Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 15:41

*male guides

OP posts:
Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 15:41

@Echobelly

You know I can't vouch for this woman and I take no particular view on her suitability for the role, but I am very irritated by some assumptions being made here, people seem to be lumping an awful lot of concerns they have about GG onto her on some tenuous evidence.

I am sick and tired, in this whole discussion of seeing both sides pick up on what appear to be at least partially misleading articles and not think about the context/check the facts because It Proves Their Point. I am really tired of seeing things and thinking 'OK, but I can see a massive Trans Rights bias here or a massive GC/trans-exclusionary one that's actually obscuring what's really going on'.

BDSM photo: yes, she has a sex life. BDSM doesn't mean 'into every perversion there including paedophelia'. The fact that people had to poke around her social media to find this suggest it's probably not a major part of her life anyway. The vast majority of BDSM enthusiasts are not paedophiles and regard them with the same disgust as everyone else.

Gun photo: There's a photo of my mate on holiday in Cambodia holding a loaded bazooka, but he's never blown anyone up, nor is he a 'gun nut'. So, she had a photo taken with a replica gun - that doesn't seem to be evidence of being a 'gun nut'

Signed Challenor letter: That one 1000+ people signed? www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/over-1000-people-have-signed-an-open-letter-condemning-pride-in-london-for-letting-an-anti-trans-group-lead-the-march-94296/ I actually used to be supportive of Glinner's stand for women initially, but really, trying to imply this woman is some best chum of Challenor for signing an open letter signed by 1000s is just barrel scraping and unfair. He writes about the vileness of Challenor's father in detail as though Sulley was his best mate or something. Not one of 1000s who signed an open letter that happen to have been created by his daughter, at a time it appears the Challenor scandal was not even known about, so I'm not sure how Sulley, who doesn't appear to be linked in any other way to Challenor, was to know about it. And to imply as much is plain cruel, however righteous you feel your cause is.

Who knows, maybe something truly dreadful will appear about her, because I don't know her and neither do you. Campaign against trans women being in these positions if that's how you feel, but digging up the slightest thing discredit an individual by extrapolating very thin evidence does not do your argument any credit.

@Echobelly I agree with you that some things on here lack balance, and I don't think are fair.

The photos. You can do what you like (within the law) in your bedroom. But the issue is that she put them on SM for the world to see. I think a cis-woman or man would also be criticised if she/he was a leader in a youth organisation or teacher etc. and did this.

I'm interested to see how Girlguiding responds to this. On previous experience of me and others raising concerns (and I'm not talking exclusively about their Diversity and Inclusion policy), I would not be surprised if they did nothing or did nothing quickly. Monica may be vindicated. None of us know yet. But I actually think the most important thing is how Girlguiding as an organisation responds, and if there have been failures, such as they failed to obtain references of Monica on recruitment as a volunteer (that wouldn't surprise me either), what they need to learn from this. Girlguiding don't seem to like admitting that they got things wrong.

I actually think the world needs to leave Monica alone. I'm not sure if they are, but they should be leaving her alone. If they want to take aim at anyone it should be Girlguiding. Questions need answered by Girlguiding, but I agree we don't necessarily know the outcome yet.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 15:40

@Echobelly

You know I can't vouch for this woman and I take no particular view on her suitability for the role, but I am very irritated by some assumptions being made here, people seem to be lumping an awful lot of concerns they have about GG onto her on some tenuous evidence.

I am sick and tired, in this whole discussion of seeing both sides pick up on what appear to be at least partially misleading articles and not think about the context/check the facts because It Proves Their Point. I am really tired of seeing things and thinking 'OK, but I can see a massive Trans Rights bias here or a massive GC/trans-exclusionary one that's actually obscuring what's really going on'.

BDSM photo: yes, she has a sex life. BDSM doesn't mean 'into every perversion there including paedophelia'. The fact that people had to poke around her social media to find this suggest it's probably not a major part of her life anyway. The vast majority of BDSM enthusiasts are not paedophiles and regard them with the same disgust as everyone else.

Gun photo: There's a photo of my mate on holiday in Cambodia holding a loaded bazooka, but he's never blown anyone up, nor is he a 'gun nut'. So, she had a photo taken with a replica gun - that doesn't seem to be evidence of being a 'gun nut'

Signed Challenor letter: That one 1000+ people signed? www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/over-1000-people-have-signed-an-open-letter-condemning-pride-in-london-for-letting-an-anti-trans-group-lead-the-march-94296/ I actually used to be supportive of Glinner's stand for women initially, but really, trying to imply this woman is some best chum of Challenor for signing an open letter signed by 1000s is just barrel scraping and unfair. He writes about the vileness of Challenor's father in detail as though Sulley was his best mate or something. Not one of 1000s who signed an open letter that happen to have been created by his daughter, at a time it appears the Challenor scandal was not even known about, so I'm not sure how Sulley, who doesn't appear to be linked in any other way to Challenor, was to know about it. And to imply as much is plain cruel, however righteous you feel your cause is.

Who knows, maybe something truly dreadful will appear about her, because I don't know her and neither do you. Campaign against trans women being in these positions if that's how you feel, but digging up the slightest thing discredit an individual by extrapolating very thin evidence does not do your argument any credit.

What anyone does in their private life should be private.

This persons public posts breach the GG social media policy.

They are very poor safeguarding practice. Insta is 13+ and many, if not all, job roles that involve safeguarding children have rules about unsuitable social media that children can access. It shows very poor understanding of boundaries which is a safeguarding risk. Thinking sexualised comments and photos on a public platform children can access is a problem.

Have you read all the research on paraphillias? Me neither, but I’ve waded through a fair bit of it and I know they tend to present in clusters. Paedophilla being the most common. Head over to fwr and ask them to explain the risks with paraphillias and you’ll get a very comprehensive answer from many much better versed than me.

Then there’s the risk from GG policies themselves. Male ‘women’ leaders and guides sharing tents, shower/changing blocks and toilets on camps is fine for safeguarding according to the GG policies.

And the GG policies encourage leaders to distribute contraception to 13+ children and to allow them to keep it a secret.

The one place girls were supposed to be free from sexualisation and they get handed condoms and told shhhh we won’t tell mummy if you don’t want us too. Adults teaching children to keep secrets is called grooming.

OP posts:
Terfydactyl · 24/11/2021 15:32

@MoveAhoy

There's something about someone being unsuitable for roles involving children who is found out to have volunteered to multiple children involved organisations.

I don't like it.

Have we reached the NATWALT stage yet?

Wasnt there someone else recently like this? Baloo challoner or am I thinking of the wrong man?
RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 15:28

@PumpkinGin

The person in the picture is advising on safeguarding at girl guides? OMG, I feel sick
www.theguardian.com/profile/jane-fae

www.independent.co.uk/author/jane-fae

Nope this is.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3710570-Astonishing-thread-from-Jane-Fae-Darvo-at-its-finest

The above egg shell skulls thread.

www.mailplus.co.uk/tv/60-second-sound-off/9125/jane-fae-jk-rowlings-comments-on-trans-people-like-me-are-painful-and-pernicious

Have you read JKR essay? It’s incredibly kind and supportive of trans people and not the least big transphobic. Yet she received enough death and rape threats to paper her huge house with them and JF thought how they felt mattered most.

OP posts:
Echobelly · 24/11/2021 15:28

You know I can't vouch for this woman and I take no particular view on her suitability for the role, but I am very irritated by some assumptions being made here, people seem to be lumping an awful lot of concerns they have about GG onto her on some tenuous evidence.

I am sick and tired, in this whole discussion of seeing both sides pick up on what appear to be at least partially misleading articles and not think about the context/check the facts because It Proves Their Point. I am really tired of seeing things and thinking 'OK, but I can see a massive Trans Rights bias here or a massive GC/trans-exclusionary one that's actually obscuring what's really going on'.

BDSM photo: yes, she has a sex life. BDSM doesn't mean 'into every perversion there including paedophelia'. The fact that people had to poke around her social media to find this suggest it's probably not a major part of her life anyway. The vast majority of BDSM enthusiasts are not paedophiles and regard them with the same disgust as everyone else.

Gun photo: There's a photo of my mate on holiday in Cambodia holding a loaded bazooka, but he's never blown anyone up, nor is he a 'gun nut'. So, she had a photo taken with a replica gun - that doesn't seem to be evidence of being a 'gun nut'

Signed Challenor letter: That one 1000+ people signed? www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/over-1000-people-have-signed-an-open-letter-condemning-pride-in-london-for-letting-an-anti-trans-group-lead-the-march-94296/ I actually used to be supportive of Glinner's stand for women initially, but really, trying to imply this woman is some best chum of Challenor for signing an open letter signed by 1000s is just barrel scraping and unfair. He writes about the vileness of Challenor's father in detail as though Sulley was his best mate or something. Not one of 1000s who signed an open letter that happen to have been created by his daughter, at a time it appears the Challenor scandal was not even known about, so I'm not sure how Sulley, who doesn't appear to be linked in any other way to Challenor, was to know about it. And to imply as much is plain cruel, however righteous you feel your cause is.

Who knows, maybe something truly dreadful will appear about her, because I don't know her and neither do you. Campaign against trans women being in these positions if that's how you feel, but digging up the slightest thing discredit an individual by extrapolating very thin evidence does not do your argument any credit.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 15:26

One of the contributors (From the Skin Two Fetish yearbook, 2009 (Skin Two Issue 60), by John Ozimek, edited in 2012 by 'Jane Fae') was also an advisor to the GGs. Note the change of name in 2012!

This author is a known extreme porn activist. They also tweeted that tweet about 'eggshell skulls' and other rather misogynistic statements.

That author was listed as one of Diva's top 100 lesbians last year.

daringdoris · 24/11/2021 15:22

I went through GG and was a young leader but haven't been involved for over 20 years now. I loved it, our unit was really outdoorsy, and looking back, our Guider gave us the confidence to do so many things - lighting fires, building obstacle courses, making trails, learning about the night sky and so much more.

Thinking about previous posters who have said

99% of local guiders, leaders and helpers would agree that current GG safe-guarding policies are unsafe for girls

and also

that they have taken/would take otheir daughter out of GG, or not let her go in the first place, or not let her go to camps

Couldn't there be a grassroots movement from the leaders themselves, all of them who agree that this policy is demonstrably unsafe? A legal action, a refusal to carry out their duties, parents stop the subs? I don't know really, it's just that if we know there's such a strong grassroots feeling about this, from leaders and parents, then perhaps something can be done?
An advantage is that GG is an existing network, so 'finding recruits' should be easier (especially when we are aware that many of them agree!)
Doing it 'together' would also make it easier for leaders who are afraid to speak out on their own.

Just thinking out loud.

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 15:18

Sorry if I’m being dim I’m alternating between this thread and work etc

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 15:17

Thanks @Helleofabore - I'm now not sure how the image is linked to the safeguarding person who undermines the seriousness of DV ‘women have egg shell skulls’ and has dangerous views on children and extreme porn?

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 15:12

@brighousepres

www.mumsnet.com/uploads/talk/201809/large-966251-last-skintwo1.jpg

Can I just confirm that this is the individual in charge of advising the Girl Guides on SAFEGUARDING? You couldn’t make this shit up!

I think a picture still says 1000 words…
Not so very different from the pictures released today of the Commissioner Monica Sulley in their underwear - only Monica is glorifying weapons and encouraging SM users to interact with her …

Between that and the disability info that @Eggybrains mentioned, I’ve seen enough - no Guides for us. But I’ll still be telling everyone else I know about this because it stinks.

I believe they were the contributor not the picture on the front. The person who we are discussing does not look like that at all. And favours twin sets.

But this is some of their work as per that thread.

DismantledKing · 24/11/2021 15:02

It’s shocking, completely predictable though.
I hope that more people are going to peaked by this kind of encroaching nonsense.

PumpkinGin · 24/11/2021 14:57

The person in the picture is advising on safeguarding at girl guides? OMG, I feel sick

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 14:40

www.mumsnet.com/uploads/talk/201809/large-966251-last-skintwo1.jpg

Can I just confirm that this is the individual in charge of advising the Girl Guides on SAFEGUARDING? You couldn’t make this shit up!

I think a picture still says 1000 words…
Not so very different from the pictures released today of the Commissioner Monica Sulley in their underwear - only Monica is glorifying weapons and encouraging SM users to interact with her …

Between that and the disability info that @Eggybrains mentioned, I’ve seen enough - no Guides for us. But I’ll still be telling everyone else I know about this because it stinks.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 13:57

The 10% who think I’m being unreasonable to think parents need to know about this care to explain why?

Other posters have asked you to engage and explain your reasoning and as it’s my AIBU? I’d like to hear why you think I’m being unreasonable to think safeguarding is something that matters to all parents? Or should at least.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 24/11/2021 13:49

Hellofabore

My goodness that thread.

I thought nothing else would shock me.

Terfydactyl · 24/11/2021 13:36

@EverNapping

YABU - go back to the Feminism boards, that's what it's for
Sigh, women shut the fuck up your making men look bad.

Again.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 13:26

I won't upload a copy of the tweet image. You can search for pictures of it if you want confirmation.

"Most murder is boring, pedestrian, even accidental stuff.

Somewhere between a third and a half result from too much alcohol. A high proportion are domestic violence gone wrong. A blow struck one time too many: an egg-shell skull."

26/3/2018

I read that as being female's fault for having 'egg-shell skull', not the male's fault for violence in the first place.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 13:20

[quote brighousepres]@Helleofabore - who is this top 100 lesbian?
Condoning DV and legalising extreme porn…
This person shaped the GG policies??
What’s their name? Was there any justification for this at the time?[/quote]
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3374614-John-Ozimek-now-Jane-Fae-on-women-feminists-and-victims-of-pornographers

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 13:05

@Helleofabore - who is this top 100 lesbian?
Condoning DV and legalising extreme porn…
This person shaped the GG policies??
What’s their name? Was there any justification for this at the time?

Whatwouldscullydo · 24/11/2021 13:00

Exactly. What sort of fools (and i mean generally, not just GG or this case) didn't realise that perverts will use the trans movement for their own sick purposes?

Unfortunately we have to abide by " acceptance without exception " " you are what you say you are"

However when something happens and someone does something dodgy, a select group of people are permitted to say they aren't really trans and therefore it doesn't count.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 12:57

@TedImgoingmad

I’ll add this too

www.transgendertrend.com/government-consultation-conversion-therapy-statement-transgender-trend/

It’s easy to cut and paste the answers. Needs done before the 10th. Emailing MP’s should be done immediately because it takes them time to get round to reading all emails.

OP posts:
Deadringer · 24/11/2021 12:56

[quote RedCarpetRebellion]@PumpkinGin

We can be respectful of trans people in day to day life, supportive of their right to not be discriminated against, and still recognise that women and girls have different needs and rights based on our sex.

No one is exempt from safeguarding laws.

We should never put girls at risk to ‘be kind’ to any group.[/quote]
Exactly. What sort of fools (and i mean generally, not just GG or this case) didn't realise that perverts will use the trans movement for their own sick purposes?

TedImgoingmad · 24/11/2021 12:53

@oxalisRed

Can we please just pause and consider this phrase "girls with penises"? Say it out loud to yourself. Hear the inherent absurdity, the absolute denial of reality.

As @Ionlydomassiveones posted earlier
Gender dysmorphia is a condition that needs psychological treatment. Or people need to chill out about what clothes people wear. It does not need society to be turned upside down and laws to be changed to appease those who would deny reality.

Gender ideology is incredibly harmful at best, systemic misogyny in disguise.

Just want to flag that the Govt is currently consulting about banning "conversion therapy". But this is not what you think it is. Traditionally, conversion therapy is a term used when attempts are made to turn gay people straight (practices found in some religious groups), which is indeed egregious and abusive to LGB people.

Here, they are terming as "conversion therapy" any talking therapy that may help people with gender dysphoria, that explores those feelings and the causes for it, rather than simply affirming that they are indeed the opposite sex and therefore require medical treatments like surgery and hormones. More about it here:

sex-matters.org/take-action/write-to-your-mp-press-pause-on-legislation-on-conversion-therapy/

DrSbaitso · 24/11/2021 12:48

One may not have replaced the other, but it still indicates who is welcome in Girlguiding under their new rules and who isn't, and why.