Another bit of a different email that might be helpful, though if you've been going back and forth for two years already you may be well past this point. Also, this was all from 2024 and we now have some new statutory guidance and court cases out there to rely on!
"To set the background for these concerns, all schools are prohibited, by statute, from promoting partisan political views. The recent government guidance on RSE states that schools “should not reinforce harmful stereotypes, for instance by suggesting that children might be a different gender based on their personality and interests or the clothes they prefer to wear. Resources used in teaching about this topic must always be age-appropriate and evidence based. Materials which suggest that non-conformity to gender stereotypes should be seen as synonymous with having a different gender identity should not be used and you should not work with external agencies or organisations that produce such material.”
In addition, the DofE statutory guidance, as well as the non-statutory implementation guidance, is clear that schools are required to vet materials themselves and not rely on external providers' imprimatur of quality or adherence to the law - even PSHE Association accreditation or endorsement cannot be taken to mean that a resource is legally correct or meets DfE guidelines. Schools are also required to consult parents to ensure that parental views are reflected when planning and delivering PSHE content. I may have missed the consultation on these issues, or possibly the recent parent talks were the consultation in which case I think they should have been signposted as such. More clarity and time spent on these issues would be helpful to all. It would be good to know when this consultation happened and RSE Policy approved, prior to the rollout of the new PSHE curriculum, and the next review date of the policy. I would check this myself but note that no PSHE or RSE Policy is listed on the school website with the other school policies.
[Note: I found out later that the reason it didn't appear is that the new PSHE teacher had drafted a policy, it hadn't been consulted on, approved, published or circulated but she went ahead with her new resources anyway. Then 6 months after I started emailing it appeared on the website back-dated by a year, with no consultation or approval date. If I hadn't checked in February 2024, I wouldn't have known when it appeared in September 2024 that a policy dated Sept 2023 hadn't been there earlier that year.]
Any teaching about gender identity must include recognition that lack of belief in gender identity and gender ideology is a protected belief under the Equality Act 2010 following Forstater. Not believing in gender identity is equally as acceptable as believing in it, and if concepts such as gender identity are to be taught at all at this stage (and in the guidance is not mandatory at this age), this position should be presented with equal weight and acceptability to avoid breaching DoE statutory guidance. This states that schools must also ensure all resources used are impartial, forbid the promotion of partisan political views in the teaching of any subject and ensure a balanced presentation of opposing political views. Further, “[schools] should be aware that the meaning of political issues does not refer solely to the discussion of party politics. Schools are advised to consider the range of issues on which there could be political views, which may include global affairs, equalities issues, religion and economics."
One final point - being able to acknowledge and openly refer to the sex of all children and adults is essential for child safeguarding. Sex is always a relevant variable when assessing risk. Most sexual assaults and harassment in schools, homes and in society are carried out by men and boys against women and girls. Any infringement on education professionals’ ability to state the sex of all children when necessary, for example when assessing risk, both puts children at risk by hampering safeguarding and infringes on professionals’ Article 10 rights (education professionals have statutory safeguarding duties). And any education that children receive that imply that it is gender identity, rather than sex which should be recognised, could also put these children at risk, particularly if they have SEND or for whom English is not their native language.
I should probably also say that there are a number of parents concerned about these issues, and any follow up on the points above would be very much appreciated by all. Very happy to further the discussion in a call or f2f meeting."