Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 02:23

Hiya! Created this thread to try to have a bit more of an understanding on a human level (not political or news based) why some people dislike and would not want to share space with trans people?

To be transparent, my sex assigned at birth is different than my current representation, I use single sex spaces that align with my phenotypic presentation and no one precieved me differently than my representation, challenged me or expressed discomfort. I do try to be as mindful as I can and I go out of my way to not cause discomfort, distress, or alarm (i.e. showering in my swimsuit in swimming pools).
(Pre-empting the they can always tell argument, in my lived experience it's definitely not true, at least for the last few years).

How does a trans person using a single sex person puts anyone in danger?
There are about 20 trans people in Scottish jails, that's roughly 0.000360652% of the population and 0.23% of the jail population (20/8517) or 0.36 per 100k. General populace rate is 154 per 100k. At that sample count you can't really conclude any patterns since they are so few trans people in prisons (pre-empting the argument that trans people are sexual offenders and dangerous, feel free to double check my maths).

Scotland stats are used as that is where I reside. Thanks for reading, looking forward your replies.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Jimmyneutronsforehead · 10/11/2026 08:35

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 08:26

OP please don't do this to yourself. You won't get rational or humane engagement here. Sending you solidarity and support. 💐

Edited

Yeah we're all hysterical robots here aren't we? Get a grip. You're incredibly privileged if you've never had to question the motives of men, or you've never seen someone so enmeshed with the idea of identity that not only does their world crumble but so does everyone's who surrounds them. You've never been in the position of someone using their identity as a means to gain access to you when you're vulnerable. You've never met an opportunistic manipulator who has manipulated everyone around them to abuse you. You've never been told you're a bigoted lesbian for not liking lady dick.

Seriously, get a bloody grip.

Imdunfer · 10/11/2026 08:37

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 08:26

OP please don't do this to yourself. You won't get rational or humane engagement here. Sending you solidarity and support. 💐

Edited

@Transperson tagging you so you actually see Lacksie's message.

You have received plenty of rational engagement and it's damned rude of Lacksie to suggest that you haven't.

You won't get "humane" if your definition of "humane" is to affirm you as female.

But if you genuinely started the thread to understand how women feel on this issue, then you have come to the right place. You are being fed misinformation about ordinary gender critical women by people like Stonewall.

There will probably be some nasty posts later on (though those mostly come from trans activists on these trans threads and they happen on all threads of all subjects) and we will do our best to get them removed as quickly as possible.

Please stay with us, we need people like you who are genuinely trying to understand our point of view instead of getting to bully us into accepting their own.

GingerBeverage · 10/11/2026 08:39

SeniorSausage · 10/11/2026 06:40

I work with offenders and have met numerous male sex offenders who have decided to adopt the trans pathway while serving their custodial sentences. In my experience these men are all doing it as part of a fetish, to get attention to themselves and to divert professionals from the risk that they present. They are hoping parole boards and prison governors will give them access to reduced category prisons, release on temporary licence and other perks.

I realise that this is not typical of the trans population in general but I have met enough of them to know that its a genuine risk and not an anomaly.

These men will one day be released from prison and will walk among us. They have spent years being pandered to and supported to develop their new identities as "women" despite still having full male sex hormones and genitalia. The possibility that one might be using the same public toilets as my teenage daughter is, frankly, terrifying.

Glad you mentioned the fetish aspect.

Imo there is a fundamental disconnect between “respectful” and “man gets erection in women’s spaces”.

Lots of chat about men’s special feelings but not much mention that those feelings often translate into a physical sexual reaction. And the lack of consent seems to be a part of that.

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 08:39

Imdunfer · 10/11/2026 08:37

@Transperson tagging you so you actually see Lacksie's message.

You have received plenty of rational engagement and it's damned rude of Lacksie to suggest that you haven't.

You won't get "humane" if your definition of "humane" is to affirm you as female.

But if you genuinely started the thread to understand how women feel on this issue, then you have come to the right place. You are being fed misinformation about ordinary gender critical women by people like Stonewall.

There will probably be some nasty posts later on (though those mostly come from trans activists on these trans threads and they happen on all threads of all subjects) and we will do our best to get them removed as quickly as possible.

Please stay with us, we need people like you who are genuinely trying to understand our point of view instead of getting to bully us into accepting their own.

Edited

But if you genuinely started the thread to understand how women feel on this issue, then you have come to the right place.

No. You will hear how a very minority subset of women , deeply immersed in anti trans ideology and anger towards trans people feel "on this issue".

Shedmistress · 10/11/2026 08:40

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 08:39

But if you genuinely started the thread to understand how women feel on this issue, then you have come to the right place.

No. You will hear how a very minority subset of women , deeply immersed in anti trans ideology and anger towards trans people feel "on this issue".

By typing words none of which are untrue?

Imdunfer · 10/11/2026 08:40

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 08:39

But if you genuinely started the thread to understand how women feel on this issue, then you have come to the right place.

No. You will hear how a very minority subset of women , deeply immersed in anti trans ideology and anger towards trans people feel "on this issue".

Well there's your mistake.

We aren't a minority.

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 08:42

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 08:35

From the poster who regularly comes on this board and calls being trans "fake" , and trans people liars and pretenders?

Like most posters on this board you barely even try to disguise your contempt.

Anyways. Sending you support OP. for your own wellbeing I hope you won't stick around xx

Edited

Please show me where I have shamed you? I have suggested on occasion that if you are as busy as you tell us you are that MN might not be the best way to spend the little time you have. This was in response to you not answering any proper questions and then telling us at various times you had to ‘do the school run/prepare a work presentation/make dinner for the kids. All placed at points on threads where you were being quite reasonably asked to answer questions.

As for my comments about trans being fake. I stand by that and if you read this whole thread many posters have referred to not likening having to lie about the truth.

They are lying about who they are and the person they are lying to the most is themselves.

You may not like this fact but it is a fact and this thread has many posters reiterating they have similar feelings. Note I did not say they agreed with me but there is a general consensus that trans ideology means the truth has to be suspended.

Sadly what you have done, again, on what was a thoughtful thread is ignore the original post and wade in with the rhetoric that unless we all comply with the trans agenda we are hateful.

I suggest you read some of the very well thought out posts on the thread. They are rational and humane. Zero hate towards @Transperson if anything personal experiences and explanations as to why we are keen to retain safe spaces.

teawamutu · 10/11/2026 08:44

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 08:39

But if you genuinely started the thread to understand how women feel on this issue, then you have come to the right place.

No. You will hear how a very minority subset of women , deeply immersed in anti trans ideology and anger towards trans people feel "on this issue".

They're still women, though. So their viewpoint counts and no-one can give their provisions away without their consent.

I know you know this. I know you find it dreadfully inconvenient. But alas for you, the point persists.

I CBA to read the whole thread but I've skimmed OP's posts. Am I correct in surmising that this is another attempt at 'of course women have concerns and they deserve single sex provision but I should get to use it too because I'm not like the others'?

Or is it the usual mansplaining womanhood to women where the general gist is, 'sure letting men in means some of you get raped but it's hardly any and it's going to happen anyway so be kind and budge up, support humans'?

brownbootsandhats · 10/11/2026 08:45

What does pheontypically mean ?

I have tried a dictionary obviously and I know trans people don’t have changes in their cells and that as a group male to female transgender people retain the body advantages they gain at puberty

in understanding that meaning - about how a body looks- made me uncomfortable as there’s a hint that a “feminine looking” man - one smaller than average for example - should be considered transgender which I think is very insulting to men who often have to put up with people questioning their masculinity just because of how they look

similarly I would hate to have people think that a soldier who has lost his genitals in war suddenly is to be considered female - ultimate insult

this leads to be reinstate my normal postion

i don’t hate transpeople
I do hate their ideology
I do hate those who try to negate my personal experiences , downplay the importance of sex and up scale the importance of gender to the extent that they see transowmen as women for all occasions

Mamalasira · 10/11/2026 08:45

teawamutu · 10/11/2026 08:44

They're still women, though. So their viewpoint counts and no-one can give their provisions away without their consent.

I know you know this. I know you find it dreadfully inconvenient. But alas for you, the point persists.

I CBA to read the whole thread but I've skimmed OP's posts. Am I correct in surmising that this is another attempt at 'of course women have concerns and they deserve single sex provision but I should get to use it too because I'm not like the others'?

Or is it the usual mansplaining womanhood to women where the general gist is, 'sure letting men in means some of you get raped but it's hardly any and it's going to happen anyway so be kind and budge up, support humans'?

Yes, with the additional claims of dubious biology.

Icedvanillacoffee · 10/11/2026 08:46

I live in London, there are a number of people who are either men cross dressing or otherwise men dressed as women out and about. Londoners are typically not warm and friendly to complete strangers in public. I dont see any extra hostility at all to these individuals.
The issues around safeguarding are it seems to me obvious, but I was a safeguarding lead for a while. This isnt about hate its about mitigating risk. Some folk could never accept this and still cant.
This OP is keen on scientific evidence but for what is a philosophical belief, that souls have a sex and a soul can be born into the wrong body. I dont think you can scientifically prove this belief or any religious of philosophical belief. Isnt faith the point?

LiuBei · 10/11/2026 08:46

When you quote your own stat about Scottish emprisonment. It looks like the trans rate of emprisonment is much closer to the male rate than the female rate (although your presentation lumped cis men and women together). Trans women commit crimes at about the same rate as men is the whole point of people's concern (and this rate is quite low. Most men and most trans people are good people. But no-one has ever said most cis men are good people, lets let them in women's changing rooms)

the7Vabo · 10/11/2026 08:48

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 08:39

But if you genuinely started the thread to understand how women feel on this issue, then you have come to the right place.

No. You will hear how a very minority subset of women , deeply immersed in anti trans ideology and anger towards trans people feel "on this issue".

I’ve posted on this thread, and I’m not “deeply immersed” in anything. You want to believe it’s a minority subset but it isn’t. Many people are too afraid to discuss it when it comes up because they don’t want to be subject to abuse.

RoyalCorgi · 10/11/2026 08:50

The OP asks the wrong question, of course.

The issue is gender ideology: an ideology that says any man who claims to be a woman should be treated, in all respects, as if he is a woman, which means having access to spaces and activities exclusively reserved for women.

That isn't a tiny minority of men - that's all men.

For some reason, the OP brings up the Scottish prison estate. But until the Scottish govt lost a recent court case, it was policy to admit trans-identifying men into women's prisons. Men like Katie Dolatowski, who sexually assaulted a 10-year old girl in the women's toilets. Imagine how frightening it would be as a woman in prison to share prison space with someone like that.

Sall Grover a few days ago wrote this about a trans-identifying rapist, Benjamin Charles Jones, who had been found dead: "This man claimed to be a woman, spent years in a women’s prison, the women inmates were terrified of him, we pushed as hard as we could to get him removed but the Victorian’s human rights commission & politicians did nothing, and when he was released he attacked another woman."

The idea that we somehow shouldn't care about the dignity and safety of women just because it's only a "few" men is never going to fly. Imagine if we allowed adults to identify as children, so that a 25-year old could, if they wanted, join the Brownies. We wouldn't allow it, even if it was just one person. Even if they really believed they were a child, and they really really wanted to join the Brownies.

So, no, forget it, OP, with your disingenuous arguments. We are never going to accept an anti-scientific, misogynistic ideology that says men can be women, however much you pretend that it's "only" a minority and that they don't do any harm. We're not that stupid.

pontefractals · 10/11/2026 08:52

BrickMaker · 10/11/2026 07:09

It's true I don't deny that. But is the solution banning trans? I don't know. It was a very upsetting experience for the women and I just don't know the full answer because as a social worker I have had such lovely trans clients that would probably be at real risk in an all men's environment. Maybe a dedicated small shelter would be better.

Do you think transwomen are the only males who might be at risk in a male environment? What happens to old men, very young men, disabled men, gay men,etc? Surely the provision that keeps them safe would also be suitable for transwomen, and this way no women would be harmed.

SparklingGlitteryWine · 10/11/2026 08:54

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 08:26

OP please don't do this to yourself. You won't get rational or humane engagement here. Sending you solidarity and support. 💐

Edited

What is that supposed to mean?

Mamalasira · 10/11/2026 08:55

SparklingGlitteryWine · 10/11/2026 08:54

What is that supposed to mean?

Posters aren't fawning.

cherryicecreamisnice · 10/11/2026 08:55

I would like to ask @Transpersonif they believe some people are “true trans” and if so, how would they define it?

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 08:55

SparklingGlitteryWine · 10/11/2026 08:54

What is that supposed to mean?

Generally @SparklingGlitteryWine it means all people on this board are bigots and transphobes. In my experience of this poster @lacksie is misinterpreting previous threads as they just have accusing me of ‘shaming’ - I have explained in a previous post what actually happened.

They have now gone totally off topic away from @Transperson original question to direct insults towards me. There is a pattern here. We may get told soon to ‘try &keep up’.

Namechanged47 · 10/11/2026 08:57

Transperson · 10/11/2026 04:18

"Transwomen are male" - not phenotypically, although most are in terms of genetic and gonadal sex.

I believe my last reply covers the rest of the message.

This is fundamentally the reason.

There's is no dislike towards trans people from most gender critical people. But we disagree on something fundamental if you believe you are truly the same as your preferred gender. I believe your sex is not changeable and your gender is a matter of preference, and I believe that women and men are entitled to single sex (not single gender) spaces. I believe that biology is much more important than presentation or internal feelings.

I'm with the first poster. I do in fact have a number of trans and non binary friends, and on an individual level we get on very well, I have zero issues, happy to interact with them as they prefer to present. With some of them, they agree that they are trans people and that this is not the same as biological sex, so we can then discuss these issues. With others, they would be offended by my views so we avoid the issue.

I'm sorry that it does mean in some circumstances trans people aren't able to be included in places they would like to be. But I believe that women's right to feel safe should not be invalidated by the wish of a very small percentage of the population to be included in a category which they are not. I do believe they should have safe facilities of their own, I just don't believe women should be made to compromise their beliefs and feelings to accommodate the beliefs and feelings of a different group. We should aim for a solution which is acceptable if not ideal to all. And that, to me, means requiring single sex spaces without exception, as well as provision for trans spaces.

LadyChilli · 10/11/2026 08:58

NapsForTheWin · 10/11/2026 02:27

I don't dislike trans people at all and would be happy to be friends with one. When I've encountered trans people in the real world, I treat them like any other.

The only thing I object to is having my own sense of what is important to me as a woman nullified. For example, motherhood has been a very important part of my life. I breast fed my babies, I didn't chest feed them. I was a birthing mother and woman, not a birthing person or parent. Those words and the terminology became a permanent part of my own perception of my femininity, and I won't have that taken from me.

Assuming you're a nice person, I don't care if you are trans or not. You would be welcome to be my friend.

I agree and would like to expand on this. There are many ways society tells us what it is to be a woman and we grow up internalising the rules - be nice, always put others first, make sure you look good at all times even to the detriment of your physical comfort, be attractive to all the men but don't compete with other women too much. Actually if you have heard the monologue from Barbie, that summarises it fairly well. And all of it is horseshit.

Being a woman actually means having all or (in rare medical cases) most of: 2 x chromosomes, female reproductive organs and female hormones. That's it. There are words we use to describe things that the above items uniquely allow us to do like breastfeed or be a mother. Taking those words away and forcing all of us to use birthing person or chest feeding, it erases what it actually is to be a woman and leaves us only with the horrible gender stereotypes that many of us spend our entire lives constrained by and fighting against.

I do not want to be told by men who do not feel they conform with male gender stereotypes what it is to be a woman. The energy should be spent redefining what it is to be a man. Then you can have your own space in society without having to shoehorn women out of the little safe spaces they have managed to carve.

I am sure most trans people are decent humans and have no hate for them. But I absolutely hate being told what a woman is.

TheKeatingFive · 10/11/2026 08:58

At its heart this is all very simple.

The facts are already firmly established.

Sex is binary and immutable.

Women have single sex spaces for their own safety and dignity.

There is zero reason to give any men access to these spaces, for any reason. Decent men understand that and wouldnt dream of asking.

All we are dealing with now is a group of loud, highly entitled men who do not care about women’s rights, consent, boundaries - and think the world should revolve around them.

The answer is and always will be - no.

StuntNun · 10/11/2026 08:59

I think you can divide “people who dislike trans people” into three distinct groups. 1. Some people are genuinely transphobic and feel revulsion at the idea of someone being trans. 2. Some people have seen everything that has happened to women and women’s rights and have lost any tolerance they might have once had. You can see that progression in JK Rowling and Martina Navratilova, for example, who came into their women’s activism very open and warm towards trans people but, after years of harassment and abuse, have become progressively more resistant to trans-inclusive language and viewpoints. 3. Some people don’t really have anything against trans people but don’t regard trans women as women in any sense and don’t want language, society, single-sex spaces to be reorganised around accommodating trans women in women’s spaces.

In answer to your claim that people can’t tell that you’re trans, they may not give you any indication that they’ve noticed. I’ve encountered a trans man at Boots, a trans woman airline hostess (who passed extremely well apart from large hands and an Adam’s apple,) a trans woman working in my local Sainsbury’s and a couple of trans women in public toilets. The first three, there was no reason for me to react any differently to them than if they weren’t trans. The trans women in toilets, I didn’t react to partly out of fear of their reaction and partly because I wasn’t absolutely certain they were trans as it was a brief encounter. Also, it was years ago; I would probably react very differently in the current climate.

“How does a trans person using a single sex person puts anyone in danger?”
There is no doubt that trans women sexually assault women at at least the same rate as men. It is inherently dangerous to allow trans women into women’s single sex spaces. It doesn’t matter how safe you personally are and how much care you take, it doesn’t overcome basic safeguarding. It is extremely intimidating for women to have to share toilets and changing rooms with males, however they identify. I have no history of sexual assault or trauma but a recent encounter with a man in a women’s changing room left me very shaken and upset. My MIL had to share a hospital ward with a trans woman and didn’t sleep a wink at night, just from the potential effect on her safety. Single-sex spaces aren’t just to protect safety, they provide dignity and comfort as well.

There’s a common misconception among trans activists that “TERFs” don’t know any trans people and that’s why we push back against trans activism. This couldn’t be further from the truth. A lot of us know trans relatives, friends, our kids’ friends etc. I have a couple of trans friends who I would be perfectly happy to share a changing room with but I can’t consent on behalf of all other women. Both use the gents anyway so it isn’t an issue. The stories we hear from the media, transwidows and detransitioners in no way give confidence that there are any reasons to welcome trans women into single sex spaces, even if that means trans men must use women’s spaces.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 09:01

To quote KJK to Dr Harrop on Sky News back in 2018, I don’t hate “trans women”, I just don’t believe they’re women. And therefore I don’t want them categorised as women, presumed to have female lived experience, or barging their very male, entitled way into spaces for women and girls any more than I want men who don’t claim to be women doing so. For my safety, my privacy and my dignity.

Whatever angels you think can dance on the head of a pin, “trans women” are men, you can’t change sex, and in some things, sex matters.

SparklingGlitteryWine · 10/11/2026 09:01

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 08:39

But if you genuinely started the thread to understand how women feel on this issue, then you have come to the right place.

No. You will hear how a very minority subset of women , deeply immersed in anti trans ideology and anger towards trans people feel "on this issue".

How dare you. Are you saying the the young girls in my daughter's guide group don't deserve their voices heard when they say they want it to be a space just for girls? Are you calling 12 year old girls with voices anti trans? Girls that say no to men and boys are anti trans? My daughter's grandma was brought up being told what to do by men, she was told by her Father and Husband to give up her dream of being a dressmaker to be a stay at home wife and mother, as were many of that time. Her Husband could legally beat and rape her. She couldn't open a bank account without his permission. Her mother before her couldn't vote. I'll be dammed if my daughter as a girl guide will be treated the same way as her ancestors and told that you do what men tell you too and your voice isn't worth a wank.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.