Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Woman with alopecia accused of being male while using female toilet at Tesco

1000 replies

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:24

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/gateshead-woman-alopecia-accused-being-34873020

"The 37-year-old, who has had the hair loss condition since she was a child, said she was left shocked when a cleaner at the Trinity Square shop asked her "Are you aware you're in the female toilet?" She said she became distressed and burst into tears."

But I thought people "could always tell"?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
Lacksie · 12/11/2026 10:28

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 15:01

Except you are advocating for mixed sex services if a facility can be used by anyone. (Although I'm still not quite clear what you think people should do if they don't pass). I'm not sure what you think changed in 2025.

This is the problem though - you refuse to accept the arrangement that we've always had is even possible.

Through my whole lifetime there have been services for women/ girls, populated by women/ girls. There has never been any policing of access to these facilities - it has been managed through social convention, with trans people using facilities according to their gender and stage of transition. This is the way it's always been.

Pingponghavoc · 12/11/2026 09:36

The hardest place for a 'doll' to pass is in a female only environment. A very feminine man will still stand out, because a feminine man isnt like a feminine women or a masculine presenting women.

The 'stealth trans' is a big assumption, too.

Margaret may pass, but we all knew him as Derek or remember when he didn't pass,we cant forget that he's a man. Regardless of the surgery and drugs, Hunter Schafer can never be stealth.

The majority of trans arent famous, but they will be known by their family, old friends, work colleagues, other regulars in pubs.

There are trans people who claim to transition then move countries, or have transitioned so young no one knows, but these are very extreme situations. That cannot be practical for the majority.

Heggettypeg · 12/11/2026 02:31

The "trans community" doesn't exactly seem to be united on the toilet front, (other than agreeing that women shouldn't have any say in the matter).

One lot seem to be saying " We feel like a woman so we are entitled to use the Ladies' whatever we look like and the Ladies will just have to put up and shut up."

Another lot seem to be saying " I am entitled to use the Ladies' because I look like a woman and the Ladies won't know."

So which is it? Do the Bricks know that (some of?) the Dolls seem to be happy to throw them under the bus to get what they want for themselves?

The whole thing is further absurdified because the Dolls-only argument treats "passing" as though it's a once and for all thing - either you pass or you don't. It isn't. It's something that either happens, or doesn't, every time you encounter another person and every time you re-encounter a person you've met before. You might fool A and B but not C. And fool A today but not A tomorrow (or thereafter). And then A might talk to B - if C hadn't already done so. And they won't necessarily tell you that they know. Passing isn't a static state or secure category. You can't know for sure that you've passed today and you can't know that you'll pass tomorrow.

So any idea that there's a "compromise" position that involves accepting transwomen who pass doesn't really work. You can't get a pass to say that you pass, so it's on self-assessment by an interested party who may be mistaken.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 11/11/2026 22:10

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 16:19

YY, this actually comes out in some of the oral evidence to the parliamentary Trans Equality Inquiry in 2015. It was tacitly understood that most TIMs didn’t use the ladies.

And yet time and time again someone will say (as an argument against single sex spaces for women) that trans identifying males have "always" used them.

In this case "always" (must) = "for less than a century", because earlier than that there were no trans identifying males as they are now recognised. Castrati, yes, eunuchs, yes, but trans as now recognised did not exist.

When someone says something like "what we have had all my life", my response is always to wonder "and when were you born?" Women being expected to accept men in female garb and lippy and wigs into their single sex spaces is recent: this century, and not even all this century. Calling them out becoming a hate crime is recent (and now thank goodness seems to have died a death).

MarieDeGournay · 11/11/2026 17:34

In fairness, LiberteLynx, SP's brave stand DID make a difference, it drew national attention to the issue, NHS Fife were found to have been in the wrong, and they were forced to make their women-only facilities biological women only.

There have been some advances, but not nearly enough obviously, and at huge personal cost to the likes of SP🙁

MyAmpleSheep · 11/11/2026 17:21

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:51

yes but what you are failing to understand is I'm not advocating for universal/ mixed sex services. Im simply advocating for what we have had all my life and did so up until 2025.

What we had all your like are de-facto mixed services, and you are advocating for them.

That may have worked when there were 12 men who used women’s toilets. It doesn’t work when there are 120,000, and the idea is so well-known that some nefarious men seize the opportunity for nefarious purposes. Nobody knew they could do that and get away with it, previously. Now they can and do.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 16:19

Pingponghavoc · 11/11/2026 16:17

I agree. Im old and it wasn't a thing. The idea that a man could stand in the queue in the 70s or 80s and women wouldnt say anything is pure fantasy. Its what transvestites say to each other, not what happened. There wasnt any 'understanding'.

If there was, why have we forgotten that understanding? Why would there have been a need for signs reminding us not to assume anyone's gender in uni loos? Why wouldnt the EqA explicitly say SSE includes these men?

I suspect it was men in gay nights in clubs, not tesco. Its only always happened since TRA told us so via stonewall and the government since 2015.

YY, this actually comes out in some of the oral evidence to the parliamentary Trans Equality Inquiry in 2015. It was tacitly understood that most TIMs didn’t use the ladies.

Pingponghavoc · 11/11/2026 16:17

Keeptoiletssafe · 11/11/2026 15:43

Can I also just repeat - it wasn’t a thing that lots of men were going into women’s toilets.I have read so many books and reports on toilets by experts on provision. Men didn’t go in unless they were cleaners or up to no good. To be blunt: the police would have been informed and notices put up.

I agree. Im old and it wasn't a thing. The idea that a man could stand in the queue in the 70s or 80s and women wouldnt say anything is pure fantasy. Its what transvestites say to each other, not what happened. There wasnt any 'understanding'.

If there was, why have we forgotten that understanding? Why would there have been a need for signs reminding us not to assume anyone's gender in uni loos? Why wouldnt the EqA explicitly say SSE includes these men?

I suspect it was men in gay nights in clubs, not tesco. Its only always happened since TRA told us so via stonewall and the government since 2015.

Keeptoiletssafe · 11/11/2026 15:43

Can I also just repeat - it wasn’t a thing that lots of men were going into women’s toilets.I have read so many books and reports on toilets by experts on provision. Men didn’t go in unless they were cleaners or up to no good. To be blunt: the police would have been informed and notices put up.

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 15:42

You all know Sandie Peggi

After being a nice girl and asking the TW to leave or use another changing area. After still being nice and talking to her NHS manager about having someone in management talk to the TW. After being thrown under the bus, doxxed, harrassed and death threated, she was pushed out of her job. Now she is fighting an employment tribunal appeal.

That is where believing in some long dead social contract and being nice and civil gets you. In a civil court fighting for your job.

This needs to be a criminal offence. The time to fight for it is now since the Supreme Court ruling on biological sex. I will document and report to the establishment CSO and the police every incidence I experience. If random cyclists can take photos of people using their mobiles in their cars and the police are happy to issue fines, then they will come round and as the data piles up, oh look this man who attacked that woman/girl has numerous reports logged regarding their obsession with provocatively using the women’s toilets it will get the attention it deserves.

When I was young people viewed flashers as harmless and upskirting was just a bit of a lark. We changed these attitudes by reporting and then it got linked to more serious offences and then society suddenly realised what we all know- these are how predators test the waters and work themselves up to the serious offences. Attitudes are not going to change on our say so, but an avalanche of data they eventually cannot ignore.

Keeptoiletssafe · 11/11/2026 15:34

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:51

yes but what you are failing to understand is I'm not advocating for universal/ mixed sex services. Im simply advocating for what we have had all my life and did so up until 2025.

I am assuming from your reply that you are a man going into women’s toilets.

I would like you to understand this:

The response many organisations, including schools, had was to change the traditional single sex designs to unregulated ones that hadn’t be seen in provision before.

You may like the door and partition gaps as much as I do, but that won’t happen in mixed sex environments because of male voyeurism and everyone’s comfort and dignity.

Look at the ‘gender-neutral’ downgrades. The quick ‘fix’ is to make the cubicles private in design. Misuse increases. The length of time it takes to find anyone in trouble increases. They are not as well ventilated and pathogens increase as they can’t be cleaned as thoroughly. These are all design points known about and documented for years.

I can directly link a change in design to many real life incidents, including deaths.

I believe you are safer in a traditional men’s toilet than a ‘gender neutral’ or universal design. Most men are good men and they would assist you if they knew you were in trouble. This doesn’t mean all men’s toilets are great. My husband doesn’t like going in to certain toilets on away day matches. I haven’t been that keen going into certain women’s toilets for many different reasons. A large % of the population will not use public toilets at all. But you need to leave women’s toilets alone because otherwise their very designs change for the worse.

You will also be safer in an accessible toilet which is the original mixed sex ‘third space’ due to pull cord alarms and the fact they have rules on where they have to be located. You are allowed to be in one and you are not singled out as a trans person. Stonewall say over 50% of trans people have disabilities so they will be crossover too.

What I would like to see is more single sex accessible toilets within single sex provision so it is inclusive of people who need these toilets so they get the benefits of single sex design too. Many people who need accessible design are not in wheelchairs or if they are, don’t need assistance to transfer.

I look at all demographics. Private designs are worse. I am looking out for your safety too.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 15:31

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 11/11/2026 15:21

There is definitely a bait and switch approach being trialled by TRAs now.

Bait - the harmless, fully 'transitioned' Dolls who pass seemlessly and have graced women's spaces since the beginning of time.
Switch - the Bricks, who will definitely, absolutely, pinkie promise not use women's spaces until they have 'socially and medically transitioned', posted their photo on reddit and been told 'yeah, of course you pass, girl'.

Also option 3 - the man whose gender is in a liminal space and who wants to disabuse you of your heteronormative expectations that he might respect your boundaries.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 15:22

Absolutely @HenriettaSwanLeavitt3

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 11/11/2026 15:21

There is definitely a bait and switch approach being trialled by TRAs now.

Bait - the harmless, fully 'transitioned' Dolls who pass seemlessly and have graced women's spaces since the beginning of time.
Switch - the Bricks, who will definitely, absolutely, pinkie promise not use women's spaces until they have 'socially and medically transitioned', posted their photo on reddit and been told 'yeah, of course you pass, girl'.

StealthTroublemaker · 11/11/2026 15:13

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 13:30

My argument is simply that it has worked well up until now and can continue to do so.

I know you think that trans people are deeply nefarious, but the vast majority of trans people are ordinary people like anyone else, who value, privacy, dignity and not drawing unwanted attention to themselves. They chose what toilet to use for the same reasons you do - for privacy, dignity and safety.

Passing is very important to the majority of trans people. And they will understandably want to avoid situations where they will obviously stand out/ not pass and potentially put themselves in an unsafe situation.

It's one of the challenges that in order to access transition-related healthcare you have to demonstrate that you have been "living in your gender" for a certain number of years - this can be incredibly uncomfortable for very obvious reasons.

Edited

So how exactly, without using outdated sexist stereotypes, does one “live in their acquired gender”? Because we have been told repeatedly that being trans is not about upholding gender stereotypes, so how does one show one’s gender without recourse to these stereotypes?

MarieDeGournay · 11/11/2026 15:04

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:51

yes but what you are failing to understand is I'm not advocating for universal/ mixed sex services. Im simply advocating for what we have had all my life and did so up until 2025.

What happened in 2025 that it suddenly became acceptable for men, any men, to use women-only facilities?
They should have been keeping out from Day 1 to 2025, and if some of them got away with it in the past, or are still getting away with it, what's that got to do with anything?
It's like someone complaining that they always used to park on that double yellow line for years, and nobody ever minded, but then in 2025 some draconian jobsworth put a parking ticket on their windscreen...

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 11/11/2026 15:01

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:51

yes but what you are failing to understand is I'm not advocating for universal/ mixed sex services. Im simply advocating for what we have had all my life and did so up until 2025.

It went under the radar and now it is firmly on the radar and women (and men) are saying NO. 'Lacksie didn't notice it happening back in the day' is not an argument.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 15:01

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:51

yes but what you are failing to understand is I'm not advocating for universal/ mixed sex services. Im simply advocating for what we have had all my life and did so up until 2025.

Except you are advocating for mixed sex services if a facility can be used by anyone. (Although I'm still not quite clear what you think people should do if they don't pass). I'm not sure what you think changed in 2025.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 14:59

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:37

i understand that you and others
mind a great deal in principle . But how many times in life has this been an issue for you in practice? Yes there are cases, but they are rare and anedoctal. I'm not saying things are perfect all the time- life doesn't work like that, but where is the evidence that this is actually an issue in practice beyond a few isolated cases? Where is The evidence That justifies new guidance for policing facilities- with all the consequences that will bring. Including for trans people. In practice in everyday contexts people will be singled out according to gender presentation regardless of whether they are trans - just like in the OP.where is the evidence that will work any better and cause any less harm. Where is the evidence of prior harm beyond people being outraged in principle on social media ?

Edited

Where is The evidence That justifies new guidance for policing facilities

There is nothing new about being asked "Sorry, did you know this is the ladies?".

People on this thread have told you that this has happened to them and they lived to tell the tale.

Legislation has to be coherent and a single sex facility that can be used by anyone is just mixed sex. It's not fair on anyone to have unclear rules.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 11/11/2026 14:52

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:37

i understand that you and others
mind a great deal in principle . But how many times in life has this been an issue for you in practice? Yes there are cases, but they are rare and anedoctal. I'm not saying things are perfect all the time- life doesn't work like that, but where is the evidence that this is actually an issue in practice beyond a few isolated cases? Where is The evidence That justifies new guidance for policing facilities- with all the consequences that will bring. Including for trans people. In practice in everyday contexts people will be singled out according to gender presentation regardless of whether they are trans - just like in the OP.where is the evidence that will work any better and cause any less harm. Where is the evidence of prior harm beyond people being outraged in principle on social media ?

Edited

Where is the evidence that it is a problem for trans-identified people to use the facilities provided for their sex or gender neutral facilities? None.

All polling shows that the majority of people want and prefer single-sex spaces (sex, not gender) to any of the other alternatives.

I'm confident that most trans-identified people will continue to respect that, and so the ones who don't will be the ones that particularly need to be called out. I imagine most gnc people will continue to accept some minor embarrassment on occassion as the price to pay for reinforcing the social contract that says adult men do not get to use the single-sex spaces that teenage girls are using.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 14:51

Keeptoiletssafe · 11/11/2026 14:47

@Lacksie you are wrong about safety in toilets. I spend a long time looking at evidence for all demographics.

It can be demonstrated clearly that the evidence about transwomen feeling unsafe in toilets, was because of an incident where two women shouted at a man to get out from women’s toilets and tried to push him out.

The man felt unsafe in the women’s toilets. It’s illogical that this is what transwomen are campaigning for if it’s about safety, as this is the very place they were ‘physically assaulted’. The only logical explanation is they want to use the women’s toilets without women being allowed to complain.

The significance of this anecdote in a piece of Stonewall literature is it was used thousands and thousands of times to demonstrate transwomen were ‘unsafe’ in toilets - in fact in most responses in a government consultation for toilet provision. Stonewall and affiliated associations coordinated the response from their supporters so much so that it appeared only 3% of the public wanted disabled (accessible) toilets.

In contrast there are deaths, injuries and sexual assaults happening to other demographics, where a certain single sex design enables a more favourable outcome. But only in a single sex environment.

Transmen tend to prefer unisex/universal designs. These are less safe than single sex designs and less hygienic. However, because of all the protesting more venues are getting universal designs. It seems the easy fix. It’s not.

In terms of toilet provision safety, in absolute terms, it’s making it worse for everyone. Particularly for those who are most vulnerable in toilets which are those who are medically vulnerable, women and children.

yes but what you are failing to understand is I'm not advocating for universal/ mixed sex services. Im simply advocating for what we have had all my life and did so up until 2025.

Keeptoiletssafe · 11/11/2026 14:47

@Lacksie you are wrong about safety in toilets. I spend a long time looking at evidence for all demographics.

It can be demonstrated clearly that the evidence about transwomen feeling unsafe in toilets, was because of an incident where two women shouted at a man to get out from women’s toilets and tried to push him out.

The man felt unsafe in the women’s toilets. It’s illogical that this is what transwomen are campaigning for if it’s about safety, as this is the very place they were ‘physically assaulted’. The only logical explanation is they want to use the women’s toilets without women being allowed to complain.

The significance of this anecdote in a piece of Stonewall literature is it was used thousands and thousands of times to demonstrate transwomen were ‘unsafe’ in toilets - in fact in most responses in a government consultation for toilet provision. Stonewall and affiliated associations coordinated the response from their supporters so much so that it appeared only 3% of the public wanted disabled (accessible) toilets.

In contrast there are deaths, injuries and sexual assaults happening to other demographics, where a certain single sex design enables a more favourable outcome. But only in a single sex environment.

Transmen tend to prefer unisex/universal designs. These are less safe than single sex designs and less hygienic. However, because of all the protesting more venues are getting universal designs. It seems the easy fix. It’s not.

In terms of toilet provision safety, in absolute terms, it’s making it worse for everyone. Particularly for those who are most vulnerable in toilets which are those who are medically vulnerable, women and children.

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 14:42

These guys won't take "no" for an answer.

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 14:41

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 12:52

I get it you think that trans people are nefarious. Very well aware. That's besides the point.

We were discussing whether enforcement is required to manage access to facilities.

We are talking about men.....trying to disguise this fact behind the term 'trans' does not fool anyone.

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 14:40

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 12:44

Yes, but that included passing trans people using facilities in accordance with their gender?

That genie is well and truly out of the bottle now, though. It was never legitimate anyway - but if it occured it occured before the advent of trans activism made people far more conscious of the issue.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.