Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Protest HP shop London

221 replies

LifeMakesMyFaceAche · 04/11/2026 23:29

Today I was in London and I walked past the brand-new Harry Potter shop in Oxford Street. I could see lots of families heading towards the shop. There was also about 16 protesters outside the shop.

I’ve seen lots protests in London and other cities over the years but this really really upset me especially as it involved families and children. Just going to do something nice in London.

The thing that upset me the most was that you could tell there was some tweens looking a bit upset who were clearly dressed in Harry Potter accessories but reluctant to join the queue I noticed more than one in tears with a parent. There was one poor police officer to monitor it, and even though there was only 16 pro testers they seemed very very loud and very, very intimidating.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
thegoodnews · 05/11/2026 07:34

Waitingfordoggo · 05/11/2026 07:25

I don’t see the connection @thegoodnews . JKR says that men are a danger to women (statistically we can all see that this is true). When men say that they are women, how are we to know if they are ‘genuinely’ trans, or just using the ideology as a way to access women’s spaces? Trump’s comments on Mexicans not relevant.

You also haven’t given your view on the lack of middle aged FTM transitioners.

I don’t see the connection

Then read some Harry Potter.

You also haven’t given your view on the lack of middle aged FTM transitioners.

Not related to this thread.

thirdfiddle · 05/11/2026 07:34

Her original statement is sympathetic to trans people while explaining why women sometimes need male free spaces. Her most recent essay spells it out very carefully indeed to avoid just the sort of misinterpretation people on this thread are attempting.

Some men are a risk, some TW are a risk, some men who are a risk say they are TW and who knows what's going on in their heads. Giving women single sex spaces makes women safer. Letting in any man who says he wants to come in renders the precaution entirely ineffective.

EmpressaurusKitty · 05/11/2026 07:35

If you go by those ridiculous I AM WHO I SAY I AM posters then we’d have to believe any man who says he’s trans. Including the likes of Sarah Jane Baker, Isla Bryson, Katie Dolatowski…

When we have women only spaces, we can’t just let the nice genuine harmless transwomen with real female brains & fake vaginas in because there is no way to do that. Women only has to mean bio, actual women only, or it’s meaningless.

The campaign ought to be, and should always have been, for transpeople to have their own spaces or to be safe & welcome in the spaces for their own sex.

sanluca · 05/11/2026 07:37

I see that just talking about the conflict between womens rights and trans demands is not enough, @thegoodnewshas to bring in an argument around racism so try and tar JK with that brush.

JK is not saying the same thing as Trump. There is no evidence or facts to support Trumps statement whereas there are many facts that support JKs. Like rapid onset prison dysphoria: men claiming to be trans to get transferred to womens prisons that have less strict regimes and then see themselves as men again once out of prison.

That is what JK is saying: there is no way to know if a man claiming to be trans is genuine and nice, so better to keep all men out than let a man in that is abusing the notion of self ID.
If you can't see the problem with self ID I can't help you.

PoisonCrystal · 05/11/2026 07:38

Consider if the author of that article arguing from a biased perspective? I personally believe so. For example, this paragraph:

Throughout her essay, Rowling talks about how easy it is for a biological man to become a woman in the eyes of the law and how potentially dangerous that could be for cis women.

I would agree with this statement. However, the article continues:

The fear that a large number of transgender women are just men who want to be able to use women-only spaces unchecked is a harmful stereotype that paints trans people as predators instead of just human beings who want to live their lives.

At no point has JKR suggested that trans people are predators. She’s only said that by allowing some men into a space, it automatically opens up that space to all men. Therefore the space is no longer a single sex space.

I’d advise re-reading both that article and JKR’s essay, and then coming to your own conclusion.

BlueLegume · 05/11/2026 07:38

thegoodnews · 05/11/2026 07:15

The quotes in the piece are from JKR 's her essay. Maybe you should read it?

Which essay? She updates them and did so blisteringly very recently. Which one in particular are you deciding to cherry pick from @thegoodnews ? Do link it and highlight her transphobia and if possible link to the funding she provides to anti trans causes. It helps us understand.

TinyGingerCat · 05/11/2026 07:38

Funny that people who are so keen for everyone to accept gender can be non-binary only have very binary arguments about this. Apparently only gender can come in very many forms but opinions cannot be nuanced in any way shape or form. Want single sex services for biological women? Then you are the very worst kind of human no if no buts.

Kingdomofsleep · 05/11/2026 07:42

Protesting outside a shop for children's toys (and other merch) is an interesting choice.

Political protest is traditionally done in front of people with decision-making power, eg outside parliament or an embassy etc.

Protesting in front of ordinary families going into a shop won't affect anyone's decision making except those families going into the shop or not.

It's cowardly. It's also characteristic of a movement that inappropriately sees children as decision-makers.

LouisTheYardTeacher · 05/11/2026 07:42

Banging on about JKR and transphobia in 2026 is bonkers. Her views are sensible and widely held. If you're going to boycott JKR and HP for being sceptical of gender ideology you should also boycott most of humanity.

BackToLurk · 05/11/2026 07:44

thegoodnews · 05/11/2026 07:21

"When Mexico sends its people, they're not sending their best. […] They're sending people that have lots of problems, and they're bringing those problems with us. They're bringing drugs. They're bringing crime. They're rapists. And some, I assume, are good people."

-Donald Trump

Many don't disagree with Trump but all of us that are honest & sane know exactly what he's doing here.

Hello again.

drspouse · 05/11/2026 07:46

ArtieChoke · 05/11/2026 06:45

Who is saying that interpretation is correct?

AI, I suspect. AKA Reddit.

Waitingfordoggo · 05/11/2026 07:48

thegoodnews · 05/11/2026 07:34

I don’t see the connection

Then read some Harry Potter.

You also haven’t given your view on the lack of middle aged FTM transitioners.

Not related to this thread.

It is related because you believe that JKR said that transitioning can be a phase for young people, and you took exception to that.

So I am asking you to evidence that it is never a phase, and part of that is asking you to comment on the detransitioners who have acknowledged that it was a phase for them; and on the lack of middle aged FTM transitioners, because this would also give us a clue as to whether it can be a phase.

BlueLegume · 05/11/2026 07:50

Kingdomofsleep · 05/11/2026 07:42

Protesting outside a shop for children's toys (and other merch) is an interesting choice.

Political protest is traditionally done in front of people with decision-making power, eg outside parliament or an embassy etc.

Protesting in front of ordinary families going into a shop won't affect anyone's decision making except those families going into the shop or not.

It's cowardly. It's also characteristic of a movement that inappropriately sees children as decision-makers.

It was a poorly organised ‘protest’. A few sickly looking individuals including a man dressed as a girl with pink hair in bunches and a very aggressive young woman who I suspect classes herself as non binary. A few cardboard signs not really saying much.

What I took away from the protest is that society has failed these young people. If not society then the people around them who should have been safeguarding them. That or the whole trans movement has sucked them in so deep they cannot not get out of the vortex of the cult.

thegoodnews · 05/11/2026 07:51

Waitingfordoggo · 05/11/2026 07:48

It is related because you believe that JKR said that transitioning can be a phase for young people, and you took exception to that.

So I am asking you to evidence that it is never a phase, and part of that is asking you to comment on the detransitioners who have acknowledged that it was a phase for them; and on the lack of middle aged FTM transitioners, because this would also give us a clue as to whether it can be a phase.

The evidence is adult 'tom boy'/'butch' females unless you think that's a 'phase' too.

GC5 · 05/11/2026 07:53

I strongly disagree with the protestors’ views, but strongly support the right to protest - unless the protest is violent, of course.

We can’t condemn the TRAs attempts to shut down dissent yet seek to do the same.

Waitingfordoggo · 05/11/2026 07:53

Adult ‘tomboys’ and butches are not claiming to be trans. Not a phase. They are women who don’t conform to gender stereotypes, which is exactly the point JKR was making. It’s great that you’ve discovered you agree with her. ❤️

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 07:53

thegoodnews · 05/11/2026 06:38

Many fans have interpreted the books as a universal allegory for accepting marginalised outsiders so they understand her generalisations & demonisation of trans people as a betrayal. The overarching narrative of Harry Potter appears to champion the oppressed and celebrate difference, condemns prejudice particularly through the concept of "blood purity" and the dehumanising rhetoric of the Death Eaters which is in opposition to her actions.

Oh dear.

You missed the themes of totalitarianism, ideological capture and standing up to a power that wants to rewrite history then?

JKR's bravery today is exactly in line with the books she wrote.

She doesn't want to hurt trans people, she just wants the lie that a man's feelings can make him interchangeable with a female body to stop being forced onto us by our laws and institutions. She wants women to have the right to say for ourselves what it means to be us.

sanluca · 05/11/2026 07:54

Are you saying that adult butch females should always be seen as trans?

Summerlovingtheraspberries · 05/11/2026 07:56

If anything it would make me more inclined to visit the shop.
These silly men need to get a grip.

intheshadyborder · 05/11/2026 07:58

thegoodnews · 05/11/2026 06:38

Many fans have interpreted the books as a universal allegory for accepting marginalised outsiders so they understand her generalisations & demonisation of trans people as a betrayal. The overarching narrative of Harry Potter appears to champion the oppressed and celebrate difference, condemns prejudice particularly through the concept of "blood purity" and the dehumanising rhetoric of the Death Eaters which is in opposition to her actions.

Celebrating difference could mean that there are all kinds of boys/men and all kinds of girls/women and that's great, not that feeling different from other boys means you should chop your dick off and say you're a girl.

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · 05/11/2026 07:58

@thegoodnews are you Jolyon Maugham? 😂😂😂😂

Fortuity · 05/11/2026 07:59

thegoodnews · 05/11/2026 06:38

Many fans have interpreted the books as a universal allegory for accepting marginalised outsiders so they understand her generalisations & demonisation of trans people as a betrayal. The overarching narrative of Harry Potter appears to champion the oppressed and celebrate difference, condemns prejudice particularly through the concept of "blood purity" and the dehumanising rhetoric of the Death Eaters which is in opposition to her actions.

I don't fully agree with all that JKR has to say on this topic, but I'm not aware of anything that could remotely be characterised as her demonising trans people. If you are, can you give details?

LifeMakesMyFaceAche · 05/11/2026 08:01

I was angry on behalf of the families who in these lean financial times had taken a day off work to get their children to London. I was angry for the children who had something precious to them demonised by these protesters. I felt angry for the staff who are either trying to earn a living or are fans of Harry Potter! There was one staff member who was supporting the queue people and he looked so lovely.

Their chants were either repeating the word HRT over and over again or yelling at the queue that they were all transphobic or not allies because they like Harry Potter. The HRT one made me especially ragey as a menopausal woman who had had to fight tooth and nail to get HRT!

I did plan to go in there and even as an adult I felt like I couldn’t do it with them screaming at the queue.

Most of them were facing the shop but one or two were right next to the police officer and the queue. The police officer just looked bored to tears by them!

Free speech is important but I don’t see how it is legal to harass a business like this for the length of time they were there.

OP posts:
RaininSummer · 05/11/2026 08:03

I wish I lived near enough to visit the shop and see these oddballs in action.

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · 05/11/2026 08:04

BTW my adult son went to the opening yesterday and said there were about 10 TRAs and everyone bemused, amused or asking if they were Slytherin. Hundreds there for the shops and a handful of men having their tantrums on the sidelines.