Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Woman with alopecia accused of being male while using female toilet at Tesco

1000 replies

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:24

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/gateshead-woman-alopecia-accused-being-34873020

"The 37-year-old, who has had the hair loss condition since she was a child, said she was left shocked when a cleaner at the Trinity Square shop asked her "Are you aware you're in the female toilet?" She said she became distressed and burst into tears."

But I thought people "could always tell"?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
lcakethereforeIam · 08/11/2026 20:47

There's been many incidents where arguably bad things have happened because people were afraid of asking questions or taking actions because they worried how just asking would make them look. The security guard at the Ariana Grande concert was worried he'd appear racist questioning the Asian man with the suitcase. The Nottingham knife murderer wasn't detain prior to his crimes because of the over-representation of young Black men in detention.

This incident is obviously on the lower end of a spectrum that would include the above examples. The cleaner spoke up to protect women. Perhaps the woman should reframe her trauma, the cleaner was looking out for her.

Wishesandhorses · 08/11/2026 20:46

I'm afraid the occasional woman being asked that question and finding it upsetting is the price of all women's safety and of regaining single sex spaces.
It's less harm than the women who were excluded, harassed, distressed and assaulted when men were freely walking in. They just (because they were not convenient to a male-focused agenda) didn't make the papers.

Some of us may just have to suck this up. It's the fault of those men that she had to deal with women needing to police their spaces; not of the women who questioned her. The answer absolutely cannot be 'don't ask questions'.

Coconutter24 · 08/11/2026 20:41

Catiette · 08/11/2026 20:26

Well, yes! This is fairly obvious and I don't think in question, given that it's, well, the whole premise of... everything.

What's in question is how to describe the tone and purpose of the question.

I'd agree with PPs that neither of the below definitions appear to fit - unless you see a direct question as indirect and being a man as a bad thing (insinuation), or the same question as an unambiguous allegation of "guilt" as opposed to equally likely to be a neutral observation of an innocent mistake (more likely).

I've posted a few times in recent days on black and white thinking, and this is more of the same. "Asking this question = negative". No, it's more complex. Insinuation, accusation and warning observation = identical. No, of course not.

The aim (or at least the assumption) of this line of argument seems to be that there was no way the cleaner could ask this question without herself being morally wrong or even, in some way, abusive. And this feels inconsistent. As PP have pointed out, as long as single sex toilets exist (even if you believe they should include transwomen), it has to remain possible to ask this question to protect those using them. Obviously.

An insinuation is an indirect, subtle, and often negative or insulting suggestion that something unpleasant or true is the case, without stating it plainly. 1, 2, 3]

An accusation is a claim, statement, or charge asserting that someone has done something wrong, illegal, immoral, or harmful. It represents an allegation of guilt rather than a proven fact. 1, 2, 3, 4]

Edited

I used the word insinuating before I read that the cleaner apologised once she realised she made a mistake. So at first take it appeared (to me) the cleaner asked the question because she thought the woman was a man. I used the word insinuating because (to me) it appeared the cleaner was indirectly suggesting the woman was a man and subtly asking why are you in a woman’s bathroom.

Catiette · 08/11/2026 20:26

Coconutter24 · 08/11/2026 17:45

So she thought she was a man? Which is the point I’m making, she asked the question because she thought she was a man

Well, yes! This is fairly obvious and I don't think in question, given that it's, well, the whole premise of... everything.

What's in question is how to describe the tone and purpose of the question.

I'd agree with PPs that neither of the below definitions appear to fit - unless you see a direct question as indirect and being a man as a bad thing (insinuation), or the same question as an unambiguous allegation of "guilt" as opposed to equally likely to be a neutral observation of an innocent mistake (more likely).

I've posted a few times in recent days on black and white thinking, and this is more of the same. "Asking this question = negative". No, it's more complex. Insinuation, accusation and warning observation = identical. No, of course not.

The aim (or at least the assumption) of this line of argument seems to be that there was no way the cleaner could ask this question without herself being morally wrong or even, in some way, abusive. And this feels inconsistent. As PP have pointed out, as long as single sex toilets exist (even if you believe they should include transwomen), it has to remain possible to ask this question to protect those using them. Obviously.

An insinuation is an indirect, subtle, and often negative or insulting suggestion that something unpleasant or true is the case, without stating it plainly. 1, 2, 3]

An accusation is a claim, statement, or charge asserting that someone has done something wrong, illegal, immoral, or harmful. It represents an allegation of guilt rather than a proven fact. 1, 2, 3, 4]

insinuation

1. the action of suggesting, without being direct, that something unpleasant is…

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/insinuation

FateAmenableToChange · 08/11/2026 20:11

Its clear from this we need a much stronger deterrent to keep males out of female spaces. A mandatory prison sentence would help. That should help remedy the insanity of the past few years and allow women to relax a bit and not feel like they have to be the police in such matters.

Cattywillow · 08/11/2026 20:03

What a beat up. If anyone actually mistook that woman for a man they need glasses. What a load of nonsense.

FeralFucker · 08/11/2026 20:00

Don't like this policing of how women should look, some people take far too much pleasure in making others feel uncomfortable.

RogueFemale · 08/11/2026 19:57

Here's one which spells out Helen's agenda.

"Helen said she feels the incident in Tesco may have stemmed from the debate in recent years over transgender rights. She said: "I suspect it's stemming from this which is a shame but I think potentially why people are being more cautious."
"I can understand the cautiousness from a business point of view but they've also got to be aware of diversity and people being different. They should not make assumptions on visible differences."
https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/woman-alopecia-tears-after-worker-37856023

Woman with alopecia in tears after worker accused her of being male in toilets

Helen Rowlands, 37, was left "humiliated and demeaned" after being challenged while using the female bathroom in Tesco.

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/woman-alopecia-tears-after-worker-37856023

RogueFemale · 08/11/2026 19:54

callmeLoretta1 · 08/11/2026 15:59

And yeah, nah, I smell a rat. There was a case in America where a trans activist faked some sort of toilet confrontation and gave an extended exclusive to Prick News. Such a setup, an obvious one. Her comments here makes it sound like she is yet another activist who set it up to muddy the waters.

Helen, who works as a complaints handler for the NHS

and

Helen said she feels the incident in Tesco may have stemmed from the debate in recent years over transgender rights. She said: "I suspect it's stemming from this which is a shame but I think potentially why people are being more cautious.

and

they've also got to be aware of diversity and people being different. They should not make assumptions on visible differences.

I smell a great big steaming RAT! I don't believe one single word of her story. Not one character or syllable. This reeks of yet another set up. And those who lack critical thinking and are easily taken in leap on it like flies on shit and gleefully rush to post it as 'proof' that womens rights is a bad thing.

Yeah, nah.

Edited

Ah, the trans stuff wasn't in the OP's linked article. So yeah, very smelly rat.

Datun · 08/11/2026 19:50

Oh for gods sake. If men didn't keep trying to sneak into women's toilets this wouldn't happen. Take it up with transactivists, or a mirror, whichever is more applicable.

BillieWiper · 08/11/2026 19:22

NibliaBiblia · 08/11/2026 19:10

Same. Baggy clothes and a mohawk as a teenager so it happened a few times. The person who made the mistake was usually a little embarrassed but it was never a big deal

Exactly. I'd have loved a mohawk. Didn't have the patience. 😍

Ended up with a number 1 when I bleached it so bad it broke off into a circle shape like the position and size of one of the skullcaps some Jewish guys wear! 🤣

But frankly if someone 'misgendered' me it was an embarrassment to them, not me! Regardless of what hair I had or didn't! 🤣

NibliaBiblia · 08/11/2026 19:10

BillieWiper · 08/11/2026 18:32

Exactly. I was regularly mistaken for a boy (mainly by men and elderly women) before puberty because I didn't conform to sexist gender stereotypes of wearing long hair, and pink dresses.

It's mens fault that the notion of a woman with short/no hair should allegedly immediately make one assume penis owner.

Women and men dressing in gender non conforming ways should have been normalised decades ago.

Edited

Same. Baggy clothes and a mohawk as a teenager so it happened a few times. The person who made the mistake was usually a little embarrassed but it was never a big deal

LeftieRightsHoarder · 08/11/2026 18:56

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:31

So "most" people can but not everyone.

So every time a woman who happens to not look conventionally female e.g. tall, short hair, alopecia, baggy clothes etc is going to have a chance each time that they will be challenged in public toilets thanks to the obsession whether a given woman might actually be a trans woman?

Sounds ironic that the campaign led by Jo is actually hurting women?

This was never a problem before men started pretending to be women and trespassed in women’s toilets and changing rooms.

Normally, no one turned a hair if a masculine-looking woman came in, because it was so very unlikely to be a man. We lived in a high-trust society and most people obeyed the rules, because they were easy and kept things running smoothly for everyone.

Misogynistic men and sex fetishists ruined this by discovering they could get a cheap thrill from trespassing in women’s spaces, and most women would too embarrassed or intimidated to challenge them.

GailBlancheViola · 08/11/2026 18:46

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 08/11/2026 15:26

They can't. Some people just want a target for their hatred, anyone will do.

This is transphobia's legacy: making our gendered, public facilities even more dangerous than they were before. Wow thanks.

Public facilities are not and never were gendered spaces they are sex based spaces. If men, whatever they identify as, had kept to their own sex spaces none of these 'mistaking incidents' would happen.

Women have the right to have confidence that the ONLY people in their single sex facilities will be the same sex as them.

OhTheCowsInTheMeadowGoMoo · 08/11/2026 18:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

A post about someone getting beaten up in a toilet makes you want the laugh emoticon back?
Why?!

naffogato · 08/11/2026 18:37

CelticSilver · 08/11/2026 17:54

From the article:
'I went to go to the toilet in Tesco and, as I was coming out of the toilet, the cleaner shouted after me. She said something along the lines of 'Are you aware you're in the female toilet?'

"I was just completely gobsmacked. She was accusing me of being male in the female toilet.

"I didn't know what to do or say. It just completely took me off guard. I think she realised she had made a mistake as she started saying there had been men in the previous week.'

So a cleaner saw her from behind, said something 'along the lines of' and immediately apologised when she turned around.

What a ridiculous non-story. Almost as if there is an ulterior motive publishing it ...

Well quite.

BillieWiper · 08/11/2026 18:32

CorvusPurpureus · 08/11/2026 13:50

I’m tall & broad shouldered, & live in tshirts & jeans. Because of recent weight loss, lots of my scruffy clothes are indeed baggy.

I also don’t wear make up very often & have quite strong features.

DD1 looks very like me, but is taller than me (over 6’), has cropped hair, & NEVER wears makeup or anything but jeans & hoodies.

We both regularly get double takes. Even I, as her bloody mother, was meeting dd1 a few months back at a tube station, thought I’d seen her heading towards me & then realised I was looking at a lanky shorthaired bloke wearing the same university jacket she lives in.

It’s a momentary double take 90% of the time, a very occasional ‘excuse me…oh sorry love!’.

DD1 & I are both fine with it.

The woman in the article looks great IMO. I’m sorry she was upset by the cleaner - who did realise her mistake & apologise.

& frankly, if we didn’t have to worry about blokes in women’s spaces in the FIRST place…this wouldn’t be an issue.

So maybe we should put the blame THERE for the occasional mistake.

Exactly. I was regularly mistaken for a boy (mainly by men and elderly women) before puberty because I didn't conform to sexist gender stereotypes of wearing long hair, and pink dresses.

It's mens fault that the notion of a woman with short/no hair should allegedly immediately make one assume penis owner.

Women and men dressing in gender non conforming ways should have been normalised decades ago.

OhTheCowsInTheMeadowGoMoo · 08/11/2026 18:30

hastenotwaste · 08/11/2026 13:34

Sounds ironic that the campaign led by Jo is actually hurting women?
Most women would laugh it off- I have when it's happened to me. The "hurt" you're referring to I presume is hurt feelings rather than actual physical assault which is more likely to happen in mixed sex spaces. I know which I'd rather risk.

"Most women would laugh it off"
Wow. Speak for yourself. It's horrible when it happens. You're coming across with the same vibe as "what's the matter with you, it's only a banter/joke love, lighten up a bit".. 🙄

Mapletree1985 · 08/11/2026 18:29

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:31

So "most" people can but not everyone.

So every time a woman who happens to not look conventionally female e.g. tall, short hair, alopecia, baggy clothes etc is going to have a chance each time that they will be challenged in public toilets thanks to the obsession whether a given woman might actually be a trans woman?

Sounds ironic that the campaign led by Jo is actually hurting women?

I have occasionally been mistake for a man, but once I speak it's all good. I don't take offense and it doesn't bother me. Being a man is not a criminal offense.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 08/11/2026 18:24

Lhori · 08/11/2026 18:17

Wasn't the hurt caused by the campaign led by trans rights activists that men should be allowed in women's spaces?

Tbf, these sorts of misunderstandings have been happening since way before the TRA idiots tried to change the world. I witnessed one as a teenager in a department store toilet. The woman just laughed and said it wasn’t the first time she’d been asked

GoodGirlFaith · 08/11/2026 18:22

HermioneWeasley · 08/11/2026 13:44

Blame the men who have been taking women’s spaces and services - if they hadn’t been stealing women’s things then we wouldn’t be on high alert

Well said, OP!

The sensible, rational people among us aren’t on any alert. How do you know that you haven’t shared the Ladies with a man before? How would you know, or be able to tell?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/11/2026 18:19

MagpiePi · 08/11/2026 18:01

I’m not sure but maybe Jo Rowling?

We all know she is a rabid transphobe using her vast wealth to whip up hatred.

Btw Jo, if you’re reading this - I’m still waiting for my funding, just in case the cheque got lost in the post. And can you give the Christian far right lot a nudge as they are being a bit tardy with their payouts too? TIA

And the Russian roubles for fomenting online discord

Lhori · 08/11/2026 18:17

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:31

So "most" people can but not everyone.

So every time a woman who happens to not look conventionally female e.g. tall, short hair, alopecia, baggy clothes etc is going to have a chance each time that they will be challenged in public toilets thanks to the obsession whether a given woman might actually be a trans woman?

Sounds ironic that the campaign led by Jo is actually hurting women?

Wasn't the hurt caused by the campaign led by trans rights activists that men should be allowed in women's spaces?

SockPlant · 08/11/2026 18:05

seahorsessky · 08/11/2026 15:23

Poor woman. Losing the way you look (hair, sometimes putting on a lot of weight due to the illness of medication) can, for some women, be one of the worst parts of illness. Being criticised for being "fat" and being confused for a man, when you're already seriously ill, can be the last straw for some people. For those of you who can laugh it off, great. Not everyone can. And the next woman treated this way is maybe one of those who will live her last few weeks upset, or feel she doesn't want to live anymore. Illness can make you feel much more fragile that you used to be.

She is aware that men try to get into women's toilets because they dress "like women". She is very well aware that shaving her head she doesn't look like the average woman, and given that a man had tried to get in the toilet the previous week, she is going to have to accept that - horrible as it is for her - this may be a feature in her life from now.

She can either try to feminise her appearance (she shouldn't and doesn't have to) or speak first (since that is usually when people realise it is a woman in front of them) or accept that now and again she's going to be challenged.

This is where we are now and the blame for this lies with the transwomen who have caused the problem by breaking the law.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/11/2026 18:02

Coconutter24 · 08/11/2026 17:52

That she was insinuating the woman was a man by asking the question

She thought the person might be a man making a mistake so she checked if the person knew they were in the ladies. At which point it became clear the person was a woman and she apologised.

"Insinuating" isn't really the right word to use here as that implies (1) she thought it was a man rather than might be, and (2) was acting with a level of bad faith to "say but not say".

"Being polite" is a more appropriate description.

It' the difference between "Oi trespasser" and "Are you sure you are supposed to be in here?". You'd have to be very sure to open with the former. If you aren't sure, you'd typically use the latter.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread