Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are certain newspapers so against WFH?

233 replies

Circlesandtriangles · 07/12/2021 05:54

AIBU for seeing a persistent agenda in The Telegraph against working from home? It also has a completely misogynist undertone. Not everyone has to be a massive fan of it, but why work so hard to stoke up opinion against it??

Example headlines from November:

"If you want to lose your job, work from home"
"Just one in ten women working from home plan to return to office"
"Take it from a mother, working from home is a disaster for women"
"HMRC spends millions so staff can abandon offices"
"Afghan allies ‘left at the mercy of Taliban’ while civil servants worked from home"
"People working from home do half an hour less each day, study finds"
"It's high time staff returned to the office"

OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 07/12/2021 07:30

Its nicknamed the Torygraph for a reason! City centre commercial prices, the lunchtime food sector, quite a lot of retail and hospitality is very reliant on everyone returning to work predominantly in offices away from home. The people who benefit most from those businesses are wealthy investors, including older people with large invested pensions.

It's a right wing newspaper. Flexibility helps women to work, and of course the Tories would like us all back in the kitchen with the baby on our hip.

FredaFox · 07/12/2021 07:24

I can't see wfh being effective long term, I agree with a pp that customer service has dropped.
I've had months of dealing with incompetence at social services sorting assistance for my mum. People ring me, then can't answer my questions so have to ring back, if they were in an office they would just ask a colleague, I get told " I can't ring back with the answer as I have to take my son somewhere "
Sorry if you can't do your job effectively at home you should be in the bloody office

ShinyHappyPoster · 07/12/2021 07:24

@manysummersago

It’s hard to say. I’m certainly hearing a lot of ‘our services may be reduced due to the coronavirus pandemic’ and I’m still waiting for a form from teachers pensions to arrive and I asked for it some three weeks ago.

this thread was quite a read, though!

That thread was filled with people saying they were wfh but just happened to be on MN when that thread was posted 🙄 a self-selecting group with no eligibility parameters means their 'anecdotes' are statistically unimportant.

The same companies who want to dissuade the general population from wfh, and from moving to more community based initiatives etc are invested financially and emotionally in having a presence across social media.
There were and are fascinating discussions taking place about how work and society can change but you need to seek them out at universities, academic panels and political/community discussion groups.

DrBlackbird · 07/12/2021 07:24

There are good arguments for wfh and good arguments for working in the office depending on the job, person, and industry. It’s not one size fits all. But the OP specifically asked about The Telegraph and it’s decision to disparage wfh and link this with working mothers the scourge of all mankind naturally.

Let’s not forget that The Telegraph is the closest paper to state run media all the more given the love-fest between its former journalist and No 10, which has been trying to get everyone back to the office since Aug 2020. This to save Pret and Tory commercial property donors… Plus, the current cabinet do believe that we’re a national of wasters that require constant supervision to make us work.

olivehater · 07/12/2021 07:22

Right then the ones that have to go to work should be paid a premium. We don’t get to have any of this lovely flexibility and most parents in my sector have to work part time so that they can be their for their kids at least a little bit. We are also the ones having to fork out childcare. If you want to have nurses and midwives in the futureetc then you need to make that attractive too. Just saying change your job then to someone in and established career is thoughtless.

requiredusername · 07/12/2021 07:21

@Mittenmob

WFH will cause career problems for women. I think in 5/10 years time we are going to see taltent pipelines that are very different because of it.
How so?
Mittenmob · 07/12/2021 07:20

WFH will cause career problems for women. I think in 5/10 years time we are going to see taltent pipelines that are very different because of it.

requiredusername · 07/12/2021 07:19

@manysummersago

It’s hard to say. I’m certainly hearing a lot of ‘our services may be reduced due to the coronavirus pandemic’ and I’m still waiting for a form from teachers pensions to arrive and I asked for it some three weeks ago.

this thread was quite a read, though!

I think you would get this in the office though on a Friday during December, our office is so quiet but you always get a higher level of noise on a Friday as people are more chatty, people bring in cakes and hover around them catching up, there is definitely a different vibe in the office on a Friday also.
icedcoffees · 07/12/2021 07:17

Because many sectors rely on office workers being in the office, and are hugely struggling with so many people working from home. And the Telegraph is a paper that's aimed at those business owners who are struggling.

Lots of food shops and cafes, for example, would do a roaring trade at lunch with office workers getting sandwiches and soups or going for business lunches.

Likewise coffee shops with people grabbing a coffee on the way to the tube or the office.

asha456 · 07/12/2021 07:16

@olivehater

As someone who has never worked from home it pisses me off. I am still paying out childcare, petrol etc. I choose to work part time and take the equivalent pay cut that goes with that while I see people on the school run that then nip to activities/coffee shop/playground with their kids. Sure there are some that put all the hours in later but their are plenty more who don’t whilst taking a full time wage. Civil service appears to be the worst for it. If this is going to carry on then this that those that have to travel to work need to be paid a premium or no one is going to choose these careers going forward. And why the hell would you when this jobs that allow working from home have it so cushy?
I think, you don't see them working and you have no idea what hours they work. If their job wasn't getting done then I'm sure they wouldn't have the job for long.

It's a good thing if people can work flexibly, fitting things around around their family, allowing them to do simple things like take their child to the park before school, rather than sitting in a car alone for an hour emitting greenhouse gasses while their kids are looked after by someone else. Why wouldn't we want families to be able to do this?

If it looks good then you can seek a career that also offers this.

ShinyHappyPoster · 07/12/2021 07:15

There are lots of business sectors that rely on people going to work eg commercial property, retail, hospitality. Most media owners have varied investments and assets, and alliances with other business owners in other sectors.

They would prefer a burnt-out, workforce with higher Covid rates than a workforce that is questioning any aspect of the status quo.

The pandemic represented a great opportunity to restructure every aspect of society. That threatens the conglomerates and multinationals who thrive in the current system.

olivehater · 07/12/2021 07:10

As someone who has never worked from home it pisses me off. I am still paying out childcare, petrol etc. I choose to work part time and take the equivalent pay cut that goes with that while I see people on the school run that then nip to activities/coffee shop/playground with their kids. Sure there are some that put all the hours in later but their are plenty more who don’t whilst taking a full time wage. Civil service appears to be the worst for it. If this is going to carry on then this that those that have to travel to work need to be paid a premium or no one is going to choose these careers going forward. And why the hell would you when this jobs that allow working from home have it so cushy?

manysummersago · 07/12/2021 07:09

It’s hard to say. I’m certainly hearing a lot of ‘our services may be reduced due to the coronavirus pandemic’ and I’m still waiting for a form from teachers pensions to arrive and I asked for it some three weeks ago.

this thread was quite a read, though!

catgirl1976 · 07/12/2021 07:06

The Daily Mail is at it today blaming the mess in Afghanistan squarely on home working 🙄. I assume their investors are city centre landlords

KatherineJaneway · 07/12/2021 07:01

They'll push the angle their readers most want to hear.

flashbac · 07/12/2021 07:00

@manysummersago

Right, I didn’t see it happening here, somehow!

@PhilCornwall1 every time WFH is discussed on MN people say similar. They are so much more productive. Yet this doesn’t tally with my experiences to be honest. I’m certainly not saying that you personally aren’t but I think overall people may think they are more productive but aren’t.

I think it depends on the role. People in certain roles probably will be able to get more done. I certainly do. However I met someone recently who 'works' from home with no childcare for her 1 year old. Local government employee in an officer role.

I've experienced nothing but poor customer service during the pandemic. This may be because of WFH or maybe not.

I think WFH is a force for good but there needs to be a mechanism to check productivity without spying or intruding on privacy.

The TORYgraph don't like WFH because it affects commercial rents.

HellonHeels · 07/12/2021 06:59

@Bellafrenum

The owners mates own Pret?
This
rrhuth · 07/12/2021 06:56

@manysummersago

I don’t think it is at all, *@rrhuth*. New jobs come along to replace the old all the time.
Have you read much about AI/automation? The point is there is an expectation of fewer jobs overall.
indigobag · 07/12/2021 06:54

As someone who's wfh for years I certainly don't work less. I imagine it's to do with their investments going down not to mention the marked hit wfh has had on the prices and sales of London flats which a lot of people in the media who are against wfh probably own.

manysummersago · 07/12/2021 06:52

I don’t think it is at all, @rrhuth. New jobs come along to replace the old all the time.

manysummersago · 07/12/2021 06:51

Right, I didn’t see it happening here, somehow!

@PhilCornwall1 every time WFH is discussed on MN people say similar. They are so much more productive. Yet this doesn’t tally with my experiences to be honest. I’m certainly not saying that you personally aren’t but I think overall people may think they are more productive but aren’t.

rrhuth · 07/12/2021 06:50

@manysummersago

Where is a universal basic income being seriously discussed?
Think it is inevitable once automation/AI kicks in seriously.
MasterGland · 07/12/2021 06:49

@manysummersago

Where is a universal basic income being seriously discussed?
Spain, Wales, some American States.
rrhuth · 07/12/2021 06:48

Because the Telegraph is written to push an agenda that is not in the interests of working people.

Also in answer to a pp: WFH, 4 day week and UBI do not link automatically to low growth. UK has very low productivity currently, we are not a high-performing economy currently. A lot is propped up on property values.

PhilCornwall1 · 07/12/2021 06:48

"People working from home do half an hour less each day, study finds"

Hmmm, having been WFH for 14 years, I've yet to have that happen. On average it's an hour and a half more each day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread