Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sex Matters Hampstead Heath Ponds - Thread 2

182 replies

rebax · 04/11/2026 15:21

Next thread on second day in court

Continuation from
Sex Matters - Hampstead Heath Ponds - | Mumsnet

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:25

TC responding now for Sex Matters

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:25

From TT

gender policy would never give rise to direct discrim.
J I will think about whether I'm prepared to do that. It might not be direct discrim in law, but I'm not prepared to do that on a hypothetical.
HS it would be so valuable for you to make a finding that it is never going

to be direct discrimination if there is a rule that includes anyone who lives as a woman and excludes anyone who lives as a man.
J you want me to find that is never direct discrim on a hypothetical
[TC reminds on time]
HS, I'm aware, the reason its important is that it is

intensely important to transpeople. And finally we would ask you to adopt the language from the SC FWS decision on TW/TM rather than the SM language where they avoid those terms.
J I was just checking if my meeting is going ahead, it's not an invitation to exceed your 45 minutes

BiologicalRobot · 04/11/2026 16:22

Thank you for the new thread and for @Ereshkigalangcleg for posting TT. It's really fascinating how different it is from an employment tribunal.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:14

From TT

together, they could have said mixed gender,
J what is the alternative
HS the alternative is providing access to people who live as women, that option was very alive in this discussion, if your judgment was that there needs to be a change in policy, I invite you to state in

your decision, the boundaries of your conclusion
J what do you mean before I commit to doing it
HS there is ambiguity, between the written policy and how it is actually applied, it will be very important for service providers to understand the boundaries so would all lived gender

policies are unlawful.
J well, let see what I'm being asked by TC.
HS you are in the unenviable position of being asked to say if people are being discriminated,
J that's not what I'm being asked, I'm being asked to consider the legality of the rule
HS but if its a direct

discrim claim it can't be held to be discriminating if its not following the rule
J I'm being asked by TC to rule on the legality of the rule as written, not on how it is being applied.
HS My 3rd submission is that I would ask you to answer the question that a single rule lived

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:08

From TT

of Cole it is not direct discrim. And the secondary attack is that it cannot be justified under sec 158 because schedule 3 has filled the space and 158 is not available.
J so you're saying that if that is the position, the convention is not settled

HS indeed and its a human rights problem if that is what the law says
HS the Ds have selected an additive policy, including bio men plus trans men.
J I'm not following the point, where is it going
HS they could have worded the policy another way, they've layered two groups

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 16:08

And the benefit to many women, who won't be questioned on their gender, if they don't meet the feminine ideal of beauty. A horrible knock effect of the current environment is that we have female rugby players, politicians wives and women out of the public eye. All of these women benefit from a lighter touch policy that doesn't question. A bio woman who didn't have a conventional appearance, would face that intrusion even with timed sessions

The subtext here is 'if you are a woman and you don't meet conventional beauty standards everyone thinks you are a man but they are just tolerating you to be kind'. It's a school bully insult.

Also obviously untrue, because if women could easily pass as men, they would have taken more advantage of it.

Wishesandhorses · 04/11/2026 16:06

'you're submitting that what women feel about a bio man coming into the changing room can't be generalised'

dealt with by providing the mixed sex facilities for those fine with it, and single sex for those not.

It just is repeated 'the women unhappy and discriminated against are a minority who shouldn't have equality'

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:04

From TT

never be offered.
J I don't think that's their position
HS it is
J the argument is that there are other measures that could be taken, but address it just in case
HS as I understand it they say it cannot be justified under sec 19, it would always be direct discrim. On both limbs

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 16:03

Wishesandhorses · 04/11/2026 15:59

Its the usual thing.

Can 'women' mean 'single sex for women AND any men who want to be in there with them' despite the SCJ?

And if there's a loud representation that men and some women really want this, can the women who don't want it, are negatively affected, and would be excluded, be made not to matter?

Edited

single sex for women AND any men who want to be in there with them

I think the lack of specificity about 'trans' is a huge part of the problem with the CoL argument although I don't know whether the judge will address it in the judgement.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 16:02

From TT

they face a threshold problem in that they haven't proved that and DS showed evidence that men are more uncomfortable with TM. Referring to the survey, many women accept TI. And the benefit to many women, who won't be questioned on their gender, if they don't meet the

feminine ideal of beauty. A horrible knock effect of the current environment is that we have female rugby players, politicians wives and women out of the public eye. All of these women benefit from a lighter touch policy that doesn't question. A bio woman who didn't have a

conventional appearance, would face that intrusion even with timed sessions.
J what is the legal submission, I'm conscious of time
HS the legal submission is that the Ds are entitled to use the results of the consultation and the experience of management team, but the main

submission, is that there are many women who benefit from this regime. The claim is inviting ML to wade into this debate among women.
J you're submitting that this is the wrong question
HS yes
J is it different for trans people
HS I'm not saying SS spaces are outside the

purview of Sec 19, my main point is that the disadvantage here being relied upon is the subjective perception of one group of women
J yes I've understood that, you're submitting that what women feel about a bio man coming into the changing room can't be generalised is that what

you're saying.
HS the idea that there is a single idea that women have about TW is wrong
J there is no single view that is universally held by women about TW
HS not saying there needs to universality. Now on to HR, TC said that Strasbourg says UK has passed the GRA and

nothing more to say. But it's not a get out of jail free card forever. Second point is that since FWS, the rights of TP to access spaces for their lived gender was subject to a step change after FWS. Third if you're reading the law, that a service provider cannot offer a

service to women that includes TW, that step change is complete. The D does not consider that a bio sex policy would be necessary. The TP right to live in their lived gender is a qualified right. The C's position is that no matter the circumstances a single gender service could

OhBotherSaidPoo · 04/11/2026 16:00

Judge seems sane

Wishesandhorses · 04/11/2026 15:59

Its the usual thing.

Can 'women' mean 'single sex for women AND any men who want to be in there with them' despite the SCJ?

And if there's a loud representation that men and some women really want this, can the women who don't want it, are negatively affected, and would be excluded, be made not to matter?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:57

20 mins of Translucent coming up

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:57

From TT

and plow on with the review,
J is this all to do with costs, why are you focused on this, do you want me to look at this decision
DS we want an answer to that, yes costs are of interests, looking at the judgment of Lieven, we are not sure on whether that has been resolved

DS unless ML has questions, I have spoken for too long.
Discussion about timing; TL has until 4:10, TC needs 45 minutes in reply.
HS rises to speak for TL.
HS SS said that the evidence on disadvantage all points in one direction,

Slothtoes · 04/11/2026 15:51

Thanks for updates and second thread.
still aghast at this whole situation

Genderists who are male have two ponds. They really don’t need a third.

The rest of this discussion is then surely just to establish

  1. q. is the patriarchy alive and well?
    a. Yes, obviously

  2. then given the above is universally acknowledged fact, the need for a women’s pond that is away from men is clearly established. Nobody needs to be interested in how men on the outside of that ladies pond area self-describe, because the material point is that they are still men, and men may not come in. Men already have two ponds!

Wishesandhorses · 04/11/2026 15:50

you are seeking to justify the disadvantage experienced by bio women

Yup. He's got it.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:44

From TT

DS its a particular disadvantage that needs to be justified, I accept that
J not sure it makes a difference on the analysis
DS I don't propose to address you on relief
J we will have to come back for that
DS the reality is that it was premature for the C to pursue this

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:44

This is entirely contrary to the C's evidence that women are more disadvantaged, more men in this survey are uncomfortable than women.

Got to look after the menz.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:44

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:42

DS the ponds have been TI for more than a decade, no woman can reasonably expect this to be a same sex space.

So if I go to the pond and see a sign saying 'women only' it's up to me to understand the subtext that it is actually mixed sex?

Apparently so! It’s a single sex space not a mixed sex space but of course you shouldn’t expect it to be a single sex space, don’t be silly!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:43

From TT

reject the entire report, but there are key points here to me, the comparative disadvantage and the experience of women
DS we see this as a piece of advocacy, yes I've got that
J do you have any thing to say about fairness and timing
DS by submitting this a month before the

hearing we have had time to do nothing and it is not necessary to resolve the issues.
J thank you
DS on the disadvantage, we rely on the consultation,
J you say the have not proved their case on disadvantage
DS if there was an individual they would have to show that they

been distressed and were a user of the LP. On justification, the legitimate aims, meeting the needs of trans user, respecting Art 8 rights
J this may not make a difference, but you are seeking to justify the disadvantage experienced by bio women, what is the impact on women

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:42

DS the ponds have been TI for more than a decade, no woman can reasonably expect this to be a same sex space.

So if I go to the pond and see a sign saying 'women only' it's up to me to understand the subtext that it is actually mixed sex?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:39

Kirschcherries · 04/11/2026 15:33

In the nicest possible way I hope you don’t have to.

However, the man Fridays have made a clear point and if the CoL win then everyday becomes man Friday day and you get to use the diving board to your hearts content,

As I said on the other thread, anything goes, as long as you’re less honest about it than Man Friday were, and claim it’s sincere.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 15:38

From TT

The 2nd document is Mr W's statement, to illustrate why we can't make any assumptions here, a report by EHRC in 2020 on attitudes to TP, men would feel uncomfortable with TM using toilets and facilities. This is entirely contrary to the C's evidence that women are more

disadvantaged, more men in this survey are uncomfortable than women.
TC Can I say that we were not expecting this evidence, and if it is admitted we were want to submit rebuttal evidence.
DS now in relation to Prof Phoenix report, in flagrant breach of requirements for early

disclosure and early notice. The reason we say it's not required to resolve any of the issues, at para 29 of her report, she accepts that there is no body of research that directly addresses the issue of are women more sensitive than men, and more distressed than men in those

circumstances.
J the word directly is very important there
DS she goes into a number of areas that are not her area of expertise, including how many showers, and talks about the amenity value whilst not acknowledging they are trans inclusive.
J are you saying that I should

rebax · 04/11/2026 15:38

Argument is coming across as "we asked everybody who's fine with it, and they agreed with us"

OP posts:
nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:37

That's not correct, most women felt that the presence of TW contribute to the environment of the LP.

And what is a TW?