Press release in full:
Brighton School Drops ‘Secret’ Policy Allowing Biological Boys To Use Girls’ Changing Rooms After Legal Challenge
Dorothy Stringer climbs down after father and daughter launch judicial review over controversial case-by-case policy
The Dorothy Stringer Secondary School in Brighton has changed its policy of allowing biological boys to use girls’ changing rooms and toilets after a teenage girl and her father launched High Court proceedings.
The legal challenge against the school has now been withdrawn, days before a hearing was due to take place, after the school finally completed alterations to its facilities and confirmed that no pupil can use changing rooms designated for the opposite biological sex or undress in front of pupils of the opposite biological sex. The claimants are delighted: this is the outcome they have been fighting for.
The nature of the dispute
At the heart of the dispute was the school’s policy of considering requests by transgender pupils to use opposite-sex facilities on a case-by-case basis. Crucially, this could, and did, happen without the girls affected, or their parents, being told. The teenage claimant discovered that she appeared to have been sharing a girls’ changing room with a biological male pupil. Neither she nor her parents had been consulted or informed.
The father became aware of the issue when his daughter raised her concerns at home in early 2025. Between January and May 2025, he submitted a total of five safeguarding complaints about the practice which, by then, had been going on for approximately three years. These included a demand that school policies comply with the Supreme Court ruling in For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers in April 2025 that the terms ‘male’ and ‘female’ under the Equality Act 2010 refer to biological sex.
In pre-action correspondence, the school vigorously defended its case-by-case approach and refused to commit at that stage to the approach proposed in draft KCSIE. After proceedings had been issued, Good Law Project was still publicly defending the school’s “current case-by-case approach” in June, saying it enabled “lawful, considered decisions” and warning that a blanket policy would remove the school’s discretion.
Involvement of Good Law Project
Unusually, Dorothy Stringer instructed Good Law Project, the campaigning legal organisation active on transgender issues, rather than relying upon the local authority’s legal team. The choice attracted particular attention because Good Law Project has publicly opposed biological-sex-based restrictions in toilets and changing facilities and has described the Supreme Court’s ruling as a “transphobic decision”. Good Law Project crowdfunded for this challenge, and in their Crowdfunder described the school’s approach as ‘responsible safeguarding’ and criticised a blanket policy because it would remove the school’s discretion.
Good Law Project has issued a surprising update on this case, claiming victory for themselves and stating amongst other things that “This case wasn’t prompted by any problem.” The evidence of the teenage claimant tells a different story. She described sharing the communal girls’ changing room with a pupil of the opposite biological sex over a period of several years, without being consulted, and becoming increasingly uncomfortable as she grew older. “I was conscious that he was there, and that affected how I changed,” she said, explaining that she covered herself more and positioned herself so that less of her body could be seen. She also said she had not felt able to complain because she feared being labelled “transphobic” or simply “shut down”. In the view of the claimants, there was most definitely a problem at the Dorothy Stringer school, one that they failed to address adequately despite multiple safeguarding complaints.
The school climbs down
After the final KCSIE guidance was published in July and came into force on 1 September 2026, the school expressly confirmed that it intended to comply with the guidance and provided evidence as to physical alterations it had made to the changing rooms and toilets, whilst GLP continued to warn publicly that implementation of the KCSIE guidance could encourage discrimination, and to advocate sensitive and flexible decisions. Eventually, in October 2026, the school provided the assurances which the claimants had been seeking, and a decision was taken to withdraw the claim.
Quotes from the claimants and their legal representative
The father of the teenage claimant said, “Girls should not have to find out by accident that a biological boy may be using their changing room, and my daughter’s privacy, dignity and safety should never have required a protracted legal battle.
“We trusted Dorothy Stringer to protect her. Instead, our family paid in time, money and emotional strain to secure protections she should have been able to take for granted. Having a policy which allowed biological males into girls’ changing rooms without telling pupils or parents was a profound betrayal of trust, affecting thousands of female pupils at this school alone. Changing the policies now does not erase that betrayal.
“Schools must listen to girls and safeguard them. No child’s protection should depend on her family’s ability to fight a legal case.”
The teenage claimant said, “This has taught me to think twice about teachers and schools who I used to trust. It’s taken so long just to keep boys out of my changing room, why aren’t girls’ voices heard?”
Paul Conrathe, representing the claimants, said, “My clients are delighted. With an utter disregard for safeguarding, the school allowed biological boys into the girls’ changing rooms and toilets on a case-by-case basis for several years, but now they have finally dropped this practice. The father’s numerous safeguarding complaints went unheeded and as a result he and his daughter had no choice but to commence proceedings in the High Court to force the school to abandon its unlawful policy.”
The recent publication of Statutory Guidance on safeguarding (KCSIE) has underlined the established legal position that under no circumstances should biological boys have access to girls’ single sex spaces in schools. The school’s belated climbdown not only vindicates an exasperated father’s attempts to protect his daughter’s privacy, dignity and safety; it sends a clear message to all schools that single sex spaces should only be accessed by those of the biological sex for which they are designated.
Notes to Editors
- The proceedings are LIN and LIP v The Governing Board of Dorothy Stringer School and Brighton & Hove City Council, claim number AC-2026-LON-001527.
- The anonymity of the teenage claimant and her father remains protected by court order.
- Judicial review proceedings were issued in March 2026 following pre-action correspondence beginning in December 2025.
- The proceedings were formally withdrawn by consent before an oral permission hearing due to take place at the High Court on 10 November. Legal costs have not yet been determined.
- The relevant paragraphs from KCSIE 2026 are the following:
Paragraph 117, which states: ‘If a gender-questioning child does not want to use the changing rooms and showers designated for their sex, schools and colleges should consider whether they can provide an alternative changing or washing facility without compromising the provision of single-sex facilities. This could be a fully enclosed room – for use by one child at a time that can be secured from the inside – or by allowing access to facilities at an alternative time. These alternative arrangements should not compromise the safety, comfort, privacy or dignity of the child or of any other children.’ (Emphasis added).
Paragraph 276, which states: ‘In line with the responsibilities of schools and colleges to adhere to the highest standards of safeguarding for the children and young people in their care, alongside obligations under the School Premises (England) Regulations 2012 and the Education (Independent School Standards) Regulations 2014, schools must not allow pupils into toilets, changing rooms, or boarding or residential accommodation designated for the opposite sex, with no exceptions.’ (Emphasis added).
- The second defendant in the proceedings was Brighton & Hove Council. It is pertinent to note that the approach taken by the school is endorsed in the Council’s Trans Inclusion Schools Toolkit, which recommends a case-by-case approach, for example:
Section 4.3.3, which states: ‘The use of changing rooms by trans children and young people should be assessed on a case-by-case basis in discussion with the individual child or young person.’
Section 1.2, which states: ‘Support for individual trans children and young people should generally be provided on a case-by-case basis in discussion with them, their family and professionals around them.’ And ‘No two cases will necessarily be alike, and schools should, as they do with other decisions, deal sensitively with each case on its individual facts.’