Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Woman with alopecia accused of being male while using female toilet at Tesco

1000 replies

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:24

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/gateshead-woman-alopecia-accused-being-34873020

"The 37-year-old, who has had the hair loss condition since she was a child, said she was left shocked when a cleaner at the Trinity Square shop asked her "Are you aware you're in the female toilet?" She said she became distressed and burst into tears."

But I thought people "could always tell"?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:31

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 12/11/2026 13:29

And how would you prevent all the fetishistic transvestites from using the women's facilities? At the mo, people can call them out. If they can counter that with 'no worries, I'm trans' how does that work for safeguarding?

Edited

I don't share your prejudice against trans people and see no evidence that women's services are being infiltrated by sexual predators/ perverts claiming trans identity. Quite simply, it's a non issue.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 12/11/2026 13:29

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:25

Again, what I am arguing for, is simply the system we have had our whole lives.

I understand that definitionally a service for women+trans women would be definitionally characterised as "mixed sex" for the purposes of interpreting equalities legislation (as per the SC clarification of these terms as they appear in the act)

however, in practice it would be a service for women + the very occasional trans woman depending on gender+stage of social transition.

And no policing required.

And how would you prevent all the fetishistic transvestites from using the women's facilities? At the mo, people can call them out. If they can counter that with 'no worries, I'm trans' how does that work for safeguarding?

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:28

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 12/11/2026 13:22

Well that makes a change from telling us we are wrong, I suppose.
Why is it wrong?

For many reasons that have been extensively covered:

  1. I think it goes well beyond what the SC judgement FWS actually said (as also backed up by the only test in court so far - the high court judgement regarding GLP legal challenge of the code), and contrary to the purposes of the EA and also the GRA.

  2. I think it is deeply discriminatory against trans people - compromises their privacy and dignity.

  3. It will lead in practice in everyday contexts to the policing of facilities by gender presentation, which will have a disproportionate impact on gender non-conforming people, regardless of whether they are trans (as per the OP).

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:25

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 12/11/2026 13:20

The trouble with 'single gender' is it would be, effectively, mixed sex. You are campaigning for mixed sex.

Again, what I am arguing for, is simply the system we have had our whole lives.

I understand that definitionally a service for women+trans women would be definitionally characterised as "mixed sex" for the purposes of interpreting equalities legislation (as per the SC clarification of these terms as they appear in the act)

however, in practice it would be a service for women + the very occasional trans woman depending on gender+stage of social transition.

And no policing required.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 12/11/2026 13:22

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:19

That is the position that the code has specifically taken, agreed.
I think it is profoundly wrong.

Edited

Well that makes a change from telling us we are wrong, I suppose.
Why is it wrong?

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 12/11/2026 13:20

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:19

That is the position that the code has specifically taken, agreed.
I think it is profoundly wrong.

Edited

The trouble with 'single gender' is it would be, effectively, mixed sex. You are campaigning for mixed sex.

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:19

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 12/11/2026 13:17

And from the impact assessment:
We recognised that these updates may impact negatively on trans people where it results in service providers needing to restrict trans people from accessing separate and single-sex services which align with their presenting gender in order for those services to enjoy the relevant exemptions. We have highlighted how this impact should be considered when deciding whether services should be provided on separate or single-sex basis and encouraged alternative provision to ensure suitable alternative services, such as mixed-sex services, are provided where possible.

So it is single sex + an alternative (where possible) or mixed sex. There isn't a realistic option of single gender.

That is the position that the code has specifically taken, agreed.
I think it is profoundly wrong.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 12/11/2026 13:17

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:10

No.

The sentence reads: ‘a trans woman will be excluded from the women-only service because her sex is male. Trans people are likely to be disadvantaged by this.’

‘This’ is exclusion from the women’s service. That is the disadvantage the Code says providers must weigh.

And from the impact assessment:
We recognised that these updates may impact negatively on trans people where it results in service providers needing to restrict trans people from accessing separate and single-sex services which align with their presenting gender in order for those services to enjoy the relevant exemptions. We have highlighted how this impact should be considered when deciding whether services should be provided on separate or single-sex basis and encouraged alternative provision to ensure suitable alternative services, such as mixed-sex services, are provided where possible.

So it is single sex + an alternative (where possible) or mixed sex. There isn't a realistic option of single gender.

MarieDeGournay · 12/11/2026 13:15

I think concepts like 'pragmatism' 'overview' 'macro level' 'established codes' 'social convention' are wasted on TRAs and their allies, their focus seems to be on what individual wants and demands.

So as long as I am 'comfortable', it doesn't matter if nobody else is.
As long as I am validated, it doesn't matter what the law says.
As long as I can get away with transgressing, I will.
As long as I get to define what a woman is, I am a woman not a man..
As long as I say so, I can use any single sex facility I choose.

We're obviously talking at cross purposes with some posters when we speak on a pro-social, macro perspective rather than a personal, individualistic one.

Keeptoiletssafe · 12/11/2026 13:11

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:01

The Code you’ve been quoting says trans people ‘are likely to be disadvantaged’ by exclusion from single-sex services, and requires providers to weigh that disadvantage against the aim. So ‘there’s nothing to balance’ isn’t objectively true, nor is it the law’s position - it's your opinion and actually the law disagrees.

In terms of absolute health and safety we are all disadvantaged when toilet facilities are mixed sex. That is absolutely true. That is why we have single sex facilities as the main provision.

Healthy men (I gather from your own posts that’s what you are) are least affected. Which is perhaps why you can’t grasp the importance.

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:10

MyAmpleSheep · 12/11/2026 13:07

Again, I think you misunderstand.

trans people ‘are likely to be disadvantaged’ by exclusion from single-sex services

Yes. It says trans people are likely to be disadvantaged by exclusion from single-sex services. It doesn't say trans people are likely to be disadvantaged by exclusion from the single-sex service for the other sex.

Trans people have the right to single-sex services just like everyone else, and they should have access to single sex services. Which we all agree they do, except when it's proportionate to exclude them. The single sex service they have access to is the one that matches their sex.

Edited

No.

The sentence reads: ‘a trans woman will be excluded from the women-only service because her sex is male. Trans people are likely to be disadvantaged by this.’

‘This’ is exclusion from the women’s service. That is the disadvantage the Code says providers must weigh.

MyAmpleSheep · 12/11/2026 13:07

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:01

The Code you’ve been quoting says trans people ‘are likely to be disadvantaged’ by exclusion from single-sex services, and requires providers to weigh that disadvantage against the aim. So ‘there’s nothing to balance’ isn’t objectively true, nor is it the law’s position - it's your opinion and actually the law disagrees.

Again, I think you misunderstand.

trans people ‘are likely to be disadvantaged’ by exclusion from single-sex services

Yes. It says trans people are likely to be disadvantaged by exclusion from single-sex services. It doesn't say trans people are likely to be disadvantaged by exclusion from the single-sex service for the other sex.

Trans people have the right to single-sex services just like everyone else, and they should have access to single sex services. Which we all agree they do, except when it's proportionate to exclude them. The single sex service they have access to is the one that matches their sex.

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 13:01

MyAmpleSheep · 12/11/2026 12:59

I think there's a misunderstanding.

A disadvantage to an "excluded" group (which is men in this case) is not strengthened when those people (or a subset of those people) object more and more strongly.

The disadvantage to women is not "because women object". It's the other way around: the objection is raised because of the disadvantage.

There is no actual disadvantage caused to trans identifying men not being able to use women's toilets. Any more than I am disadvantaged by not being able to steal your money and spend it on myself. There's simply nothing to balance. There is objection against not being allowed to do this - but objection is not disadvantage.

Women's objections are reasonable because of the disadvantage. Men's objections are not reasonable because there is no disadvantage. Either way the law requires the disadvantage to be balanced, not the objections.

Edited

The Code you’ve been quoting says trans people ‘are likely to be disadvantaged’ by exclusion from single-sex services, and requires providers to weigh that disadvantage against the aim. So ‘there’s nothing to balance’ isn’t objectively true, nor is it the law’s position - it's your opinion and actually the law disagrees.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 12/11/2026 12:59

Heggettypeg · 12/11/2026 12:54

The default starting point of equality legislation is that everything should be for everybody.

However, in the case of the protected characteristic of sex, it is recognised that there will be some situations where separate single sex provisions are justified.

But if the conclusion is that single sex provision is not proportionate in a particular case, then the single sex exception is disallowed and the facility must be open to all, i.e. mixed sex. Not to "women plus a select band of men who identify as women on the grounds of gender, but no other men".

Well, we will see this play out in the Hampstead Ponds case.
Most people, though, just view this as adult men trying to access facilities in which women and girls are vulnerable. Whatever the motivations of these men, it is not a good look with Jo and Joe public.

MyAmpleSheep · 12/11/2026 12:59

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 12:38

It’s reasonable for women to object to toileting next to men, and the law agrees.

yes: the law treats that objection as a legitimate ground for separate provision.

Thats about as far as the story needs to go. Whether or not men agree if that’s reasonable.

No. The same provision requires the provider to show the arrangement is proportionate — which, as the Code spells out, means weighing the disadvantage to the excluded group and considering whether a less intrusive option would do.
The objection starts the assessment; it doesn’t end/ settle it. And ‘reasonable’ is an objective test — it isn’t settled by your say-so (I say "NO!") any more than by a man’s, a trans person’s, or another woman’s with a different view.

I think there's a misunderstanding.

A disadvantage to an "excluded" group (which is men in this case) is not strengthened when those people (or a subset of those people) object more and more strongly.

The disadvantage to women is not "because women object". It's the other way around: the objection is raised because of the disadvantage.

There is no actual disadvantage caused to trans identifying men not being able to use women's toilets. Any more than I am disadvantaged by not being able to steal your money and spend it on myself. There's simply nothing to balance. There is objection against not being allowed to do this - but objection is not disadvantage.

Women's objections are reasonable because of the disadvantage. Men's objections are not reasonable because there is no disadvantage. Either way the law requires the disadvantage to be balanced, not the objections.

lcakethereforeIam · 12/11/2026 12:58

One of the things that did my head in at school was the line of best fit. The dots were all over the place but a line, a boundary if you wish, had to be drawn anyway. AI summarises it as 'a line of best fit (or trendline) is a straight or curved line drawn through a scatter plot to capture the general direction and relationship between two variables'. I don't think it applies to sex because sex is not two variables. Arguably is doesn't apply to gender either; believers in gi seem to have three classes masculine, feminine and whatever the fuck non-binary is. Even someone who is fluid only vacillates between. As a thought experiment, to indulge the genderists amongst us, we could draw a line of best fit on 'passing' to decide who gets to use which toilet. I don't know how that would be applied in practice though? Above the line, grand, off to the ladies with you. Below...to the gents, or pop back home and put some slap on.

Also, even if tw have been using the ladies since time immemorial, times change. Slavery is no longer legal, neither is marital rape, you can no longer marry a child. At least in this country. I think using the past as a defence doesn't wash. Consent (not that women's consent was ever sought) is an ongoing thing, the right to say no, at any time, is absolute.

Heggettypeg · 12/11/2026 12:54

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 12:38

It’s reasonable for women to object to toileting next to men, and the law agrees.

yes: the law treats that objection as a legitimate ground for separate provision.

Thats about as far as the story needs to go. Whether or not men agree if that’s reasonable.

No. The same provision requires the provider to show the arrangement is proportionate — which, as the Code spells out, means weighing the disadvantage to the excluded group and considering whether a less intrusive option would do.
The objection starts the assessment; it doesn’t end/ settle it. And ‘reasonable’ is an objective test — it isn’t settled by your say-so (I say "NO!") any more than by a man’s, a trans person’s, or another woman’s with a different view.

The default starting point of equality legislation is that everything should be for everybody.

However, in the case of the protected characteristic of sex, it is recognised that there will be some situations where separate single sex provisions are justified.

But if the conclusion is that single sex provision is not proportionate in a particular case, then the single sex exception is disallowed and the facility must be open to all, i.e. mixed sex. Not to "women plus a select band of men who identify as women on the grounds of gender, but no other men".

naffogato · 12/11/2026 12:49

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 12:25

Right. But the law doesn't say 'a user objects therefore that is determinative'. 'User says NO, end of conversation'.

The law says a user might reasonably object — and ‘reasonably’ is an objective standard, what the law has determined a reasonable person could object to, not whatever any individual declares their boundary to be. Then it requires the provider to show the arrangement is a proportionate balance between the people it helps and the people it excludes.

If personal boundaries settled the conversation, there’d be no need for either test ('reasonability', and proportionate balance); every facility would simply be run by whoever objected loudest. But that's not how it works. That's why "MY boundaries", "I say NO", is not the beginning and end of the conversation.

We all have our personal boundaries. I do, you do, trans people do. No one trumps another.
The question is how do we reasonably and proportionately balance competing interests in the delivery of services.

Edited

The fact that a single sex space exists is because the service provider has already decided it is proportionate and a legitimate aim.that is it reasonable to object to people of the opposite sex using the facility. The service provider cannot then allow access to those of the opposite sex.

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 12:38

MyAmpleSheep · 12/11/2026 12:34

It’s reasonable for women to object to toileting next to men, and the law agrees.

Thats about as far as the story needs to go. Whether or not men agree if that’s reasonable.

Trying to get around that by telling everyone that words have changed their meaning is silly nonsense, when you boil it down.

It’s reasonable for women to object to toileting next to men, and the law agrees.

yes: the law treats that objection as a legitimate ground for separate provision.

Thats about as far as the story needs to go. Whether or not men agree if that’s reasonable.

No. The same provision requires the provider to show the arrangement is proportionate — which, as the Code spells out, means weighing the disadvantage to the excluded group and considering whether a less intrusive option would do.
The objection starts the assessment; it doesn’t end/ settle it. And ‘reasonable’ is an objective test — it isn’t settled by your say-so (I say "NO!") any more than by a man’s, a trans person’s, or another woman’s with a different view.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 12/11/2026 12:36

@Lacksie The question is how do we reasonably and proportionately balance competing interests in the delivery of services.

There are no competing interests in the case of providers offering single-sex (and an additional gender neutral) facilities. Everyone has two that they can choose from.
The only interest not being served is the man who wants to change with the women and girls.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 12:35

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 12:34

Yes I would agree with this.

Hurrah 🙌

Keeptoiletssafe · 12/11/2026 12:35

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 12:25

Right. But the law doesn't say 'a user objects therefore that is determinative'. 'User says NO, end of conversation'.

The law says a user might reasonably object — and ‘reasonably’ is an objective standard, what the law has determined a reasonable person could object to, not whatever any individual declares their boundary to be. Then it requires the provider to show the arrangement is a proportionate balance between the people it helps and the people it excludes.

If personal boundaries settled the conversation, there’d be no need for either test ('reasonability', and proportionate balance); every facility would simply be run by whoever objected loudest. But that's not how it works. That's why "MY boundaries", "I say NO", is not the beginning and end of the conversation.

We all have our personal boundaries. I do, you do, trans people do. No one trumps another.
The question is how do we reasonably and proportionately balance competing interests in the delivery of services.

Edited

@Lacksie Your ‘boundaries’ are insignificant.

Rules, standards, regulations, legislation are significant. They prove your boundaries aren’t permissible in this country.

If you want things to change then campaign to change standards, regulations and legislation and delve into changing the Sexual Offences Act to try and iron out the conflicts of interest when single sex designs are used for both sexes.

You’ve got your work cut out.

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 12:34

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 12:28

Why is it often considered reasonable for a single sex space to exist in the first place? The acceptance that most people’s boundaries around the opposite sex makes it uncomfortable for them in certain circumstances to be undressed in front of the other sex.

Yes I would agree with this.

MyAmpleSheep · 12/11/2026 12:34

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 12:25

Right. But the law doesn't say 'a user objects therefore that is determinative'. 'User says NO, end of conversation'.

The law says a user might reasonably object — and ‘reasonably’ is an objective standard, what the law has determined a reasonable person could object to, not whatever any individual declares their boundary to be. Then it requires the provider to show the arrangement is a proportionate balance between the people it helps and the people it excludes.

If personal boundaries settled the conversation, there’d be no need for either test ('reasonability', and proportionate balance); every facility would simply be run by whoever objected loudest. But that's not how it works. That's why "MY boundaries", "I say NO", is not the beginning and end of the conversation.

We all have our personal boundaries. I do, you do, trans people do. No one trumps another.
The question is how do we reasonably and proportionately balance competing interests in the delivery of services.

Edited

It’s reasonable for women to object to toileting next to men, and the law agrees.

Thats about as far as the story needs to go. Whether or not men agree if that’s reasonable.

Trying to get around that by telling everyone that words have changed their meaning is silly nonsense, when you boil it down.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/11/2026 12:34

If someone wants to explain why a mental gender identity should be considered interchangeable with an opposite sex body in the first place, it would be a good start.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.