Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The TERF Diaries : Dispatches From The Decade When The World Lost Its Mind by Addie Klein

39 replies

BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 07:03

Debated if this is the right place for a conversation about this book - The TERF Diaries : Dispatches From The Decade When The World Lost Its Mind
by Addie Klein.

I’m over half way through it and am liking the way the author has looked at various things that have happened over the past decade or so that have us in the position we are now.

If it should go somewhere else please suggest a move. I expect push back from people. The thread is about the book really and how people are receiving it.

I have checked and cannot see this being discussed elsewhere, but happy to be corrected.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BlueLegume · 11/11/2026 18:54

MarieDeGournay · 11/11/2026 18:31

I'm looking forward to reading this book, I think it will be valuable for nailing down the reality of all the
TWAW-and-how-dare-you-suggest-I'm-less-of-a-woman-than-you-you-bigot stuff that is now either airbrushed out of history or replaced with
'but of course no one is suggesting that anyone actually changes sex! heaven forfend! it's all about how transpeople present themselves..'
or something like that.

The Great Trans Shifting Goalposts.

Agreed ❤️💐

OP posts:
MarieDeGournay · 11/11/2026 18:31

I'm looking forward to reading this book, I think it will be valuable for nailing down the reality of all the
TWAW-and-how-dare-you-suggest-I'm-less-of-a-woman-than-you-you-bigot stuff that is now either airbrushed out of history or replaced with
'but of course no one is suggesting that anyone actually changes sex! heaven forfend! it's all about how transpeople present themselves..'
or something like that.

The Great Trans Shifting Goalposts.

BlueLegume · 11/11/2026 15:41

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/11/2026 10:06

You're not in any position. Trans people exist, always have, always will - and are currently being targeted for being trans.

it's their rights being removed, no one else's. Their safety and wellbeing being compromised. They who are suffering appalling abuse in schools, and greatly increased street violence.

A tiny minority existing doesn't affect you - or the author - in the slightest.

Thank you for posting your opinion @TransParentlyAnnoyed

First question - what did you mean by ‘you’re not in any position? I am reading a book. The topic is interesting so why am I not in any position?

Second question - who are you to dictate to me what does and doesn’t affect me in life?

Third question - what rights are being removed?

You may feel they are being targeted. Perhaps consider women in particular have felt very targeted for some years as the book describes to step aside and allow their hard won rights to be erased by being expected to allow men into our spaces and sports.

All straightforward questions.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 12:53

BlueLegume · 11/11/2026 12:48

Yes @Ereshkigalangcleg good description. It was also around the time people like me working in education at the time were seeing Stonewall packs distributed. Many of the messages were I recall, ‘it’s ok to be gay’ - absolutely.

However many of the other messages outlined gender as well. They got to the kids essentially as our progressive SLT worshiped at the altar of Stonewall.

Within a short time we saw several girls identifying as boys. At this point girls were not being diagnosed with autism but they all followed the same pattern. Socially awkward, shy, quite immature and often from homes which were quite fragile.

Anyhow, I think it is worth a listen or read. It very much does talk about if you didn’t go along with the mantras/ideology/TWAW/TMAM then you were simply called a bigot. Considering our recent two threads that filled up so rapidly started by Transperson I would say we do now feel we can explain we have no hate towards well meaning people who want to live in a different sex. It should also be acceptable to equally want them to have a good life but also be able to shop at the Harry Potter store without being called transphobic or anti trans.

Is the tide turning towards a more sensible approach? Some days I think it is but sadly some TRAs and allies are so wedded to the cause they can’t extricate themselves for fear of being turned on by the very people they have championed.

I downloaded it when the author posted her original thread but not yet got around to reading. It’s on the list!

Grammarnut · 11/11/2026 12:52

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/11/2026 10:06

You're not in any position. Trans people exist, always have, always will - and are currently being targeted for being trans.

it's their rights being removed, no one else's. Their safety and wellbeing being compromised. They who are suffering appalling abuse in schools, and greatly increased street violence.

A tiny minority existing doesn't affect you - or the author - in the slightest.

It effects women hugely (and girls) when men and boys muscle into our spaces and places, sports, prizes, toilets and changing rooms and bloody swimming ponds. You and your friends do not want to live in peace you want to take what belongs to women and pretend to be women in public to feed your fetish. Go away.

BlueLegume · 11/11/2026 12:48

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 12:36

It’s a diary of a significant period, not a history of transgenderism. 2015 was significant for two things: the government’s trans equality inquiry which led to TRAs (mostly Gendered Intelligence) being asked to have heavy, biased input into EHRC guidelines. Also was the year Stonewall started to support “trans rights” seeing the potential lucrative gravy train approaching.

Yes @Ereshkigalangcleg good description. It was also around the time people like me working in education at the time were seeing Stonewall packs distributed. Many of the messages were I recall, ‘it’s ok to be gay’ - absolutely.

However many of the other messages outlined gender as well. They got to the kids essentially as our progressive SLT worshiped at the altar of Stonewall.

Within a short time we saw several girls identifying as boys. At this point girls were not being diagnosed with autism but they all followed the same pattern. Socially awkward, shy, quite immature and often from homes which were quite fragile.

Anyhow, I think it is worth a listen or read. It very much does talk about if you didn’t go along with the mantras/ideology/TWAW/TMAM then you were simply called a bigot. Considering our recent two threads that filled up so rapidly started by Transperson I would say we do now feel we can explain we have no hate towards well meaning people who want to live in a different sex. It should also be acceptable to equally want them to have a good life but also be able to shop at the Harry Potter store without being called transphobic or anti trans.

Is the tide turning towards a more sensible approach? Some days I think it is but sadly some TRAs and allies are so wedded to the cause they can’t extricate themselves for fear of being turned on by the very people they have championed.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 12:36

It’s a diary of a significant period, not a history of transgenderism. 2015 was significant for two things: the government’s trans equality inquiry which led to TRAs (mostly Gendered Intelligence) being asked to have heavy, biased input into EHRC guidelines. Also was the year Stonewall started to support “trans rights” seeing the potential lucrative gravy train approaching.

BlueLegume · 11/11/2026 11:34

PermanentTemporary · 11/11/2026 07:34

Sounds interesting though I’m not convinced I would agree with the timeline, the viewpoint or what’s included - let’s see once I actually manage to read it. This issue has been a part of my own personal life since my first marriage in 1995 and I would see the Goodwin case in the late 90s as the obvious starting point, so I will perhaps be able to comment on the structure later.

Am nearly at the end @PermanentTemporary and would agree that the timeline is very much one personal to Addie Klein, but it still works. Many of the books on this subject are a lot more in depth and Addie has set out a series of events that work in my opinion certainly if you have not been aware of any of this. She links numerous events which will all have been somewhere on most peoples radar but that many will not have connected - trans agenda.

I have enjoyed it actually more than I expected. There is definitely a place for it alongside other books around the subject.

OP posts:
Pabbel · 11/11/2026 11:22

Mmm thats a shame, will wait then, thanks

RareGoalsVerge · 11/11/2026 08:56

Pabbel · 11/11/2026 08:31

Ive tried googling this morning, able to get audio, but no paperback available apart from Amazon, whom i dont deal with.

Ah - it says "Independently Published" which might mean that it's only available through amazon because they have a setup for independent publication - authors just upload print-ready pdfs and copies are printed on-demand as and when someone buys one, rather than a publisher having to guess how many will sell and then provide storage for boxloads. If this is the case you'll have to either hold your nose and deal with amazon or wait till copies start appearing in 2nd hand bookshops.

BlueLegume · 11/11/2026 08:46

Pabbel · 11/11/2026 08:31

Ive tried googling this morning, able to get audio, but no paperback available apart from Amazon, whom i dont deal with.

As suggested try your local independent book shop or any independent book sellers who will ship it to you. Most small independents do this.

OP posts:
Pabbel · 11/11/2026 08:31

Ive tried googling this morning, able to get audio, but no paperback available apart from Amazon, whom i dont deal with.

RareGoalsVerge · 11/11/2026 07:46

Pabbel · 11/11/2026 07:28

Does anybody know were i can buy a paperback copy other than amazon?

Support independent bookshops! Google for where your nearest one is that you can easily get to and drop them an email giving the title, author and ISBN 979-8197356505 - most bookshops can get in any title within 24-48hrs of getting a request like this.

PermanentTemporary · 11/11/2026 07:34

Sounds interesting though I’m not convinced I would agree with the timeline, the viewpoint or what’s included - let’s see once I actually manage to read it. This issue has been a part of my own personal life since my first marriage in 1995 and I would see the Goodwin case in the late 90s as the obvious starting point, so I will perhaps be able to comment on the structure later.

Pabbel · 11/11/2026 07:28

Does anybody know were i can buy a paperback copy other than amazon?

WaterThyme · 11/11/2026 06:38

1973 BBC discussion on “transex liberation”group. Count how many women take part.

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p0jy43dv/open-door-transex-liberation-group

AlonsoMosley · 11/11/2026 03:38

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/11/2026 10:06

You're not in any position. Trans people exist, always have, always will - and are currently being targeted for being trans.

it's their rights being removed, no one else's. Their safety and wellbeing being compromised. They who are suffering appalling abuse in schools, and greatly increased street violence.

A tiny minority existing doesn't affect you - or the author - in the slightest.

it's their rights being removed, no one else's.

This is terrible - which rights are being withheld from trans people?

IwantToRetire · 11/11/2026 02:09

LeftieRightsHoarder · 11/11/2026 01:39

What rights that the rest of us have got are being denied to trans-identifying people?

Transwomen aren’t supposed to use women’s facilities because they are men and have their own facilities. Women have separate facilities for safety and privacy.
They aren’t supposed to play in women’s sports because male puberty has given them advantages women can’t attain by working harder.

But you know all these things. You haven’t lost any rights. But you are trying very hard to remove women’s rights to privacy and safety.

Please don't let a thread about an interesting new book by and for women be derailed by hijackers, which is what happens when they provoke a reply.

Its a wind up.

If we had a thread about domestic violence and some man or men started posting about how they feel, you wouldn't think oh I must respond.

If you replied at all you would ask them to respect boundaries and not intrude.

Sad
Manyanamanyana · 11/11/2026 01:57

Super, thanks OP, have just purchased on Kindle, looking forward to reading it!

LeftieRightsHoarder · 11/11/2026 01:39

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/11/2026 10:06

You're not in any position. Trans people exist, always have, always will - and are currently being targeted for being trans.

it's their rights being removed, no one else's. Their safety and wellbeing being compromised. They who are suffering appalling abuse in schools, and greatly increased street violence.

A tiny minority existing doesn't affect you - or the author - in the slightest.

What rights that the rest of us have got are being denied to trans-identifying people?

Transwomen aren’t supposed to use women’s facilities because they are men and have their own facilities. Women have separate facilities for safety and privacy.
They aren’t supposed to play in women’s sports because male puberty has given them advantages women can’t attain by working harder.

But you know all these things. You haven’t lost any rights. But you are trying very hard to remove women’s rights to privacy and safety.

UtopiaPlanitia · 09/11/2026 23:49

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 09/11/2026 10:24

Slightly random post from TPA there.

However, since it has bumped the thread I will comment on Terf Diaries, which I purchased and read. It is an interesting and easy read which fills in some of the gaps for those of us who were not in this fight from the start. As the genre is 'diary', the author has to 'pretend' ignorance of events beyond the year in question. However she does sometimes hint at them which I found mildly irritating because a true diary couldn't do that. That's a mild quibble though.

Overall it is definitely worth purchasing alongside The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht.

Tovarich TPA is always vigilant and always on message 🫡

IwantToRetire · 09/11/2026 21:34

Also available on Audible https://www.audible.co.uk/pd/The-TERF-Diaries-Dispatches-from-the-Decade-When-the-World-Lost-Its-Mind-Audiobook/B0HLRBDHCD

The origins go back to when queer politics took over universities, having previously been a rather fringe political strand.

Within a very short period of time queer politics had got Women's Studies (still relatively new) closed down and replaced with Gender Studies. (1980s/90s). And the then transvestism was taken up by the left as part of their attack on Mary Whitehouse. They all thought the were very "avant garde" and secure in their understanding that most people would never listen to a prim old fashioned woman. This strand of queer politics was also taken up by some in the early years of Women's Liberation.

But the strategic position in Universities was the big break through. Because it didn't just remain a fringe student set of beliefs but became something that those who left college to take up jobs in the media and civil service. And from this the creep of the use of the word gender instead of sex, etc., etc.. eg the editor of the Guardian, not sure if she is still there, said everything I do is influenced by my queer politics.

And then consolidated by Stonewall adopting it as the new source of "rights" they could adopt once same sex marriage etc., became law.

Its not even clear that Stonewall had any real belief in what is now trans ideology or whether it was just a new funding stream.

So what had been some "cross dressing" and a few people who were diagnosed with an actual condition called gender dysphoria, became an every expanding number of identities that could be campaigned for.

And how the GRA was weaopnised to be used against women.

Just adding that no one should over look the role of NCCL now Liberty, who were very pro trans, anti the concept that women should be entitled to women only support services, whilst also supporting PIE - the Information Exchange.

The TERF Diaries: Dispatches from the Decade When the World Lost Its Mind

Check out this great listen on Audible.com. The TERF Diaries are the real and contemporaneous diaries of Addie Klein, an ordinary Scottish woman. Addie stepped into the gender trenches in 2015 when, like many women, she began to realise that as all aro...

https://www.audible.co.uk/pd/The-TERF-Diaries-Dispatches-from-the-Decade-When-the-World-Lost-Its-Mind-Audiobook/B0HLRBDHCD

BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 12:27

AstonCanKissMyArse · 09/11/2026 12:16

I hadn't heard about this - off to order a copy, thanks 👍

I think its interesting / frightening to see the societal shift from "I don't agree with you" to "I'm right, you're wrong" to "I'm right, you're an evil bigot". You see it in a few other issues (immigration, blasphemy laws) but principally used to silence any opposition to TWAW breaking everything for women.

We used to be able to discuss things, now its all shut down usually with insults by people who cannot answer a straightforward question about what they believe- see our resident scolder.

Is there much about this phenomenon in the book?

Hi @AstonCanKissMyArse there is a running thread through the book addressing the silencing of any women and men who spoke/speak up. Definitely worth adding to your books about the whole trans movement mobilising to really push their agenda over the past decade. For me the fact they dragged children into it is and always will be utterly shocking and that MPs and other adults backed them. It is like some people do not understand safeguarding.

OP posts:
AstonCanKissMyArse · 09/11/2026 12:16

I hadn't heard about this - off to order a copy, thanks 👍

I think its interesting / frightening to see the societal shift from "I don't agree with you" to "I'm right, you're wrong" to "I'm right, you're an evil bigot". You see it in a few other issues (immigration, blasphemy laws) but principally used to silence any opposition to TWAW breaking everything for women.

We used to be able to discuss things, now its all shut down usually with insults by people who cannot answer a straightforward question about what they believe- see our resident scolder.

Is there much about this phenomenon in the book?

BlueLegume · 09/11/2026 11:15

TrappedByThisDesk · 09/11/2026 11:10

I think the more interesting period was prior to this. The roots go back to the 1970s (there was a clip on this site, from the BBC I think? of about 4 or 5 transwomen in a circle discussing their goals), and the UK gay marriage legislation was 2013, by which time Stonewall would already have been casting around for a new role to keep the money coming in. I would love to read a detailed analysis of the roots of the trans movement prior to 2015.

By 2015 the bandwagon was already rolling.

Very good point @TrappedByThisDesk

I remember seeing that clip and there was a similar one for the US where the men cross dressers admitted it was a kink.

I also do think the success of gay marriage saw Stonewall realise they had won rights and then needed to look where any future funding would come from. Trans rights became their new battle but the reality is the cause is to ensure men get in women’s spaces/sports/prisons/crisis centres.

what is telling from the book is just how if you were not ‘on board’ you were immediately cast as a bigot.

OP posts: