Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH doesn't want a baby, or to use a condom...

217 replies

coracrawley1 · 08/02/2022 06:46

My DH and I have one child.

He loves being a dad, but says he is done, and doesn't want anymore. He talks openly about getting the snip and contraception being his responsibility now, though hasn't done anything about it. I'm sure he would get it if I looked into it, arranged appointments, essentially nagged him into actually doing it and organised it all - however, I would like us to have another child if possible, so I selfishly haven't pressed this at all, and am just letting him happily procrastinate!

I stopped taking the pill about a year before conceiving our DS, and in that time realised the effect it had been having on my body... skin, sex drive, moods, etc. I spoke to DH openly about it when our DS was born and said I didn't want to go back on hormonal contraception, so he knows I am not taking anything and am essentially leaving it up to him to deal with.

DH also detests condoms, and in the heat of the moment, despite me reminding him, will regularly hold off on putting one on... he seems to think pulling out is good enough, despite being well into his 30s 🤷‍♀️

AIBU to feel like, if DH is definitely done with kids, it's up to him to remember to, (and actually wear!) a condom, or organise his own vasectomy? And AIBU to keep having sex with him knowing we are essentially playing with fire and may very well conceive accidentally? He obviously knows this as much as me.

I've been pretty clear that I'd be happy if we conceived again accidentally, and I'm sick of being the one reminding him about condoms when he's the one who is necessitating them!


If you've found this page in search of condoms that have been tried and tested by fellow Mumsnet users, you might find our guide to the best condoms useful. Hope this helps! MNHQ

OP posts:
RantyAunty · 08/02/2022 10:23

You've talked to him about it. He knows and he's done nothing so crack on.

You'll be announcing your pregnancy soon and you can organise his snip during the last trimester.

Crayfishforyou · 08/02/2022 10:18

Honestly OP just tell him unless he does something about it you’re going to have another baby. End of.

Lemis · 08/02/2022 10:13

@Ducksurprise no the partner is being just as irresponsible. But someone needs to take responsibility for this baby that could very much so be brought into this situation.

It is irresponsible for the lartner to not use contraception when he doesnt want a child

As equally as it is irresponsible for op to presume her dp will just suddenly do a 180 and be happy when the child arrives

Both need to come to an understanding and agreement before this happens. Its playing with fire otherwise and op puts herself in a risky and vunerable position where she could end up pregnant and alone all because she was chancing on her partner to come around.

There are so many threads with the same narrative on here. Its just not worth it.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 08/02/2022 10:13

"The thing is I do want a baby"

So does he otherwise he wouldn't be prepared to take that risk.

Aderyn21 · 08/02/2022 09:58

This is partly why women end up so put upon and doing all the wife work - other women telling the OP it's her responsibility to do all the thinking and managing for her husband, even though he's a fully functioning adult.
I'm another one wondering why the OP has to deprive herself of sex because of choices her husband is making!

Porcupineintherough · 08/02/2022 09:56

So you are in effect trying to conceive a baby your husband says he doesn’t want?

Er, no. He is trying to conceive a baby he allegedly doesnt want.

OP sit him down and ask him what he's planning to do if you get pregnant.

Pinkpantslady · 08/02/2022 09:55

Sounds to me that you want another baby . Nothing wrong with that !
Maybe subconsciously your body is telling you to conceive before DH gets the snip and it’s too late x

Phobiaphobic · 08/02/2022 09:55

Well, he'll have to grow up, won't he? I'd just say, I'm happy to have another baby so I'm going to leave it entirely to you to prevent another pregnancy, if that's what you want.

YahBooFucks · 08/02/2022 09:54

As a little aside, the much-derided 'pull out method' worked very well for us for YEARS. When we wanted to conceive, and he stopped 'pulling out', I got pregnant straight away. I obviously wouldn't advise it as a reliable method of contraception to my son or daughter (and, now that I 100% definitely don't want any more kids myself, I'm not using it) but I think the idea that pulling out is totally useless isn't true.

Your DH doesn't sound stupid to me. He is clearly either very confident in his pulling out skills or has secretly accepted that fate may well decide that you have another baby. I'd crack on, OP.

girlmom21 · 08/02/2022 09:52

Why are people telling OP to withhold sex? She wants sex. She wants a baby.

CounsellorTroi · 08/02/2022 09:50

@coracrawley1

"This sounds pretty rapey tbh"

@thedancingbear Jesus Christ. To be clear, I'm very happy to have sex with my husband without a condom. He knows this. I'm reminding him that he should be using a condom because HE said he doesn't want any more kids!

So you are in effect trying to conceive a baby your husband says he doesn’t want?

I think the most responsible thing to do would be to say no sex until DH makes up his mind either way.

Snaketime · 08/02/2022 09:47

I asked my DH's opinion on this and he says that it is totally on him. He knows where he stands, you have made it clear. I would maybe just cover yourself, sit him down and make it clear, tell him again that you want another baby, that contraception is on him, you are not going to remind him anymore and if you get pregnant it is on him. See what he does then.

AllyBama · 08/02/2022 09:47

So what’s your AIBU?
You’re happy to get pregnant.
You think he’ll be ok with it.

Of course it’s up to him to organise his own vasectomy, or deal with the consequences if he doesn’t use a condom. Does he not agree? I fail to understand the point of this thread.

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 08/02/2022 09:43

Men are very good at pretending that pregnancy won't happen, despite having unprotected sex with no birth control involved (pulling-out doesn't count, obvs).
If he maintains that he doesn't want more children, yet is doing the above, I don't know what to say. You need to sit down (away from the bedroom) and have an actual discussion - spell it out to him that if you both continue to have unprotected sex, you will likely get pregnant, and ask how he plans to deal with that if/when it happens. It's not great that you're both having unprotected sex, with you hoping to get pregnant and him hoping not to.

Orchid876 · 08/02/2022 09:42

It's an odd one, presumably if he was really really really dead against having another child he'd wear a condom, or get the snip. I do wonder if he's struggling with the decision to have another child or not, and is letting fate be the decider. It's not exactly mature behaviour, but it's sort of understandable. As long as he doesn't use the excuse that the pregnancy was unplanned as an excuse to shirk his responsibilities later on, I'd crack on OP.

girlmom21 · 08/02/2022 09:41

@Marvellousmadness

Tell him he isn't going to have sex with you no more until he gets a vasectomy. What a manchild
Well this is counterproductive because OP wants a baby.
Marvellousmadness · 08/02/2022 09:37

Tell him he isn't going to have sex with you no more until he gets a vasectomy. What a manchild

UKorNZdilemma · 08/02/2022 09:36

@coracrawley1

Honestly I'm going to have to stop reading MN (after a million years) because the level of comprehension has fallen so far & the calls of rape (for oerfectly normal stuff couples do/say) is ridiculous. OP's having to continually repeat things they've posted because others are going off on a daft tangent... it's become entirely bonkers!!

I think your DH is probably trying to avoid the pressure to conceive or something like that.

He's an adult, he knows how babies are made & how to prevent them being made but is choosing not to prevent the possibility, when he knows you want a baby. He's making the choice to keave it up to nature. It's a shame really as it's making you unsettled and neither of you are getting to enjoy the feelings that you could be

The sensible thing is to have another conversation about 'why' he doesn't want another one, but in your situation, with your DH, I'd just be upping my chances of getting pregnant!!

girlmom21 · 08/02/2022 09:30

[quote Lemis]**@girlmom21* there would be an uproar if a guy knew his partner didnt want a baby* but clearly not respecting that, taking it seriously and putting his OWN wants over hers.

If his attitude was well i want a baby so i wl happily impregnate her i think you find people on her would be telling him off.

It should be no different for a woman[/quote]
Oh ok, so you're talking about a man who won't allow his wife to use contraception and repeatedly rapes her because he wants a baby? Not really the same, is it....

BoredZelda · 08/02/2022 09:28

If he is having unprotected sex, he can’t be too bothered about having a new baby.

gingerhills · 08/02/2022 09:28

He knows how babies are made, right? I'd stop reminding him. You want a baby. He wants to have sex without protection. He can hardly blame you if that happens., If he is absolutely certain no more children, he needs to get a vasectomy.

JonSnowIsALoser · 08/02/2022 09:27

The "rapey" comment upthread refers to the fact that if a man and a woman agree to have consensual sex with a condom, but he doesn't use one or secretly takes it off, exposing her to the risk of STD or unwanted pregnancy, it is considered rape.

It's obviously completely not relevant to OP's situation, however.

Ducksurprise · 08/02/2022 09:26

Its very blaze and irresponsible fuck me, always the woman's fault. The only person here being irresponsible is really DH.

Gonnagetgoing · 08/02/2022 09:25

hmm it's tricky. He should be sorting contraception now but he should also be thinking and chatting properly with you as to why he doesn't want another baby. Not just, he doesn't want another baby and that's that, done deal!

I also wouldn't fall pregnant accidentally and expect things to miraculously work out and no resentment on his side. That needs sorting ASAP.

I recall a few years ago I was approx 41/42 and seeing a boyfriend (had then been 4 months) - things were going really well and he said he loved me at the 3 month stage (maybe too soon but I don't think it was lovebombing).

He knew I potentially wanted kids but he had a teenager from a previous relationship and he'd also been adopted as a baby and was a bit messed up over that. He actually went along with it with me, encouraged us to try etc. Then suddenly he said no, one reason was his ex had left a lot of the "fathering" to him, shopping with baby in buggy by himself etc - probably just doing his share. But he also recalled how his son as a toddler/baby cried a lot, sleepless nights for him and he didn't want to go back there. We ended not long after that, not for this reason though.

FFW a few years, he's now married to a woman who has twin girls under 10, one of whom is seriously ill and needs regular hospital treatment and she also has a young son from another relationship. He has a very good job so is the breadwinner and his teenager is now an adult and at uni/first job. Kind of ironic that he's taken this on - the girls were approx 5-6 when he met their mum.

Lemis · 08/02/2022 09:23

My point still stands that no one should be bringing a baby into this mix until both parents are on the same wanting page as each other.

And the op should not assume her partners future feelings for him.

There is no guarantee he will be happy about ir nor accept it. Especially when he has made it clear that he doesnt want another child. Its very blaze and irresponsible of the op to just think he will come around and in that sense she isnt taking her partners feelings seriously.

Swipe left for the next trending thread