Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DdraigGoch · 30/11/2021 06:56

@catzwhiskas

And again I see no explanation from the 11% as to why they aren’t concerned about this issue....
11% now? Looks like some ballot box stuffing has been going on.
Eggybrains · 30/11/2021 02:03

[quote DaphneDeloresMoorhead]@Eggybrains I'm pretty sure there were some brownies in the background of her Facebook bannery picture as there was a bunch of little girls and she was in her DC uniform[/quote]
They look of varying ages, if this is the picture you mean, with some too young to be Brownies. I suspect this picture was taken at a wedding, not at Girlguiding. thecritic.co.uk/jeepers-creepers/

I have concerns about Monica, but I don't think that this photo is necessarily breaching photo policy of Girlguiding, as I think it's quite likely to be nothing to do with Girlguiding in term of its origins. It may have relevance to Girlguiding in terms of its implications.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 23:16

@Eggybrains I'm pretty sure there were some brownies in the background of her Facebook bannery picture as there was a bunch of little girls and she was in her DC uniform

Eggybrains · 29/11/2021 22:34

[quote DaphneDeloresMoorhead]@brighousepres when I was a gg leader the restrictions on photos etc were really tight. Parents had to give consent on one of 3 levels - no consent at all to any photos/consent for internal gg media/consent for photos to be shared publicly.
As far as I remember there was no consent option for "leader can share photos on their private SM account"[/quote]
But I didn't think the pictures on her profile were of people in Girlguiding? Is there another picture?

Suzanne999 · 29/11/2021 22:31

A person posing with weapons when in a position of trust and responsibility with children is disturbing ( and IMO unacceptable) regardless of their gender / sexual orientation / gender identity.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 29/11/2021 22:27

Is there an alternative to GG?

This is clearly not an organisation putting girls first.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 22:21

Abd I specifically highlight...
Make sure girls are aware that they should not share photos or videos of their friends online without permission from parents/carers.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 22:18

And as a district commissioner, responsible for ensuring the units under their leadership follow those rules, Monica would be well aware of GG photography policy

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 22:16

@brighousepres when I was a gg leader the restrictions on photos etc were really tight. Parents had to give consent on one of 3 levels - no consent at all to any photos/consent for internal gg media/consent for photos to be shared publicly.
As far as I remember there was no consent option for "leader can share photos on their private SM account"

brighousepres · 29/11/2021 21:07

@DaphneDeloresMoorhead - normally I would give the SM user the benefit of the doubt here - but seeing as Monica has put up photos of herself with guns and bondage gear and invited people to comment… and is a Guide leader… I’m thinking that benefit of the doubt may not be necessary?

I am gobsmacked that Girl Guides think this is acceptable behaviour. (Actually - have they said anything re? Not that I know if)

Presumably it’s ok if the Guides copy this sort of behaviour then, and also comment on the breasts etc? FFS.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 17:46

I wonder if the girls featured on her personal Facebook page ticked their media consent form to cover personal use on personal social media 🤔

catzwhiskas · 29/11/2021 17:00

And again I see no explanation from the 11% as to why they aren’t concerned about this issue....

catzwhiskas · 29/11/2021 16:50

So Bosky, there are still special people to whom the normal rules do not apply? Thank you for posting all these very relevant links. Thank goodness this thread is now in AIBU. Here to be read by anyone concerned about what is happening to young girls where there are very few safe and exclusive places and organizations left.

brighousepres · 29/11/2021 14:01

So if you’re a Guide leader it’s fine to do what the Monica person has done? Unbelievable. You couldn’t make this up…

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 28/11/2021 22:28

In plain sight.

EmpressaurusWitchDoesntBurn · 28/11/2021 21:34

@DrSbaitso

I wonder if an actual middle aged woman, a real one, would have been so supported if she'd been posing online as a dominatrix and toting a gun.
I think we all know the answer to that one.

And if Guide numbers plummet in that district, I wonder if they’ll face up to why?

DrSbaitso · 28/11/2021 21:12

I wonder if an actual middle aged woman, a real one, would have been so supported if she'd been posing online as a dominatrix and toting a gun.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 28/11/2021 21:09

Update: the page is back up with Monica still in place

It seems Girl guides have decided that there’s no problem with Monica’s behaviour on social media or indeed gaslighting girls to call clearly male people, women

Bosky · 28/11/2021 05:58

@Theeyeballsinthesky

Didn’t we discuss on FWR that if someone has a GRC that wipes out their former identity re seeing CRB useless??

I might be misremembering but I’m sure it was discussed at length

No, that's not how it works - thankfully!

DBS Sensitive applications

Transgender applicants are protected in legislation and are not obliged to include details indicating a previous gender in their application form.

The DBS has a process in place which allows any details indicating a previous gender to be checked without being disclosed on the completed certificate.

They are, however, required by law to provide all name details to the DBS in their current and any previous identity. Deliberately withholding this information may be an attempt to prevent conviction information being revealed and is an offence.

Scroll right down this DBS page to see the section on "Sensitive applications":

www.gov.uk/government/organisations/disclosure-and-barring-service

============

DBS Guidance

Transgender applications

Guidance and information regarding the sensitive applications route for transgender applicants.

The Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) offers a confidential checking service for transgender applicants in accordance with the Gender Recognition Act 2004. This is known as the sensitive applications route, and is available for all levels of DBS check - basic, standard and enhanced.

The sensitive applications route gives transgender applicants the choice not to have any gender or name information disclosed on their DBS certificate, that could reveal their previous identity.

So the only difference with people who have a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC) is that, for privacy reasons, any issues that apply under a pre-GRC name can be listed under the current name and “gender”, if the person with a GRC requests this.

All of those issues would still be listed on the DBS disclosure, none would be omitted. The only information not disclosed, if requested by the GRC-holder, would be the pre-GRC name and the actual sex of the person.

This does create a loophole but not the one suggested.

When a previous name is undisclosed this could present a barrier to accessing “informal intelligence”. To that extent, the current DBS system for people with a GRC does not deal with all of the intelligence failures that the recommendations in the Bichard Inquiry set out to address, ie. in the wake of the Soham Murders of Holly Wells and Jessica Chapman by Ian Huntley.

www.virtual-college.co.uk/resources/public-inquiry-holly-wells-jessica-chapman

DBS checks can only result in disclosure of information that is known to the DBS. If incidents have not been reported they will not be known to the Police and so to the DBS.

For example, some organisations have an "anti-punitive and anti-carceral" ethos and prefer to deal with incidents "in house", eg. by "restorative justice". Others simply cover them up.

Nevertheless, knowledge of the incidents and the names of alleged perpetrators may be common knowledge within the organisation or the sector. Failure to list a previous name on a DBS disclosure can present a safe-guarding issue in these circumstances.

A recent example of an "anti-punitive and anti-carceral" approach is in the training given to Oxfam staff in the UK, which said that women who report rape or sexual assault to the police promote "racism" and "white supremacy":

"Oxfam training guide blames ‘privileged white women’ over root causes of sexual violence"
The Telegraph, 9 June 2021

Extracts

Oxfam has produced guidance which states that: “Mainstream feminism centres on privileged white women and demands that ‘bad men’ be fired or imprisoned”.

Accompanied by a cartoon of a crying white woman, it adds that this “legitimises criminal punishment, harming black and other marginalised people”.

"Learning About Trans Rights and Inclusion" was drawn up in 2020, whilst Oxfam was still reeling from sexual exploitation scandals in Haiti and Chad.

The charity suffered further blows in April this year, when a female aid worker quit alleging that there was a “toxic culture” and her sexual harassment complaint had been ignored,

<a class="break-all" href="https://web.archive.org/web/20211029194646/www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/06/09/oxfam-training-guide-blames-privileged-white-women-root-causes/" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">web.archive.org/web/20211029194646/www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/06/09/oxfam-training-guide-blames-privileged-white-women-root-causes/

Other examples of organisations with “anti-punitive, anti-carceral” policies that prefer in-house “restorative justice” approaches include "Action for Trans Health" and "Edinburgh Trans Health".

This account illustrates how it is possible for individuals with a long history of allegations of sexual misconduct to benefit from well-meaning people, policies and organisations that do not prioritise safeguarding, in this case of vulnerable young adults:

<a class="break-all" href="http://web.archive.org/web/20210806210146/www.sarahmcculloch.com/statement-jess-bradley/" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">web.archive.org/web/20210806210146/www.sarahmcculloch.com/statement-jess-bradley/

See also:

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3626735-Update-on-the-Jess-Bradley-position

No sex-scandals that I am aware of but for an insight into the aims of these esteemed advisors to the Scottish Government, see Edinburgh Trans Health:

<a class="break-all" href="http://web.archive.org/web/20210916165239/edinburghath.tumblr.com/post/163521055802/trans-health-manifesto" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">web.archive.org/web/20210916165239/edinburghath.tumblr.com/post/163521055802/trans-health-manifesto

(Anyone seeing a pattern here? A pattern that parents would not want to see promoted within an organisation for young girls?)

========

Some aspects of the "name change issue" apply to everyone:

Anyone can change their name at any time. There is no requirement to change name "officially", eg. by deed poll, although this can be a convenient way to provide proof of a name change. Therefore, it is difficult to see how the “name change loophole” could be closed.

”If you have any pending criminal prosecutions against you then you will be required to notify the police about the change. If you are on licence or under probation, then you will be required to inform your probation officer and if you are on the Sex Offenders Register, you are required to notify the police within 3 days of changing your name. Failure to inform the police may result in a criminal conviction.”

hub.unlock.org.uk/knowledgebase/changing-name/

Police role in the DBS checking process

www.gov.uk/guidance/police-role-in-the-dbs-checking-process

==========

Responsibilities of recruiting organisation

It is worth having a look at the requirements for the recruiting body to check the identity of the potential employee or volunteer in order to apply for a DBS check.

If GG is delegating this responsibility to untrained volunteers, is an untrained volunteer also responsible for receiving the DBS check and making the decision about whether a new potential volunteer is suitable?

I do hope not.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/dbs-identity-checking-guidelines/id-checking-guidelines-for-standardenhanced-dbs-check-applications-from-1-july-2021

===========

DBS - Reporting concerns.

The Government provides this information:

”Report someone as unfit to work with children or vulnerable adults”

Parents or members of the public who are concerned about someone working with children or vulnerable adults should contact the police, social services or the person’s employer.

Refer someone to Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS)

Employers must refer someone to DBS if they:

  • sacked them because they harmed someone
  • sacked them or changed their role because they might have harmed someone
  • were planning to sack them for either of these reasons, but they resigned first

You’re breaking the law if you do not refer someone to DBS when you should.

Contact the helpline for help referring someone to DBS.

DBS helpline
Telephone: 0300 0200 190

www.gov.uk/report-unfit-work-children-vulnerable-adults

=====

There is copious information on the Government DBS site about how the DBS system operates:

www.gov.uk/government/organisations/disclosure-and-barring-service

=====

More worrying than DBS provisions for GRC-holders are:

  • DBS provisions for sex-offenders to have their names removed from the Sex Offenders Register on request

  • the apparent laxity and lack of seriousness reported in at least some sections of GG with respect to conducting DBS checks

  • evidence that promotion of "trans inclusion" within the voluntary sector is being paired with promotion of an "anti-punitive, anti-carceral" ethos that stigmatises the reporting of sexual assault and rape to the police.
Terfydactyl · 26/11/2021 21:50

@Theeyeballsinthesky

Didn’t we discuss on FWR that if someone has a GRC that wipes out their former identity re seeing CRB useless??

I might be misremembering but I’m sure it was discussed at length

Yes the much missed lang I think said theres a huge hole in the DBS process. If a person has changed name, they have to let DBS know. If they dont then what happens?
samholborn · 26/11/2021 20:11

Hilariously, it seems their complaints email address is down. I wonder if the mailbox is full?

Eggybrains · 26/11/2021 19:49

[quote ShinyHappyPoster]@Eggybrains did you contact CHQ in writing with your concerns? Volunteers may be lax - although I never saw any laxness around DBS etc - but paid staff shouldn't be.[/quote]
Yes, I did.

They've not done anything. I'm reluctant to tell you how long ago I raised it as it may identify me if noone else raised it around that time, but it's been a long, long, long time, and they've done nothing, except tell me not to tell parents.

It's the responsibility of volunteers (DC etc) to send of disclosures and ask volunteers to complete them. HQ are responsible for processing once they're filled in, but if local volunteers don't fill in the forms, HQ have nothing to process. In my view something this important shouldn't be left up to volunteers with variable levels of knowledge, skill, training, understanding of why this is important and attitudes towards disclosures. Something this important should be put in the hands of a few dedicated members of staff who process all vetting for new volunteers, and ensure existing volunteers documentation is kept up to date too.

ShinyHappyPoster · 26/11/2021 19:39

@Eggybrains did you contact CHQ in writing with your concerns? Volunteers may be lax - although I never saw any laxness around DBS etc - but paid staff shouldn't be.

Helleofabore · 26/11/2021 18:03

That sounds incredibly concerning Eggy. As a parent of a recent GG and a helper, I am horrified to know that shortcuts have been taken. I am very appreciative of leaders such as you, who take a stand to do the right thing.