright and can be happy - but “every bit as happy and successful” (sucess being defined as more than just parent combined income). Short answer, no.

But don’t be offended by that, it doesn’t mean I don’t like them or can’t even be friends with them, but those are my private thoughts. Sure as hell people have no trouble here talking down on SAHM in a snide way (and they know what they’re doing).

Oh, I'm not offended in the slightest because I know that you're wrong, and I can see that you're still stuck on this bizarre assumption that it's a binary choice between being a SAHP and 8-6pm childcare 5 days a week. I'm just bemused that people still think mums WOH is damaging to the children when there is so much evidence to the contrary.

I feel a bit sorry for you tbh if that's actually your view. I have no issue with people actively choosing to be a SAHP because that's what they really want in life, and I can see how that might suit some people, even if it isn't what I might choose for myself. However, choosing it as a preferred lifestyle just because you want to is very different from feeling that you would be compromising your children's happiness or wellbeing somehow by making a different choice. That leaves you without much real choice at all, and it sounds very limiting.

It just makes me very thankful tbh that I know my dd will never feel limited by such beliefs because she has seen first hand that it's perfectly possible to have a career and a happy family life with equally positive outcomes for the children. If she chooses to combine work and kids, or if she chooses to be a SAHP, I will at least know that it is a free choice and not because of any misplaced guilt or limiting beliefs.

NerrSnerr · 15/05/2022 16:28

Didn't mean that stray apostrophe!!

NerrSnerr · 15/05/2022 16:28

Sure as hell people have no trouble here talking down on SAHM in a snide way (and they know what they’re doing).

And people do exactly the same for working mum's and know exactly what they're doing.

Some children are unhappy in childcare, some are not. Mine loved it. Some children with SAHP would be happier or better off in childcare (the 2 year old funding is to get children into childcare as it benefits the child).

Tamzo85 · 15/05/2022 16:19

@Mumwantingtogetitright

I accept it can happen but I think it’s rarer for it to be happy and to last happy. But it can happen if two people are both those highly motivated organised types with a lot of energy needed for all the ferrying to and fro and such. And that if those same people are incredibly good at getting along in stressful times and being ok with re organising around each other’s and the children schedules and this being their way of life. Then I accept that they can be happily married. I can’t imagine it, but I can accept other people may feel that way.

What I can’t accept is that children are really happy doing long days in care or nursery - as some have said 5 days a week 8 to 6. Forget the eventual outcomes - I don’t believe children are happy that way or that it’s best for them and I don’t care what anyone says, I never will. Just my opinion.
And because of that I could never be as happy knowing it.

So don’t take offense but not really, no. I accept they can turn out alright and can be happy - but “every bit as happy and successful” (sucess being defined as more than just parent combined income). Short answer, no.

But don’t be offended by that, it doesn’t mean I don’t like them or can’t even be friends with them, but those are my private thoughts. Sure as hell people have no trouble here talking down on SAHM in a snide way (and they know what they’re doing).

Mumwantingtogetitright · 15/05/2022 16:02

Also not to be rude but you talk about how hard it is but how it can be done, and you talk about not crediting your partner for your career, and you say this as though this lead to a successful home life and yet you also say you are a single mum so….

Wow, @Tamzo85 , you're really invested in WOHMs having a miserable home life, aren't you? You have no idea why @Villagewaspbyke became a single mum. She might have been widowed, he might have been abusive. There is no reason to assume that the marriage broke down because she worked or because she didn't credit him with her success at work just because he did a bit of extra laundry. FFS!

Do you accept that it's possible for families with two WOHPs to be every bit as happy and successful as families with a SAHP? Or are you still convinced that it's somehow "against nature"?

Tamzo85 · 15/05/2022 15:46

Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 13:49

Why do you think your dh couldn’t have been successful on his own? Does he have any female colleagues?

are you retired now?

most high achieving females I know are married to high achieving men too. It can be hard to balance things but very possible to do it successfully. also I can tell you from the higher earners perspective that I certainly didn’t consider my partner should get credit for my career success because he did more childcare or the laundry. I did it. Not him. I don’t think men feel any differently.

I’m a single mum now and I’ve managed to work and raise dds. I’m pretty proud of that. I wouldn’t be proud of living off someone else for my adult life but each to their own.

@Villagewaspbyke

That was auto correct - I meant to say he could have been successful on his own (in his career) but WE couldn’t have been successful as a family and that (for him) would have been empty success and he probably wouldn’t have been happy and then who knows what he would or wouldn’t have continued doing?

I also think your dead wrong about high earning men not seeing or valuing their SAHM partners as valuable in their sucess. This isn’t PC but from what I’ve seen these men are happy to credit their wives with a lot of influence and responsibility for their sucees - it’s usually the higher earning women who have trouble appreciating men in this role. Whether that’s ingrained naturally or because it seems alien to them I don’t know. But it’s like you say, most of the high earning women you know have high earning husbands, because that is the kind of man who appeals to high earning women, but high earning men are no more likely to be attracted to high earning women than they are SAHM, or even as we used to say (and you’ll probably hate this), ladies of leisure. Perhaps they’re even less so.

You yourself say it can be “hard to balance”. It wasn’t hard for me, there was nothing to balance, there was a clear separation of roles (in the main though I guess my husband did do some things at home, reading stories to our kids, some home maintenance, not to mention that because of his work we were able to afford some help). That’s my point. I think a lot of people are happier like that, where expectations are known and not ever changing.

Also not to be rude but you talk about how hard it is but how it can be done, and you talk about not crediting your partner for your career, and you say this as though this lead to a successful home life and yet you also say you are a single mum so….

And yes I would say my husband had success at home.

I’m also not to afraid of being left by my 72 year old husband of 40 years lol, so I think I’ll be alright there. And believe me, it certainly feels like our money. Well except for our seperate fuck money lol. Fyi, that’s money I do whatever the fuck I want with no matter how frivolous.

Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 13:59

Tbf I’d probably like to spend all week horse riding too. But it wouldn’t make me a better (or worse) parent.

while sometimes I think it might be nice not to work if I could afford it, to me living off someone else wouldn’t be an option. It wouldn’t feel like my money or an equal partnership.

Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 13:54

Also @Tamzo85 - why don’t you think you can have a successful home life with children in childcare? They’re at school most of the time anyway. How much time did your dh spend with them? Did he have “success at home”?

Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 13:49

Tamzo85 · 15/05/2022 07:39

@Mumwantingtogetitright

Perhaps some people do claim credit for their partners work success. That wasn’t what I was saying in my post - my husband couldn’t have been successful on his own and was already on the path to that when I met him, but I can certainly claim a lot of credit for OUR family’s success and for his success actually having meaning and value to both of us and our children, rather than just being empty.

The main thing I was trying to say wasn’t that people can’t be successful single, but rather that both partners trying to work full time and work in childcare around that, or both drop hours has the potential to hold them back in their career. Especially if they’re adjusting their work choices based on family and vice versa. Plus I don’t define sucess as just success at work, it’s also about how do you have success at work AND success at home, to me one partner focusing on career and one on family is the easiest way to do that.

You say you know successful people who also have very ambitious partners as well and I don’t doubt that those couples can both Be be very successful at work - however their children will be spending long hours in care by neccissity and hurried around - and to me that isn’t sucess at home though others may disagree. So to me that’s neglecting your successful home life for a successful career life. And when I say “your”, I mean the couple together as a unit.

It really seems like some FT working Mums want to misrepresent the actual views of SAHM or make them out to be naive dummies, especially when they are in wealthy families. Perhaps it’s out of jealousy or insecurity, I don’t know.

Call me naive but I’ve managed to raise a happy family of 6 and have a long marriage, seen more of the world than most people will ever do, been horse riding 3 days a well for the last 40 years (sans pregnant time) and all without a career. I think I’m doing all-fucking-right!

Why do you think your dh couldn’t have been successful on his own? Does he have any female colleagues?

are you retired now?

most high achieving females I know are married to high achieving men too. It can be hard to balance things but very possible to do it successfully. also I can tell you from the higher earners perspective that I certainly didn’t consider my partner should get credit for my career success because he did more childcare or the laundry. I did it. Not him. I don’t think men feel any differently.

I’m a single mum now and I’ve managed to work and raise dds. I’m pretty proud of that. I wouldn’t be proud of living off someone else for my adult life but each to their own.

Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 13:42

Also @Tamzo85 - why isn’t it important for your dh to give the kids his best? Why is it ok for him to work all the time?

Villagewaspbyke · 15/05/2022 13:39

Tamzo85 · 14/05/2022 20:34

@Villagewaspbyke

Ot may sound like that to you, but it’s definetly not what I meant - There is no “sacrificing womens financial future” when my husbands financial future and theirs are the same.

The point is you say those women just “get on with managing home and work demands” - well when you have a split division you don’t have to just manage or slog it out, it’s much easier, that’s the whole point. It’s easier for the husband (or I guess wife if the roles are reversed though I’ve never seen it with high earners) when he is home and at work because he doesn’t have other stresses and it’s easier for the wife because she doesn’t have other stresses AND can use that extra money to get actual day in day out help with the children at home to make her life easier, instead of having to use up that help when she’s at work and then have no time for herself between work and kids.

Also the thing you overlook is there is no sacrifice if you don’t really want the whole career thing anyway - in fact it’s a boon to have a relationship which brings out the best in both and you get the benifets of a career without the boredom of actually having to have one and you can give your kids your best with time left over. So there really is no “we” who tolerate this begrudgingly who are going to stop doing so, because plenty of people think there’s absolutely nothing wrong with it at all - and for us it’s the right thing to do and something good.

Team work makes the dream work after all.

Yeah your husbands financial future and yours is the same at the moment perhaps. It’s not even just that half of all marriages end in divorce- marriages with such financial inequality tend to have a pretty unequal power balance. Even if the man is not entirely calling the shots he gets the final decision. I wouldn’t want to live like that.

I get it that you say you never really had much of a career so are not giving anything up. But that’s quite different from what you said before- that it just works better if only one party works.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 15/05/2022 13:27

Frankly, I would challenge anyone to meet my daughter and tell me that we have not "succeeded" at home. Whatever that means.

Whether you measure the success (or otherwise) of a parent by looking at the "end product" (ie how the child turned out) or whether you measure it in in terms of how positively the child themselves reflects on their childhood and on their relationship with their parents, it does not seem that either SAHPs or WOHPs have a monopoly on "successful" parenting. There are so many more important variables at play than whether both parents work or not.

brookstar · 15/05/2022 13:13

You say you know successful people who also have very ambitious partners as well and I don’t doubt that those couples can both Be be very successful at work - however their children will be spending long hours in care by neccissity and hurried around - and to me that isn’t sucess at home though others may disagree

You object to sweeping generalisations about SAHPs yet here you are making assumptions about families with two parents working in successful careers. 🤷🏼‍♀️

brookstar · 15/05/2022 13:10

I'm surprised how many mums go back to work after mat leave.

It's really not that surprising.
Many households need two incomes
Enhanced maternity benefits often require you to return for a certain length of time.
It's not possible to take a two year career break in many sectors
Many women enjoy work and want to progress their careers

Do you find it surprising that so many men carry on working once they've had children?

As for childcare not being beneficial for under twos - while the research shows it's not adding any benefits, it also shows that it's not detrimental. The key is good quality childcare.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 15/05/2022 12:38

Tamzo85 · 15/05/2022 07:39

@Mumwantingtogetitright

Perhaps some people do claim credit for their partners work success. That wasn’t what I was saying in my post - my husband couldn’t have been successful on his own and was already on the path to that when I met him, but I can certainly claim a lot of credit for OUR family’s success and for his success actually having meaning and value to both of us and our children, rather than just being empty.

The main thing I was trying to say wasn’t that people can’t be successful single, but rather that both partners trying to work full time and work in childcare around that, or both drop hours has the potential to hold them back in their career. Especially if they’re adjusting their work choices based on family and vice versa. Plus I don’t define sucess as just success at work, it’s also about how do you have success at work AND success at home, to me one partner focusing on career and one on family is the easiest way to do that.

You say you know successful people who also have very ambitious partners as well and I don’t doubt that those couples can both Be be very successful at work - however their children will be spending long hours in care by neccissity and hurried around - and to me that isn’t sucess at home though others may disagree. So to me that’s neglecting your successful home life for a successful career life. And when I say “your”, I mean the couple together as a unit.

It really seems like some FT working Mums want to misrepresent the actual views of SAHM or make them out to be naive dummies, especially when they are in wealthy families. Perhaps it’s out of jealousy or insecurity, I don’t know.

Call me naive but I’ve managed to raise a happy family of 6 and have a long marriage, seen more of the world than most people will ever do, been horse riding 3 days a well for the last 40 years (sans pregnant time) and all without a career. I think I’m doing all-fucking-right!

Of course you're doing alright. If you're happy and your set-up works for your family, then that is the very definition of alright.

I am certainly not judging, but I'm not jealous or insecure either. I am merely addressing some of the erroneous assumptions that some sahms seem to make with regards to wohps.

It simply isn't true that two careers necessarily mean that your kids will inevitably spend long hours in childcare and get rushed around etc. Thanks to flexible working, that hasn't been our experience at all, as I have outlined above. DD never spent more than four hours in childcare on any given day, and that was with a nanny in our own home. Even that had become unnecessary by the time she started school. It seems that you're very eager to prove that the dc of dual career parents must be missing out in some way, but they're really not. DD is nearly an adult now; she is happy and thriving, confident and secure, and has a fantastically close relationship with both of her parents. She was never rushed around, she never spent long days in childcare and she never had to manage without us at school events etc. She has had two interested and involved parents who have always been able to put her needs first.

To be honest, I am so often bemused by the characterisation of life as a working parent that I see here in MN. This idea that we barely see our kids and that they spend their lives being shuttled from one form of childcare to another. I wonder if perhaps the WOHP in families with one SAHP must disengage from family life to such an extent that the SAHP just assumes that it's normal for all WOHPs to be quite disconnected from their kids, and that that disconnection is just an inevitable feature of having a career. That really isn't true in my experience, though. Yes, there are families who put their kids in childcare for very long days every day of the week, but they are not the norm...most people are eager to minimise the childcare costs if nothing else! And yes, there are families who are a bit chaotic and rush their kids around in a big whirlwind of stress, but those are the really extreme examples and not typical at all. The vast majority of families with two WOHPs really aren't like that. Yes, they have to be organised and yes they have to negotiate a bit with their employers, but the majority of dual career families that we know use flexible working to work around each other so that they are both able to achieve a sensible balance between work and family life. Their kids get plenty of time and attention from their parents, and lead happy, balanced lives.

FWIW, I don't see success in terms of career only either. My family is and always has been my absolute first priority, and I have never hesitated to drop everything for dd if I have needed to. These days, I am more likely to drop everything in order to provide assistance to my elderly parents, but the same principle applies. This hasn't held me back in my career in the slightest, but it does mean that, as an employer, I recognise that each and every one of my employees will have lives and priorities outside of work as well, whether they have kids or not. I know that I will get the very best out of those employees if they feel able to balance their work with their other commitments. I don't need them to sign over their entire lives to work, and actually, I don't want that because I don't think it's very healthy and it doesn't lead to a particularly engaged or creative workforce.

I'm genuinely glad that you are happy with how your life has turned out. I'm glad that your family is happy, and that you feel that you have given your kids a great start in life. You don't have to justify the choices that you've made or defend them in any way. I am very happy with my choices too. My dd is thriving, and I feel that she has enjoyed the kind of ideal childhood that I had envisaged for her. Neither way is inherently "better" for the kids. Neither way is "against nature" as you previously suggested. They are just personal choices about the lives that we want for ourselves.

Sinthie · 15/05/2022 09:15

A 3 day working week sounds great.

whiteroseredrose · 15/05/2022 09:12

GarlicGnocchi · 14/05/2022 10:04

Completely normal. They aren't just shut in a room at nursery. They'll love it. Loads of entertaining things to do, crafts, food, other children.

Give it a go. If it doesn't work you can leave.

My DS loved nursery but DD hated it. Even after 6 months there she was still howling 45 mins after drop off and couldn't get out of there fast enough, which is why I became a SAHM.

Depending on where you live, school is a lot less flexible than a private nursery and throws up different problems.

When I wanted to go back to work I trained as a Teaching Assistant and worked P/T in a local school so that I could still be there for the school gate and holidays.

RidingMyBike · 15/05/2022 09:03

gymNamaste · 14/05/2022 22:06

I do think the commute is too much, is it such a place you can ask to WFH predominantly? That would give you a much better work life balance.

I personally think kids need to be at home until 2. I'm sure there are studies supporting this that pre-two childcare isn't beneficial but post two it is. Of course I understand that some families need to work, but childcare is such a massive bill I'm surprised how many mums go back to work after mat leave. But I totally get you on the wanting to an adult time and engage your brain. I adore my kids but i do find it quite boring playing at home, and going out is great but exhausting managing the behaviour, roads, especially with two.

Because if you don't go back to work after maternity leave you usually have to pay back any enhanced pay you received? And if you wait until two for them to start at nursery you've then got to find a new job, whereas if you go back to work after maternity you go back to your existing one, already have the right to request flexible working and are 'known'. My job is very niche. Think only 4-5 suitable jobs advertised a year across the entire U.K. If I'd left, I probably wouldn't have got back in again, whereas going back after maternity leave and keeping going at the same level until school age meant I was then able to get a much better job/promotion. So, much more beneficial for my family.

I didn't want to put a baby under one into nursery so took the full year's maternity, then she went three days a week. I now wish I'd started her off with a half day at six weeks. We had no family support and nursery became the extended family we didn't have - trusted adults in DD's life, a great source of advice and support and suddenly the option to have some childfree time by using annual leave whilst she was there.

CharSiu · 15/05/2022 08:43

Everyones set up is slightly different. I worked FT but had money to pay a cleaner and a DH who though often overseas did his share when he was around. One thing that is very personal is a persons mindset and efficiency levels.

The Mother I admired the most and really had no idea how she did it was a friend of a friend. She was a nurse in a private school and her accommodation was tied to her job. She had three children in quick succession by choice and then had surprise twins. She had 5 children under 7.

I am one of six. My Mother had a really decent professional career and my elderly Grandmother to look after. To be honest the way she managed all that whilst still looking perfectly coiffured was amazing.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread