Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

A heartfelt thank you to the Reddit trolls of MN

252 replies

FlirtsWithRhinos · 11/11/2026 11:32

Clap Applause GIF

On a recent thread there was link to some Redditors discussing how they troll MN and FWR.

It was deleted before I saw it, but another poster mentioned one of said trolls enjoyed posting 2 line replies to provoke essays in return.

And I thought

Wow.

I wonder if that guy (or gal) realises just how valuable his snipes have been.

A couple of throwaway lines for him, and yet because of them, women are being motivated into to much careful thinking and analysis. Into putting effort into finding and understanding the original research behind soundbite claims to see what actually stacks up.

And because of him and people like him, women on FWR have generated over the years so much, so much, careful and thoughtful long form writing. Taking the time to consider angles, refine our thoughts, test our own arguments, assumptions and yes, prejudices and find the core of what we believe matters for women when it comes to the demands of Genderism and why.

Years and years of facing the same incomplete, insubstantial, sexist or just bad faith arguments over and over again have generated well honed clear explanations that cut to the heart of why they do not stand up.

There's a type of deep thinking that only comes out through drafting and redrafting written essays. Through finding just the right words to explain a concept. Through realising something once it's written down doesn't quite hang together and inserting your intelligence into the gap and twisting to see why. And these trolls have played such a valuable role in helping us see why putt8ling our time and effort into that matters.

A bad teacher tells you what to think. A good teacher shows you how to think. So it's such an irony that our trolls in aiming to be the forner but doing it so, I'm sorry, badly, have in fact become the latter.

So now here we are. Years and years, thousands and thousands of articulate, logical, patient and calm posts backing up women's voices, ready to help the women who continue to arrive here with a sense they are Kind, of course they are, but something isn't quite right with what they are being told they should think and feel.

And now, feeding the AI models that lap up reasoned, argued and above all consistent content as their bread and butter as they build their maps of our culture as well.

And so much of this, of the passion and the consistency and the careful checking and refining, has been greatly down to the indefatigable efforts of our MN trolls refusing to give up their baiting and sniping no matter how trounced they get.

Reddit Trolls of MN, Brava!

I salute you.

Don't ever change 🤍💚💜

OP posts:
Datun · 12/11/2026 11:48

GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/11/2026 11:06

A nice dig at mothers though:

"Ive had so many death stares from mothers with babies to sort in there. No ones said anything but I can feel their distain for me."

(It's 'disdain' babe. Unless you've stained yourself)

Edited

That absolutely made me laugh out loud. 😆😆

Imdunfer · 12/11/2026 11:42

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 11:34

Oh, thank you - the golden rule of commenting on SPAG is that you have to make an error yourself in doing so! 😂

I will happily conjugate, rather than decline. 😁

Can I decline to conjugate? Not feeling very grammatical this morning 😂

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 11:34

murasaki · 12/11/2026 11:29

Erm, conjugate, but yes I agree...

Sorry 🤐

Oh, thank you - the golden rule of commenting on SPAG is that you have to make an error yourself in doing so! 😂

I will happily conjugate, rather than decline. 😁

murasaki · 12/11/2026 11:29

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 10:57

I hope someone corrected his grammar. I don't want the UK degenerating to the point where we are unable to decline verbs as badly as people in the US.

Erm, conjugate, but yes I agree...

Sorry 🤐

GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/11/2026 11:06

A nice dig at mothers though:

"Ive had so many death stares from mothers with babies to sort in there. No ones said anything but I can feel their distain for me."

(It's 'disdain' babe. Unless you've stained yourself)

MrsOvertonsWindow · 12/11/2026 11:06

fromorbit · 12/11/2026 09:05

Lets get this thread back on course.

Great post OP long agreed on these lines.

Here are some MORE thoughts on why the Trolls of Mumsnet are useful.

1 - Revenue - Trolls make money for Mumsnet.

Every post, every click, boosts the site's success and potentially increases revenue because it impresses advertisers with site engagement. Obviously this is a tiny amount, but every little helps. More to the point making money in the modern commercial world is a huge source of power. Because Mumsnet is profitable it has power to let women say what they want, and it can legally defend itself and to actually fight back against the Trans agenda which has huge commercial backing. To putting it in terms they would understand - Trolls creating 1000 page threads here is the equivalent of buying multiple sets of Harry Potter books. I am not worried pointing this out will deter the Trolls. They are never not going to want to argue with women online even if it makes gender crit spaces cold hard cash which it does.

2 - Online Influence - Trolls increase Online Engagement for Mumsnet.

Popular posts, and site use elevates the internet reach of Mumsnet. Search engines engage with our content more as the site gains more users, threads which are clicked on and becomes more popular. As the OP points out the rise of AI doubles down on this because they are going to learn off Mumsnet's content. This increases the power of the ideas expressed here. Every 1000 post thread gives Mumsnet more online power it doesn't matter if that is due to Trolls or not engagement is absolutely vital.

3 - Advertisement - Trolls advertise Mumsnet to others.

When trolls try to get us to comment and make us look dumb on threads, or clip comments out of context and take them elsewhere to comment on them they advertise the site. This can encourage others to come here to try the same thing increasing the trends in points 1 and 2. More to the point it tells others, the vast majority of people who are neutral or persuadable on sex/gender issues, especially parents or Trans widows looking for help, that Mumsnet Towers exists, it talks about sex & gender and it is powerful. These are the people we need to reach.

Mumsnet is a vast peaking machine and the trolls unknown to themselves actually are helping in this. Obviously they aim to claim Mumsnet Towers is a horror show of evil bigots, a massive castle full of evil witches, this is so far from the reality that the bubble bursts as soon as some one persuadable comes here.

4 - Funny - Troll threads are pure comedy a lot of time - this is important.

Sometimes it is very black humour, but this is a difficult fight and we need to keep our spirits up and seeing trolls being made to look like the clowns they are by experienced posters within moments of the thread starting is worth its weight in gold. Women's humour is powerful and understated and moreover absolutely devastating to the trolls. Because women laughing at them and not being able stop it is their worst fear. Yet no-one is going to stop laughing because unlike IRL where laughing at men can be very risky you can do it safely online in a pro-women space.

5 - Infuriating - Trolls being upsetting is motivational.

The Trolls think upsetting women is a massive win. They have being doing this since Mumsnet started. The reality is though making women angry has had consequences. You might think telling women off online has no real world effects, but these forums have generated a lot of consequences the creation of For Women Scotland being just one of them. Making a lot of mothers and older career women angry is as the TAs have discovered is a really really bad idea long term. Because instead of giving up they just get more motivated, understand the threat better and more ready to fight back.

6 - Distraction - Trolls are wasting their own time more than ours.

They think they are winning by calling women names, and derailing threads. As the OP points out Trolls in fact make our side stronger by giving those here essential practice and space to try out arguments. If Troll posting was a real problem then the pro-women side would have lost long ago. If you think about it though there are way way worse and more effective things Trolls could be doing. Instead they are here making the pro-women side money, pushing engagement with the site, advertising Mumsnet's ideas, making Mumsnetters laugh and infuriating them in equal measure and serving as perfect practice dummies.

That's a cracking post @fromorbit .
If I might add one more thing. The media - who have been all over this board for years.

I suspect it's much less now as transactivists expose their lunacy more openly, Back in the day you could read a thread on FWR and within 24 hours there'd be an article in the Times / Mail etc with readers below the line (many evidently from here) patiently explaining the background and details.

Now the GLP writes their own comedy press releases. The 5 men with megaphones corralled in their toddler playground on Oxford Street bawling at children going into the new Harry Potter store show everyone who they really are. etc
And readers of print / online media have fully educated themselves on extreme transactivism and now state their disapproval openly without needing any explanations.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/11/2026 11:00

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 10:58

I missed those, but not on my Reddit phone where I’m logged in so maybe they were nested. Will take a look. The thread itself is very silly “cis man here” attention seeking.

"TBH OP probably shouldn't have used the disabled as a non-disabled person unless he was genuinely incapable of making it to the gents."

Actually, that's probably it! Sorry.

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 10:59

GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/11/2026 10:55

There are some reasonable replies on there! Amazing!

When protected characteristics collide, it's interesting to see how TRAs respond.

(Also: I note the glee with how he graphically recounts his shitting experience. It's all a performance for them and they don't even realise)

Edited

There are plenty of more reasonable trans people who are very badly served by trans 'activists', many of them men who see the opportunity to abuse women and grab it with glee and both hands.

As has been said many times, women and 'trans' people managed to rub along fine before extremists tried to literally destroy the definition of women, and with it all of our hard fought-for rights.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 10:58

GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/11/2026 10:55

There are some reasonable replies on there! Amazing!

When protected characteristics collide, it's interesting to see how TRAs respond.

(Also: I note the glee with how he graphically recounts his shitting experience. It's all a performance for them and they don't even realise)

Edited

I missed those, but not on my Reddit phone where I’m logged in so maybe they were nested. Will take a look. The thread itself is very silly “cis man here” attention seeking.

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 10:57

I hope someone corrected his grammar. I don't want the UK degenerating to the point where we are unable to decline verbs as badly as people in the US.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/11/2026 10:55

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 10:51

Talking of Reddit, this thread is a doozy. Some misogynistic “cis man” ally comes to post that he felt entitled to use a disabled toilet because he’d been drinking all night and needed a shit. A woman bangs on the door and asks if he’s going to be long, he’s pissed off, he opens the door and there’s a woman (he calls her large as if that’s relevant to why a disabled woman should be allowed to call him out) on a mobility scooter, she clocks his pink jumper, assumes he’s a TIM and calls him a slur. He then says “I’d have shit in your mouth if I knew it was vacant”. And strops off, but he’s still angry and aggrieved, and of course he and “the trans community” are the sole victims here. And of course on the thread they all fawn over him and hope that he shat everywhere before she came in like the lovely people they are.

https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/comments/1xr0oub/just_had_my_first_transphobic_incident_cis_male/?utm_source=app_first_navigation&mweb_loid=t2_285tv9kw76

There are some reasonable replies on there! Amazing!

When protected characteristics collide, it's interesting to see how TRAs respond.

(Also: I note the glee with how he graphically recounts his shitting experience. It's all a performance for them and they don't even realise)

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 10:51

asert · 12/11/2026 10:28

it was trolls, transactivists and redditers who peak transed me over a decade ago. They’re the literal definition of useful idiots.

Talking of Reddit, this thread is a doozy. Some misogynistic “cis man” ally comes to post that he felt entitled to use a disabled toilet because he’d been drinking all night and needed a shit. A woman bangs on the door and asks if he’s going to be long, he’s pissed off, he opens the door and there’s a woman (he calls her large as if that’s relevant to why a disabled woman should be allowed to call him out) on a mobility scooter, she clocks his pink jumper, assumes he’s a TIM and calls him a slur. He then says “I’d have shit in your mouth if I knew it was vacant”. And strops off, but he’s still angry and aggrieved, and of course he and “the trans community” are the sole victims here. And of course on the thread they all fawn over him and hope that he shat everywhere before she came in like the lovely people they are.

https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/comments/1xr0oub/just_had_my_first_transphobic_incident_cis_male/?utm_source=app_first_navigation&mweb_loid=t2_285tv9kw76

asert · 12/11/2026 10:28

it was trolls, transactivists and redditers who peak transed me over a decade ago. They’re the literal definition of useful idiots.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 10:11

I’m so proud, more than anything else, of Mumsnet’s role in the resistance to the overreach of gender identity ideology in the UK. We have been pivotal. We were talking about it early, before it was mainstream, before we could be influenced by “far right media propaganda”.

We’ve funded crowdfunders, we’ve joined and set up groups. We’ve honed all the arguments to perfection. Trans rights activists hate Mumsnet because it has “more balls than Millwall”. Millwall caved to trans activist pressure, MN did not, they largely held the line and it’s been critical to have a space to discuss. While the government was consulting on full self ID in England and Wales, and then the Scottish government in Scotland, Twitter, Facebook, Reddit, Instagram would all ban you for wrongthink if you were unlucky.

Mumsnet has political influence. Sex Matters and FWS are both groundbreaking organisations which have changed the legal picture founded by MNers. Keep Prisons Single Sex had a huge effect on getting prison policy changed in England - also founded by a MNer. Let Women Speak founded by KJK, a former MNer, has done a lot to centre the voices of ordinary women around the world. We rock.

ICouldHaveCheckedFirst · 12/11/2026 09:55

Well said, @fromorbit!

fromorbit · 12/11/2026 09:05

Lets get this thread back on course.

Great post OP long agreed on these lines.

Here are some MORE thoughts on why the Trolls of Mumsnet are useful.

1 - Revenue - Trolls make money for Mumsnet.

Every post, every click, boosts the site's success and potentially increases revenue because it impresses advertisers with site engagement. Obviously this is a tiny amount, but every little helps. More to the point making money in the modern commercial world is a huge source of power. Because Mumsnet is profitable it has power to let women say what they want, and it can legally defend itself and to actually fight back against the Trans agenda which has huge commercial backing. To putting it in terms they would understand - Trolls creating 1000 page threads here is the equivalent of buying multiple sets of Harry Potter books. I am not worried pointing this out will deter the Trolls. They are never not going to want to argue with women online even if it makes gender crit spaces cold hard cash which it does.

2 - Online Influence - Trolls increase Online Engagement for Mumsnet.

Popular posts, and site use elevates the internet reach of Mumsnet. Search engines engage with our content more as the site gains more users, threads which are clicked on and becomes more popular. As the OP points out the rise of AI doubles down on this because they are going to learn off Mumsnet's content. This increases the power of the ideas expressed here. Every 1000 post thread gives Mumsnet more online power it doesn't matter if that is due to Trolls or not engagement is absolutely vital.

3 - Advertisement - Trolls advertise Mumsnet to others.

When trolls try to get us to comment and make us look dumb on threads, or clip comments out of context and take them elsewhere to comment on them they advertise the site. This can encourage others to come here to try the same thing increasing the trends in points 1 and 2. More to the point it tells others, the vast majority of people who are neutral or persuadable on sex/gender issues, especially parents or Trans widows looking for help, that Mumsnet Towers exists, it talks about sex & gender and it is powerful. These are the people we need to reach.

Mumsnet is a vast peaking machine and the trolls unknown to themselves actually are helping in this. Obviously they aim to claim Mumsnet Towers is a horror show of evil bigots, a massive castle full of evil witches, this is so far from the reality that the bubble bursts as soon as some one persuadable comes here.

4 - Funny - Troll threads are pure comedy a lot of time - this is important.

Sometimes it is very black humour, but this is a difficult fight and we need to keep our spirits up and seeing trolls being made to look like the clowns they are by experienced posters within moments of the thread starting is worth its weight in gold. Women's humour is powerful and understated and moreover absolutely devastating to the trolls. Because women laughing at them and not being able stop it is their worst fear. Yet no-one is going to stop laughing because unlike IRL where laughing at men can be very risky you can do it safely online in a pro-women space.

5 - Infuriating - Trolls being upsetting is motivational.

The Trolls think upsetting women is a massive win. They have being doing this since Mumsnet started. The reality is though making women angry has had consequences. You might think telling women off online has no real world effects, but these forums have generated a lot of consequences the creation of For Women Scotland being just one of them. Making a lot of mothers and older career women angry is as the TAs have discovered is a really really bad idea long term. Because instead of giving up they just get more motivated, understand the threat better and more ready to fight back.

6 - Distraction - Trolls are wasting their own time more than ours.

They think they are winning by calling women names, and derailing threads. As the OP points out Trolls in fact make our side stronger by giving those here essential practice and space to try out arguments. If Troll posting was a real problem then the pro-women side would have lost long ago. If you think about it though there are way way worse and more effective things Trolls could be doing. Instead they are here making the pro-women side money, pushing engagement with the site, advertising Mumsnet's ideas, making Mumsnetters laugh and infuriating them in equal measure and serving as perfect practice dummies.

Shedmistress · 12/11/2026 08:56

Getting up with a spring in my step with thanks for all the nonsense merchants.

We love you guys.

Im Out Jon Stewart GIF by The Problem With Jon Stewart
Leafstamp · 12/11/2026 07:57

Imdunfer · 11/11/2026 21:11

I'm always shocked when trans people tell us in all seriousness that we are in a minority on this forum. They really seem to believe it and I don't understand where they are getting this information from.

In my whole life at its widest the only people I come across who think a man can become a woman are the handful of trans activists who come onto this forum.

I meet some "kind"women who think men that "pass"should be allowed in women's spaces until you point out that if they legally let in the slight, pretty one then they can't keep out either the brick shithouse with a dress on or the rapist heterosexual with mal intent, when most would change their minds.

Is there any reputable research anywhere that we can use to show these people that we are the majority?

You Gov has done surveys - you can do a search.

This isn’t the only one, but is discussed here: https://sex-matters.org/posts/single-sex-services/poll-shows-support-for-sex-meaning-sex-in-equality-act/

YouGov poll shows support for sex meaning biological sex in the Equality Act

Growing support for single-sex provision

https://sex-matters.org/posts/single-sex-services/poll-shows-support-for-sex-meaning-sex-in-equality-act/

Toseland · 11/11/2026 23:28

Mumsnet class of 2026! There are so many educated and articulate women now!

FlirtsWithRhinos · 11/11/2026 23:04

Cheers!

leonardo dicaprio GIF
OP posts:
Catiette · 11/11/2026 22:17

Cheers!

Fabulous OP - 100%. And some really lovely other posts - I need to catch up tomorrow. Manyanamanyana's "they are not our audience, simply our canvas" - just perfect.

I love reading others' replies and working stuff out in mine. All the while knowing the difference slowly being made - really knowing it, because this place made that same difference to me. I've opened a few eyes with arguments honed here, and some of those people will be out there opening other eyes in their turn, and so on, and so on, and...

Trans activism has been a tragedy classic, wreaking its own destruction in more creative and unconsciously ironic ways than we could dream of, Horatio...

Shedmistress · 11/11/2026 21:50

Just ending the day with a Cheers guys.

Drink Sante GIF by Black Rickers Baseball Softball Club
NannyOggsFavouriteJug · 11/11/2026 21:47

BettyBooper · 11/11/2026 20:40

If I (as an adult) said 'i identify as a child. I was assaulted by an adult and as such, I need to get undressed with children in order to be safe. I have to be safe. I don't assault anyone.'

Would you be happy for me to be with your kids, or would you think I was a massive red flag?

Seriously now.

Listen to yourself and how your words and actions come across. Women are not your security. You cannot invade women's spaces on your own say so because you feel like it 'makes you feel safe'.

You cannot invade women's spaces on your own say so

It’s an incredibly arrogant, intrusive and aggressive attitude. Typical of the oppressor class.

ETA I did write an essay; it was cathartic, but boils down to this.

Manyanamanyana · 11/11/2026 21:19

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 11/11/2026 15:57

I just had a fleeting concern that maybe they will read this thread and think oh bollocks, we had better pull our socks up and go and read something and make proper arguments and stuff.
But twas merely fleeting.

Good luck to them I say! They might accidentally find themselves "educated".

Imdunfer · 11/11/2026 21:11

I'm always shocked when trans people tell us in all seriousness that we are in a minority on this forum. They really seem to believe it and I don't understand where they are getting this information from.

In my whole life at its widest the only people I come across who think a man can become a woman are the handful of trans activists who come onto this forum.

I meet some "kind"women who think men that "pass"should be allowed in women's spaces until you point out that if they legally let in the slight, pretty one then they can't keep out either the brick shithouse with a dress on or the rapist heterosexual with mal intent, when most would change their minds.

Is there any reputable research anywhere that we can use to show these people that we are the majority?