Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Hont1986 · 09/12/2021 19:35

there are no circumstances in which women can get what they NEED which is single sex spaces because you don't believe that women needing single sex spaces, even traumatised women have the political right to spaces for them?

I don't have a disagreement with single-sex spaces in theory. I think you should be able to offer your privately-run refuge/gym/support group to anyone you wish. If OP or anyone who agrees with her wants to set up their own space and offer it to the people of their choosing, then I believe she has a political right to it and will have my moral support.

Feminists set up these spaces through their blood, sweat, and tears, and shouldn't be told who they can and can't let in the spaces. In this case, the people who actually shed the blood, sweat, and tears have chosen to make the women's group open to all those who they feel are women, and not offer a cis-only group. If you disagree with it, set up your own.

Artichokeleaves · 09/12/2021 19:31

If this was a private charity operating alongside fully accessible for all females women's services funded by the LA then whatever. No problem.

It's not.

No taxation without representation. And no bloody women's services run by people who are not competent or willing to provide services to women. Its ridiculous.

Artichokeleaves · 09/12/2021 19:26

@Hont1986

I voted YABU. There were some comments earlier saying that people who voted YABU should explain why. Charities don't have unlimited resources and I don't feel you can expect them to provide additional groups that go against their moral/political beliefs at your request. So that's why.
This group is tax payer LA funded as public service for raped women.

They are not providing accessible resources for all females. They are providing no less than three varied accessible, carefully planned resources for males. Major issue number one.

They are perfectly capable of resourcing one single accessible group for females alongside their current provision. They refuse to. Major issue number two.

Political intolerance is not an acceptable reason to refuse to provide women's rape crisis services to women. Major issue number three.

Moral/political extremist beliefs have no place in public services. This is sexist, discriminatory, exclusionary and politically intolerant of other beliefs and protected characteristics. Incidentally all the female ones. It does not have the faintest vestige of a leg to stand on.

SolasAnla · 09/12/2021 19:22

@urbanbuddha

How are they different to a man who has lost his genitals to injury/illness? Because the ones I know would be very distressed and offended to be told that they are now women.

Because their desire/need to be accepted as a woman is demonstrably strong and dominates the way they live their lives. A man injured in an accident is not subject to this - it's a red herring to raise this when discussing the position of transwomen in society.

I also think that the assimilation of a transwoman into society is a process which takes time and requires empathy on all sides. It does not happen overnight.

As I said earlier I think there is room - and a great need - for much more nuanced discussion on this.

Almost everyone on this thread agrees that the presence of a penis, the lack of a penis or the surgical reconfiguration of a penis is not a deciding factor.

It about where the service allocate services and the criteria used to allocate finite resource.

It's not a red herring.
Its asking why, as you describe it, a desire/need to be accepted gives someone a higher social status that others in a community. And that is what is happening the service is gatekeeping on the basis of a male saying "I want" v a female saying "I want.

The provider has created an hierarchy.
They begin by forcing all women in the service to comply or loose access to the services. They allocate extra specialist resources too.

Excluding IamSarah is justified when a male says "I want to be recognised as a woman". She must subjugate her desire/need and instead validate a claim that that male is the same sex as IamSarah or at least passes some invisible threshold of "womanhood".

And it's not assimilation of a transwoman into society is it?
It's annihilation of the meaning of the word women and the annihilation of women as a sex class.

Empathy is not forcing IamSarah out of the service when she questions her placement in the hierarchy.
If the service refused to provide a single sex service and now no service at all, there is no all sides option.

Nuanced discussions can only start when the meaning of words can be agreed.

bloodycoldagain · 09/12/2021 19:19

@Hont1986

It was a man who was dressed as a man and male identified

No, it wasn't, it was a trans woman who presumably identified as a woman. OP claimed that they 'presented as male' because they were wearing 'male clothing' of a sweatshirt and jeans.

So does Hont believe that women's needs are always secondary to other groups' wants? Or does Hont believe that women who have been victims of male sexual violence are unreasonable to have a need for female only spaces? And how does Hont believe that one can tell 'genuine' transwomen from males who will get off from the power and control of being able to be in a room with women recounting their sexual abuse, and the women being able to do nothing about it? Or does Hont think this is an acceptable price for women to pay for the inclusion of another group?

Genuinely interested.

NeedsCharging · 09/12/2021 19:18

So Hont what you are saying is women and in this case raped women should not believe their own eyes but instead believe whatever the male infont of them says...and you still think its ok to have a male in a female rape support group?

lifeturnsonadime · 09/12/2021 19:13

So Hont1986 men who identify as women get what they want, access to single sex spaces, but there are no circumstances in which women can get what they NEED which is single sex spaces because you don't believe that women needing single sex spaces, even traumatised women have the political right to spaces for them?

Wow.

This is a man's world. You are enabling a patriarchal society where women come last. This is not progressive.

Hont1986 · 09/12/2021 19:09

It was a man who was dressed as a man and male identified

No, it wasn't, it was a trans woman who presumably identified as a woman. OP claimed that they 'presented as male' because they were wearing 'male clothing' of a sweatshirt and jeans.

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 19:08

[quote Hont1986]@ClaudiaJ1 OP was asking them to set up an additional cis-only group.

Please explain how having a safe space for women would be against anyone's "moral/political beliefs"? What moral/political beliefs are there that say women don't have the right to have a safe space? Please explain your thinking on this.
So you can go through in red pen and nitpick? Shan't, miss.[/quote]
No, I am genuinely trying to understand. Why do you think women don't deserve safe spaces?

NeedsCharging · 09/12/2021 19:07

And there was no man joining in on a women's group, because it was a woman, a trans woman. I know you don't believe that, but I and more importantly the charity providing the service do.

The OP clearly states it was a male presenting as a male.
Even if the male was a TW they had 3 I believe other groups they could get support but they chose the WOMAN only group.
The OP was expelled because they chose to support a male over a female.
It is disgusting the way males are put above females even in a rape support group.

Hont1986 · 09/12/2021 19:07

@ClaudiaJ1 OP was asking them to set up an additional cis-only group.

Please explain how having a safe space for women would be against anyone's "moral/political beliefs"? What moral/political beliefs are there that say women don't have the right to have a safe space? Please explain your thinking on this.
So you can go through in red pen and nitpick? Shan't, miss.

EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 19:04

It was a man who was dressed as a man and male identified. It wasn't a trans woman. If you can't see that it was a male who entered a woman's group to voyeuristically 'get off' on hearing trauma stories, then naive doesn't really cover it....

Men and transwomen are both male. So it does cover it. Neither should be in a woman's support group.

EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 19:02

Charities don't have unlimited resources and I don't feel you can expect them to provide additional groups that go against their moral/political beliefs at your request. So that's why.

So men take over women's support and rape crises centres. Both at the top level, and at level of service user. Suddenly women's needs don't fit in with mens moral and political needs. (You forgot to add womanly identities and fetishes here btw). So men, enabled by sheer determination and the #bekind women, get rid of the women's only groups and set them up so that voyeuristic men can get off on women's trauma and pain, inflicted for a second time. By men eager to sit back and be part of that journey. To go home and enact it out in many cases.

So which are you? A male with a special interest in women's trauma from male violence or a #bekind woman?

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 19:01

@Hont1986

You think its ok for a womans rape support group to expel a raped woman because a man wants to join in on a WOMENS rape support group... I cannot say what I want as MNHQ will delete me.

Well, they didn't expel her. OP chose to leave because she didn't find it acceptable.
And there was no man joining in on a women's group, because it was a woman, a trans woman. I know you don't believe that, but I and more importantly the charity providing the service do.

@Hont1986 It was a man who was dressed as a man and male identified. It wasn't a trans woman. If you can't see that it was a male who entered a woman's group to voyeuristically 'get off' on hearing trauma stories, then naive doesn't really cover it....
MizzFizz · 09/12/2021 19:00

If it was a male presenting as male (by that I assume you mean cis-male... Or did you mean he is a trans male?), why would he be allowed at the women's group? I'm confused...

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 18:59

@Hont1986

I voted YABU. There were some comments earlier saying that people who voted YABU should explain why. Charities don't have unlimited resources and I don't feel you can expect them to provide additional groups that go against their moral/political beliefs at your request. So that's why.
@Hont1986 They already have a female only group, they just need to enforce it. It doesn't cost any extra funding.

Please explain how having a safe space for women would be against anyone's "moral/political beliefs"? What moral/political beliefs are there that say women don't have the right to have a safe space? Please explain your thinking on this.

Hont1986 · 09/12/2021 18:57

You think its ok for a womans rape support group to expel a raped woman because a man wants to join in on a WOMENS rape support group... I cannot say what I want as MNHQ will delete me.

Well, they didn't expel her. OP chose to leave because she didn't find it acceptable.
And there was no man joining in on a women's group, because it was a woman, a trans woman. I know you don't believe that, but I and more importantly the charity providing the service do.

VestofAbsurdity · 09/12/2021 18:42

@urbanbuddha

How are they different to a man who has lost his genitals to injury/illness? Because the ones I know would be very distressed and offended to be told that they are now women.

Because their desire/need to be accepted as a woman is demonstrably strong and dominates the way they live their lives. A man injured in an accident is not subject to this - it's a red herring to raise this when discussing the position of transwomen in society.

I also think that the assimilation of a transwoman into society is a process which takes time and requires empathy on all sides. It does not happen overnight.

As I said earlier I think there is room - and a great need - for much more nuanced discussion on this.

Because their desire/need to be accepted as a woman is demonstrably strong and dominates the way they live their lives.

They have no right to dominate the way I live my life which is what they are doing. They can believe what they like about themselves they cannot force me to do so, I do not have to agree that they are women, I do not have to remove my boundaries, I do not and should not be expected to give up spaces, services and sports that are designed for my use in order to validate their view of themselves -that is authoritarian and dictatorial.

Where is their empathy for me and other women?

Where is their kindness and understanding?

It is all about them and them changing the world to revolve around them and bugger those that lose what was theirs by right of their sex.

NeedsCharging · 09/12/2021 18:41

Charities don't have unlimited resources and I don't feel you can expect them to provide additional groups that go against their moral/political beliefs at your request. So that's why.

WOW.
You think its ok for a womans rape support group to expel a raped woman because a man wants to join in on a WOMENS rape support group... I cannot say what I want as MNHQ will delete me.

Borderterrierpuppy · 09/12/2021 18:39

I am so sorry they didn’t respect your request, the world has gone completely mad.

NeedsCharging · 09/12/2021 18:39

Part of trauma of rape comes from the fact that (in most cases) the penis, the instrument of the physical expression of love, or just plain good fun, has been used as a weapon in an act of violence and degradation.

I was raped and my trauma comes from the fact a man forced his penis in side me, ejaculated, beat me and left me for dead.
My trauma comes from waiting weeks to find out if I was pregnant with my rapists baby, had a STD and being viciously questioned by police to find out if I was in some way responsible.
Women are fully aware that penises are used as weapons our trauma does not start by realising that fact ffs.

Hont1986 · 09/12/2021 18:35

I voted YABU. There were some comments earlier saying that people who voted YABU should explain why.
Charities don't have unlimited resources and I don't feel you can expect them to provide additional groups that go against their moral/political beliefs at your request. So that's why.

MrsTerryPratchett · 09/12/2021 18:32

But @urbanbuddha that woman was raped with a penis. The fact that very rare joint venture can happen doesn't mean rapes don't involve penises.

urbanbuddha · 09/12/2021 18:27

Link fail

found guilty of towpath rape

urbanbuddha · 09/12/2021 18:26

But if it's fundamentally about SEX you behave that way. And in the UK at least, rape is with a penis. It's is SEX based.

I know the thread has moved on but I often see it said on discussions around trans on MN that only people with a penis can rape. This is not the case.

From 2001
Woman found guilty of towpath rape

Part of trauma of rape comes from the fact that (in most cases) the penis, the instrument of the physical expression of love, or just plain good fun, has been used as a weapon in an act of violence and degradation. This is a betrayal that is one of the main causes of the trauma. In the above case the woman found guilty of rape had betrayed the victim in a similarly violent and degrading way despite being penis-free.

Swipe left for the next trending thread