Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

A boy played in a girls footballl Match

138 replies

FootballMum26 · 08/11/2026 15:43

My daughter plays girls U10 football and her team is registered in the girls league. At a recent match, there was a boy playing for the opposite side. The player’s teammates were calling him Sophie. I’m 100% sure this was a boy. Other parents commented and were not particularly happy that there was a boy on the other team.

Our league rules state it discourages clubs from registering boys except in ‘exceptional circumstances’ which the club should discuss with the league secretary before registration. I couldn’t find any examples of what that means in practice.

How would you feel about a boy playing in a girls U10 league?

I’d like to ask my daughter’s coaches about it and I’m Unsure how to approach it.

I feel strongly that my daughter should have the right to play football with girls, as she is playing in a specific girls Football league, not a mixed league.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tsukimi · 11/11/2026 09:35

Comtesse · 11/11/2026 09:34

It would be entirely reasonable to raise this with the team coach and ask them to flag it with the other team. No need to pick on Sophie or anyone else, but I don’t think OP was proposing to do anything of the sort.

I assume OP isn't really planning to do anything or she'd have done it already.

Comtesse · 11/11/2026 09:34

It would be entirely reasonable to raise this with the team coach and ask them to flag it with the other team. No need to pick on Sophie or anyone else, but I don’t think OP was proposing to do anything of the sort.

SchoolOfCool · 10/11/2026 18:06

In a world where female football players had exactly the same opportunities, funding, respect etc as male footballers perhaps I'd not get too bothered by a pre pubescent boy playing on the girls' team.

Perhaps that world would also have to be one in which girls felt just as comfortable to participate in secondary school PE as boys; where those that needed them could access proper sports bras for far less than the £40 - £60 I have to pay; where girls felt just as entitled to use public outdoor spaces for sport as boys do; where girls are safe to run after dark.

To be clear, I think mixed sex teams absolutely have their place. But a boy in the girls team, in this world we live in? Unfair. Like so much that girls have to put up with.

Grammarnut · 10/11/2026 17:50

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:46

Guaranteed if the Op had seen him in multiple matches - it would have been mentioned don’t you think?

No, because people are afraid to speak up. A boy called 'Sophie' should not be on a girls' team any time, anyway. His parents should be ashamed.

Manteiga · 09/11/2026 21:45

ItsOnlyMee1 · 09/11/2026 20:52

So he should be allowed to train with that girls team if they are in agreement. But should be asking the opposition players and coaches for permission to play matches, their decisions should be final.

It'd be nice of the girls to have him - might do them some good if they're lacking confidence to play in a mixed team - but it always seems to fall to girls to be nice, doesn't it? Presumably no coaches, parents at a boys or mixed team prepared to lend a hand.

alcovecupboards · 09/11/2026 21:24

ItsOnlyMee1 · 09/11/2026 20:52

So he should be allowed to train with that girls team if they are in agreement. But should be asking the opposition players and coaches for permission to play matches, their decisions should be final.

Didn't they give permission by joining a club in a league that allows this?

ItsOnlyMee1 · 09/11/2026 20:52

MyDpsanarse · 09/11/2026 14:26

@Sleepster if that fell within the rule then fine, what I'm saying is there should be clear guidelines under which an exception can be made. It's a bit like when a child is invited to a party, some people would be fine about you bringing along a sibling, some only want the DC who've been invited, it's up to the host, with a team everyone has to agree to the same rules

So he should be allowed to train with that girls team if they are in agreement. But should be asking the opposition players and coaches for permission to play matches, their decisions should be final.

ehb102 · 09/11/2026 18:51

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:44

So? For this ONE match they were obviously very short of players so he stepped in

That is never a good enough reason for an FA league game.

Manteiga · 09/11/2026 18:08

Helleofabore · 08/11/2026 17:31

Sex-based differences in track running distances of 100, 200, 400, 800, and 1500m in the 8 and under and 9–10-year-old age groups
Gregory A Brown, Brandon S Shaw, Ina Shaw
5th February 2024

^https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ejsc.12075^

"In conclusion, although some have stated that sex-based differences in athletic performance do not arise until puberty, the present data indicate that in the 8 and under and 9–10-year-old age groups males run faster than females in distances of 100, 200, 400, 800, and 1500m. While some females in these age groups are faster than some males, the average male finalists are faster than the average female finalists, and the fastest males are faster than the fastest females. As running is a key component of many sports, these sex-based differences between prepubertal males and females should be considered when sport governing bodies and policy makers consider the issue of sex-based sporting categories"

Sex Differences in Track and Field Elite Youth

Mira A. Atkinson, Jessica J.James, Meagan E.Quinn, Jonathon W. Senefeld andSandra K. Hunter

https://sportrxiv.org/index.php/server/preprint/view/324/version/419

RESULTS: Males ran faster than females at every age in the 100, 200, 400 and 800 m (P<0.001). When combining all running events, the sex difference (%) was 4.0 ± 1.7% between 7-12 years and increased to 6.3 ± 1.1% at 13 years, and 12.6 ± 1.8% at 18 years (P<0.001). Similarly, males jumped higher and further than females at every age (P<0.001). For long jump, the sex difference was 6.8 ± 2.8% between 7-12 years, increasing to 8.5 ± 1.7% at 13 years, and 22.7 ± 1.4% at 18 years (P<0.001). For high jump, the sex difference was 5.3 ± 5.2% between 7-12 years, increasing to 10.3 ± 2.4% at 14 years, and 18.4 ± 2.04% at 18 years (P<0.001).

CONCLUSION:Prior to puberty in elite youth track and field athletes, there is a small but consistent sex difference, such that males run faster and jump higher and further than females. The sex difference in performance was event dependent and increased significantly from ~12 years for running and 13-14 years in jumping events.

Another study from Gregory Brown and team regarding children. They have now covered running, swimming and now other track events.

Sex-based differences in shot put, javelin throw, and long jump in 8-and-under and 9–10-year-old athletes

Gregory A Brown, Brandon S Shaw & Ina Shaw
Published 14 December 2024

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ejsc.12241

Highlights
Males in the 8-and-under age group outperformed females of the same ages by 19.3% in shot put, 32.6% in javelin throw, and 4.7% in long jump.
Males in the 9–10-year-old age group outperformed females of the same ages by 6.5% in shot put, 23.5% in javelin throw, and 3.9% in long jump.
The average differences between the first through fourth place finishers within males and within females were smaller than the sex-based differences between males and females in all but 9–10-year-old shot put.

CONCLUSION
In conclusion, although some have stated that the prepubertal sex-based differences in athletic performance are immaterial or absent, the present data indicate that in the 8-and-under group and 9–10-year-old age group, males achieved greater distances in shot put, javelin throw, and long jump. Although some females in these age groups threw or jumped farther than some males, the average distances for shot put, javelin throw, and long jump for males were farther than for females; the best performing males threw and jumped farther than the best performing females and the average differences between the sexes were larger than within sex differences for the top 4 finalists (i.e., those in closest competition for a medal) for all events and ages except shot put in the 9–10-year old age group. As throwing and jumping are key components of many sports, these sex-based differences in shot put, javelin throw, and long jump between males and females ages 10-and-under should be considered when sport governing bodies and policy makers consider the issue of sex-segregated sporting categories.

Sex Differences in Grip Strength From Birth to Age 16: A Meta-Analysis
James L Nuzzo

15 February 2025

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ejsc.12268

Conclusion
Boys have greater grip strength than girls from birth onward. Prior to age 11, the sex difference in grip strength is small-to-moderate in size, with female grip strength about 90% of male grip strength. At age 11, the sex difference in grip strength decreases because girls reach puberty earlier than boys. Nevertheless, boys still retain a strength advantage at age 11. After male puberty, the size of the sex difference in grip strength increases markedly. At age 16, female grip strength is 65% of male grip strength. With a few exceptions, the observed effect sizes have been largely consistent across time and place. Together, with other findings from the biological and medical literature, the current results suggest a largely biological origin of the sex difference in grip strength in children and adolescents.

I think the first two papers are especially interesting as they're comparing athletic girls with athletic boys - I had wondered how much of the effects reported in the others might be due to girls' playing less sport or exercising less, on average. Thanks

Manteiga · 09/11/2026 16:13

It does apply: her club has both a mixed and a girls' U10 team, and she plays for both. There didn't used to be a girls' U10, but they started one because they found that while girls who'd started tag rugby at a younger age were happy to continue with their mixed team, girls who were interested in joining later, once tackling, rucks, scrums and the like were part of the game, were put off by the idea of have to play with boys.

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 09/11/2026 15:56

nutmeg7 · 09/11/2026 07:59

Stop it with the “shame” and finger pointing, it’s medieval.

If they are concerned parents, there are definitely ways to make a polite and behind the scenes enquiry that don’t involve asking “Sophie” publicly or causing the child public distress at the next match.

They have every right to find out by asking the coach of the opposite teams to confirm the birth sex of all the players is female. It is supposed to be a female team and it is not fair to those girls to have a male playing on the team.

I can finger point with shame should I choose to do so based on my opinion of a very judgemental OP without any evidence in this century no less.

They don't have a right to ask the birth sex of the children, but the team needs to adhere to the rules of the league. If there is no rule break then there isn't any issue.

And at 8/9 years old, there isn't proof and it's shameful that a parent wants to point a finger themselves at a kid they think is bigger/faster/better/stronger because they don't like it.

I stand by what I said.

Liforme · 09/11/2026 15:52

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn.

Manteiga · 09/11/2026 15:51

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn.

That's right.

Her club does have a girls' U10 team (as well as a mixed one), and she already plays for them too. I expect enough will carry on to keep the girls' U12s going.

Smaller clubs can face the problem of not having enough girls for U12; one thing they sometimes do is join up with another club nearby to field a joint team.

Liforme · 09/11/2026 15:28

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn.

Manteiga · 09/11/2026 15:17

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn.

It's not a boy's team, it's a mixed team (though predominantly boys). She can still play with them or with the girls' U12s (school years 6 & 7). Or both - in fact she also plays with the girls' U10s now! But the year after next she can only play with the girls' U12s.

Liforme · 09/11/2026 15:04

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn.

Manteiga · 09/11/2026 14:41

WinterIsComing5 · 08/11/2026 21:10

If a girl chooses to play in a boys team, she has chosen to accept the risk and the disparity in physical advantages, and is pushing herself to keep up with boys who have an approximately 20% physical advantage over her. none of the boys playing are subjected to any unfairness or danger

This simply isn't true. As the parent of an under 10's rugby player, having a girl on the opposing team absolutely causes unfairness. Because most of the boys tackle far lighter. Avoid her. Give more space. No one wants to be the one that made the girl cry. And it gives the other team, and the female player, an unfair advantage.

Boys shouldn't be allowed to join girls' teams, absolutely. But neither should girls be allowed to join teams mainly of boys. They should be separated past age 7 or 8 imo.

I haven't noticed the boys' going easy on the girls in my daughter's matches (Rugby Union U10s). Perhaps that's because round our way there's often a couple of girls or so in a mixed team and they boys have got used to it. Still, many of the smaller clubs wouldn't have the numbers for a separate girls' team, even combining two age grades.

MyDpsanarse · 09/11/2026 14:26

@Sleepster if that fell within the rule then fine, what I'm saying is there should be clear guidelines under which an exception can be made. It's a bit like when a child is invited to a party, some people would be fine about you bringing along a sibling, some only want the DC who've been invited, it's up to the host, with a team everyone has to agree to the same rules

Sleepster · 09/11/2026 08:13

MyDpsanarse · 09/11/2026 08:10

So l'd want to know what the exceptional circumstances covered Op because a rule that's not kept to is no use to anyone. If Sophie is a boy then letting him play isn't a kindness, not when getting older will see him unwelcome in the girl's team

Example

Single parent in serious ill health. Doesn’t drive. Rural. Neighbour takes her daughter and the single parent’s daughter to football training every weekend. The single parent has a son too, twin of her daughter. They ask club if he can attend because only way he can play.

happened in my daughters club

MyDpsanarse · 09/11/2026 08:10

So l'd want to know what the exceptional circumstances covered Op because a rule that's not kept to is no use to anyone. If Sophie is a boy then letting him play isn't a kindness, not when getting older will see him unwelcome in the girl's team

nutmeg7 · 09/11/2026 07:59

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 09/11/2026 07:48

So you don’t know Sophie was a boy definitively. You are guessing based on your assumptions. Shame on you.

Stop it with the “shame” and finger pointing, it’s medieval.

If they are concerned parents, there are definitely ways to make a polite and behind the scenes enquiry that don’t involve asking “Sophie” publicly or causing the child public distress at the next match.

They have every right to find out by asking the coach of the opposite teams to confirm the birth sex of all the players is female. It is supposed to be a female team and it is not fair to those girls to have a male playing on the team.

BananaPeels · 09/11/2026 07:54

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 09/11/2026 07:48

So you don’t know Sophie was a boy definitively. You are guessing based on your assumptions. Shame on you.

How does anyone know definitively anyone else’s sex? We can go off characteristics which in most cases give us a person’s sex 99.9% of the time. In this case the OP is seeing a mismatch which is reasonably making them query if a boy is trying to stealthily play in a girls league. I have queried ages before myself in a similar. Don’t see any issue with this

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 09/11/2026 07:48

FootballMum26 · 08/11/2026 16:57

For those asking how I know this was a boy called Sophie.

There a lots of signs that point to being a boy. He had a boys physique. He had a boys gait. He was physically a boy. He had facial features of a boy.

boys and girls are different. He was the only boy on the pitch. It was obvious.

So you don’t know Sophie was a boy definitively. You are guessing based on your assumptions. Shame on you.

Sleepster · 09/11/2026 06:35

Arguing about it on Mumsnet isn’t going to achieve anything @FootballMum26 . You clearly think that “Sophie” is indisputably a boy and you and other parents are not happy about it. However - nothing seems to have been said and so Sophie continues to play in the matches and you and the other parents continue to look on raging. Why don’t you say something if your exercised about it?

BridasShieldWall · 08/11/2026 22:11

arethereanyleftatall · 08/11/2026 21:01

Rather obviously, that is a completely different situation and again, blindingly obviously, absolutely fine.

im happy to explain it to you if you don’t understand why it’s fine. Boys are physiologically stronger than girls. If a girl chooses to play in a boys team, she has chosen to accept the risk and the disparity in physical advantages, and is pushing herself to keep up with boys who have an approximately 20% physical advantage over her. none of the boys playing are subjected to any unfairness or danger.

if a boy plays on a girls team, every girl on the opposition are subjected to unfairness and danger which they haven’t consented to. A girl on the bench in the team he’s on, is sat there not playing because a less talented boy has taken her place.

I agree with you on the impact on girls if a boy plays on a team. I would also add that it impacts girls playing with the boy on the same team. Their skills and development will be impacted as the plays, especially at key points will tend to be through the stronger, male player rather than through the girls.

Swipe left for the next trending thread