Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

A heartfelt thank you to the Reddit trolls of MN

252 replies

FlirtsWithRhinos · 11/11/2026 11:32

Clap Applause GIF

On a recent thread there was link to some Redditors discussing how they troll MN and FWR.

It was deleted before I saw it, but another poster mentioned one of said trolls enjoyed posting 2 line replies to provoke essays in return.

And I thought

Wow.

I wonder if that guy (or gal) realises just how valuable his snipes have been.

A couple of throwaway lines for him, and yet because of them, women are being motivated into to much careful thinking and analysis. Into putting effort into finding and understanding the original research behind soundbite claims to see what actually stacks up.

And because of him and people like him, women on FWR have generated over the years so much, so much, careful and thoughtful long form writing. Taking the time to consider angles, refine our thoughts, test our own arguments, assumptions and yes, prejudices and find the core of what we believe matters for women when it comes to the demands of Genderism and why.

Years and years of facing the same incomplete, insubstantial, sexist or just bad faith arguments over and over again have generated well honed clear explanations that cut to the heart of why they do not stand up.

There's a type of deep thinking that only comes out through drafting and redrafting written essays. Through finding just the right words to explain a concept. Through realising something once it's written down doesn't quite hang together and inserting your intelligence into the gap and twisting to see why. And these trolls have played such a valuable role in helping us see why putt8ling our time and effort into that matters.

A bad teacher tells you what to think. A good teacher shows you how to think. So it's such an irony that our trolls in aiming to be the forner but doing it so, I'm sorry, badly, have in fact become the latter.

So now here we are. Years and years, thousands and thousands of articulate, logical, patient and calm posts backing up women's voices, ready to help the women who continue to arrive here with a sense they are Kind, of course they are, but something isn't quite right with what they are being told they should think and feel.

And now, feeding the AI models that lap up reasoned, argued and above all consistent content as their bread and butter as they build their maps of our culture as well.

And so much of this, of the passion and the consistency and the careful checking and refining, has been greatly down to the indefatigable efforts of our MN trolls refusing to give up their baiting and sniping no matter how trounced they get.

Reddit Trolls of MN, Brava!

I salute you.

Don't ever change 🤍💚💜

OP posts:
Manyanamanyana · 11/11/2026 21:09

RareGoalsVerge · 11/11/2026 14:17

Absolutely.

The 2 threads (because 1000 posts wasn't enough obviously) were indeed full of well reasoned, thoughtful and rational responses.

The thing that the narcisist trolls of Reddit don't get is that they are not the only audience for these posts. Yes they have started the thread with no intention of actually listening, they just want to waste our time and energy. But the energy and time is not wasted - it's read by other people - more rational and sane people than them - who thereby come to understand the importance of our message. The posts are found by search engines and found by other curious people, and sanity prevails. They fact that they don't realise the good they are doing for us is all part of the total "it's all about meeeeeeee" attitude they have - other people don't really properly exist as humans for them.

Thank you for this thread OP. I was frustrated earlier because I wrote the following when thread 2 was at about 900 messages but didn't manage to press "Post" before I started having to do "real life" stuff and when I got back to my phone, the thread was full and I couldn't post:

TRA (with faux wide-eyed innocence):
"please tell me why you hate me"
Women:
"We do not hate you. These behaviours harm us"
TRA (removing faux persona):
"You are not allowed to feel that. You are wrong. I am allowed to keep doing the things you say are harmful because I am more important than you and your experience doesn't count like mine does."

Women spot that that the "I am more important than you" is just one more product of patriarchal misogyny from a male socialised to see women as service creatures. We get on with being feminists and stop engaging with the disingenuous sexists.

But actually come to think of it, that 2nd paragraph is wrong. We don't have to ignore them because every thread that is full of these long responses to narcisitic whining builds up the unassailable body of evidence that womens rights are important and sometimes have to take precidence even when they make a male person sad.

100% they are not our audience, simply our canvas. I first visited the Mumsnet sex and gender board 3 or 4 years ago, with no idea that this was an issue. I was blown away by the serious and committed nature of the incredible women here who knew their stuff, referred to policy and law and took action, all those small local actions that make change happen. From memory, the first thread I was reading through was a Mum challenging a school toilet policy, where (before FWS) a school had replaced sex with "gender identity" on a poster, and the OP and the other posters iterated a letter response until it was bulletproof. This was my first eye-opener to what was going on, and I was completely peaked. Since then I have joined a local feminist chapter, taken political action, written too and met with politicians, and importantly, made sure my kids and family know what this is actually about.
The women of Mumsnet make change happen. You are all amazing, and you keep me sane and hopeful. I am not from TERF Island, but you are obviously a beacon of hope to the rest of the world, honestly. And yes, to the trolls, thank you so much for the many many opportunities to hone my message, understand your twisted logic and occasionally, vent my rage. Your contribution to our fight should not go unacknowledged.

Hedgehogforshort · 11/11/2026 21:02

I lurked on the transperson threads, and made no contribution partly because I can trust others, who have the energy, and also because I have trans fatigue.

it’s just so fucking tedious. I assume it is some kind of process one goes through.

i had my entry be kind ish thingy, dashed of and read a lot of books.

and finally became hard line GC.

I talk about the issues in my normal life as it is important, what I have found in my market town and village, nobody thinks trans people are a thing with validity.

I am currently wandering around you tube and seeing how the world outside here is going.

All good I would say.

i stumbled upon a you tube video with billboard Chris against 10 trans women and of course Buck Angel.

what was striking was the lack of knowledge, and the hyperbole very much reflected from the TRAs on here

I think they all know the game is up and congregate here in a last ditch attempt to save themselves from reality.

currently watching the gay therapist, we need them on board, and what happens in the USA happens to us.

BettyBooper · 11/11/2026 20:46

BettyBooper · 11/11/2026 20:40

If I (as an adult) said 'i identify as a child. I was assaulted by an adult and as such, I need to get undressed with children in order to be safe. I have to be safe. I don't assault anyone.'

Would you be happy for me to be with your kids, or would you think I was a massive red flag?

Seriously now.

Listen to yourself and how your words and actions come across. Women are not your security. You cannot invade women's spaces on your own say so because you feel like it 'makes you feel safe'.

Oh and to add, I don't believe for one single second that you use the women's changing room by 'passing' or that you do so to 'feel safe' 🙄.

Just so that we're clear.

Anyway that'll be my last post to you as you are detailing a thread.

BettyBooper · 11/11/2026 20:40

Transperson · 11/11/2026 18:11

I am so sorry you went through do that, no one deserves that. Would you want me to get assaulted too (I have alredy have in the past)? I understand your pain but I have to be safe, I don't assault anyone.

If I (as an adult) said 'i identify as a child. I was assaulted by an adult and as such, I need to get undressed with children in order to be safe. I have to be safe. I don't assault anyone.'

Would you be happy for me to be with your kids, or would you think I was a massive red flag?

Seriously now.

Listen to yourself and how your words and actions come across. Women are not your security. You cannot invade women's spaces on your own say so because you feel like it 'makes you feel safe'.

ICouldHaveCheckedFirst · 11/11/2026 20:31

Am I the only one who reads Main Character Energy as Male Character Energy?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 11/11/2026 19:59

MrsOvertonsWindow · 11/11/2026 19:56

Hopefully you're getting the thread back Flirts rather than another self indulgent whine fest about mean women.

So many of the posts I read on the whining threads were incredible, articulate posts from women. They reinforced what's happened in recent years. A decade ago you had to explain everything. But now, the serious overreach of these men has resulted in so many of the population educating themselves. The court cases, succession of sex offenders, murderers etc claiming to be women & the endless employment tribunals. Plus of course the targeting of children in schools.
So now, everyone's been educated. And what they've seen is the anti social, anti democratic, anti women and anti child safety. So they're speaking out - very clearly.
As the whining threads showed. 😅

Yes, Transperson posted upthread to recognise this isn't a continuation of his threads. I'm hoping he'll start thread three for some of the open questions.

OP posts:
MrsOvertonsWindow · 11/11/2026 19:56

Hopefully you're getting the thread back Flirts rather than another self indulgent whine fest about mean women.

So many of the posts I read on the whining threads were incredible, articulate posts from women. They reinforced what's happened in recent years. A decade ago you had to explain everything. But now, the serious overreach of these men has resulted in so many of the population educating themselves. The court cases, succession of sex offenders, murderers etc claiming to be women & the endless employment tribunals. Plus of course the targeting of children in schools.
So now, everyone's been educated. And what they've seen is the anti social, anti democratic, anti women and anti child safety. So they're speaking out - very clearly.
As the whining threads showed. 😅

CohensDiamondTeeth · 11/11/2026 19:29

Tears0fTheMushroom · 11/11/2026 19:14

Why not say "trans women" rather than trans people. It is, after all, what you actually mean.
I doubt you give a flying fuck about transmen who are just women and don't matter to you.

The only person who matters to this guy is himself.

He's not even attempting to hide his selfish attitude, he said he didn't care about other trans identified males either.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 11/11/2026 19:14

Transperson · 11/11/2026 17:44

I am saying it's unacceptable for trans people and women to be out in danger by men.

Why not say "trans women" rather than trans people. It is, after all, what you actually mean.
I doubt you give a flying fuck about transmen who are just women and don't matter to you.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 19:11

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 11/11/2026 18:17

I'm one of these men. And I have <some> insight into the TIM mind, hey, they're my clan and share my biology, hormones.
I have insight into Brand and Walliams too, they're easier to understand, but TIM mindset is something I've more and more got to understand, especially as I move way past my older, harsher attitudes to women.
Changing my outlook brings my old outlook into sharper relief.

Good. Keep going. You'll find, as many women do, that there are apparently fucking infinite layers of sexism.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 11/11/2026 19:09

Transperson · 11/11/2026 17:45

Literally have, was a very nervous experience since there wasn't any other showers...

No men's showers? Where was this? I can only assume it was a women's only gym or shelter where you shouldn't have been anyway if there were showers provided for women but not men.

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 19:06

"If you'd been like this or that, things would've been different."

This is the classic DARVO line.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 11/11/2026 19:03

GriseldaandMike · 11/11/2026 17:23

If women will spot you are male if you shower naked why can you not just shower naked in the mens? You are covering up your body in the showers while getting an eyeful of naked women/ girls who according to you have no idea they are naked in front of a male person.

The law says female single sex spaces are just for women, not women and men who sneak in without being spotted, not women and unhappy men not women and scared men, just women.

Oh and glad to see you are backing away from last night's my sexual partners have no right to know they are shagging a bloke stance.

Edited

"Passing" is just another iteration of the adolescent boys' fantasy of being invisible in the girls changing rooms - but for adult men - isn't it?

Spying on the women/girls without them "seeing" you.

Except, of course, women CAN see you. You're not invisible. You don't "pass" and most of you fucking KNOW this and are perfectly aware of the distress you are causing.

And if you WERE effectively "invisible" it's still not OK. It's worse. There is literally NO WAY to make this hideous violation of women's privacy, dignity and safety OK.

STAY OUT!

hajiugbbhg · 11/11/2026 18:54

From Reddit today:

“Cis people should be banned from writing books about trans people's lives”

They don’t see the irony AT ALL do they????

hajiugbbhg · 11/11/2026 18:47

I love reading the trans uk Reddit, I swear they’re just a bunch of spoilt 20 year olds. “Waaa I’m a girl, my parents don’t understand me but I’m pathetic with no job prospects and have no money so have to live here”.

allthemind · 11/11/2026 18:45

Transperson · 11/11/2026 17:55

Well communal showers have 1 door. There wasn't any individual showers. Won't say exactly where exactly for privacy reasons (and also wouldn't want anyone from here to contact them)

Right, you've really jumped the shark here transperson. I've been a member of 4 gyms in the UK, 2 in NY, 2 in Europe, been to circa 30 different leisure centre and university pools in the UK, countless spas and hotel pools, around the world, including Asia, Africa, US and Europe and have never, ever seen one that had communal showers. Not even on crappy campsites. Every single female changing room in all of the above had individual shower cubicles with doors, and all the changing rooms had lockable cubicle options.

You've given yourself away here. You're thinking of the mens. And yet again, you don't understand women's lives.

GwenPost · 11/11/2026 18:34

Transperson · 11/11/2026 17:55

Well communal showers have 1 door. There wasn't any individual showers. Won't say exactly where exactly for privacy reasons (and also wouldn't want anyone from here to contact them)

wouldn't want anyone from here to contact them

isnt that a TRA tactic though

From what i've seen recently the people on here are more the type to sit on their hands and refrain from even airing personal disputes let alone trying to cause trouble irl for people they disagree with.

cherryicecreamisnice · 11/11/2026 18:33

This is so true, though it’s hard to feel positive sometimes. Scrolling through the thread that I think you’re referring to for hours, I once again questioned why I put myself through it; the stupid posits that show no empathy and prove that answers haven’t been read make depressing reading.
But regarding the enormous body of work provided by all the hard working women on here is what makes it so rewarding. So much so that instead of arguing IRL lately, I refer them to the encyclopaedic bank of information provided by the tireless contributors on Mumsnet.

Verisregina · 11/11/2026 18:33

Transperson · 11/11/2026 17:48

"Is that ’I don’t really care’ about women’s experiences of violence, of trauma, of historic injustices and current struggles to protect our spaces?" As in I don't influence any of these.

"disregard the rights and expectations of women to single sex spaces, regardless of whether or not we know you’re doing it"

Well here we can go to the point of if I make no difference then how am I changing the expectations? If people don't know their expectations aren't changed and I don't change the expectations.

@Transperson

You don’t believe that accessing women’s single sex spaces without their knowledge is wrong.

You are happy to disregard women’s experiences of violence, trauma and historic injustices, as to all intents and purposes; ‘it’s nothing to do with me guvnor’.

You believe it doesn’t matter if you invade women’s single sex spaces if they don’t know you’re doing it.

You believe your ‘phenotype’ allows you to access our single sex spaces regardless of what we and society in general would prefer.

I wonder if you recognise how deeply disturbing your position is?

I am sure I’m not alone in finding it inherently unpleasant, creepy and threatening.

And as for my expectations, you’re certainly living up to them.

CohensDiamondTeeth · 11/11/2026 18:33

Transperson · 11/11/2026 18:14

You compared me to a dog (or was it a banana?).
To show the absurdity of that I called you a gorilla (as it's more similar to human genotype).

Edited

Total bullshit.

If anyone cares to go back and read through the thread they will see clearly that the poster was saying that human beings share some common dna with dogs, and bananas.

Absolutely no one made the comparison between you and any animal or fruit.

You are ridiculous.

After your cloth eared and offensive response to a woman who explained politely how she would feel on finding a male in a female single sex space, I stand by my assertion that you are just attempting to upset women on purpose.

solerolover · 11/11/2026 18:31

BiGuy · 11/11/2026 16:49

I think that there is at least one who is just arguing for the sake of it. They claim not to be trans & to have no trans friends or relatives yet they lecture us on the trans experience with no explanation of their bona fides.

Ah yes, the self proclaimed "debate pervert", with no less than 15 usernames.

GriseldaandMike · 11/11/2026 18:24

Transperson · 11/11/2026 18:14

You compared me to a dog (or was it a banana?).
To show the absurdity of that I called you a gorilla (as it's more similar to human genotype).

Edited

No I didn't - you claimed to have 'some' biological over lap with women. I pointed out that there is a lot of biological over lap between men and women. I didn't call you anything.

Even though every woman who frequents this board could lists dozens of differences between males and females none of us would say there is no over lap so your claim to have 'some' isn't news to us.

SabrinaThwaite · 11/11/2026 18:24

ItsCoolForCats · 11/11/2026 14:19

This is such a good point. I assumed that they like to think that we don't have lives and careers because it comforts them to tell themselves this. They also think the women on here are outliers, whereas we know that the general public's views on sex are much more aligned with this board than echo chambers such as Reddit.

But your point has made me think that perhaps they really do think that we are all jobless and unable to think for ourselves because their views about women are rooted in misogyny. It makes sense.

There’s a Reddit thread from a day or so ago that calls the entire UK population ‘monstrously transphobic’ on the basis of the regular YouGov surveys.

Cue Redditors asking if YouGov can be astroturfed / is it representative. One reply did point out that no Redditor would be asking that if the YouGov surveys were wholeheartedly supportive of trans people.

MyAmpleSheep · 11/11/2026 18:24

On the subjects raised in the original post, I declare a profound gratitude to UK Trans Reddit. I have learned so much from the posts there. The Talmud asks "who is wise?" - the answer is "the one who learns from everyone". I do my best to be wise.

solerolover · 11/11/2026 18:23

CompleteGinasaur · 11/11/2026 17:57

Meanwhile, back in the real world...

I was thinking the same thing. This is very, very clearly through the lens of male fantasy. Sickening.

Swipe left for the next trending thread