Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Woman with alopecia accused of being male while using female toilet at Tesco

1000 replies

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:24

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/gateshead-woman-alopecia-accused-being-34873020

"The 37-year-old, who has had the hair loss condition since she was a child, said she was left shocked when a cleaner at the Trinity Square shop asked her "Are you aware you're in the female toilet?" She said she became distressed and burst into tears."

But I thought people "could always tell"?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 10:13

MarieDeGournay · 09/11/2026 10:09

Again, I accept that you are arguing about the strict legal position, and again I admit to not knowing enough about UK law to say yay or nay.

However, sometimes common sense, respect, etc. are more immediately applicable than the letter of the law, so would you accept that, whatever the law does or does not say,
the moment that "any male" puts even a toe over the threshold of a women's loo
he is entering a space where he is not entitled to be, and as soon as he realises it /it is pointed out to him, he should get his toe back over the threshold ASAP and go to the toilet that is designated for his biological sex?
edited to say that some males e.g. young boys with mothers/carers or male workers are allowed in women's toilets in certain circs.

Edited

Yes of course I would agree with that.

None of that changes the legal position re: sexual harassment though.

Voltaroldemort · 09/11/2026 10:13

chef's kiss, @FlirtsWithRhinos . Perfectly stated.

TRA's leverage womens distress, just as they leverage the distress of people with DSDs, PCOS, alopecia, whatever-the-fuck is currently at hand to rotate the whole wide world around to whatever-the-fuck it is that they happen to want at any given moment.

I have alopecia. I also have only one ovary, making me unwilling raw material for fake gotchas in two respects - able to be mistaken for a man in specific circumstances and not having the full inventory of female anatomy that TRAs claim that sex realists claim to be neccessary for actually baing a woman.

And yet here I am, an actual 3D person who isn't just a trope in a man's angry online posturing, a man's needy projection of his needs onto material reality.

SirChenjins · 09/11/2026 10:09

Voltaroldemort · 09/11/2026 10:05

Ah, ok, then I agree with you @Limeandfigs . I'm guilty of skim-reading this fast-moving thread.
What really gets me is that there is so much idiotic hyperbole on this very simple issue. On both sides. And then each side can accuse the other of being daft and making an issue out of nothing. And so there is then soo much white noise that simple truths about the neccesity and reasonableness of single-sex spaces get drowned out.
It's the same across a whole range of issues. The angry dynamics on online chat seem to completely replace the real outlines of real issues in the real world.

Edited

You're absolutely right - it is simple. Men (regardless of how they choose to present their bodies to the world) need to keep out of women's spaces.

This is what women have been fighting for and will continue to fight for until all men respect that.

MarieDeGournay · 09/11/2026 10:09

Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 10:00

I completely agree, it doesn't matter. Men should stay out of women's spaces.

It still does not constitute sexual harassment in and of itself if a man enters a women's loo, because that would be totally unworkable in law and would criminalise an awful lot of innocent people.

And yes, there are other offences that might be committed, but in all cases these require more to happen than for a man to simply enter a women's loo. Unfortunately the previous poster seems to think the moment that "any male" puts even a toe over the threshold of a women's loo then an offence of sexual harassment has been committed, which is clearly ludicrous.

Again, I accept that you are arguing about the strict legal position, and again I admit to not knowing enough about UK law to say yay or nay.

However, sometimes common sense, respect, etc. are more immediately applicable than the letter of the law, so would you accept that, whatever the law does or does not say,
the moment that "any male" puts even a toe over the threshold of a women's loo
he is entering a space where he is not entitled to be, and as soon as he realises it /it is pointed out to him, he should get his toe back over the threshold ASAP and go to the toilet that is designated for his biological sex?
edited to say that some males e.g. young boys with mothers/carers or male workers are allowed in women's toilets in certain circs.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 09/11/2026 10:06

Pingponghavoc · 09/11/2026 09:57

When a service provides single sex toilets and changing rooms, they can tell anyone to leave who is using the incorrect space. They dont have to be harassing anyone or causing distress- a man alone in a women space is enough to tell him to leave.

As a society, we can remind people of these rules. I dont understand why that's considered controversial or similar to performing a citizens arrest?

Ooo ooo I know this one!!

It's because the distress and humiliation of a woman can be leveraged to get men access where the majority of women don't want them based on some sexist idea that being a woman is something to do with how you think.

The distress and humiliation this would cause to many more women is apparently not a problem.

Personally I find being forced by society to pretend I as a female person share some undefined wommaniness of the mind with a set of self identified male people, with the subtext that said male people know more about being a woman than I do, and that whatever I may feel, experience or need because I am female is so inconsequential we don't even need a word to name ourselves, let alone legal rights or protections, far more distressing, humilating, sexist and dehumanising than the times I've been mistaken for a bloke.

Looking forward to the T/MRA blocks leaping to my defence please.

Voltaroldemort · 09/11/2026 10:05

Ah, ok, then I agree with you @Limeandfigs . I'm guilty of skim-reading this fast-moving thread.
What really gets me is that there is so much idiotic hyperbole on this very simple issue. On both sides. And then each side can accuse the other of being daft and making an issue out of nothing. And so there is then soo much white noise that simple truths about the neccesity and reasonableness of single-sex spaces get drowned out.
It's the same across a whole range of issues. The angry dynamics on online chat seem to completely replace the real outlines of real issues in the real world.

Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 10:00

Voltaroldemort · 09/11/2026 09:55

Why does it matter whether or not criminal law prevents men entering womens spaces, @Limeandfigs ? Of course it doesn't, unless there are circumstances that reveal it to be connected with an offence such as voueurism, exhibitionism, sexual assault, etc etc. So what?

It is still a civil offence. The service provider can take action to prevent the offence, such as terminating membership of a gym, asking the person to leave a shop/bar/whatever.

Plus there are some more generl criminal offences such as threatening or disorderly behaviour that might allow the police to take action in cases where the man's behviour was abusive, aggressive, clearly influenced by something more woman-hating/woman-exploiting than "needing to pee"

Edited

I completely agree, it doesn't matter. Men should stay out of women's spaces.

It still does not constitute sexual harassment in and of itself if a man enters a women's loo, because that would be totally unworkable in law and would criminalise an awful lot of innocent people.

And yes, there are other offences that might be committed, but in all cases these require more to happen than for a man to simply enter a women's loo. Unfortunately the previous poster seems to think the moment that "any male" puts even a toe over the threshold of a women's loo then an offence of sexual harassment has been committed, which is clearly ludicrous.

FlatCatYellowMat · 09/11/2026 09:59

If you want another way it is criminal (although not in this case, and not for those men entering the ladies) the Health and Safety at Work act 1974 explicitly mandates single sex toilets.

Not complying with it can result in criminal conviction for the company or the directors of the company involved.

Pingponghavoc · 09/11/2026 09:57

When a service provides single sex toilets and changing rooms, they can tell anyone to leave who is using the incorrect space. They dont have to be harassing anyone or causing distress- a man alone in a women space is enough to tell him to leave.

As a society, we can remind people of these rules. I dont understand why that's considered controversial or similar to performing a citizens arrest?

Voltaroldemort · 09/11/2026 09:55

Why does it matter whether or not criminal law prevents men entering womens spaces, @Limeandfigs ? Of course it doesn't, unless there are circumstances that reveal it to be connected with an offence such as voueurism, exhibitionism, sexual assault, etc etc. So what?

It is still a civil offence. The service provider can take action to prevent the offence, such as terminating membership of a gym, asking the person to leave a shop/bar/whatever.

Plus there are some more generl criminal offences such as threatening or disorderly behaviour that might allow the police to take action in cases where the man's behviour was abusive, aggressive, clearly influenced by something more woman-hating/woman-exploiting than "needing to pee"

SwirlyGates · 09/11/2026 09:54

Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 08:24

I'd agree with this to be honest.

I've been called 'sir' before (I'm tall and I've had very short hair in the past) - I was slightly bemused for a minute then it didn't matter.

But I'm not recovering from breast cancer having lost my hair and both my breasts. I'm not suffering from a condition like alopecia. I'm fortunate enough to never have been bullied for my looks.

I can imagine how upsetting it would be to be challenged repeatedly if you're already raw.

If you think someone shouldn't be in a particular loo, it's best to get staff to deal with it IMO.

Staff? Depends where you are. Supermarkets, department stores, many places - staff have been cut to the bone.

callmeLoretta1 · 09/11/2026 09:53

Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 09:50

You're the one who can't cite the law mate.

I have. I've even directed you to the verdict of the SC, in addition to having given you a definition of sexual harassment. You've provided absolutely nothing but obfuscation and pretending you don't understand basic social mores, law and common sense. It's all you lot have when you are losing. PRETEND it's 'all too complicated' and you 'don't understand'. You genuinely think we haven't seen this tactic over and over and over again.

FlatCatYellowMat · 09/11/2026 09:53

Actually we have to challenge this behaviour when we can - as one of the tests in the public order act 1986 is 'refuses to leave when asked'. If we don't ask these men to leave (or ask the management to ask them to leave), then we're complicit in normalising it.

Much like the evidence for a GRA includes coercing those around you to use the wrong pronouns/'treat' you as the wrong sex. Which is why we shouldn't comply with that either - it's not 'being kind' it's being an instrument of our own oppression.

EdithStourton · 09/11/2026 09:51

CoolforKats · 09/11/2026 09:22

There's this thing called 'locked cubicles'. Is that so hard to understand?

Are you always so patronising?
Sometimes the locks are a bit dodgy and would pop with pressure.
Very often changing rooms only have curtains.

And then there's the issue of menstruation. I was once with a friend who'd had a major flood, so there she was, washing out her pants in the sink and using the hand dryer to try and get them dry enough to wear. Having another woman walk in would have been embarrassing enough (she was only about 20 at the time), but a man?

I wouldn't give a monkey's if I was challenged in a ladies, and it could happen: I'm tall, I've been told I walk like a bloke (long stride), I often wear baggy clothing, my favourite winter coat is in fact a man's one (fits me brilliantly). In fact, if I was challenged I'd be reassured that SSSs were being taken seriously.

SirChenjins · 09/11/2026 09:51

MarieDeGournay · 09/11/2026 09:47

I accept that you are referring specifically to what the law says, or does not say, about men using spaces designated for use by biological women.

But the law is not the only thing that keeps society running as friction-free as possible: there is no law that says 'It is a criminal offence to walk in a dead straight line down a pavement, causing other pedestrians to take evasive action so as not to be mown down by you', but normally we take the line of least resistance when walking through a crowded space.

There is no law that says that on the day before the last posting date for Christmas, a local business may not completely clog up the only local postbox with all their cards, leaving no space for anybody else's cards - yes that's a real-life example😒

There's no law that says an able-bodied person can't use the accessible toilet just because they want to, not because they are disabled and need to.

There is no law that says you must not tell random 4 year olds to get real, Santa Claus doesn't exist.

Another 'there's no law' social convention is that when a space is designated as being for the sole use of one sex, members of the other sex respect that.
'The good men stay out so the bad men stand out'.

Up to very recently, that worked very well - of course sometimes men entered the women's toilet, but it was usually by mistake - hence the 'Excuse me, this is the ladies!' challenge - and occasionally a man entered a women's toilet to do harm to women.
In both cases, the men knew they shouldn't be there, they were there through mistake or malice.

What's different now is a bizarre obsession with men deliberately and knowingly using spaces designated solely for women.

Saying 'there's no law against it' may be accurate, I don't know enough about UK law to agree or disagree, but being legal doesn't make something pro-social.

Especially when it causes women and girls to feel unsafe, uncomfortable, and that their privacy and dignity is being trampled on by a man - and creating the possibility for harassment.

Women must not put up with this, and girls must not grow up believing they must put up with this.

Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 09:50

callmeLoretta1 · 09/11/2026 09:43

We're not talking about criminal law, we are talking about the Equality Law that PREVENTS the act of sexual harassment by males entering female spaces.

You are way out of your depth here. And on some level, you must know it.

You're the one who can't cite the law mate.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 09/11/2026 09:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MarieDeGournay · 09/11/2026 09:47

Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 09:28

Where are these provisions in the law please? All legislation is freely available on legislation.gov.uk - please post the link.

And again, please post the link to the actual law stating that any man in a woman's loo is automatically guilty of sexual harassment.

The law is not "whataboutery".

I accept that you are referring specifically to what the law says, or does not say, about men using spaces designated for use by biological women.

But the law is not the only thing that keeps society running as friction-free as possible: there is no law that says 'It is a criminal offence to walk in a dead straight line down a pavement, causing other pedestrians to take evasive action so as not to be mown down by you', but normally we take the line of least resistance when walking through a crowded space.

There is no law that says that on the day before the last posting date for Christmas, a local business may not completely clog up the only local postbox with all their cards, leaving no space for anybody else's cards - yes that's a real-life example😒

There's no law that says an able-bodied person can't use the accessible toilet just because they want to, not because they are disabled and need to.

There is no law that says you must not tell random 4 year olds to get real, Santa Claus doesn't exist.

Another 'there's no law' social convention is that when a space is designated as being for the sole use of one sex, members of the other sex respect that.
'The good men stay out so the bad men stand out'.

Up to very recently, that worked very well - of course sometimes men entered the women's toilet, but it was usually by mistake - hence the 'Excuse me, this is the ladies!' challenge - and occasionally a man entered a women's toilet to do harm to women.
In both cases, the men knew they shouldn't be there, they were there through mistake or malice.

What's different now is a bizarre obsession with men deliberately and knowingly using spaces designated solely for women.

Saying 'there's no law against it' may be accurate, I don't know enough about UK law to agree or disagree, but being legal doesn't make something pro-social.

callmeLoretta1 · 09/11/2026 09:43

Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 09:40

It is still not criminal law and it does not apply to individuals.

You can bluster as much as you like, the fact is you're incorrect about UK law and you know you have nothing to support it.

We're not talking about criminal law, we are talking about the Equality Law that PREVENTS the act of sexual harassment by males entering female spaces.

You are way out of your depth here. And on some level, you must know it.

Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 09:40

callmeLoretta1 · 09/11/2026 09:39

The Equality Act deals with public spaces and venues.

In fact, it was a large part of what WFS's case was about.

It is still not criminal law and it does not apply to individuals.

You can bluster as much as you like, the fact is you're incorrect about UK law and you know you have nothing to support it.

callmeLoretta1 · 09/11/2026 09:39

Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 09:38

Yes I know.

What you clearly don't understand is that the SC judgement dealt with the Equality Act. This is civil law which applies to organisations like shops and venues.

Criminal law, which includes the provisions for sexual harassment, is an entirely different piece of legislation.

Please post the link to the legislation which states it is a criminal offence - namely sexual harassment - for a man to enter a women's bathroom.

The Equality Act deals with public spaces and venues.

In fact, it was a large part of what WFS's case was about.

Babyyourafirework · 09/11/2026 09:38

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:24

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/gateshead-woman-alopecia-accused-being-34873020

"The 37-year-old, who has had the hair loss condition since she was a child, said she was left shocked when a cleaner at the Trinity Square shop asked her "Are you aware you're in the female toilet?" She said she became distressed and burst into tears."

But I thought people "could always tell"?

Maybe she looked like a man? Maybe she was wearing man's clothes? Who knows?
One swallow don't make a summer

callmeLoretta1 · 09/11/2026 09:38

Sexual harassment is any unwelcome behavior of a sexual nature that makes a person feel offended, humiliated, or intimidated. It can be physical, verbal, or written, and occurs across workplaces, schools, public spaces, and online.

Women, girls, and rape and trauma survivors feel intimidated by a male in an intimate female only space. This, should not need to be explained to anyone with an IQ above room temperature. And I am not going to, as a rape survivor, and someone who receives flashbacks and trauma responses to males, go backwards and forwards with a disingenuous person who pretends not to understand, so as to avoid addressing the issue.

Limeandfigs · 09/11/2026 09:38

callmeLoretta1 · 09/11/2026 09:33

Read the SC judgement. The judge mentions young boys entering toileting facilities with their mother.

Yes I know.

What you clearly don't understand is that the SC judgement dealt with the Equality Act. This is civil law which applies to organisations like shops and venues.

Criminal law, which includes the provisions for sexual harassment, is an entirely different piece of legislation.

Please post the link to the legislation which states it is a criminal offence - namely sexual harassment - for a man to enter a women's bathroom.

Grammarnut · 09/11/2026 09:37

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:31

So "most" people can but not everyone.

So every time a woman who happens to not look conventionally female e.g. tall, short hair, alopecia, baggy clothes etc is going to have a chance each time that they will be challenged in public toilets thanks to the obsession whether a given woman might actually be a trans woman?

Sounds ironic that the campaign led by Jo is actually hurting women?

Were men not dressing up as women and entering female-only spaces no-one would need to 'tell' because everyone in there would be a woman. And that one woman made a mistake - which must have been immediately corrected by the woman speaking - does not mean that men should all be allowed to go into women's spaces. Quite the reverse, in fact.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.