Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 02:23

Hiya! Created this thread to try to have a bit more of an understanding on a human level (not political or news based) why some people dislike and would not want to share space with trans people?

To be transparent, my sex assigned at birth is different than my current representation, I use single sex spaces that align with my phenotypic presentation and no one precieved me differently than my representation, challenged me or expressed discomfort. I do try to be as mindful as I can and I go out of my way to not cause discomfort, distress, or alarm (i.e. showering in my swimsuit in swimming pools).
(Pre-empting the they can always tell argument, in my lived experience it's definitely not true, at least for the last few years).

How does a trans person using a single sex person puts anyone in danger?
There are about 20 trans people in Scottish jails, that's roughly 0.000360652% of the population and 0.23% of the jail population (20/8517) or 0.36 per 100k. General populace rate is 154 per 100k. At that sample count you can't really conclude any patterns since they are so few trans people in prisons (pre-empting the argument that trans people are sexual offenders and dangerous, feel free to double check my maths).

Scotland stats are used as that is where I reside. Thanks for reading, looking forward your replies.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
JJWT · 10/11/2026 09:27

For me a big issue is cis women being told by their employers they have to take their clothes off in changing spaces at work in the presence of an adult who has a penis. I dont think anyone should be forced to put up with that. I was forced to remove my clothes when SA by a man as a child and not having control over concepts like that is abhorrent to me. I'm not in a job where this applies but when I see it cropping up eg for nurses who need to change for theatre it makes me very angry on their behalf. Its not as basic as thinking this man could assault me, its the awkwardness of getting undressed in front of a person you regard as physically a man and lack of autonomy in not being allowed to refuse this. To me, its astonishing its even being suggested. I don't think it helps with acceptance at all. Quite the opposite.

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 09:27

Shedmistress · 10/11/2026 08:27

Which engagement so far has been 'inhumane' or 'irrational'?

For example :

"All we are dealing with now is a group of loud, highly entitled men who do not care about women’s rights, consent, boundaries - and think the world should revolve around them.
The answer is and always will be - no"

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 09:28

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 09:27

For example :

"All we are dealing with now is a group of loud, highly entitled men who do not care about women’s rights, consent, boundaries - and think the world should revolve around them.
The answer is and always will be - no"

Perfectly put, I’d say!

SwirlyGates · 10/11/2026 09:28

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 10/11/2026 09:19

Wrong place to ask. While there are decent people on here, the forum's dedicated to weird conspiracy theories and fantastical origin stories about trans people, getting vexed at sighting one and calling young nb people attending school 'gaslighting'. Perfectly normal pronouns are violence, known racists are heroines and trans people's genitals are discussed with zero awareness that it's a deeply abnormal thing to do.

Outside of here, there is the street violence, prejudice and parental rejection which the terf movement enables - but most people are fine with normal human difference.

I'd ask somewhere else. The replies you'll get will be variants of "I have no problem with trans people apart from everything they do" followed by a series of weird accusations.

Just, no sense at all that there are good and bad people within all populations. To this place, trans women are gay men who were 'transed' and now can't walk past an M&S girdle without orgasming. Where trans men are all autistic survivors with MH issues; sterile but nothing special when they give birth; and on and on it goes. Madness. all day. Look!.Another Reddit thread. Sighted! A trans woman (they think) in a queue. Non-binary person attends Parliament/school/doughnut shop! Trans woman wears skirt! Trans guy wears skirt, what does this mean?!

Fearing and hating trans people is a hobby on here. Might as well as Reform what's wrong with immigrants.

Do try to stick to the truth for once, eh?

teawamutu · 10/11/2026 09:29

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 09:27

For example :

"All we are dealing with now is a group of loud, highly entitled men who do not care about women’s rights, consent, boundaries - and think the world should revolve around them.
The answer is and always will be - no"

Facts check out. What's the problem?

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 09:29

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 10/11/2026 09:19

Wrong place to ask. While there are decent people on here, the forum's dedicated to weird conspiracy theories and fantastical origin stories about trans people, getting vexed at sighting one and calling young nb people attending school 'gaslighting'. Perfectly normal pronouns are violence, known racists are heroines and trans people's genitals are discussed with zero awareness that it's a deeply abnormal thing to do.

Outside of here, there is the street violence, prejudice and parental rejection which the terf movement enables - but most people are fine with normal human difference.

I'd ask somewhere else. The replies you'll get will be variants of "I have no problem with trans people apart from everything they do" followed by a series of weird accusations.

Just, no sense at all that there are good and bad people within all populations. To this place, trans women are gay men who were 'transed' and now can't walk past an M&S girdle without orgasming. Where trans men are all autistic survivors with MH issues; sterile but nothing special when they give birth; and on and on it goes. Madness. all day. Look!.Another Reddit thread. Sighted! A trans woman (they think) in a queue. Non-binary person attends Parliament/school/doughnut shop! Trans woman wears skirt! Trans guy wears skirt, what does this mean?!

Fearing and hating trans people is a hobby on here. Might as well as Reform what's wrong with immigrants.

Tell me you have actually read some of the posts @TransParentlyAnnoyed ?

A series of posts clarifying there is most definitely not hate towards trans people but there is fatigue about being asked to go along with the lies that validate them.

Mamalasira · 10/11/2026 09:29

teawamutu · 10/11/2026 09:04

Always liked this way of putting it.

Brilliant

lifesaconfusingwonder · 10/11/2026 09:31

Ok, I can only speak for myself here, but here are my reasons;

Being a woman is hard, and at times, completely grim. Lots of blood, procedures, degrading medical care etc I feel men who dress as women are gaslighting me to what being a woman actually means.

I feel like drag queens are mocking women.

I strongly believe that men are amazing and women are amazing- in their own ways and that should be celebrated. I don’t believe one can turn into another (well, that’s fact not my belief of course)

I can feel unsafe around people who obviously have serious mental health challenges who are trying to be something they are not.

I want to be safe and daughter to be safe, and any other remotely vulnerable woman.

I am a conformist and like a peaceful society. I think trans men have done an awful lot of damage in the past years that’s been detrimental to society. (I thinking of men in women’s sport as an example) and I think they’ve been incredibly selfish.

vickylou78 · 10/11/2026 09:31

I don't dislike trans people and in fact know quite a few trans people who are absolutely lovely! I would happily share a single sex space with them. Because I know them and I'm confident they don't pose any harm to me.

But here's the thing. If I was in a hospital ward or in a public toilet and men identifying as women were allowed in, deep in my gut I just wouldnt feel safe. The reality is men are stronger, bigger, taller, have stronger grip strength etc. and so if you allow men (even those identifying as women) into women's spaces we are at more risk of being attacked or raped. I don't mean that trans women are more likely to attack or rape but if you allow some men in you really allow 'any' men in. How do we know which men are a risk and which aren't? Are we safe just because they are wearing more feminine clothing? It's tricky.

Also in a hospital scenario, I think most women would be embarrassed to deal with undressing and dealing with sanitary/period issues etc. in front of men identifying as women.
Really we need third spaces for trans people to be safe.

AlwaysExtraHot · 10/11/2026 09:32

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 10/11/2026 09:19

Wrong place to ask. While there are decent people on here, the forum's dedicated to weird conspiracy theories and fantastical origin stories about trans people, getting vexed at sighting one and calling young nb people attending school 'gaslighting'. Perfectly normal pronouns are violence, known racists are heroines and trans people's genitals are discussed with zero awareness that it's a deeply abnormal thing to do.

Outside of here, there is the street violence, prejudice and parental rejection which the terf movement enables - but most people are fine with normal human difference.

I'd ask somewhere else. The replies you'll get will be variants of "I have no problem with trans people apart from everything they do" followed by a series of weird accusations.

Just, no sense at all that there are good and bad people within all populations. To this place, trans women are gay men who were 'transed' and now can't walk past an M&S girdle without orgasming. Where trans men are all autistic survivors with MH issues; sterile but nothing special when they give birth; and on and on it goes. Madness. all day. Look!.Another Reddit thread. Sighted! A trans woman (they think) in a queue. Non-binary person attends Parliament/school/doughnut shop! Trans woman wears skirt! Trans guy wears skirt, what does this mean?!

Fearing and hating trans people is a hobby on here. Might as well as Reform what's wrong with immigrants.

Oh, hello, I wondered when you'd turn up!
Hyperbole firmly in place, I see.

lifeturnsonadime · 10/11/2026 09:33

The trouble is that the behaviour of TRAs has damaged the way in which people see trans people generally.

Cross dressers and transexuals and gender non conforming people have always been around, it's only relatively recently that women have received death threats for wanting to feel safe away from ALL MALES in single sex spaces.

You reap what you sow.

If trans people and trans activists were respectful of women's rights then there would be less of a problem.

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 09:34

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 09:28

Perfectly put, I’d say!

I had no doubt you would! And I'm sure the majority of the pps on this thread concur, hence my original advice to the OP.

allthemind · 10/11/2026 09:34

OP @lacksie and @TransParentlyAnnoyed unfortunately have an agenda, for reasons you can probably guess at, and so feel the need to come on every thread on this topic on this forum and try and derail it unfortunately. Its a shame because it stifles debate as everyone will just go and get on with their day instead of engaging with people that have no cogent arguments or input to add other to insult and minimise people's lived experiences, like the bigots they truly are, and the whole thread becomes hostile and abusive.

Have a great day everyone!

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 09:34

vickylou78 · 10/11/2026 09:31

I don't dislike trans people and in fact know quite a few trans people who are absolutely lovely! I would happily share a single sex space with them. Because I know them and I'm confident they don't pose any harm to me.

But here's the thing. If I was in a hospital ward or in a public toilet and men identifying as women were allowed in, deep in my gut I just wouldnt feel safe. The reality is men are stronger, bigger, taller, have stronger grip strength etc. and so if you allow men (even those identifying as women) into women's spaces we are at more risk of being attacked or raped. I don't mean that trans women are more likely to attack or rape but if you allow some men in you really allow 'any' men in. How do we know which men are a risk and which aren't? Are we safe just because they are wearing more feminine clothing? It's tricky.

Also in a hospital scenario, I think most women would be embarrassed to deal with undressing and dealing with sanitary/period issues etc. in front of men identifying as women.
Really we need third spaces for trans people to be safe.

Edited

The issue is @vickylou78 you make a really sensible point but they do not want a third space they want our space as we know. So whilst we are reasonably trying to come up with an idea for trans people they just shout us down as being transphobic bigots until we agree to acquiesce and let them into our spaces. That is coercive behaviour.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 09:34

JJWT · 10/11/2026 09:27

For me a big issue is cis women being told by their employers they have to take their clothes off in changing spaces at work in the presence of an adult who has a penis. I dont think anyone should be forced to put up with that. I was forced to remove my clothes when SA by a man as a child and not having control over concepts like that is abhorrent to me. I'm not in a job where this applies but when I see it cropping up eg for nurses who need to change for theatre it makes me very angry on their behalf. Its not as basic as thinking this man could assault me, its the awkwardness of getting undressed in front of a person you regard as physically a man and lack of autonomy in not being allowed to refuse this. To me, its astonishing its even being suggested. I don't think it helps with acceptance at all. Quite the opposite.

I totally agree with you on everything you say, but there is no such thing as “cis” - you don’t have to define yourself in terms of these men. And I certainly don’t consent to my sex being misrepresented in this way.

Women are the category, we only come in one sex. It’s a loaded, sexist term that doesn’t make much sense. “Trans women” are not a type of woman. They are a type of man. While you are perfectly free to call yourself “cis”, I’m not a “cis woman” because that is not actually a thing. If “trans woman” means a woman who identifies as a man, I’ll concede it has some descriptive value. Otherwise, if it’s being used to suggest that a TIM is a type of woman, no.

SparklingGlitteryWine · 10/11/2026 09:35

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 10/11/2026 09:19

Wrong place to ask. While there are decent people on here, the forum's dedicated to weird conspiracy theories and fantastical origin stories about trans people, getting vexed at sighting one and calling young nb people attending school 'gaslighting'. Perfectly normal pronouns are violence, known racists are heroines and trans people's genitals are discussed with zero awareness that it's a deeply abnormal thing to do.

Outside of here, there is the street violence, prejudice and parental rejection which the terf movement enables - but most people are fine with normal human difference.

I'd ask somewhere else. The replies you'll get will be variants of "I have no problem with trans people apart from everything they do" followed by a series of weird accusations.

Just, no sense at all that there are good and bad people within all populations. To this place, trans women are gay men who were 'transed' and now can't walk past an M&S girdle without orgasming. Where trans men are all autistic survivors with MH issues; sterile but nothing special when they give birth; and on and on it goes. Madness. all day. Look!.Another Reddit thread. Sighted! A trans woman (they think) in a queue. Non-binary person attends Parliament/school/doughnut shop! Trans woman wears skirt! Trans guy wears skirt, what does this mean?!

Fearing and hating trans people is a hobby on here. Might as well as Reform what's wrong with immigrants.

You can paint yourself yellow and identify as a Banana for all I care, when 11 year old girl guides are called bigots for telling boys that they don't want them in their space, and made to feel that those boys feelings are worth more than their feelings and safety, you can get in the bin as far as I'm concerned.

Manyanamanyana · 10/11/2026 09:36

Igneococcus · 10/11/2026 06:29

I've not had Goody Gumdrops icecream for decades, or a Hokey Pokey

I didn't even know Goody gum drops was an ice-cream. We do have hokey pokey though, here in Aus. And Buffalo Bill's.

HenriettaHippopotamus · 10/11/2026 09:38

What I hate about these debates, discussions, whatever they are, is that people don't listen.

If someone points out the many issues around children identifying as trans, for example, the response is to accuse the person of hating trans people or to ask why they care. It's weird when any other welfare issue concerning children is raised no one asks why someone else cares. I have no connection to homeless youth but if I was raising concern about it no one would be like "And what's that got to do with you?".

I would say that in general people who are gender critical don't hate people who identify as trans. They dislike the ideology for several reasons.

Firstly, unlike gay with rights, every day people are required to reframe their own identity in ways they don't agree with. I'm now apparently a cis-woman which means that my gender identity aligns with my sex. So me being a woman is not to do with being female but some gender soul. Gender identity is not how you present, not your sex etc, it's some mystical entity within us apparently. Far too religious for my liking.

Along with this comes the change of language. In the not so distance past some feminist took issue with being referred to as female because of reasons such as it being demeaning and dehumanising to be referred to just in biological term as it stripped personhood. But now some of them still hate this but are apparently fine with menstruator (urgh spell check has this word) and womb-haver etc, which are even more demeaning. Then we have that "biological woman" is apparently offensive and so you get to the place where you can't actually talk about the experiences of women as words like woman and female can now include males. Also even cis woman doesn't always mean a biological woman as people like Caster Semenya were assigned female at birth and so they are a cis woman too. I just find it incredibly misogynistic that in this ideology there's no word to only describe half the population.

Another issue is the children. There's no strong evidence for and plenty against blocking children's puberty. Prior to this becoming politicised, charities such as Mermaids endorsed the 'watchful waiting' method, recognising that gender related distress often resolves during adolescence. Research showed this. Often these children will be gay and that is tied up with the issues they were having. Some professionals at Tavistock worried about this issue concerning the medicalising of gay children. The whole reason the Dutch first used puberty blockers was because they acknowledged that most children grew out of it but that some didn't and they wanted to help that group. They thought by giving all children a delay those that would continue to want to transition in adulthood would be helped. What ended up happening though was that basically all children continued on to cross sex hormones precisely because their puberty was blocked. Going through their own natural puberty would have helped them.

You mentioned numbers being small but in things like prisons and sports it can have a meaningfully negative impact on women. Women were harassed in prisons by predatory males. In sports, women have lost places and prizes. People often concentrate on the medals but it's also important to acknowledge that for some just getting into a competition is a great achievement.

Anyway that's just some of things, don't want to make this longer. I think if activists would actually acknowledge issues and not just centre males and their wants and needs only things might be better.

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 09:39

SparklingGlitteryWine · 10/11/2026 09:35

You can paint yourself yellow and identify as a Banana for all I care, when 11 year old girl guides are called bigots for telling boys that they don't want them in their space, and made to feel that those boys feelings are worth more than their feelings and safety, you can get in the bin as far as I'm concerned.

Well said @SparklingGlitteryWine perhaps @Lacksie or @TransParentlyAnnoyed can dissect your post top spin it as transphobic bigotry or be fair and accept what you said is spot on. Mainly because that is a safeguarding issue and also educating our girls to know how to stay safe around males.

Waterbaby41 · 10/11/2026 09:39

I would have more support for transpeople if they were campaigning for their own spaces. Like it or not, trans women will always be that - trans. They will never be women. Ditto for transmen. Yes there is space for all in our society, but not in safe spaces for women only. There are very good reasons why those spaces were created in the first place. Campaign for trans spaces, keep out of ours

Mamalasira · 10/11/2026 09:40

Do you have any idea how girls and women have struggled to get where we are now? Do you think all we've ever done is wear flowery outfits and lipstick?
It's been a litany of harrasment, violence, threats, imprisonment, rape, poverty and exclusion.
Read some books on women's history, then come back and say it's ok to do as you please and go into spaces reserved for girls and women.

RareGoalsVerge · 10/11/2026 09:40

Transperson · 10/11/2026 05:06

Hiya, thanks for another reply, to your previous replies & others I would get back to them tomorrow.

Sex is divided to phenotypic, gonadal, and genetic. Medically transitioing effects phenotypic sex.

By this I am not saying it's 100% one or another, but that it simply has an effect.

So a medically transitioned trans women most commonly is genotypically and gondally male. Phenotypically somewhere leaning towards female.

Hope this helps.

Edited

Not true.

A male person who has had surgery does not have a female phenotype. Surgical attempts to mimic female attributes do not actually create the attributes they mimic. Silicon pouches in the chest are not breasts. An artificial fistula kept open with dilation is not a vagina. The thought that they are even a close mimicry is a fundamentally male phenomenon, perceiving these things only to the extent that they are useful to a man and thinking that is the whole thing.

There is no shame in being a transwoman, there is nothing wrong with living your best life with free choices within what is factually and practically possible. If having these artificial changes to your body makes you feel better that's great. They no more make you any more female than having similar surgical procedures to give you pointy ears and a tail would make you feline.

Manyanamanyana · 10/11/2026 09:41

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 06:52

“I use single sex spaces that align with my phenotypic presentation and no one precieved me differently than my representation, challenged me or expressed discomfort.”

This kind of statement is really not useful in anyway.

What “phenotypic presentation” ?

It needs to be clarified.

If phenotypic presentation means a female person who has taken testosterone and had a phalloplasty, that is different to a male person who has grown their breast tissue or got implants and had a cavity inserted where their penis used to be.

However, single sex provisions are not based on what phenotypical presentation a person has! Otherwise any male person who has developed their breast tissue in all the ways possible would be included in the female single sex provision. Moobs, implants.. whatever.

Again though, there is a huge difference between a female person with a transgender identity and a male person with a transgender identity. So, @Transperson, which sex category of transgender people do you refer to.

Because this constant reference to transgender people in general is missing the highly significant point.

This kind of statement is really not useful in anyway.
What “phenotypic presentation” ?
It needs to be clarified.

It can't be. It needs to be ignored 🤣

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 09:43

allthemind · 10/11/2026 09:34

OP @lacksie and @TransParentlyAnnoyed unfortunately have an agenda, for reasons you can probably guess at, and so feel the need to come on every thread on this topic on this forum and try and derail it unfortunately. Its a shame because it stifles debate as everyone will just go and get on with their day instead of engaging with people that have no cogent arguments or input to add other to insult and minimise people's lived experiences, like the bigots they truly are, and the whole thread becomes hostile and abusive.

Have a great day everyone!

My only "agenda" is to answer the harmful misinformation about trans people promoted this board with evidence, reason and some basic humanity. If that counts as an agenda, I’ll own it.

Easilyforgotten · 10/11/2026 09:44

I think the problem is that the trans community has been hijacked by extremists. The quiet ones who just want to present in their chosen fashion and go about their lives in peace have every right to do so. The problem comes about, in my option, when self id comes in to the picture because that changes the narrative from trans to all. If any man who identifies as a woman can access female spaces, then what you are realistically saying is that all men can access female spaces. You are then looking at the statistics relating to the risk of males as a whole group.
I also completely agree that the erasure of language relating to womanhood.is totally unacceptable. I refuse to be reduced to a person with a uterus, or whatever other nonsense is expounded. I am a woman, full stop.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread