Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Reported in The Guardian today: 'Two courtrooms, one celebrity: how did the Russell Brand case compare with the rape trial next door?'

30 replies

Another2Cats · 14/11/2026 13:47

A pretty grim but compelling read. This is about the differences between a high profile trial and just randomly what happens in an ordinary trial.

The author spent some time covering the Brand trial but also a rape trial in a nearby crown court involving a very ordinary man. She compares and contrasts what happened in each trial (the other defendant was also convicted of some rapes but not others).

Two courtrooms, one celebrity: how did the Russell Brand case compare with the rape trial next door?

One was a high-profile defendant watched by more than 100 journalists. Another was an unknown man who preyed on a girl almost half his age. Their stories played out minutes apart, one entirely out of the spotlight

[...]

This is the story of two rape cases; one that the whole world is paying attention to and one that has attracted no attention at all.

[...]

I’m the only journalist here; the creeping extinction of local newspapers has prompted a stark decline in coverage of most court cases. This morning, there were no lines of police and photographers outside the court, there was no jostling for a seat in the courtroom, no artists sketching the scene.

https://www.theguardian.com/news/2026/nov/14/two-courtrooms-one-celebrity-russell-brand-case-compare-rape-trial-next-door

Two courtrooms, one celebrity: how did the Russell Brand case compare with the rape trial next door?

One was a high-profile defendant watched by more than 100 journalists. Another was an unknown man who preyed on a girl almost half his age. Their stories played out minutes apart, one entirely out of the spotlight

https://www.theguardian.com/news/2026/nov/14/two-courtrooms-one-celebrity-russell-brand-case-compare-rape-trial-next-door

OP posts:
OhBotherSaidPoo · 14/11/2026 14:05

Interesting how Michael, the other convicted rapist, referred to the women of the jury as females but men were men.

JustAMiddleAgedDirtBagBaby · 14/11/2026 16:13

That's a fascinating read OP, thanks for the link. It's good to hear that rape myths are debunked in court - not that you'd know it from Winter's performance for Brand.

ItWasThe80s · 14/11/2026 16:15

I saw that this morning - I thought it was wonderfully written. The banality of evil etc.

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 14/11/2026 16:34

Incredible that Michael conceived in the first place to try to have sex with a teenage girl he picked up on the street within hours of meeting her. What do men like that think they are doing? I don't know if Michael intended to rape his victim or whether that was due to opportunity - but it's clear he intended to have sex with a teenager barely older than his child. That kind of thinking is so, so depraved and dysfunctional, even if it were 'consensual'.

GrumpyPanda · 14/11/2026 16:39

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 14/11/2026 16:34

Incredible that Michael conceived in the first place to try to have sex with a teenage girl he picked up on the street within hours of meeting her. What do men like that think they are doing? I don't know if Michael intended to rape his victim or whether that was due to opportunity - but it's clear he intended to have sex with a teenager barely older than his child. That kind of thinking is so, so depraved and dysfunctional, even if it were 'consensual'.

The father's solidarity made particularly grim reading. And yes, I too noted the "females" language.

SwearOnChanel · 14/11/2026 17:07

Very good piece, I read it carefully.

Ponderingwindow · 14/11/2026 17:10

The part of the recent noise in the last week that has bothered me the most is that all the attention has been on celebrity offenders. Articles like this are refreshing and necessary.

Peoplesfrontofjudea2000 · 14/11/2026 17:33

I wondered what happened to the friend who went to the bedroom with the 15 year old. Why wasn’t he prosecuted. 😡

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 14/11/2026 17:36

A grim read all round. What was Michael thinking indeed? We'll never know if he set out to rape or or it just happened. Only he really knows. I have my suspicions. What's amazing as has been pointed out is that it happened <so quickly>. In the end, any self-mitigation from him is worthless, he was absolutely in a position of power (adult, older, stronger, is a parent FFS!) over effectively a defenceless girl. Even if she was in any way willing, it's his duty to absolutely say no.
Impressed with the women in court in the Brand case. Refusing to be pigeonholed or categorized by his KC. They said it exactly as it happened, under the most awful duress hence ones reaction from behind the screen.

RPRegionalPosh · 14/11/2026 17:37

I was very pleased to see Brand's sentence but had expected something around 7 years, not because I don't think he deserves what he got but because I work in this field and see sentencing day in day out. The judge in Brand's case was very good especially his sentencing remarks and explaining aggravating and mitigating factors, but I did wonder if the profile wasn't so high and the judge not that particular one, would the sentence have been the same.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 14/11/2026 17:47

RPRegionalPosh · 14/11/2026 17:37

I was very pleased to see Brand's sentence but had expected something around 7 years, not because I don't think he deserves what he got but because I work in this field and see sentencing day in day out. The judge in Brand's case was very good especially his sentencing remarks and explaining aggravating and mitigating factors, but I did wonder if the profile wasn't so high and the judge not that particular one, would the sentence have been the same.

This male nurse got 7 years for sexual assault on a woman patient in 2023. The case took over 3 years to get to court.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwx2z91znjrgo

Ernest Paul Cruz mugshot. He has short, slicked back black hair and a black earing.

Former Bournemouth nurse jailed for sexually assaulting patient

Ernest Paul Cruz attacked his victim in a room at the Royal Bournemouth Hospital in July 2023.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwx2z91znjrgo

RachelDuffy · 14/11/2026 17:56

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 14/11/2026 16:34

Incredible that Michael conceived in the first place to try to have sex with a teenage girl he picked up on the street within hours of meeting her. What do men like that think they are doing? I don't know if Michael intended to rape his victim or whether that was due to opportunity - but it's clear he intended to have sex with a teenager barely older than his child. That kind of thinking is so, so depraved and dysfunctional, even if it were 'consensual'.

And apparently he’s a ‘devout catholic’. WTAF. Er, no. You’re a married man who, by your own admission, seeks sex with teenagers. And when they don't consent, you rape them.
Despicable excuse for a human being.

RPRegionalPosh · 14/11/2026 17:58

MrsOvertonsWindow · 14/11/2026 17:47

This male nurse got 7 years for sexual assault on a woman patient in 2023. The case took over 3 years to get to court.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwx2z91znjrgo

Yes I know there is variation, I think the aggravating factors here because of the context and the professional setting will have increased the sentence (rightly so), I'm not saying Brand should have received less, just that I see many other cases where I think the sentences shouldn't be at the bottom end of the sentencing guidelines but are. If all sentencers were like the one in Brand's case we'd be getting somewhere

LottieMary · 14/11/2026 18:49

It was absolutely compelling. And yes to
the solidarity of father and friend (who didn’t seem to take it seriously). And about 2/3 through the revelation that Michael too is married.

men also appear to have no concept of abuse of power, their lack of recognition of privilege is staggering. Thinking too of the Nvidia CEO who had affairs not only with the alleged spy but others in the company, who obviously he substantially outranked.

ButMyGoshDontYouKnowIt · 14/11/2026 18:53

Michael has a 16 year old son. The child he preyed on was the same age as his son.

Sausagenbacon · 14/11/2026 19:51

You know what like to see in the Guardian?
An apology for enabling and fawning-over RB.

JanesLittleGirl · 14/11/2026 20:18

RPRegionalPosh · 14/11/2026 17:58

Yes I know there is variation, I think the aggravating factors here because of the context and the professional setting will have increased the sentence (rightly so), I'm not saying Brand should have received less, just that I see many other cases where I think the sentences shouldn't be at the bottom end of the sentencing guidelines but are. If all sentencers were like the one in Brand's case we'd be getting somewhere

The unusual feature in Brand's sentence was the judge giving him consecutive terms rather than the far more common concurrent terms. Had the terms been concurrent, Brand could be out in 4 years and 8 months. The judge really didn't like Brand and what he had done.

Stilson · 14/11/2026 20:25

I read the article but couldn't find what Michael was sentenced to?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 14/11/2026 20:25

RPRegionalPosh · 14/11/2026 17:58

Yes I know there is variation, I think the aggravating factors here because of the context and the professional setting will have increased the sentence (rightly so), I'm not saying Brand should have received less, just that I see many other cases where I think the sentences shouldn't be at the bottom end of the sentencing guidelines but are. If all sentencers were like the one in Brand's case we'd be getting somewhere

Yes. I understand that there are so many factors involved in sentencing (some of which many will disagree with). It does seem to be very hard for the general public to understand why some receive seemingly lenient sentences compared to others.

RPRegionalPosh · 14/11/2026 20:29

JanesLittleGirl · 14/11/2026 20:18

The unusual feature in Brand's sentence was the judge giving him consecutive terms rather than the far more common concurrent terms. Had the terms been concurrent, Brand could be out in 4 years and 8 months. The judge really didn't like Brand and what he had done.

Just anecdotally we have been setting more consecutive sentences this year (work) and not just for sexual offences, I think it's sentencers' way of saying they don't like the sentencing act and what it does to release dates, so by making sentences consecutive it extends the sentence so even under the SA 26, they won't get out earlier than if they'd been in under old legislation and sentenced concurrently

JanesLittleGirl · 14/11/2026 20:33

RPRegionalPosh · 14/11/2026 20:29

Just anecdotally we have been setting more consecutive sentences this year (work) and not just for sexual offences, I think it's sentencers' way of saying they don't like the sentencing act and what it does to release dates, so by making sentences consecutive it extends the sentence so even under the SA 26, they won't get out earlier than if they'd been in under old legislation and sentenced concurrently

Interesting. Many thanks. Although Brand (I hate even typing his name) wouldn't be eligible for early release would he?

singthing · 14/11/2026 20:34

When I was around 13-14 I ended up in a situation in a derelict flat in a not very nice area where I could easily have been assaulted or raped, but thankfully was not. It was one of those boiling frogs scenarios where a friend and I started the day quite innocently going to meet her new boyfriend but little adjustments to the plan kept happening outwith our original intentions.

As pp said earlier, the banality of it all is what shocks me looking back. We were too naïve to see the red flags at each stage, possibly or probably didn't want to look "uncool", who knows. But we could so easily have been like the girl "Michael" picked up and fared far worse.

RPRegionalPosh · 14/11/2026 20:39

JanesLittleGirl · 14/11/2026 20:33

Interesting. Many thanks. Although Brand (I hate even typing his name) wouldn't be eligible for early release would he?

No not eligible, contact sexual offences. Images etc are still eligible as are sexual assaults on adults without penetration.
The ineligible sexual offences are rape, sexual assault by penetration, causing sexual activity without consent against adults, then pretty much all contact child sexual offences and grooming.
Also anyone on a life sentence, extended determinate sentence or IPP (the latter are not issued anymore but SA26 is retrospective)

There are other exemptions around unlawful killing and terrorism offences.
MAPPA eligible cases are eligible for early release, but not eligible for unsupervised final third licence.

InSlovakiaTheCapitalOfCourseIsBratislava · 14/11/2026 21:43

I got to the end of the article so relived that the Michael had been found guilty . I was sure earlier in the article he was going to get off

Rightsraptor · 14/11/2026 22:01

A slight aside to the main points of Amelia Gentleman's piece, but I read an article the other day - can't recall for the life of me where or by whom - that de-bunked the 'laddish era' claims that are being made about Brand and Walliams (the latter not being charged with any offence afaik and denies having broken the law). Essentially the argument was that they were the very opposite of 'laddish' as they both feigned being gay, or camp at the very least. Which was an obvious strategy to ensnair women, as we know.