Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

A boy played in a girls footballl Match

138 replies

FootballMum26 · 08/11/2026 15:43

My daughter plays girls U10 football and her team is registered in the girls league. At a recent match, there was a boy playing for the opposite side. The player’s teammates were calling him Sophie. I’m 100% sure this was a boy. Other parents commented and were not particularly happy that there was a boy on the other team.

Our league rules state it discourages clubs from registering boys except in ‘exceptional circumstances’ which the club should discuss with the league secretary before registration. I couldn’t find any examples of what that means in practice.

How would you feel about a boy playing in a girls U10 league?

I’d like to ask my daughter’s coaches about it and I’m Unsure how to approach it.

I feel strongly that my daughter should have the right to play football with girls, as she is playing in a specific girls Football league, not a mixed league.

OP posts:
ifonlytheydlisten · 08/11/2026 17:42

She’ll be a girl. Was another thread like this recently

FootballMum26 · 08/11/2026 17:40

LGSHHC · 08/11/2026 17:24

Have you seen my comment about the team sheet/card which is a requirement by the FA for grassroots leagues to stop this sort of thing happening (ie- wrong gender/age playing in a match)

was this not done? If not, why? Did you know this is a requirement by the FA as a safeguarding rule to protect your child?

Thanks for this. I wasn’t aware

ive googled and found a sample team sheet from the FA. it doesn’t state anywhere about a players sex so I don’t see how this can help? It just states registered players names and DOB

Photo below of a sample team sheet

A boy played in a girls footballl Match
OP posts:
BlueLegume · 08/11/2026 17:39

alcovecupboards · 08/11/2026 17:36

So nothing resembling anything that would be "100% sure" worthy of evidence then? In this case, I would speak to your daughter's coach quietly (to avoid embarrassment frankly) and raise your concerns.

Great suggestion @alcovecupboards

If the OP then discovers that Sophie is a biological male and is (hell bent) on taking a place off a biological female to make the team - what would your take be on that scenario where everyone has to pretend Sophie is a girl when she is in fact a boy?

Obviously if Sophie is a girl none of this is an issue.

LGSHHC · 08/11/2026 17:38

MamaNell · 08/11/2026 17:33

My son played football and girls were allowed to play in the boys teams up until U15 I believe. It’s the FA rules. They are kids let them play where they like at a standard that suits them.
they don’t share toilets or changing rooms what’s the problem?

Yes, girls can play in boys leagues (my daughter has done till under 15s too)

the issue here is that the OP assumes a boy is playing in a girls league- which isn’t allowed.

however, this is where there safeguarding rules from the FA to stop this happening.

i am wondering why the the team sheet was not checked & if this child surely was a boy, they would not have appeared on the team sheet & would have not been allowed to play.

alcovecupboards · 08/11/2026 17:36

FootballMum26 · 08/11/2026 16:57

For those asking how I know this was a boy called Sophie.

There a lots of signs that point to being a boy. He had a boys physique. He had a boys gait. He was physically a boy. He had facial features of a boy.

boys and girls are different. He was the only boy on the pitch. It was obvious.

So nothing resembling anything that would be "100% sure" worthy of evidence then? In this case, I would speak to your daughter's coach quietly (to avoid embarrassment frankly) and raise your concerns.

Helleofabore · 08/11/2026 17:36

Sex Differences in 1600-m Running Performance and Participation for Children Aged 6–12 yr

Christensen, Mandy W.; Griffiths, Christine M

Summer 2025

journals.lww.com/acsm-esm/fulltext/2025/07000/sex_differences_in_1600_m_running_performance_and.5.aspx

Abstract
Introduction
In children, females participate in sport and physical activity less than males and have lower peak oxygen intake values. How this sexual dimorphism in the aerobic capacity of children affects the aerobic performances of children in a 1600-m race and whether the reported discrepancy in sport and physical activity participation accounts for any sex differences in aerobic performance are unknown. The purpose of this study was to 1) identify sex-based differences in aerobic running performance at 1600 m for children aged 6–12 yr and 2) investigate sex-based differences in participation in children and any relationship between participation and sex differences in aerobic performance.
Methods
We compared 1600-m running velocities (in m·s−1) and participation for 3621 children in the United States in grades 1–6 (ages 6–12 yr) for the years 2007–2014 that were obtained from a publicly available website (runnercard). We correlated the female participation with the performance difference between the sexes for each year and grade. We also created a mathematical model to predict the mean velocity () needed to equalize the sex difference in performance if participation was equalized.
Results
Male children were faster (3.00 ± 0.53 m·s−1) than female children (2.77 ± 0.49 m·s−1) at every grade level, with an average difference of 7.7% (P < 0.001). Participation was lower for female children (46.2%; χ2 = 13.0, P = 0.02) and there was no correlation between female participation and the performance difference between sexes (Pearson’s r= 0.255, P = 0.96). needed to equalize the sex difference in performance if participation was equalized was 4.39 m·s−1, which was greater than the observed female mean plus two standard deviations.
Conclusions
Male children are faster than female children at running 1600 m at ages 6–12 yr. This sex difference was not a result of lower female participation and suggests that innate physiological sex differences may be responsible.

Interesting research and important when discussing inclusion of male athletes who have not experienced male puberty / androgenisation in female sports.

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ajhb.70155

When and Why Do Sex Differences in Handgrip Strength Emerge? Age-Varying Effects of Testosterone From Childhood to Older Adulthood
Jun Seob Song, Heontae Kim, Myungjin Jung
First published: 06 October 2025

ABSTRACT
Objectives : On average, males are stronger than females, with hormonal changes during puberty often cited as a contributing factor to this advantage. However, not all evidence consistently supports this explanation. The purpose of this study was to determine (1) when sex differences in handgrip strength and testosterone emerge, and (2) whether testosterone mediates the sex difference in handgrip strength and if this effect varies across age.
Methods : Time-varying effect modeling (TVEM) was used to examine age-specific trajectories of handgrip strength and testosterone, and to assess whether these trajectories differed by sex. A moderated mediation analysis was conducted to test whether the sex difference in handgrip strength was mediated by testosterone level, and whether this effect varied across age. Data were drawn from the 2011–2012 and 2013–2014 cycles (N = 11,035) of the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey.
Results : TVEM indicated that the sex difference in handgrip strength emerged at age 8, whereas the sex difference in testosterone level became evident at age 10. A moderated mediation analysis revealed that testosterone mediated the association between sex and handgrip strength, and this effect decreased with age (IMM = −0.18, 95% CI: −0.20, −0.16).
Conclusion : Sex difference in handgrip strength appears to be driven, in part, by the testosterone levels. However, this difference can be observed even before the onset of puberty, which suggests that testosterone alone does not fully explain the sex difference in muscle strength. This finding may have important implications for decisions regarding inclusivity and fairness in sports that emphasize strength.

Sex Differences in Upper- and Lower-Limb Muscle Strength in Children and Adolescents: A Meta-Analysis

James L. Nuzzo, April 2025

ABSTRACT
On average, adult men are physically stronger than adult women. The magnitude of this difference depends on the muscle tested, with larger sex differences observed in upper- than lower-limb muscles. Whether body region-specific sex differences in strength exist in children is unclear. The purpose of the current meta-analysis was to determine whether sex differences in muscle strength in children and adolescents differ between upper- and lower-limb muscles. Data were extracted from studies of participants aged ≤ 17 years who completed tests of maximal isometric or isokinetic strength of upper-limb muscles (e.g., elbow flexors and elbow extensors) or lower-limb muscles (e.g., knee extensors and ankle dorsiflexors). Participants were partitioned into three age groups: 5–10 years old, 11–13 years old, and 14–17 years old. The analysis included 299 effects from 34 studies. The total sample was 6634 (3497 boys and 3137 girls). Effect sizes of sex differences in upper- and lower-limb strength were g = 0.65 (95% confidence intervals (CI) [0.46, 0.84]) and 0.34 (95% CI [0.19, 0.50]) in 5–10-year-olds; g = 0.73 (95% CI [0.56, 0.91]) and 0.43 (95% CI [0.27, 0.59]) in 11–13-year olds; and g= 1.84 (95% CI [1.64, 2.03]) and 1.18 (95% CI [1.00, 1.37]) in 14–17-year-olds. Upper- and lower-limb strength were 17% and 8% greater in boys than girls when 5–10 years old, 18% and 10% greater when 11–13 years old, and 50% and 30% greater when 14–17 years old. Thus, boys are stronger than girls on average. This sex difference exists before puberty, increases markedly with male puberty, and is more pronounced in upper- than lower-limb muscles throughout development.
Summary
-Before, during, and after puberty, boys are stronger than girls on average.
-The sex difference in muscle strength increases markedly with male puberty, averaging ∼10% in 5–10-year-olds and then ∼40% in 14–17-year-olds.
-Throughout development, sex differences in strength are more pronounced in upper- than lower-limb muscles.
Conclusion
Muscle strength is greater in boys than girls before, during, and after puberty, though the presence of this sex difference is more certain after puberty. At all stages of development, the difference is greater in upper- than lower-limb muscles. Between 5 and 13 years old, boys have, on average, 17%–18% greater upper-limb strength than girls and 8%–10% greater lower-limb strength. Male puberty causes the sex difference in muscle strength to increase dramatically, such that, between the ages of 14–17 years, boys have, on average, 50% greater upper-limb strength than girls and 30% greater lower-limb strength. Sex differences in body height, body mass, and body composition are the likely causes of greater muscle strength in boys than girls throughout development.

Tsukimi · 08/11/2026 17:36

I just don't think you can be sure it was a boy given they're pre-pubescent.

MamaNell · 08/11/2026 17:33

My son played football and girls were allowed to play in the boys teams up until U15 I believe. It’s the FA rules. They are kids let them play where they like at a standard that suits them.
they don’t share toilets or changing rooms what’s the problem?

Helleofabore · 08/11/2026 17:31

Sex-based differences in track running distances of 100, 200, 400, 800, and 1500m in the 8 and under and 9–10-year-old age groups
Gregory A Brown, Brandon S Shaw, Ina Shaw
5th February 2024

^https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ejsc.12075^

"In conclusion, although some have stated that sex-based differences in athletic performance do not arise until puberty, the present data indicate that in the 8 and under and 9–10-year-old age groups males run faster than females in distances of 100, 200, 400, 800, and 1500m. While some females in these age groups are faster than some males, the average male finalists are faster than the average female finalists, and the fastest males are faster than the fastest females. As running is a key component of many sports, these sex-based differences between prepubertal males and females should be considered when sport governing bodies and policy makers consider the issue of sex-based sporting categories"

Sex Differences in Track and Field Elite Youth

Mira A. Atkinson, Jessica J.James, Meagan E.Quinn, Jonathon W. Senefeld andSandra K. Hunter

https://sportrxiv.org/index.php/server/preprint/view/324/version/419

RESULTS: Males ran faster than females at every age in the 100, 200, 400 and 800 m (P<0.001). When combining all running events, the sex difference (%) was 4.0 ± 1.7% between 7-12 years and increased to 6.3 ± 1.1% at 13 years, and 12.6 ± 1.8% at 18 years (P<0.001). Similarly, males jumped higher and further than females at every age (P<0.001). For long jump, the sex difference was 6.8 ± 2.8% between 7-12 years, increasing to 8.5 ± 1.7% at 13 years, and 22.7 ± 1.4% at 18 years (P<0.001). For high jump, the sex difference was 5.3 ± 5.2% between 7-12 years, increasing to 10.3 ± 2.4% at 14 years, and 18.4 ± 2.04% at 18 years (P<0.001).

CONCLUSION:Prior to puberty in elite youth track and field athletes, there is a small but consistent sex difference, such that males run faster and jump higher and further than females. The sex difference in performance was event dependent and increased significantly from ~12 years for running and 13-14 years in jumping events.

Another study from Gregory Brown and team regarding children. They have now covered running, swimming and now other track events.

Sex-based differences in shot put, javelin throw, and long jump in 8-and-under and 9–10-year-old athletes

Gregory A Brown, Brandon S Shaw & Ina Shaw
Published 14 December 2024

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ejsc.12241

Highlights
Males in the 8-and-under age group outperformed females of the same ages by 19.3% in shot put, 32.6% in javelin throw, and 4.7% in long jump.
Males in the 9–10-year-old age group outperformed females of the same ages by 6.5% in shot put, 23.5% in javelin throw, and 3.9% in long jump.
The average differences between the first through fourth place finishers within males and within females were smaller than the sex-based differences between males and females in all but 9–10-year-old shot put.

CONCLUSION
In conclusion, although some have stated that the prepubertal sex-based differences in athletic performance are immaterial or absent, the present data indicate that in the 8-and-under group and 9–10-year-old age group, males achieved greater distances in shot put, javelin throw, and long jump. Although some females in these age groups threw or jumped farther than some males, the average distances for shot put, javelin throw, and long jump for males were farther than for females; the best performing males threw and jumped farther than the best performing females and the average differences between the sexes were larger than within sex differences for the top 4 finalists (i.e., those in closest competition for a medal) for all events and ages except shot put in the 9–10-year old age group. As throwing and jumping are key components of many sports, these sex-based differences in shot put, javelin throw, and long jump between males and females ages 10-and-under should be considered when sport governing bodies and policy makers consider the issue of sex-segregated sporting categories.

Sex Differences in Grip Strength From Birth to Age 16: A Meta-Analysis
James L Nuzzo

15 February 2025

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ejsc.12268

Conclusion
Boys have greater grip strength than girls from birth onward. Prior to age 11, the sex difference in grip strength is small-to-moderate in size, with female grip strength about 90% of male grip strength. At age 11, the sex difference in grip strength decreases because girls reach puberty earlier than boys. Nevertheless, boys still retain a strength advantage at age 11. After male puberty, the size of the sex difference in grip strength increases markedly. At age 16, female grip strength is 65% of male grip strength. With a few exceptions, the observed effect sizes have been largely consistent across time and place. Together, with other findings from the biological and medical literature, the current results suggest a largely biological origin of the sex difference in grip strength in children and adolescents.

Sex Differences in Track and Field Elite Youth | SportRxiv

https://sportrxiv.org/index.php/server/preprint/view/324/version/419

caringcarer · 08/11/2026 17:31

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:44

So? For this ONE match they were obviously very short of players so he stepped in

Why was he being called Sophie then? Boys are physically stronger than girls and every girl in the girls league has the right to play against other girls. I'd complain OP. Actually I'd have complained on the day.

Helleofabore · 08/11/2026 17:27

Here are just a few of the studies that have shown that even from 6 years old that boys have advantages that girls do not have. The issue is that at speed and tackling, this can cause injury to the girls, just like it does when male people play football against female people in a female single sex football match.

Danish study on VO2 max and LBM in children from age 6
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1725036/pdf/v039p00725.pdf

Maximum oxygen uptake and objectively measured physical activity in Danish children 6-7 years of age: the Copenhagen school child intervention study

Eigberg, Hasselstrom, Gronfeldt, Friberg, Svensson, Anderson
October 2005

Objectives: To provide normative data on maximum oxygen uptake (Vo(2)max) and physical activity in children 6-7 years of age and analyse the association between these variables.

Methods: Vo(2)max was measured in 366 boys (mean (SD) 6.8 (0.4) years of age) and 332 girls (6.7 (0.4) years of age) from preschool classes in two suburban communities in Copenhagen, during a progressive treadmill exercise. Habitual physical activity was measured with accelerometers.
Results: Boys had higher Vo(2)max both in absolute values (1.19 (0.18) v 1.06 (0.16) litres/min (+11%), p<0.001) and relative to body weight (48.5 (6.0) v 44.8 (5.6) ml/kg/min (+8%); p<0.001) than girls. The difference in Vo(2)max between boys and girls decreased to +2% when expressed relative to lean body mass (LBM). Absolute Vo(2)max was related to LBM, body mass, and stature (all p<0.001). Boys were more physically active than girls (mean counts +9.4%, p<0.001), and even when boys and girls with the same Vo(2)max were compared, boys were more active. The difference in physical activity between the sexes was higher when sustained activity of higher intensity was compared.

Conclusions: Vo(2)max is higher in boys than girls (+11%), even when related to body mass (+8%) and LBM (+2%). Most of the difference in Vo(2)max relative to body mass was explained by the larger percentage body fat in girls. When boys and girls with the same Vo(2)max were compared, boys engaged in more minutes of exercise of at least moderate intensity.
_
Australian children
<a class="break-all" href="https://web.archive.org/web/20251230112235/citeseerx.ist.psu.edu//document?repid=rep1&type=pdf&doi=021cccdaed57d120bb05bac71c05ee82b0c5b315" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/document?repid=rep1&type=pdf&doi=021cccdaed57d120bb05bac71c05ee82b0c5b315

Greek ( for those who have access)
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17461391.2015.1088577?needAccess=true

This link has many links and is particularly good for children’s advantages.
https://www.ultraphysical.us/p/beyond-t-sex-based-differences-in

Gregory Brown, Professor Exercise Science (primarily Exercise Physiology) at the University of Nebraska at Kearney.

Beyond T: Sex-Based Differences in Athletic Performance

For anyone who has seen the 4X400-meter running mixed relay final from the World Athletic Championships in September 2019 (World Athletics) the differences in athletic performance between men and women are blatantly obvious. A woman, Justyna Święty-Ers...

https://www.ultraphysical.us/p/beyond-t-sex-based-differences-in

LGSHHC · 08/11/2026 17:24

FootballMum26 · 08/11/2026 16:57

For those asking how I know this was a boy called Sophie.

There a lots of signs that point to being a boy. He had a boys physique. He had a boys gait. He was physically a boy. He had facial features of a boy.

boys and girls are different. He was the only boy on the pitch. It was obvious.

Have you seen my comment about the team sheet/card which is a requirement by the FA for grassroots leagues to stop this sort of thing happening (ie- wrong gender/age playing in a match)

was this not done? If not, why? Did you know this is a requirement by the FA as a safeguarding rule to protect your child?

Helleofabore · 08/11/2026 17:24

OP, I would raise it as a general question to the coaches and then ask what the process is for the club if there is a suspicion about a player. If you have a concern, raise it.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 08/11/2026 17:14

MoistVonL · 08/11/2026 15:48

If it's a team for girls, he shouldn't be on it. Women and girls are allowed to have their own things away from men and boys.

However, I find it hard to get overly bothered about mixed sex teams pre-puberty. I don't think there's much difference in ability or strength at that point, so it's not taking a place away from a girl or endangering other players. (I'm happy to be corrected if that's not the case.)

1 But it's NOT a mixed sex team, it's a GIRLS' team.

2 OP has said there were girls benched from the team, so he's taking a playing space from one of those girls.

3 Boys might not be much stronger than girls pre puberty (I don't know) but they are definitely generally socialised to be a lot rougher and more inclined to hit and push.

4 Did anyone ask those girls if they minded? I bet they didn't.

FootballMum26 · 08/11/2026 17:09

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 17:04

Someone assumed my daughter was a boy when she was 12. Boys and girls have the same physique when they are 9. I have seen plenty of women walk with a gait like a man. They do not have distinctive facial features at 9.

I hear your experience about your child.

This scenario is different. This was a boy on the pitch. Some boys are more developed than others at this age.

I hope you can appreciate that not all children develop at the same time or pace.

OP posts:
Tears0fTheMushroom · 08/11/2026 17:06

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:44

So? For this ONE match they were obviously very short of players so he stepped in

And changed his name to Sophie because... ?

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 17:04

FootballMum26 · 08/11/2026 16:57

For those asking how I know this was a boy called Sophie.

There a lots of signs that point to being a boy. He had a boys physique. He had a boys gait. He was physically a boy. He had facial features of a boy.

boys and girls are different. He was the only boy on the pitch. It was obvious.

Someone assumed my daughter was a boy when she was 12. Boys and girls have the same physique when they are 9. I have seen plenty of women walk with a gait like a man. They do not have distinctive facial features at 9.

FootballMum26 · 08/11/2026 16:57

For those asking how I know this was a boy called Sophie.

There a lots of signs that point to being a boy. He had a boys physique. He had a boys gait. He was physically a boy. He had facial features of a boy.

boys and girls are different. He was the only boy on the pitch. It was obvious.

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 08/11/2026 16:56

I would ask the coach how you complain to the league about one team regularly fielding a boy. Then follow that advice.

If they have an exceptional circumstances exception to the no boys rules they may have granted a waiver in which case I'd make a complaint about that, but my guess is the team have just registered him as a girl. If the girls share any kind of changing room I'd be making an even bigger stink.

tokennamechange · 08/11/2026 16:56

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:44

So? For this ONE match they were obviously very short of players so he stepped in

why do people say 'obviously' about something that they didn't actually witness themselves, know absolutely nothing about other than what they've heard second hand and have absolutely no evidence for?🙄

BananaPeels · 08/11/2026 16:55

Rabbitmother1 · 08/11/2026 16:48

How would I feel about a male pre-pubescent’s child playing football with my female pre-pubescent child? Couldn’t care less

At 10, my son could easily knock me over. I don’t think your realise that by that age, boys are exceedingly strong. They aren’t toddlers. My brother was 5ft 3 at age 10. That’s almost the height of an average women.

TeensNoMore · 08/11/2026 16:54

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 16:50

I'm amazed at PPs have took the OPs word for it that someone called Sophie who is under the age of 10 and playing in a girls football team is a boy. Where is your common sense?

Unfortunately the way things have been in recent years have created a situation of mistrust. Everyone loses out due to the actions of parents of boys & schools conspiring to let boys identify as girls.

The OP or the coach of the OP's team need to raise a query so everyone knows whether this was an all female team or not.

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 08/11/2026 16:53

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 16:50

I'm amazed at PPs have took the OPs word for it that someone called Sophie who is under the age of 10 and playing in a girls football team is a boy. Where is your common sense?

Are you saying you think the OP's situation is not real. In which case have you reported it?
My advice still stands: anyone with concerns like this approaches her child's coaching team.

BananaPeels · 08/11/2026 16:53

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 16:44

Sophie is a girls name. It's really not that easy to differentiate sex on a clothed 10 year old. Making the wrong assumption about it could be very damaging to a childs self-esteem and confidence. Why do you think it was a boy?

A toddler not easy, at 5 it’s easier, by 10 you absolutely can tell in most cases. But yes, absolutely there will be some outliers at age groups here it is ambiguous. Very very few though. It isn’t just how a child looks by face, even at 10 their bodies re different and you could tell by the way they stand and run. Clearly enough people have suspicions that they should raise it. As someone else has said this can be done by their FA card where the details are checked. The parents of the child should not be committing fraud by registering the wrong sex. That would be wrong on so many levels.

SirChenjins · 08/11/2026 16:53

I would raise it as a request for clarification on the rules, and how it would be dealt with if a boy was playing.

Girls have rights - and it's up to the adults surrounding them to ensure those rights are upheld. Not, 'oh it's just one match, girls', or 'it doesn't matter at this age, if s boy wants something just let him have it', or anything else of that ilk. Girls have been expected to give up their rights and step aside for boys for too long, and enough is enough.