Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Woman with alopecia accused of being male while using female toilet at Tesco

1000 replies

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:24

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/gateshead-woman-alopecia-accused-being-34873020

"The 37-year-old, who has had the hair loss condition since she was a child, said she was left shocked when a cleaner at the Trinity Square shop asked her "Are you aware you're in the female toilet?" She said she became distressed and burst into tears."

But I thought people "could always tell"?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:37

MyAmpleSheep · 11/11/2026 14:26

passing/ transition trans people use facilities according to their gender and no barely notices / minds.

assuming you meant to type people barely notice and nobody minds- this simply isn’t true.

Lots of people mind, some people mind very much, and a significant number of people mind to such an extent they are prepared to go to court over it.

The evidence of quite how much people mind is right in front of you.

Edited

i understand that you and others
mind a great deal in principle . But how many times in life has this been an issue for you in practice? Yes there are cases, but they are rare and anedoctal. I'm not saying things are perfect all the time- life doesn't work like that, but where is the evidence that this is actually an issue in practice beyond a few isolated cases? Where is The evidence That justifies new guidance for policing facilities- with all the consequences that will bring. Including for trans people. In practice in everyday contexts people will be singled out according to gender presentation regardless of whether they are trans - just like in the OP.where is the evidence that will work any better and cause any less harm. Where is the evidence of prior harm beyond people being outraged in principle on social media ?

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 14:31

MyAmpleSheep · 11/11/2026 14:26

passing/ transition trans people use facilities according to their gender and no barely notices / minds.

assuming you meant to type people barely notice and nobody minds- this simply isn’t true.

Lots of people mind, some people mind very much, and a significant number of people mind to such an extent they are prepared to go to court over it.

The evidence of quite how much people mind is right in front of you.

Edited

I wonder where Rose Henderson from Darlington Memorial Hospital fits into all this.

Clearly not passing, and clearly people did mind.

Is this case supposed to be an aberration?

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 14:28

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:23

Well quite. But the things they look at are how you dress, your name/ pronouns , possibly what services you use! Etc. what you hear from trans people is that they don't feel comfortable and safe doing these things when they so obviously don't pass, that social transition is something that needs to happen alongside medical transition- not for a period of time prior to it.

The only reason I brought it up was to demonstrate the point that people don't just realise they are trans in their head and walk into a cross sex facility . That's not how things work in the real world. How things actually work is that passing/ transitioned trans people use facilities according to their gender and no barely notices / minds. Meanwhile Forcing them to use the ones according to their birth sex will cause much greater disruption (hence the provision to exclude transitioned trans men from female facilities).

Edited

How would they know which facilities somebody is using?

what you hear from trans people is that they don't feel comfortable and safe doing these things when they so obviously don't pass, so social transition is something that needs to happen alongside medical transition

The reality is that most men won't pass, and if they are having treatment on this basis they are being misled and that is malpractice.

How things actually work is that passing/ transition trans people use facilities according to their gender and no barely notices / minds.

Again, your experience seems to be quite narrow and exclude the majority who don't pass.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 11/11/2026 14:26

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:23

Well quite. But the things they look at are how you dress, your name/ pronouns , possibly what services you use! Etc. what you hear from trans people is that they don't feel comfortable and safe doing these things when they so obviously don't pass, that social transition is something that needs to happen alongside medical transition- not for a period of time prior to it.

The only reason I brought it up was to demonstrate the point that people don't just realise they are trans in their head and walk into a cross sex facility . That's not how things work in the real world. How things actually work is that passing/ transitioned trans people use facilities according to their gender and no barely notices / minds. Meanwhile Forcing them to use the ones according to their birth sex will cause much greater disruption (hence the provision to exclude transitioned trans men from female facilities).

Edited

...and you know all this how?

MyAmpleSheep · 11/11/2026 14:26

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:23

Well quite. But the things they look at are how you dress, your name/ pronouns , possibly what services you use! Etc. what you hear from trans people is that they don't feel comfortable and safe doing these things when they so obviously don't pass, that social transition is something that needs to happen alongside medical transition- not for a period of time prior to it.

The only reason I brought it up was to demonstrate the point that people don't just realise they are trans in their head and walk into a cross sex facility . That's not how things work in the real world. How things actually work is that passing/ transitioned trans people use facilities according to their gender and no barely notices / minds. Meanwhile Forcing them to use the ones according to their birth sex will cause much greater disruption (hence the provision to exclude transitioned trans men from female facilities).

Edited

passing/ transition trans people use facilities according to their gender and no barely notices / minds.

assuming you meant to type people barely notice and nobody minds- this simply isn’t true.

Lots of people mind, some people mind very much, and a significant number of people mind to such an extent they are prepared to go to court over it.

The evidence of quite how much people mind is right in front of you.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:23

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 14:14

Why would evidence based healthcare require something that is unreasonable and unrealistic? What does it mean to live in a gender? How would I know if I were succeeding in living in a gender?

Well quite. But the things they look at are how you dress, your name/ pronouns , possibly what services you use! Etc. what you hear from trans people is that they don't feel comfortable and safe doing these things when they so obviously don't pass, that social transition is something that needs to happen alongside medical transition- not for a period of time prior to it.

The only reason I brought it up was to demonstrate the point that people don't just realise they are trans in their head and walk into a cross sex facility . That's not how things work in the real world. How things actually work is that passing/ transitioned trans people use facilities according to their gender and no barely notices / minds. Meanwhile Forcing them to use the ones according to their birth sex will cause much greater disruption (hence the provision to exclude transitioned trans men from female facilities).

MyAmpleSheep · 11/11/2026 14:18

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:30

My argument is simply that it has worked well up until now and can continue to do so.

I know you think that trans people are deeply nefarious, but the vast majority of trans people are ordinary people like anyone else, who value, privacy, dignity and not drawing unwanted attention to themselves. They chose what toilet to use for the same reasons you do - for privacy, dignity and safety.

Passing is very important to the majority of trans people. And they will understandably want to avoid situations where they will obviously stand out/ not pass and potentially put themselves in an unsafe situation.

It's one of the challenges that in order to access transition-related healthcare you have to demonstrate that you have been "living in your gender" for a certain number of years - this can be incredibly uncomfortable for very obvious reasons.

Edited

My argument is simply that it has worked well up until now

It hasn't worked well up to now, which is why we are here discussing it. It has worked well only for the people for whom it has worked well, and nobody bothered to consider (or, god forbid, ask) the people for whom it has worked extremely badly.

I know you think that trans people are deeply nefarious, but the vast majority of trans people are ordinary people like anyone else, who value, privacy, dignity and not drawing unwanted attention to themselves. They chose what toilet to use for the same reasons you do - for privacy, dignity and safety

Echoing what someone else wrote, because it's important: I don't think trans people on the whole are deeply nefarious. The vast majority of all men aren't deeply nefarious and choose to use toilets on the basis of privacy dignity and safety too. We still don't let them into women's toilets.

Passing is very important to the majority of trans people. And they will understandably want to avoid situations where they will obviously stand out/ not pass and potentially put themselves in an unsafe situation.

Unarguably.

It's one of the challenges that in order to access transition-related healthcare you have to demonstrate that you have been "living in your gender" for a certain number of years - this can be incredibly uncomfortable for very obvious reasons.

This is indeed a problem: what you are saying is that doctors used to - I don't know if they still do - say "go and live among the women as a woman, and come back in a couple of years."

The problem is - doctors don't have the right, the power, or the authority to tell men they can use women's toilets, not once, not for a week, and not for a couple of years. They should never have done so, and having done so doesn't excuse it or make it lawful or acceptable.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 14:14

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:09

This does indeed seem completely impossible and unreasonable, and an argument against the validity of translation-related healthcare

Eh? No this doesn't follow. It's an argument that the current requirements/ criteria for eligibility are unreasonable and unrealistic.

Why would evidence based healthcare require something that is unreasonable and unrealistic? What does it mean to live in a gender? How would I know if I were succeeding in living in a gender?

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:09

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 14:04

My argument is simply that it has worked well up until now and can continue to do so.

And the system that you are describing does not consider the large numbers of men who do not pass as women. It does sound as though you aren't in an environment where there are many trans people and perhaps you aren't aware of all the people covered by the term.

I know you think that trans people are deeply nefarious

No, I have never expressed this view. It is you that seems to be questioning the existence of a large proportion of the community.

but the vast majority of trans people are ordinary people like anyone else, who value, privacy, dignity and not drawing unwanted attention to themselves.

Indeed the vast majority of men value privacy, dignity and not drawing attention to themselves, but you aren't really addressing my question about passing.

Passing is very important to the majority of trans people.

But rarely possible for men, so what do you think they should do?

It's one of the challenges that in order to access transition-related healthcare you have to demonstrate that you have been "living in your gender" for a certain number of years

This does indeed seem completely impossible and unreasonable, and an argument against the validity of translation-related healthcare.

This does indeed seem completely impossible and unreasonable, and an argument against the validity of translation-related healthcare

Eh? No this doesn't follow. It's an argument that the current requirements/ criteria for eligibility are unreasonable and unrealistic.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 14:08

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:54

If you want to justify the introduction of new policy for policing facilities on the basis of gender presentation, surely you need to demonstrate actual evidence of a problem?

Not just projections or theories, but actual evidence that there is an issue, beyond the odd isolated incident?

Edited

I for one am completely against any policy of policing anything on the basis of gender presentation. I do not think anything should be segregated according to gender presentation, and I suspect it might be unlawful sex discrimination. Also confusing. Which facility am I supposed to use?

Sex, on the other hand is sometimes relevant and everyone knows their own sex. If you don't think sex is relevant, the thing to do is to make an honest argument for mixed sex services like @Anothercoffeeafter3 . Whether or not I agree, at least the terms used make sense.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 14:04

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:30

My argument is simply that it has worked well up until now and can continue to do so.

I know you think that trans people are deeply nefarious, but the vast majority of trans people are ordinary people like anyone else, who value, privacy, dignity and not drawing unwanted attention to themselves. They chose what toilet to use for the same reasons you do - for privacy, dignity and safety.

Passing is very important to the majority of trans people. And they will understandably want to avoid situations where they will obviously stand out/ not pass and potentially put themselves in an unsafe situation.

It's one of the challenges that in order to access transition-related healthcare you have to demonstrate that you have been "living in your gender" for a certain number of years - this can be incredibly uncomfortable for very obvious reasons.

Edited

My argument is simply that it has worked well up until now and can continue to do so.

And the system that you are describing does not consider the large numbers of men who do not pass as women. It does sound as though you aren't in an environment where there are many trans people and perhaps you aren't aware of all the people covered by the term.

I know you think that trans people are deeply nefarious

No, I have never expressed this view. It is you that seems to be questioning the existence of a large proportion of the community.

but the vast majority of trans people are ordinary people like anyone else, who value, privacy, dignity and not drawing unwanted attention to themselves.

Indeed the vast majority of men value privacy, dignity and not drawing attention to themselves, but you aren't really addressing my question about passing.

Passing is very important to the majority of trans people.

But rarely possible for men, so what do you think they should do?

It's one of the challenges that in order to access transition-related healthcare you have to demonstrate that you have been "living in your gender" for a certain number of years

This does indeed seem completely impossible and unreasonable, and an argument against the validity of translation-related healthcare.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:54

If you want to justify the introduction of new policy for policing facilities on the basis of gender presentation, surely you need to demonstrate actual evidence of a problem?

Not just projections or theories, but actual evidence that there is an issue, beyond the odd isolated incident?

MyAmpleSheep · 11/11/2026 13:49

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:43

Are you going to claim that despite there being increasing numbers of trans-identifying people, the number of "non-passing" trans-identifying men using women's toilets has not increased?

I haven't seen any evidence that there has been a material change in the demographic composition of female facilities , with increasing numbers of people who obviously appear male, correct. Where is the evidence for this?

Just because more people are coming out as trans, it doesn't follow at all that the number of non-passing people using cross birth-sex facilities will increase.

For example, as a pp pointed out in the recent census as many as a third of all trans people identify as non-binary, it's very plausible that this group generally use toilets according to birth sex.

Indeed on these threads people love to declare that all trans men continue to use female facilities. Isn't that one of the favourite claims? And let's examine another very popular claim - that the growth in numbers of trans people is primarily among birth registered females. You do the maths...

Edited

Just because more people are coming out as trans, it doesn't follow at all that the number of non-passing people using cross birth-sex facilities will increase.

Unless a smaller proportion of them decide to do so, it really does follow.

My argument is that they have always been self-policed on the basis of passing sex, for reasons of privacy and dignity and people not wanting to draw attention to themselves.
This is how it has always worked, it has worked absolutely fine until now (with the odd exception perhaps as there always will be), and it can continue to work just fine moving forward.

This sounds very much like you feel non-passing trans-identifying people should not use cross-sex toilets. Because what really has changed in recent years is the idea (albeit incorrect in fact) that bathrooms are not divided up by appearance of sex, but now fashionably by inner gender identity, and it's no longer necessary on a practical basis remotely to pass as a woman to use a women's toilet.

As a response to the idea that toilets are chosen by inner gender identity, we want them to go back to the actually correct idea that they're chosen by sex, and not even by appearance of sex.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:43

MyAmpleSheep · 11/11/2026 13:37

Are you going to claim that despite there being increasing numbers of trans-identifying people, the number of "non-passing" trans-identifying men using women's toilets has not increased?

That would be quite extraordinary: it would mean either that the proportion of trans people who "pass" has increased, or that the proportion of trans-identifying people who use the incorrect toilet for their sex has decreased, or some combination of the two. Both of those would need to be evidenced!

I am quite content to understand that:

  • the number of trans-identifying men has recently increased
  • the proportion of trans-identifying men who don't "pass" is either the same or recently increased (likely the same)
  • the proportion of trans-identifying men who use the incorrect toilet for their sex is either the same, or increased recently

and therefore it holds that the number of of non-passing trans-identifying men using the incorrect toilet for their sex recently has increased.

Edited

Are you going to claim that despite there being increasing numbers of trans-identifying people, the number of "non-passing" trans-identifying men using women's toilets has not increased?

I haven't seen any evidence that there has been a material change in the demographic composition of female facilities , with increasing numbers of people who obviously appear male, correct. Where is the evidence for this?

Just because more people are coming out as trans, it doesn't follow at all that the number of non-passing people using cross birth-sex facilities will increase.

For example, as a pp pointed out in the recent census as many as a third of all trans people identify as non-binary, it's very plausible that this group generally use toilets according to birth sex.

Indeed on these threads people love to declare that all trans men continue to use female facilities. Isn't that one of the favourite claims? And let's examine another very popular claim - that the growth in numbers of trans people is primarily among birth registered females. You do the maths...

MyAmpleSheep · 11/11/2026 13:37

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 12:50

I mean if this is your source of evidence no wonder you are in a panic. I wonder what else you are panicking about!

Are you going to claim that despite there being increasing numbers of trans-identifying people, the number of "non-passing" trans-identifying men using women's toilets has not increased?

That would be quite extraordinary: it would mean either that the proportion of trans people who "pass" has increased, or that the proportion of trans-identifying people who use the incorrect toilet for their sex has decreased, or some combination of the two. Both of those would need to be evidenced!

I am quite content to understand that:

  • the number of trans-identifying men has recently increased
  • the proportion of trans-identifying men who don't "pass" is either the same or recently increased (likely the same)
  • the proportion of trans-identifying men who use the incorrect toilet for their sex is either the same, or increased recently

and therefore it holds that the number of of non-passing trans-identifying men using the incorrect toilet for their sex recently has increased.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:30

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 13:23

My argument is that they have always been self-policed on the basis of passing sex, for reasons of privacy and dignity and people not wanting to draw attention to themselves.

So implicitly that only works if you believe people who don't pass shouldn't or don't want to use women's facilities. I'm just following your logic, but it's as though you don't quite know what to do with the majority of the trans community who either can't or don't organise their lives around passing.

My argument is simply that it has worked well up until now and can continue to do so.

I know you think that trans people are deeply nefarious, but the vast majority of trans people are ordinary people like anyone else, who value, privacy, dignity and not drawing unwanted attention to themselves. They chose what toilet to use for the same reasons you do - for privacy, dignity and safety.

Passing is very important to the majority of trans people. And they will understandably want to avoid situations where they will obviously stand out/ not pass and potentially put themselves in an unsafe situation.

It's one of the challenges that in order to access transition-related healthcare you have to demonstrate that you have been "living in your gender" for a certain number of years - this can be incredibly uncomfortable for very obvious reasons.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 13:23

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:17

I'm not in the business of prescribing what other people should do based on sex/ gender.

The question we are debating is whether female spaces require policing.

My argument is that they have always been self-policed on the basis of passing sex, for reasons of privacy and dignity and people not wanting to draw attention to themselves.

This is how it has always worked, it has worked absolutely fine until now (with the odd exception perhaps as there always will be), and it can continue to work just fine moving forward.

And that, therefore, there is no justification/ need whatsoever for draconian new enforcement measures than can only rely on gender presentation and will only single out gender non-conforming people, regardless of whether they are trans. Hence this thread.

Edited

My argument is that they have always been self-policed on the basis of passing sex, for reasons of privacy and dignity and people not wanting to draw attention to themselves.

So implicitly that only works if you believe people who don't pass shouldn't or don't want to use women's facilities. I'm just following your logic, but it's as though you don't quite know what to do with the majority of the trans community who either can't or don't organise their lives around passing.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:17

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 13:10

That doesn't answer my question.

Are you arguing that men who identify as women but don't pass should not use women's toilets?

I'm not in the business of prescribing what other people should do based on sex/ gender.

The question we are debating is whether female spaces require policing.

My argument is that they have always been self-policed on the basis of passing sex, for reasons of privacy and dignity and people not wanting to draw attention to themselves.

This is how it has always worked, it has worked absolutely fine until now (with the odd exception perhaps as there always will be), and it can continue to work just fine moving forward.

And that, therefore, there is no justification/ need whatsoever for draconian new enforcement measures than can only rely on gender presentation and will only single out gender non-conforming people, regardless of whether they are trans. Hence this thread.

TheHereticalOne · 11/11/2026 13:17

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 13:10

That doesn't answer my question.

Are you arguing that men who identify as women but don't pass should not use women's toilets?

🍿

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 13:16

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:13

DU expressly asked permission from her employer, she didn't just wander in there. Clearly NHS fife should have made better arrangements, although notable that there were no other formal complaints and no one else testified to having an issue at the tribunal. However, for the sake of SP and DU NHS fife should have handled the issue more carefully.

Goodness, a reasonable response! Not sure it jives with other things you’ve written but I’ll take it.

TheHereticalOne · 11/11/2026 13:15

dementedpixie · 08/11/2026 13:29

I"m sure once she spoke she would have been identified as female.

Are you saying that because one woman was misidentified we should let all men into the female toilets @MintBird?

taptaptap @MintBird ?

Is that your solution?

Do tell!

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:13

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 13:04

Like Dr Upton, for eg, eh @Lacksie

DU expressly asked permission from her employer, she didn't just wander in there. Clearly NHS fife should have made better arrangements, although notable that there were no other formal complaints and no one else testified to having an issue at the tribunal. However, for the sake of SP and DU NHS fife should have handled the issue more carefully.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 13:13

NowSober · 11/11/2026 13:12

What absolute bollocks. I'm a man & a few weeks ago was in a pub where I did accidentally go into the Ladies. One of the bar staff spotted me going in & before I could enter a cubicle came in & said "Excuse me, did you know this is the lLadies?" That is absolutely the correct language if you spot a man in the Ladies.

Edited

To be fair, pubs do often have very confusing novelty signs for toilets.

NowSober · 11/11/2026 13:12

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 09:49

The language is normal, but the content is not. Asking a person if they are in the correct toilet is patronising and rude. It is not at all normal.

Your examples only highlight this further as they are all to do with the recipient’s behaviour having a direct, adverse impact on the asker- taken your handbag, blocking the door you need to go through, jumping a queue you are in.

What absolute bollocks. I'm a man & a few weeks ago was in a pub where I did accidentally go into the Ladies. One of the bar staff spotted me going in & before I could enter a cubicle came in & said "Excuse me, did you know this is the lLadies?" That is absolutely the correct language if you spot a man in the Ladies.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 13:10

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:06

Has your experience been that female toilets and changing rooms in the UK are inclusive of people who are obviously men?

That doesn't answer my question.

Are you arguing that men who identify as women but don't pass should not use women's toilets?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.