Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Ireland: Quashing Gender Identity Ideology

8 replies

FanOfGailDines · 05/11/2026 21:28

There is enough momentum: we just need to keep it up! Suggestions welcome for things to post, conversation starter ideas when out with the dog or in the supermarket, email subjects for Ministers etc.

I'll start. Send this link:
s
Movie starts some way in, maybe 30 minutes in.
Everybody in County Clare where I live has a relative in Oz. Sending this link to WhatsApp groups and other Social Media would be a great start. Everyone can watch a film. And the sports stuff will get people realising this isn't a niche topic and the education stuff that is so clearly paralleled in Ireland.

Also, I was in Brussels on Tuesday listening to speakers organised by Athena Forum. Great night. Strong Irish representation. They have brilliant explanatory materials on the way in which Gender Identity Ideology is bumping up against the rights of women and children. That would be excellent to send to politicians.

Join us for the global Premiere of Who Decides Film.

The debate we're not supposed to have!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=416s&v=NFE9q-l8vIQ

OP posts:
FanOfGailDines · 05/11/2026 22:20

The link to the Australian film Who Decides says age restricted but I found it easy to play on YouTube. Recommended.

OP posts:
FanOfGailDines · 06/11/2026 11:08

An aspect of this that I think is good to point out to people is that the trans lobby do not believe in parental rights. Evidence of this would be the Conversion Practices Draft Bill in UK.

https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

Also, talking to people about the madness of WPATH 8 Standards of Care (World Professional Association for transgender Care) which has a chapter on Eunuch Identity and recommends no age restrictions on drugs or surgery. So if a child decides they have a Eunuch Identity then the only kind response as a parent or teacher or medical professional is to affirm them in that identity and hopefully there would be 'good healthcare' meaning that boy could be put straight on puberty blockers at 9 years old and then have body bits removed. I suppose a girl could decide to be a Eunuch too. Any identity possible. Why not a different race or age or animal?

BelongTo and TENI want Ireland to follow WPATH. BelongTo are on the cloth bags in Supervalu when you check out.

Submit evidence to the Conversion Practices Bill committee

The joint committee on the government’s draft Conversion Practices Bill has issued its call for written evidence. The deadline is Monday 16th November

https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

OP posts:
Emilesgran · 06/11/2026 17:16

FanOfGailDines · 06/11/2026 11:08

An aspect of this that I think is good to point out to people is that the trans lobby do not believe in parental rights. Evidence of this would be the Conversion Practices Draft Bill in UK.

https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

Also, talking to people about the madness of WPATH 8 Standards of Care (World Professional Association for transgender Care) which has a chapter on Eunuch Identity and recommends no age restrictions on drugs or surgery. So if a child decides they have a Eunuch Identity then the only kind response as a parent or teacher or medical professional is to affirm them in that identity and hopefully there would be 'good healthcare' meaning that boy could be put straight on puberty blockers at 9 years old and then have body bits removed. I suppose a girl could decide to be a Eunuch too. Any identity possible. Why not a different race or age or animal?

BelongTo and TENI want Ireland to follow WPATH. BelongTo are on the cloth bags in Supervalu when you check out.

Thats something that puzzles me with respect to Ireland going all-in like this: the constitution gives far more rights to parents than, say the UK would do. To the extent that children have been left in terrible situations in the past because of parental rights.

So how can they manage to just ignore that to fulfill this ideological goal? They can’t really believe that children can change sex, so they must be doing it knowing that it is all in service of a lie?

FanOfGailDines · 07/11/2026 17:18

This is from the Athena Forum Report on How Gender Identity is Reshaping Europe. P23 on the Council of Europe:

2024 CofE Commissioner for Human Rights releases an updated Issue Paper, Human Rights and Gender Identity and Expression, reaffirming the 2009 framework and expanding it further. The report promotes legal self-ID (including for minors and "a third gender category"), access to single-sex spaces based on self-ID, and inclusion of trans identified men in female sports categories.

Trans-identified men in female sports would be overwhelmingly rejected by the Irish Population and most elected officials. Ireland has the presidency of the council of Europe and many European leaders coming to Dublin on the 12th November. Now would be a good time to ask that this be addressed at those meetings or quietly talked about over canapés.

If Irish women are competing abroad there should be fairness. Ireland is a sporting nation. The women of Ireland won't tolerate this. It is obviously cracked to have men in women's sports. I talked to a swimmer today who had to compete some years ago against a boy identifying as a girl. He, of course, took gold that race. There was outrage. That doesn't happen now in Swim Ireland but it should not be on the Council of Europes Framework for Human Rights and Gender Identity Expression. Makes a laughing stock of Human Rights.

OP posts:
FanOfGailDines · 08/11/2026 16:09

This article from The Telegraph could be sent to Ministers such as Norma Foley or anyone who looks enthusiastic about a Conversion Practices Bill in Ireland to give them pause. Then they can kick it into the grass that is so long it will never see the light of day. They might not be so enthused about pushing this kind of thing if they think they are going to get lots of kick back in Ireland. Pushing something that is anti-parent and anti-safeguarding is a bad look.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/667f405142aa53f7

Labour MPs urge Burnham to scrap trans bill

Fears that parents could be criminalised for having honest conversations with children

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/667f405142aa53f7

OP posts:
FanOfGailDines · 08/11/2026 18:38

Please look at Athena Forum Website. They are doing fantastic work in Europe. Helen Joyce was speaking at a night they organised in Brussels last Tuesday. As was the very inspiring Anna Kalvig from Norway.
https://athena-forum.eu
The U.K. is part of the Council of Europe and European Decisions have an impact in the U.K. Obviously, Ireland needs to get involved with this organisation. Particularly since there is a perception that those speaking out for sex-based rights and those that are questioning gender identity ideology are from the Right but Athena Forum is set up by an ex Green politician from Austria who is a lesbian. Irish politicians need to be made aware that there are many people who are left leaning and LGB who are pushing back against this malignant ideology.

Athena Forum

Become a founding supporter 🎉 To keep our work going, we need regular donations that give stability to our work and allow us to grow. With 200 supporters we can get started. With 300 supporters we can plan ahead and become more sustainable. With 500 s...

https://athena-forum.eu

OP posts:
FanOfGailDines · 11/11/2026 11:02

Tomorrow holds a couple of opportunities:

European leaders are visiting Dublin Castle and many elected officials in Ireland will be in conversation with each other. They should be talking about keeping women's sports for women amongst other things. But that particular conversation is easy to explain and highlights where rights are bumping up against each other.

Also, there will be teachers striking. Last time they were on strike I talked to a big group of teachers standing outside our local secondary school. It is a rare opportunity to have a conversation with teachers. They are not busy. They are there to talk. They are on the street. By and large they don't know about the Cass Review or that BelongTo don't pay attention to the recommendations of Cass. They don't know that organisations such as BelongTo and TENI are ignoring detransitioners. They don't know that Eunuch Identity and no age restrictions are part of the WPATH Standards of Care and WPATH is what TENI and BelongTo want to follow for Ireland. They haven't thought that there is no such thing as a trans child actually or that gender identity ideology is just an idea and shouldn't be taught as fact. They know that a man can't be a woman and vice versa but they think everyone else knows that too because of course you can't actually change sex. They haven't thought of trans a bit like anorexia or that you can't suddenly take on a black identity if you are white or a horse identity if you are human. Or if you do then that is up to you but that should not be backed up in the curriculum and not everyone should be made to be part of your role play in fear of being called horrid names like a bigot and a bully. They shouldn't be having Stand Up Week. I could go on but people are busy, they think this stuff is niche and doesn't really matter too much but...

tomorrow teachers are not busy! And it does matter.

OP posts:
FanOfGailDines · 13/11/2026 19:37

I've been recommending Who Decides film on You Tube to people I meet on a dog walk or at the supermarket. I explain what it is about. I've yet to get any push back from any adults when I express concern about institutional capture and not being able to openly discuss things.
I have been called a bigot and more by secondary school kids of the older year groups when I asked, for example, what the difference was between taking on a black identity when I am white or a male identity when I am female? That brought on the name calling. He felt sorry for my kids etc. I'd give those boys quite a lot of credit though as they were able to make a case and argue a point and also were open to discussion. We parted on friendly terms.
You are pretty safe to have an easy chat in most of Ireland outside the cities and or to those who have recently been in education.
But still, by and large, people know that they can't change sex here. We need to keep talking so that they know they can say that too without getting in trouble.

whodecidesfilm.com/#full-film

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread