Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

2nd thread: AIBU to OBJECT to being asked to reframe my trauma by Edinburgh Rape Crisis CEO?

88 replies

herewegogc · 13/08/2021 12:55

Hi all 2nd thread as the last one was filling up fast.

OP posts:
catzwhiskas · 14/08/2021 10:37

HAs there been any official response from the Scottish Govt, MSPs , Local authorities or other funding bodies to this shitshow. Or are we supposed to believe that everything is hunky dory and we all know that of course TWAW ?

DrSbaitso · 14/08/2021 10:23

@Datun

Wadwha has also said that men working in these roles is completely unacceptable.
But male people get to decide who the men are...
R0wantrees · 14/08/2021 10:23

I have an Indian passport that says female

Investigation into the circumstances in which men in UK and abroad can change the sex marker on their passports is long-overdue. What must be considered are the potential consequences of doing so for children and women's welfare as well as fraud, criminality etc.

R0wantrees · 14/08/2021 10:16

Datun on that point I completely agree.

Datun · 14/08/2021 10:12

Wadwha has also said that men working in these roles is completely unacceptable.

R0wantrees · 14/08/2021 09:11

21 August 2015
Written evidence submitted by Mridul Wadhwa to the Transgender Equality Inquiry
(extracts)
"I work for Rape Crisis Scotland as a Training and Volunteer Co-ordinator and as the Information and Education Officer for Shakti Women’s Aid.

I am also an associate of the College of Policing, England and Wales where I present on transgender and migrant women’s issues on the Equality and Human Rights course and am a domestic abuse trainer on the college of policing’s Domestic Abuse matters training program.

I also co-wrote and co-facilitated the Scottish Government’s training on forced marriage.

I have been involved in the violence against women sector in Scotland since 2005. I moved to Scotland from India in 2004.
[To study for a Masters at Edinburgh University in 'training']

I have consulted with the Scottish Transgender Alliance in making this submission and endorse all the issues and recommendations made by the Scottish Transgender Alliance
[relevant thread] www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3829786-James-Morton-scottish-trans-alliance-quote

I believe the gender reassignment General Occupation Provision in recruitment is discriminatory to transsexual people especially trans women. I genuinely believe that there is no space for it in the gender based violence sector and that it has no place in violence against women work. I was unaware of its existence until a few weeks ago. I
have worked in the violence against women sector since 2005 and have never known for it to be used. I am disappointed to think that someone has the right to refuse work to me and others like me in my sector just because they think that I might not be a woman. When I started working in this sector, I was not out as a trans person, this was not out of fear of discrimination but more because I did not think it was necessary.

In Scotland, all fund recipients from the Scottish Government’s Violence against women funds are expected to implement a trans inclusion policy as a requirement of the grant. I would welcome similar mandatory requirements of all public, private and third sector grant recipients and contractors receiving funding to carry out work with those affected by sexual violence and other forms of gender based violence.

I migrated from India as a student and then an economic migrant. I was able to do so post transition and did not suffer significant life harming discrimination due to my trans status. This is only because of privileges that I had through my social background, a supportive family and my own resilience to challenge the structural and social barriers that exist for trans people in India. I have an Indian passport that says female, am married and am about to adopt a child in Scotland."
data.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/committeeevidence.svc/evidencedocument/women-and-equalities-committee/transgender-equality/written/19653.pdf

Re the "gender reassignment General Occupation Provision in recruitment":

Equality Act 2010
Exceptions allowing services to be provided only to women (or only to men)

The first two relevant exceptions (Schedule 3, Paragraphs 26 and 27) allow service providers to provide separate services for men and women, or to provide services to only men or only women in certain circumstances. The symmetrical nature of the ban on sex discrimination means without these exceptions it would be illegal, for example, to hold women-only sessions at a leisure centre or a new fathers’ support group at a nursery.

Exception allowing single sex services to discriminate because of gender re-assignment

The third exception (Schedule 3, paragraph 28) allows providers of separate or single-sex services to provide a different service to, or to exclude, someone who has the protected characteristic of gender reassignment. This includes those who have a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC), as well as someone who does not have a GRC but otherwise meets the definition under the Equality Act 2010.

Application of this exception must be objectively justified as a means of achieving a legitimate aim. An example given in the explanatory notes to the Act is that of a group counselling service for female victims of sexual assault where the organisers could exclude a woman with the protected characteristic of gender reassignment if they judge that clients would be unlikely to attend the session if she was there."

Effect
787. This paragraph provides a general exception to what would otherwise be unlawful direct discrimination in relation to work. The exception applies where being of a particular sex, race, disability, religion or belief, sexual orientation or age – or not being a transsexual person, married or a civil partner – is a requirement for the work, and the person whom it is applied to does not meet it (or, except in the case of sex, does not meet it to the reasonable satisfaction of the person who applied it). The requirement must be crucial to the post, and not merely one of several important factors. It also must not be a sham or pretext. In addition, applying the requirement must be proportionate so as to achieve a legitimate aim.

Examples [include]:

A counsellor working with victims of rape might have to be a woman and not a transsexual person, even if she has a Gender Recognition Certificate, in order to avoid causing them further distress.
publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmwomeq/1470/147010.htm

Mridul Wadwha

"When I started working in this sector, I was not out as a trans person, this was not out of fear of discrimination but more because I did not think it was necessary."

Blah1881 · 14/08/2021 08:25

Just found this thread again- couldn’t see it anywhere and thought it had been disappeared. This whole scenario is so sinister. It reminds me of the 1970s PIE scandal in the way the liberal elite have been cowed into support of an ideology.

Orgasmagorical · 14/08/2021 08:23

From the link that Purgatory posted:

"But something felt "off", I felt slightly dirty. I felt I was betraying something in me, something called truth and something called self-respect."

That's also how we have to treat narcissists if we have to have them in our lives and try and keep them happy. How many of MW's 'fans' are genuinely admiring of MW and how many are keeping MW on side, for whatever reason.

It's already been said that anything said against MW or this 'cause' or even the truth being told results in accusations of transphobia. A very handy card to play when there is no actual defence.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/08/2021 19:52

@catzwhiskas

For the 5% who think it is entirely reasonable for a male to question women about their transphobia, please could you give your reasons. For most women here it is abusive behaviour and I cannot think what possible rationale there could be. But harder even to understand how many women’s services have capitulated to an ideology that is completely separate to the needs of women after rape.
Some of that 5% may have been the wrong way round before the thread title was clarified. But yes, would like to hear from anyone who thinks the OP is being unreasonable what their reasoning is.
catzwhiskas · 13/08/2021 19:47

For the 5% who think it is entirely reasonable for a male to question women about their transphobia, please could you give your reasons. For most women here it is abusive behaviour and I cannot think what possible rationale there could be. But harder even to understand how many women’s services have capitulated to an ideology that is completely separate to the needs of women after rape.

Artichokeleaves · 13/08/2021 19:47

As I pointed out on another thread: two vested interests.

  1. a vested interest in enforcing one set belief on all service users, that belief being the same one that justifies their own job position.

  2. the husband so usefully acquiring contracts stripped from single sex provisions to turn them mixed sex.

This is a particularly appalling example of a widespread belief. I would suggest for those looking for evidence, you can watch the videos of the Scots Parliament meetings and see how such questions about single sex provision were responded to and treated.

However there is a MNetter (I won't name her, its for her to share if she chooses to) who has explained on a FWR thread how she and a number of other survivors in refuge met with management and tried to explain how they were affected by natal males being present, regardless of how they identified. They were treated with absolute disdain during the meeting, many of them were in tears by the end. One of the senior people at the meeting later publicly stated that no women had ever raised any concerns at having natal males in their refuges.

Another MNetter spent much of the past year living in a tent in all weathers, finding spots to pitch it where she could, as all the refuges approached insisted on a mixed sex policy and insisted she overcome her trauma to be able to accept natal male users alongside her to be allowed shelter.

These are the realities of this policy.

If anyone can spot the 'kindness' and 'inclusion' and 'diversity' and rainbows in all this please tell me. Because I find it appalling, cruel sexism that is about blaming victims and forcing female exclusion from female spaces for the better freedoms of choice and well being of people born male.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/08/2021 19:43

YANBU, op.Thanks

DrSbaitso · 13/08/2021 19:29

@LittleMyTopKnot

Sorry, I am a bit slow tonight…

But did I read that link correctly???

a) MW has argued for years that biological males who self ID as women (MW has no GRC) should provide trauma counselling and do rape tests on women? And if they refuse they are bigots??? After rape???

b) MW was so cross that women weren’t legally obligated to accept biological males as counsellors/do rape tests after rape that MW resigned form a political position?!!

c) a single sex service has now lost funding which has been given to a mixed sexed service where MW’s husband was a director until late this year?

Really?? Really???

Yes.
LongBlobson · 13/08/2021 19:07

YANBU

It's a ridiculous situation where I'm checking myself repeatedly to make sure I'm not being unkind...

Trans people should absolutely be able to access rape crisis services and I recognise their vulnerability. Some men and trans women will be excellent counsellors and there's no reason they can't be involved in providing rape crisis services. There should ideally be a variety of services - some that are totally inclusive, some that are women only but include trans women, some that exclude trans women...

The reality is though, that there is a clear need for women only services, where women does not include trans women. And this should be the majority of services, because the vast majority of victims of sexual assault are biological women and the vast majority of women who have experienced sexual assault need to be or have a very strong preference to be supported by other biological women.

In the name of being inclusive, women's services have changed into something that women are now quietly self-excluding from.

LittleMyTopKnot · 13/08/2021 18:49

Sorry, I am a bit slow tonight…

But did I read that link correctly???

a) MW has argued for years that biological males who self ID as women (MW has no GRC) should provide trauma counselling and do rape tests on women? And if they refuse they are bigots??? After rape???

b) MW was so cross that women weren’t legally obligated to accept biological males as counsellors/do rape tests after rape that MW resigned form a political position?!!

c) a single sex service has now lost funding which has been given to a mixed sexed service where MW’s husband was a director until late this year?

Really?? Really???

DrSbaitso · 13/08/2021 18:24

[quote PurgatoryOfPotholes]Most of what is in the public domain is narrated from Wadhwa's perspective, naturally.

I think this is interesting, as it is related from the point of view of someone meeting Wadhwa. If I have my sums right, this would have been a year or two before MW took up a role at Shakti Women's Aid.

virginiasroom.co.uk/f/on-validation-and-tolerance[/quote]
That's a very telling anecdote.

"It is the lie people objected to, not the person, not the person's choice or expression. It was the demand that our moral purity and values (kindness vs. truth) must be put on display, weighed and judged, that people objected to."

I think this absolutely nails how a lot of us feel about this. We don't care if someone is trans. We'll accept them as they are, like them for their character, most of us will use their preferred pronouns, and just go with the flow. But then we are tested as to how far do we really, deep down, believe that there's no difference between a trans woman and a natal one? Enough to let them join women's weightlifting? Enough to put aside our trauma and fear to prove our worth even if we just want to see a female counsellor after being raped?

What will be enough?

CharlieParley · 13/08/2021 18:10

It's at the same time or shortly after MW started at Shakti (2005).

CharlieParley · 13/08/2021 18:05

I cannot help thinking that reframing a female survivor's trauma in regard to male transgender people would involve the opposite of what MW threatened in both the podcast and the statement intended to set the record straight.

Reframing a female survivor's trauma in this regard would involve helping her understand that if her involuntary trauma responses happen also in the presence of male transgender people, that's not because she is bigoted or prejudiced against transgender people, but because her brain correctly recognises their sex as male which in turn triggers her trauma responses.

It's not happening because she is triggered by transgender people but by males. That's not evidence of transphobia but evidence of trauma. And counsellors would help a survivor understand that.

This is why btw what MW wants to do cannot work other than by brainwashing. There is no way to stop your lizard brain recognising sex. It doesn't respond to reason. It's wholly instinctive. All you can do is brainwash a survivor to impress upon her the strict prohibition to vocalise that recognition and to object to the male's presence.

I mean FFS, I was in despair explaining to my counsellor that I couldn't stop my trauma responses when the nice nurse who came to take my blood turned out to be a man. (He was nice btw and I was in a place where I've always felt safe.) But I didn't know the surgery now had a male nurse, so I wasn't prepared. So my body went into fight or flight mode, while I'm just saying over and over again in my head I'm safe calm down I'm safe calm down I'm safe calm down I'm safe calm down and on and on to no avail.

I felt really bad about that and was not for the first time in my life grateful that mindreading is a science fiction trope and not real.

And my counsellor reframed my response for me, by explaining why it happened, why telling myself to calm down had zero effect and what I might try in that situation next time to work with my lizard brain instead of trying to fight it and above all she helped me understand that I wasn't a bad or mad person for reacting in that way.

(I'm sure there's a more scientific word for lizard brain but I can't remember right now.)

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 13/08/2021 17:52

Most of what is in the public domain is narrated from Wadhwa's perspective, naturally.

I think this is interesting, as it is related from the point of view of someone meeting Wadhwa. If I have my sums right, this would have been a year or two before MW took up a role at Shakti Women's Aid.

virginiasroom.co.uk/f/on-validation-and-tolerance

DrSbaitso · 13/08/2021 17:52

@Cailleach1

How on earth can something like this happen to services which have been established by the efforts of women, for women at a time of great need?

Men/males get to use them in a way which may heap more trauma on already traumatised women.

How?

www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-document-that-reveals-the-remarkable-tactics-of-trans-lobbyists

TeaAndStrumpets · 13/08/2021 17:38

[quote Lynnikins]Today's (Friday's) update on this, courtesy of Graham Linehan.

grahamlinehan.substack.com/p/mridrul-wadha-sacro-and-the-14-million?r=a0bsx&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium[/quote]
Not fishy AT ALL.

Lynnikins · 13/08/2021 17:33

[quote Lynnikins]Today's (Friday's) update on this, courtesy of Graham Linehan.

grahamlinehan.substack.com/p/mridrul-wadha-sacro-and-the-14-million?r=a0bsx&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium[/quote]
Sorry, I see this link has already been posted. If I could find how to delete it I would.

Lynnikins · 13/08/2021 17:30

Today's (Friday's) update on this, courtesy of Graham Linehan.

grahamlinehan.substack.com/p/mridrul-wadha-sacro-and-the-14-million?r=a0bsx&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium

Cailleach1 · 13/08/2021 17:29

How on earth can something like this happen to services which have been established by the efforts of women, for women at a time of great need?

Men/males get to use them in a way which may heap more trauma on already traumatised women.