Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Well done, FWS, and women everywhere. There are no men in women's jails in Scotland.

404 replies

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 20:08

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c962p8217zxdo

'All transgender inmates have been moved out of women's prisons, according to the Scottish Prison Service (SPS).
SPS deputy chief executive Adam Jobson told Holyrood's Equalities Committee that a small number of transgender prisoners had been moved. He said that trans women - biological males who identify as women - were now held in men's prisons.
The move was to comply with a judge's ruling in June, that sex segregation in prisons must be based on biological sex rather than gender identity.'

An image of a series of security gates in a prison - with floor-to-ceiling white metal bars. Above the first set it says "E/F Wing" and a prison officer - a bald man in a white shirt and black trousers - is opening the gate. We see him from behind.

No biological males in women's prisons, Scottish Prison Service confirms

All transgender women - biological males who identify as women - have now been moved into men's jails to comply with a legal ruling.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c962p8217zxdo

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
Wishesandhorses · 13/11/2026 16:36

ArabellaScott · 13/11/2026 14:36

Sorry, I've ruined the thread. What a dreadful song.

It's quite an activist friendly one really. 'I like women best when they SHUT UP'.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/11/2026 16:37

ArabellaScott · 13/11/2026 16:14

Heman famously wasn't all that fussed about clothes. I wonder what gender they was.

Wouldn’t he be He-Man? Literal violence!

Perenelle · 13/11/2026 16:38

ArabellaScott · 13/11/2026 16:14

Heman famously wasn't all that fussed about clothes. I wonder what gender they was.

Non binary, because of Prince Adam.🙃

SirChenjins · 13/11/2026 16:39

Justnot · 13/11/2026 16:15

Do we ever get baldy beardy big boobed ones on here or do they all pass…….

eta: baldy

Edited

They all pass - and then men like Mr Splintery Rolling Pin post photos of themselves on other sites and it's very clear that's it's been a while since their last visit to Specsavers.

nicepotoftea · 13/11/2026 16:40

Transperson · 13/11/2026 12:30

"On this pageChapters and ArticlesYou might find these chapters and articles relevant to this topic.ChapterSex Determination2011, The Human Genome (Third Edition)Julia E. Richards, R. Scott HawleySecondary Sexual CharacteristicsSecondary sexual characteristics are those sexually dimorphic characteristics that are not directly involved in reproduction. For males, secondary characteristics include facial and chest hair, increased body hair, pelvic build (lack of rounded hips), upper body muscular build, and the ability to generate muscle mass at a faster rate than the female. For females, secondary sex characteristics include relative lack of body hair, thicker hair on the head (in some cases), rounded hips/figure, a decreased ability to generate muscle mass at a fast rate, decreased upper body strength, breasts, ability to nurse children, a menstrual cycle, and increased body fat composition. There are, of course, exceptions to any efforts to use a list of features to classify people into the conventionally defined sex categories. For instance, not all women succeed in breast-feeding their infants, even if they otherwise fit the conventional definition of female."

https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/veterinary-science-and-veterinary-medicine/secondary-sex-characteristic

There are, of course, exceptions to any efforts to use a list of features to classify people into the conventionally defined sex categories.

Absence of a period in a woman indicates pregnancy, age, malnutrition, illness, a disorder.

Absence of a period in a man, just means it's Tuesday.

MrEdwardElizabethHitler · 13/11/2026 17:16

Well done to FWS!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/11/2026 17:21

SirChenjins · 13/11/2026 16:39

They all pass - and then men like Mr Splintery Rolling Pin post photos of themselves on other sites and it's very clear that's it's been a while since their last visit to Specsavers.

This. There’s another very vocal man on Reddit who claims to totally pass. Reader, he does not.

RNApolymerase · 13/11/2026 17:27

Sometimes male entitlement just shines so brightly you don't even need to see a person.

TheKeatingFive · 13/11/2026 18:02

As I said to TP on another thread, ‘passing’ is in the eye of the beholder. These trans identifying men are the very last people in a position to judge on whether they ‘pass’ or not.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 13/11/2026 18:03

I'm not a biologist, but I'm pretty sure people with CAIS have male gondors/gonands/gonads/.....testes

solerolover · 13/11/2026 18:05

WearyAuldWumman · 13/11/2026 16:09

Some years ago, I frequented a Doctor Who forum.

One of the posters there introduced us to the term 'cis'. In heart-rending detail, this person told us of their struggles as a transwoman and of how they passed so completely that they'd been mistaken for 'cis' and raped by a straight man.

It is absolutely shocking that this person had experienced such a vile crime, and of course, they got a great deal of sympathy.

They posted a great deal over several months. One day, they decided to show off a new outfit and hairstyle and posted a picture of themselves. For some reason, they were reclining on a couch, but it was a perfectly respectable picture.

Believe me when I tell you that my dad would have passed better than this poor deluded soul - and Dad was a 6ft Eastern European coal miner with the muscles to go with his job. Actually, my uncle would have passed better - and he looked like a slightly tougher version of Ernest Borgnine.

Edited

This reminds me of a post on one of the trans reddit forums I came across, where a middle-aged trans-identified man, bragged about dating and "converting" a Trump-loving "transphobic" man into the belief that TWAW. Anyway, he also talked about how proud he was to be a transwoman, who now "passes" and is read as "cis" by everyone around him. I'm not joking when I saw, my jaw dropped to the floor, cartoon-style, when I saw this person's picture, they were undeniably male, massive jaw, large skull, massive shoulders, just overall strongly built like a brick shithouse, all of this in spite of his makeup and dress.

What these men fail to realise is that most people are playing along with them to avoid a meltdown or things turning violent, also, very few people are going to be explicitly mentioning their "trans status" to their faces during every single interaction because that's not polite. The fact that they take this to mean that they "pass" as women, is really quite pathetic. I do think that there's other factors at play too, with regards to porn consumption, low self esteem and also some neurodivergence, which skews their perceptions of their self-image and leads them to missing glaring social cues.

Helleofabore · 13/11/2026 18:05

I also think it is important to remember that having empathy can be performative but also fully dependant on a person’s definition of empathy which may not match the commonly accepted definition. A bit like inclusion, respect, kind and all the words female people and our bodies.

Helleofabore · 13/11/2026 18:12

Transperson · 13/11/2026 12:13

This is about right.

"Surely the observable characteristics of a person are just that: observable characteristics, there are also layers of characteristics that are not observable - for instance, XX or XY chromosomes are not observable, but they are discoverable, and they are what determines whether a person is male or female." Yes you are correct those deeper layers are the gonandal and genotypic sex and they don't have to match in terms of sex. You can be genotypically male but gonandally female (which is what people with CAIS are) this is a simplification but im glad you understand the concept.

I do believe as scientific advances progress trans people would be able to influence their gonandal sex (and maybe even genotypic).
Currently it's just the phenotype.

How?

What the fuck have you been reading that gives you the impression gonadal sex in adolescents and adult will be able to change?

Please describe exactly how you expect this to change? Even plug and play gonads will require significant infrastructure changes. How will this happen?

I think you just keep repeating trope you see on line and you simply have no idea of even the basics.

AstonCanKissMyArse · 13/11/2026 18:13

IwantToRetire · 12/11/2026 20:24

Men's feelings of course should always take precedence of women's you mean!

It's high time you ask MNHQ to set up a forum of Trans Ideology not linked to feminism, so you can get on with talking about that instead of endlessly intruding on a forum for women to discuss issues within the framework of women's sex based rights.

Trans ideology has nothing to do with feminism, so not sure why you persist in posting on this forum.

I think MNHQ would get a lot of support if it set up a forum in its own right about Trans, Queer Politics.

But I suppose that wouldn't be as much fun as derailing as many threads as you can of a forum for women to discuss their sex based rights.

Hear, hear.

Imagine if the doghouse forum was overrun by people constantly whining 'what about the cats? You are all hateful feline exclusionists. Cats exist !!!!!!' Ad nauseam?

Helleofabore · 13/11/2026 18:17

Transperson · 13/11/2026 12:41

So no paper will ever change your mind? Very scientific of you.

Is that the sum of your academic links that support your repeated claims?

Good to know there was nothing behind your claims then and that a new paper hadn’t come out that we had missed. We do like analysing new papers.

nutmeg7 · 13/11/2026 18:32

Transperson · 13/11/2026 11:59

Only because I don't adopt your moral framework doesn't mean that my moral framework is corrupt.

As we said, no empathy for female people if they get in the way of what you want when you want it.
We are only non-human walk-on parts in your own personal validation drama.

nutmeg7 · 13/11/2026 18:40

Transperson · 13/11/2026 12:32

"Most individuals fall into one of two categories, clearly male or clearly female with complete consistency of genetic, gonadal, anatomic, and psychological aspects of sex within any one individual. However, there clearly is a complex gradient that runs from male to female occupied by many different varieties of people who do not fall neatly into one of the two standard sexual definitions."

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/chapter/monograph/abs/pii/B9780080918655000084

It's not black and white

Most people are clearly male or female, especially when take a look at whether their body is designed to produce sperm or eggs.

You are confusing superficial appearance with the substance of sex, which is a reproductive strategy that very very rarely (0.018%) throws up a fault that is a DSD but is otherwise absolutely black and white. Sperm are not eggs.

Superficial appearance is not sex.

TheKeatingFive · 13/11/2026 18:45

On the point of ‘passing’, can anyone point to a single trans identifying man in the public eye who genuinely passes?

Because I can’t think of a single one, even among those who were puberty blocked. There is
Something unmistakably male about them all the same.

Just to be clear, I mean when they move/speak, not just a very carefully posed, heavily filtered photo.

DialSquare · 13/11/2026 21:46

Taken from House of Games earlier today!

Well done, FWS, and women everywhere. There are no men in women's jails in Scotland.
Helleofabore · 13/11/2026 22:16

TheKeatingFive · 13/11/2026 18:45

On the point of ‘passing’, can anyone point to a single trans identifying man in the public eye who genuinely passes?

Because I can’t think of a single one, even among those who were puberty blocked. There is
Something unmistakably male about them all the same.

Just to be clear, I mean when they move/speak, not just a very carefully posed, heavily filtered photo.

When I think of all the men who declare that they ‘pass’, I think of the well known male people who have declared they have taken puberty blockers and none of them ‘pass’. Yet we are supposed to believe that all the male
people who say they pass?

When I see comments about Hunter Schafer being hailed as a man that passes, I have to wonder at what that means. At least now after this year’s educator posters, I understand that it probably means that the person has developed breast tissue.

I don’t believe that the bar is very high at all. I think men think if they have breast development they are female and no one can tell the difference.

RareGoalsVerge · 13/11/2026 22:30

You're right @Helleofabore

It is entirely possible that female humans are evolutionarily adapted to be able to spot a male very quickly in an ambiguous situation. I can certainly imagine that being a survival trait in prehistoric times. It would be interesting research to compare the capacity of male and female (biologically speaking) people to correctly classify a spectrum of still images and video clips - including plenty of transmen and transwomen as well as gender-nonconforming people of both sexes who don't identify as trans, according to whether the observer test subject believes the person shown is genetically male or female. If female people are more likely to identify the correct sex that might explain the myth of the "passing" transwoman?

A certain well-know thread-derailer stated on another thread that they know they fully pass as female because they actually think they would be able to detect if any woman nearby was distressed by their presence in a female space, and therefore conclude that no one can tell. The arrogance and ignorance intrinsic in this belief, including the lack of understanding of the possibility that someone might either hide their distress as a defence mechanism or might have self-excluded from the space knowing that the transwoman would be there, is too mindboggling to grapple with.

BettyBooper · 13/11/2026 22:37

WearyAuldWumman · 13/11/2026 16:09

Some years ago, I frequented a Doctor Who forum.

One of the posters there introduced us to the term 'cis'. In heart-rending detail, this person told us of their struggles as a transwoman and of how they passed so completely that they'd been mistaken for 'cis' and raped by a straight man.

It is absolutely shocking that this person had experienced such a vile crime, and of course, they got a great deal of sympathy.

They posted a great deal over several months. One day, they decided to show off a new outfit and hairstyle and posted a picture of themselves. For some reason, they were reclining on a couch, but it was a perfectly respectable picture.

Believe me when I tell you that my dad would have passed better than this poor deluded soul - and Dad was a 6ft Eastern European coal miner with the muscles to go with his job. Actually, my uncle would have passed better - and he looked like a slightly tougher version of Ernest Borgnine.

Edited

For some reason, they were reclining on a couch, but it was a perfectly respectable picture.

Well, thank god they had some kind of chair. Dr Dame Katy Denise is doing excellent work.

Praise be!

WearyAuldWumman · 13/11/2026 23:47

BettyBooper · 13/11/2026 22:37

For some reason, they were reclining on a couch, but it was a perfectly respectable picture.

Well, thank god they had some kind of chair. Dr Dame Katy Denise is doing excellent work.

Praise be!

I needed that laugh. Thank you.

I'm no longer on X, but have fond memories of Dr Dame Katy Denise. (Can't remember her being both a Dr and a Dame, tbh, but her chair campaign definitely made an impression.)

Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 12:17

I think that what is great is seeing the pushback continue the no male people are in any way female and women across the internet are saying this very clearly now.

Because, partly, of the FWS decision.

Speaking of phenotypically female, let's all remember Jordan.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5284774-jordan-gray-on-c4-tonight

And I would have to point out that Jordan would also use that claim that he is 'phenotypically' female. And yet... even before he got out his penis, he is very clearly male.

https://x.com/Mark1957/status/2120495834265448607?a=-QIRT5Aq6JiZNISOtmo&s=20

And I bet every single man in this photo believes he passes. And yet, their breasts are very clearly male breasts on a male body.

But, near enough is good enough, eh?

Jordan Gray Nominated for Female Award | Mumsnet

Unbelievable! Jordan Gray (remember "she" played the piano with "her" penis) has been nominated for Best Female Comedy Appearance for Transaction....

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5501636-jordan-gray-nominated-for-female-award

Ereshkigalangcleg · 14/11/2026 15:42

Robin Moira White “somatically female”

Dr Upton “I’m biological and I’m a woman so I’m a biological woman. Biological sex is a nebulous dog whistle.”

neither of these men pass as female

Swipe left for the next trending thread