Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sex Matters Hampstead Heath Ponds - Thread 2

182 replies

rebax · 04/11/2026 15:21

Next thread on second day in court

Continuation from
Sex Matters - Hampstead Heath Ponds - | Mumsnet

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:34

From TT

DS I would respectfully adopt that but my primary submission is that proportionality is assess in the real world, overwhelmingly the evidence suggests that it is just fine in the way that it seems to work.
J if TC wanted argue this was a legal ruse, it would have to fought out

in the County Court, but you say I should consider the rule as written
DS the evidence says that it does work.
J thank, points that I will have to think about.
DS to say that merely being the presence of a TW
J we are focused on the changing room

DS the ponds have been TI for more than a decade, no woman can reasonably expect this to be a same sex space. It is a wholly unreasonable expectation, give that this is a cause celebre. Particular disadvantage must be experienced by the entire class, and the individual

and that is the users of the ponds
J or those who might want to use the ponds
DS there is no evidence that women using ponds expect it to be segregated by bio sex. The overwhelming majority of women favour current arrangements and see them as advantageous. 3 types of evidence

1st is C's WS, we say they are insufficient, anecdotes from a handful of people set against the consultation process. Let me make 2 points, the results of the survey of MP members, 3.8% said privacy dignity compromised by the presence of a TM. It is an issue for men.

Kirschcherries · 04/11/2026 15:33

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:30

Looking forward to using that diving board in the men's pond.

In the nicest possible way I hope you don’t have to.

However, the man Fridays have made a clear point and if the CoL win then everyday becomes man Friday day and you get to use the diving board to your hearts content,

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:32

From TT

Second part of afternoon session, 4 Nov.

DS found it. What is characterised as a negative experience is a disagreement with the policy. We have a very small number 288 out of the entire respondents of many thousands. Those are likely to be included in MF's evidence. That's why we say it's not a simple numbers

game. If one looks at the numbers on the ground minimal evidence that would render the policy disproportionate. Finally, there is no basis for the Cs to say we are not in 158 territory. An argument that TP are free to express their gender elsewhere on the Heath. Of course

anyone can walk around on the Heath. I'm going to go on to talk about indirect discrim.
J what about the incoherence argument that the combined classes are dissimilar. Can you say something about that
DS 158 always discriminates against another group, we've got 2 vulnerable

groups according to MLF. That's not correct, most women felt that the presence of TW contribute to the environment of the LP.
J the second point, proportionality considers a less intrusive measure, and must be tailored to the aim, the arrangements are tailored to the

class of pc with GRA, but in fact is much wider than that in practice. Stewards are instructed not to question anyone's assertion of identity. A much wider group of people are being advantaged than envisaged.
DS is this too blunt an instrument is that the question

J one way to look at it, its not proportionate because you need to look at the consequences on the other protected group, women. It doesn't seem confined to the protected group
DS I would disagree, there is no evidence that this policy is being misused, for example large groups

of cis men
J you don't need to put it in alarmist terms, as I understand things no one is questioning anyone about the lived gender
DS there is no evidence that there is a group of people that are not trans who are benefitting from this policy, if there was evidence that there

were non-trans individuals benefitting from this policy, there is no evidence.
J I'll consider that, but understand I have taken from the evidence that the rule is not being enforced
DS even if there is a problem with some without the pc of the GRA, if one person went in,

that's not disproportionate, if there were large groups of people breaking the rule
J I thought you would say that TC's case is specifically about the rules, in other words the logic in that seems to be that I should assess the rule no matter what is happening on the ground

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:30

Looking forward to using that diving board in the men's pond.

Kirschcherries · 04/11/2026 15:30

Thank you @rebax for the continuation thread.

I was about to post a comment from the Judge J lived gender is not a pc

DS is arguing TP should use the pool on the basis of their gender not GRC status or even GReassignment, DS knows that it’s self id by the back door I.e. only allowing those with a GRC to use the LP is completely ridiculous.

DS is arguing for option 3 - all 3 ponds become mixed sex whilst stating option 3 is not what anyone wants. Completely contradictory.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:28

Well done thank you! Coming up

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread