Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The TERF Diaries : Dispatches From The Decade When The World Lost Its Mind by Addie Klein

39 replies

BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 07:03

Debated if this is the right place for a conversation about this book - The TERF Diaries : Dispatches From The Decade When The World Lost Its Mind
by Addie Klein.

I’m over half way through it and am liking the way the author has looked at various things that have happened over the past decade or so that have us in the position we are now.

If it should go somewhere else please suggest a move. I expect push back from people. The thread is about the book really and how people are receiving it.

I have checked and cannot see this being discussed elsewhere, but happy to be corrected.

OP posts:
TrappedByThisDesk · 09/11/2026 11:10

BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 10:27

The diary starts in 2015.

I think the more interesting period was prior to this. The roots go back to the 1970s (there was a clip on this site, from the BBC I think? of about 4 or 5 transwomen in a circle discussing their goals), and the UK gay marriage legislation was 2013, by which time Stonewall would already have been casting around for a new role to keep the money coming in. I would love to read a detailed analysis of the roots of the trans movement prior to 2015.

By 2015 the bandwagon was already rolling.

BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 10:46

RoyalCorgi · 09/11/2026 10:39

I think this may be the previous thread about it:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5541779-advice-from-mumsnet-terven

Thanks @RoyalCorgi I was aware of that but saw it more as a promotion of the book by the author.

I started this thread really to sound out anyone else who has read it or is reading it and what they took away from it.

Many little things at the start of the book passed me by a bit at the time so it is good to put jigsaw pieces into a timeline. Just lots and lots of examples where woman have been put in jeopardy all to placate men who think that they are women. It feels sinister and it is. Made worse by all being dressed up with the ‘be kind’ mantra. As the thread asks any takes from others who have read or are reading it.

I ask this because the TRAs and allies deny so much of what the book highlights. Yet here it is in black and white with dates and times and actual evidence. It is almost like some TRAs and allies are defending the indefensible.

OP posts:
BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 10:36

MarieDeGournay · 09/11/2026 10:29

There are lots of tiny minorities in society, TPA - can you name any other tiny minority that has has such disproportionate influence on the media, the law, education, language, etc etc?

I look forward to reading this book as it seems to address one of the major questions: how on earth did such a tiny minority, with such flawed and irrational arguments, achieve the position of power and influence the transgender
movement has in some [though by no means all] countries?
A question for future social scientists to mull over...

I think one of the obvious factors is that the trans movement is inherently anti-women - what better way to deprive a group of its rights than to alter how it is defined, so 'women' now means 'women PLUS men who say they are women'.
Any inherently anti-women ideology is bound to appeal to a patriarchal society dealing with a troublesome women's rights movement which by the1980s and 90s appeared to have made some progress.

Agree @MarieDeGournay about the disproportionate influence this tiny minority has had. As for the areas addressed in the book the hard reads are about places such as the Edinburgh Rape Crisis centre and the verbal gymnastics used by the man pretending to be a woman who ran it. Harrowing to think how women trying to address their traumatic experiences were advised to ‘reframe their trauma’.

Sport and prisons as a well. Demonstrations where urine is used to splatter a building where a woman’s conference is going on. Hideous thing to do.

Trans could have been much more accepted had they not tried to ensure they made women HAVE to let them in. Every protest is aggressive.

Women do not matter to these activists. Their desire to access our spaces/sports/prisons/crisis centres seems to be their main motivation.

OP posts:
MarieDeGournay · 09/11/2026 10:29

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/11/2026 10:06

You're not in any position. Trans people exist, always have, always will - and are currently being targeted for being trans.

it's their rights being removed, no one else's. Their safety and wellbeing being compromised. They who are suffering appalling abuse in schools, and greatly increased street violence.

A tiny minority existing doesn't affect you - or the author - in the slightest.

There are lots of tiny minorities in society, TPA - can you name any other tiny minority that has has such disproportionate influence on the media, the law, education, language, etc etc?

I look forward to reading this book as it seems to address one of the major questions: how on earth did such a tiny minority, with such flawed and irrational arguments, achieve the position of power and influence the transgender
movement has in some [though by no means all] countries?
A question for future social scientists to mull over...

I think one of the obvious factors is that the trans movement is inherently anti-women - what better way to deprive a group of its rights than to alter how it is defined, so 'women' now means 'women PLUS men who say they are women'.
Any inherently anti-women ideology is bound to appeal to a patriarchal society dealing with a troublesome women's rights movement which by the1980s and 90s appeared to have made some progress.

BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 10:27

TrappedByThisDesk · 09/11/2026 10:26

How far back does the book go? i.e. when does the diary start from?

The diary starts in 2015.

OP posts:
TrappedByThisDesk · 09/11/2026 10:26

How far back does the book go? i.e. when does the diary start from?

akkakk · 09/11/2026 10:25

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/11/2026 10:06

You're not in any position. Trans people exist, always have, always will - and are currently being targeted for being trans.

it's their rights being removed, no one else's. Their safety and wellbeing being compromised. They who are suffering appalling abuse in schools, and greatly increased street violence.

A tiny minority existing doesn't affect you - or the author - in the slightest.

Allow me to correct that for you...

There isn't one single example anywhere in the world of a biological male becoming a biological woman, or v.v. - so no... no-one has ever transitioned.

'Trans people' are not being targetted - dishonesty / lies / deceit / violence / aggression / harassment / etc. - yup, those are fair game.

Name a single 'right' that 'trans people' have that is being removed?
e.g. as a man a 'trans woman' has all of the rights that a man has - which is being removed? A 'trans woman' has never been a woman - so has never had women's rights, so they can't be removed...

Show the evidence for the claim of increased violence in schools or on the streets - actual stats and figures? There is no such evidence and constructed anecdotes don't count.

And so much of what is being demanded by 'trans women' in particular absolutely affects over 50% of the world population by removing their rights - removing respect and the right to decency, removing the ability to have safe spaces - forcing on people what they do not choose, male doctors insisting that they should be seen as women and can deal with vulnerable women patients / men running women's rape centres and telling female victims that it is their issue if they don't want to deal with a man in their safe space / men in women's swimming costumes with their bits hanging out in women's spaces / men in their underwear insisting that women undress in front of them in women's spaces and harassing them when they don't comply...

yup - I think that those being affected is very very clear...

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 09/11/2026 10:24

Slightly random post from TPA there.

However, since it has bumped the thread I will comment on Terf Diaries, which I purchased and read. It is an interesting and easy read which fills in some of the gaps for those of us who were not in this fight from the start. As the genre is 'diary', the author has to 'pretend' ignorance of events beyond the year in question. However she does sometimes hint at them which I found mildly irritating because a true diary couldn't do that. That's a mild quibble though.

Overall it is definitely worth purchasing alongside The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht.

BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 10:21

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/11/2026 10:06

You're not in any position. Trans people exist, always have, always will - and are currently being targeted for being trans.

it's their rights being removed, no one else's. Their safety and wellbeing being compromised. They who are suffering appalling abuse in schools, and greatly increased street violence.

A tiny minority existing doesn't affect you - or the author - in the slightest.

Have you read or listened to the book? My thread is about the book. I am finding the timeline of things that happened very interesting as if anything rather than trans people ‘being targeted’ it very much highlights how woman have been targeted to accept men in their spaces.

You are of course correct. Transvestites and transsexual people have always existed. But the fact is that it is relatively recent that they have demanded access to women’s spaces and sports.

So yes it does affect me. If I want to attend a women’s only swim session I do not want to see a man in the pool. The book is highlighting lots of issues that women being expected to accept men in our world.

OP posts:
TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/11/2026 10:06

You're not in any position. Trans people exist, always have, always will - and are currently being targeted for being trans.

it's their rights being removed, no one else's. Their safety and wellbeing being compromised. They who are suffering appalling abuse in schools, and greatly increased street violence.

A tiny minority existing doesn't affect you - or the author - in the slightest.

BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 07:36

DworkinWasRight · 09/11/2026 07:34

I’m fairly sure the author is a Mumsnetter and has posted about the book on here previously.

Ah ok interesting. So far I haven’t investigated her background. Am reading/listening and bits of the narration are a little odd - but the message is clear that we have sort of sleep walked into ‘tolerating’ small things to end up finding our selves in a mess - thinking of the CT draft bill.

OP posts:
DworkinWasRight · 09/11/2026 07:34

I’m fairly sure the author is a Mumsnetter and has posted about the book on here previously.

BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 07:30

Much of the book points out things that have happened over the past 10 years and the recent final paragraph of JKRs post on X endorses what we have tolerated/railed against/questioned etc.

From JKR….
I believe people will look back on this period and analyse your arguments, not because they admire them, but because they're trying to fathom how so many supposedly intelligent people fell, hook, line and sinker for a bunch of vacuous, post-modern, pseudo-intellectual cobblers, while being completely indifferent to the real world harm they were enabling.

Interested to hear from people about how the book is being received and/or interpreted.

OP posts: