Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 02:23

Hiya! Created this thread to try to have a bit more of an understanding on a human level (not political or news based) why some people dislike and would not want to share space with trans people?

To be transparent, my sex assigned at birth is different than my current representation, I use single sex spaces that align with my phenotypic presentation and no one precieved me differently than my representation, challenged me or expressed discomfort. I do try to be as mindful as I can and I go out of my way to not cause discomfort, distress, or alarm (i.e. showering in my swimsuit in swimming pools).
(Pre-empting the they can always tell argument, in my lived experience it's definitely not true, at least for the last few years).

How does a trans person using a single sex person puts anyone in danger?
There are about 20 trans people in Scottish jails, that's roughly 0.000360652% of the population and 0.23% of the jail population (20/8517) or 0.36 per 100k. General populace rate is 154 per 100k. At that sample count you can't really conclude any patterns since they are so few trans people in prisons (pre-empting the argument that trans people are sexual offenders and dangerous, feel free to double check my maths).

Scotland stats are used as that is where I reside. Thanks for reading, looking forward your replies.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
nicepotoftea · 10/11/2026 16:06

Transperson · 10/11/2026 15:30

Single sex provision is for service providers. I am not a service provider and therefore I am not actually doing anything wrong. Service providers have no real way of determining someone's at birth assigned sex. So it's completely unworkable.

For comparison, it is not illegal for me to walk up my neighbour's path, but it may be illegal if I refuse to leave their garden when asked. This may become a criminal matter, depending on the nature of my conduct.

Service providers have no real way of determining someone's at birth assigned sex.

But, as with proof of ID for other purposes, we might reach the point where this is required if people continually misrepresent their sex.

Hoardasurass · 10/11/2026 16:06

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 15:54

Lol I've answer the question about anorexia over and over and over again. The answer is they are not comparable. They are completely different 'conditions' with completely different treatments. Most importantly, anorexia is not compatible with life, unless anorexic people are treated, they typically die. This is completely different to being trans.

They are comparable because they are both types of body dismorphia and back when we practiced proper mh medicine they were treated in exactly the same way and were often in group therapy together my group had several anorexic girls another with billemia(sp) and 4 of us with with what you would call gender dysphoria and the rest had plain old body dismorphia.
Its long past time that sanity returned and we stop affirming disorderd thinking

ChequerToRed · 10/11/2026 16:06

Transperson · 10/11/2026 15:56

Yeah and again I was more interested on a human level rather than politics/news.

Tldr is if I don't tell anyone or cause issue people can't know and can't have a reaction to it. As I am not hurting anyone. If I sense that my presence caused alarm or discomfort I would obviously rethink things, but that's not the case here.

If you really did know anything about living as a woman then you’d realise that we are very good at hiding our distress and discomfort for our own safety, as women in abusive relationships will do for years, putting up a front of being in a happy and loving marriage till it all falls apart and those close to the family will state they ‘had no idea, everything seemed fine’.

You also have no idea what’s behind the facade. You’re not sensing, you’re assuming.

Mamalasira · 10/11/2026 16:06

Secretsquirrel2 · 10/11/2026 16:05

The simple answer to the question of a trans women peeing in a female toilet is they're scared of men.

I hate the saying but 'no shit Sherlock ' applies here.

They don't see it though. Genuinely.

Datun · 10/11/2026 16:07

Secretsquirrel2 · 10/11/2026 16:05

The simple answer to the question of a trans women peeing in a female toilet is they're scared of men.

I hate the saying but 'no shit Sherlock ' applies here.

That's the argument they put forward. It's not backed up by any evidence.

A considerable number of men are quite happy to say they like to use the women's toilets because it validates them/gives them a hard on.

there's quite a few men on this thread. All of them think he should be using the gents.

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 16:08

Shortshriftandlethal · 10/11/2026 15:51

I can imagine Russell Brand and his father thought that too. -and then they came up against the hard reality of other people's experience and their accompanying rights.

Comparing the OP to Russell Brand now?

Do you think that's an acceptable and rational way to conduct this conversation?

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:08

Shortshriftandlethal · 10/11/2026 15:59

Ever heard of the classic feminist saying that 'the personal is political and the political is personal'?

Edited

Well it's easier to engage when it's more of an exchange of ideas than bombardment of GC believes. I will go back and interact with the more humane replies.

OP posts:
EarthSight · 10/11/2026 16:08

Transperson · 10/11/2026 15:05

Unfortunately being gender critical is currently a "protected belief", being dismissed for it would be discrimination.

And thank goodness for that. The gender critical feminists of today are the modern day equivalent of the suffragettes, ensuring that women do not lose hard worn rights.

Medically transitioing changes them phenotypically, which effect how they are precieved

a) Most trans identified males don't medically transition

b) Medical transition, or cultural transition, may affect how they are perceived, but it does not, as far as I'm aware, affect their rates of sexual and violent offending against women. Therefore, even if they they do transition, they still pose a greater risk.

The behaviour of trans activists today is pretty much identical to the disgusting incel misogyny I saw on darker parts of the web in the noughties, by men's rights activists.

Their arguments & demands broadely being - we will define what women are, and what they aren't, tell them what they should and shouldn't have with regards to their rights, and if they resist, we will call them man haters, or subject them to death and rape threats.

Today, this has simply been relabelled as trans activism.

Easilyforgotten · 10/11/2026 16:09

@Lacksie, can I again ask you to define what, exactly, is the fundamental reality of being a woman?

Datun · 10/11/2026 16:09

Comparing the OP to Russell Brand now?

He's freely admitted he neither seeks, nor respects women's consent.

I mean it's lovely that you're so willing to support him and let everyone know that you agree.

Whatever floats your boat.

murasaki · 10/11/2026 16:09

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 16:08

Comparing the OP to Russell Brand now?

Do you think that's an acceptable and rational way to conduct this conversation?

Edited

Well they're both male. And boundary transgressors, albeit to vastly different degrees, as far as we know.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 16:09

Secretsquirrel2 · 10/11/2026 16:05

The simple answer to the question of a trans women peeing in a female toilet is they're scared of men.

I hate the saying but 'no shit Sherlock ' applies here.

I don’t believe this is the primary reason for all of them. For plenty of them, it’s more about “validation” of their identity and spite that women shouldn’t have anywhere without them. And obviously some men like to make women uncomfortable and some want access to women for predatory reasons or to sexually harass them. See Russell Brand for an example of a man who doesn’t identify as a women doing it in plain sight, even apart from his actual assaults. Now imagine if he put a dress on and called himself Rose.

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 16:09

To be honest @Transperson and @Lacksie of all the weeks to bring this up the very week a man has been jailed for violating women’s boundaries over a period of many years, do you not think it is a bit tone deaf trying to ‘gotcha’ as to why men should be allowed into women’s spaces?

Tone deaf being a kind response.

Many of us will have seen the Russell Brand verdict and had memories of being violated over our lifetimes. Sometimes it is just a feeling of being around someone creepy.

Can you honestly not understand as women this is something we grow up with and have to navigate with men. Adding in men who think they are women is even more of a violation of our boundaries and doing it without consent is appalling.

We are now going to listen to whatever David Walliams says defending allegations about emailing under age and very young girls with inappropriate behaviour. Again it will bring up memories for many women.

How far do we have to move our boundaries before trans people are happy? Because to me I recall the PIE and MAPS back in the 70s and 80s, Peter Tatchell and his cronies, Stephen Fry all alluding to the classics to justify underage sexual activity.

WhitneySpears · 10/11/2026 16:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 16:11

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 16:09

I don’t believe this is the primary reason for all of them. For plenty of them, it’s more about “validation” of their identity and spite that women shouldn’t have anywhere without them. And obviously some men like to make women uncomfortable and some want access to women for predatory reasons or to sexually harass them. See Russell Brand for an example of a man who doesn’t identify as a women doing it in plain sight, even apart from his actual assaults. Now imagine if he put a dress on and called himself Rose.

For the avoidance of doubt I am speaking generally about men who call themselves women, not suggesting anything about the op in particular.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 10/11/2026 16:11

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:08

Well it's easier to engage when it's more of an exchange of ideas than bombardment of GC believes. I will go back and interact with the more humane replies.

Well, you'd better get a move on because the end of the thread isn't far away and you've done very little interacting so far.

Apart from to tell women you're going to do whatever you want anyway, despite what we say.

MoistVonL · 10/11/2026 16:11

Transperson · 10/11/2026 15:56

Yeah and again I was more interested on a human level rather than politics/news.

Tldr is if I don't tell anyone or cause issue people can't know and can't have a reaction to it. As I am not hurting anyone. If I sense that my presence caused alarm or discomfort I would obviously rethink things, but that's not the case here.

You have literally hundreds of replies telling you that you ARE hurting people, that your presence DOES cause alarm and discomfort.

I have come across transwomen in single sex spaces in my city quite often and I don't say anything because it's far too dangerous to do so. Because they are male.

So like many women I get out of there as quickly as I can, and I self exclude from there as it's clearly not somewhere I can be sure of safety and dignity.

That's what you're doing, OP. Making women uncomfortable and unsafe, and effectively keeping them out of spaces that were built for them and not you.

Again, it's not about being trans, it's about being male. And you have no right to female spaces.

ChequerToRed · 10/11/2026 16:12

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 16:08

Comparing the OP to Russell Brand now?

Do you think that's an acceptable and rational way to conduct this conversation?

Edited

As the topic is male people and their complete obliviousness to and disregard of women’s feelings, it seems like a very apt comparison to me.

Interesting that you find it so uncomfortable.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/11/2026 16:12

@Transperson - you know that you are male, and therefore you know you are not allowed to use women’s single sex facilities, yet you fully intend to carry on using them, in the full knowledge that you should not be there.

Can you see why this is problematic? Why many of us would consider that to be predatory? You should be honest and say you don’t care about causing distress to women.

Coatsoff42 · 10/11/2026 16:12

PrettyPickle · 10/11/2026 16:05

Why are people being so harsh to a person who's simply trying to exist?

He’s not trying to exist, he is existing. He will
exist even if he can’t use ladies changing rooms. Even if everyone knows he is a man who prefers to wear women’s clothes he will exist. He might feel a bit put out that no one is satisfying his vision of himself, but he will still exist.
its a shame OP can’t live an authentic life and show the consideration to others that he wants shown to him.

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 16:13

Datun · 10/11/2026 16:09

Comparing the OP to Russell Brand now?

He's freely admitted he neither seeks, nor respects women's consent.

I mean it's lovely that you're so willing to support him and let everyone know that you agree.

Whatever floats your boat.

She said that she doesn't require your consent to use a public toilet to pee, which is entirely correct.

Do you ask for the consent of everyone present before you enter a public loo?

(God knows why I'm even engaging in addressing this despicable comparison).

MichaelmasDaisiesAndAutumSunset · 10/11/2026 16:14

Transperson · 10/11/2026 15:47

I mean in a way it already is, things like threatening language or hate speech aren't allowed, that should be expended to include GC speech, as it's offensive and causes alarm.

Yes, and many people believe that those limits on the freedom are dangerous. But there are three points you are missing:

  1. freedom of expression is a legal (human) right. It is not an absolute right. This means that under the ECHR, governments can limit it or even violate it, if there is justification for doing so and the limitation is proportionate.
  2. So far as I am aware, there is no limit placed on use of “threatening language” (whatever you think that is), merely that if you do use it, the factual matrix around your use of it may amount to a criminal offence.
  3. similarly, there is no legal meaning of hate speech. There is a crime of stirring up hatred, components of which are speech or writing and some protected characteristics. But the freedom of expression is only limited where other criteria are met. There is no absolute ban on any form of speech - its criminalisation tends to be linked to its effects.

So you are both ignorant, and wrong, on this one. Do you think if you better understood your comparators you might understand why the world does not operate the way you think it should?

But - and this is important - “gc speech” as you call it is someone’s opinion, just as your opinion might be (because I don’t know this) that you are a woman. Their being able to express that opinion respectfully shouldn’t cause you harm. If -because of your unusual sensitivity - it does, then in my view that is a price you should gladly pay for freedom of expression. I know people hold and express a variety of views that I find deeply distressing, but that’s my problem, not society’s.

I am firmly of the view that people cannot change sex, and that societal norms for each of the sexes are just that, norms. We all live on a normal curve in every aspect of ourselves compared to others. But I rarely express that view because it can upset people and it is rarely important that I express it. See, I self-police in the pursuit of good manners.

Why can you not do the same when entering single sex spaces of the opposite sex? Accept that while you can because you pass that the feelings of some of the people in that space matter more than yours? We have disagreed with each other for centuries and not annihilated the human race over it because of fundamental human empathy and good manners. It might be hypothesised that a person who is focussing entirely on their own perceptions and feelings is bound to fail on both counts.

SparklingGlitteryWine · 10/11/2026 16:14

RareGoalsVerge · 10/11/2026 14:50

Quotes out of context do not prove your point. You are using quotes that aren't even directed at Trans People -

"What you are saying us that we should upset n+1 number of women so that 1 man can get his wish fulfillment?
Get in the sea."

  • That's not directed at trans people, that is directed at people who say that males are more important than females. That is a category that includes both men and women, and both trans and non-trans people. There are trans people who uphold women's rights. Comments about people who prioritise males over females are anti-patriarchy, not anti-trans.

If girls are being girl called bigots for telling boys that they don't want them in their space, and made to feel that those boys feelings are worth more than their feelings and safety, you can get in the bin as far as I'm concerned.

  • That's not directed at trans people, that is directed at people who say that boys are more important than girls. Same as above - comments about people who prioritise males over females are anti-patriarchy, not anti-trans.

If anti-patriarchy comments are experienced by you as anti-trans that is more evidence that your viewpoint is intrinsically patriarchal.

Thank you. The get in the bin comment was absolutely me and it was aimed at anyone calling 11 year old girl guides bigots for not wanting boys in their space. My daughter and her fellow guides said this and as far as I'm concerned their views are the most important and override those of the boys that want to join. Some of the comments I saw everywhere when it was first deemed that guides must remain a biological girls space were absolutely disgusting, grown adults making disgusting comments about not just these young girls who dared use their voices and say no, and the adults that spoke out for them. So the get in the bin comment was aimed at anyone who has a problem with young girls asserting their private space and as usual it's being twisted into bigotry to silence and shame women and girls into feeling like bigots for speaking out. Bigot is one of the most thrown around words that is becoming cheapened by overuse and losing it's actual meaning. If Bigotry is protecting the comfort and safety of my young daughters and ensuring they are never to intimidated to say no to men and boys then colour me bigoted!!

nicepotoftea · 10/11/2026 16:14

Medically transitioing changes them phenotypically, which effect how they are precieved

This narrow definition of 'trans' really isn't relevant anymore. Those who disagree really should have had that argument with trans advocates a decade or more ago.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/11/2026 16:14

@Lacksie - he knows he is not supposed to use women’s single sex facilities, and that many of us don’t want him in there - he just doesn’t give a shit.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.