Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Holyrood Equalities Committee

14 replies

ArabellaScott · 14/11/2026 22:21

Greens Holly Bruce and Katie Nevens put hostile questions to ForWomen Scoltand, Sex Matters, and Women's Rights Network.

Apologies for the clickbait headline, it's an edit of some of the highlights of the meeting.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IuKM4GW0xMQ

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
itstoolateforsnacks · Today 08:23

To be fair, I think they ask the kinds of questions that people coming at it from their viewpoint would ask. Luckily they were met with incredibly clear, calm and factual answers that I can’t see how any observer can really argue with. The trouble is that people have a viewpoint that a man saying he is a woman makes his wish come true. Everything they hear will be through that lens. All the legal challenges are sadly necessary as people can’t just deal in facts when they are in thrall to ideology and fantasy.

fabricstash · Today 07:47

Thanks for the link. These politicians do not live in the real world. Women deserve rights too

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 21:27

No. Democracy is looking quite peely wally these days.

OP posts:
UtopiaPlanitia · Yesterday 21:26

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 09:57

The questions are entirely loaded and calculated as antagonistic. An atrocious way to treat an invited panel.

Absolutely! Exactly the same behaviour in questioning happens at Westminster from the majority of the WESC - sneering, aggressive, haughty, loaded questions (very obviously written by somebody other than the MP in question). It's not a great development for democracy to have public representatives of this calibre.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 21:21

Airy and spacious?

OP posts:
JanesLittleGirl · Yesterday 20:00

It must be wonderful to have the sort of head that allows the spoken word to pass from one ear to the other without any attempt to analyse what was actually being said.

Transperson · Yesterday 19:40

Love them, actually not letting sex matter get away with its transphobia.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 09:58

Questions could have been worded in a neutral way and a constructive session might have surfaced any potential positives or negatives re the Code.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · Yesterday 09:57

The questions are entirely loaded and calculated as antagonistic. An atrocious way to treat an invited panel.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · Yesterday 09:49

I wouldn’t say the questions of themselves were hostile, more the sneering I'm better than you tone in which they were asked, accompanied by smug expressions on their faces, were hostile.
Sanctimonious TRAs is what they came across as. I can imagine the pair of them went to the pub afterwards for a couple of bottles of chicken wine with their trans mates and gave themselves a good pat on the back for the job they think they did in showing up those uppity bigoted FWS / SM women.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 09:44

And the fact they make pious points about representing their trans constituents makes it especially galling that this means they are deliberately ignoring or actively working against their constituents who are women in favour of single sex spaces.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · Yesterday 09:42

I do struggle to grasp what the fuck the motivations of these women are.

I suppose silos and bubbles and self righteousness go a long way.

Its just extraordinary to see them drag out mythical lesbians getting questioned in the women's loos to argue that actually men must be included in women's rape crisis services.

'Fuck the rape victims, think of the sad men' is such an astonishing take.

And in this case, 'fuck the cancer patients, think of the sad men'. A horrible fucking performance from Holly.Bruce. Shameful.

OP posts:
SwirlyGates · Yesterday 08:08

It's always especially galling to see women arguing against women's rights.

But then Kate Nevens believes that trans people (i.e. transwomen, i.e. males) are not a threat to women, the threat to women is from the right wing, or so she claimed in my local hustings. How do you argue with stupid?