Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Novel centred around the publication of The Well Of Loneliness

4 replies

Scout2016 · 03/11/2026 23:55

I've just finished As A Lover by Hilary McCollum and I'm giving it a push here because I enjoyed it and thought it might be of interest. I might be wrong but I think it's from a small publishing house and won't be on the tables at Waterstones so I'm flagging it.

There are parallel narratives - Maggie, a young Irish woman in London who is realising she is a lesbian, and John (Radclyffe Hall) who we meet celebrating the publication of The Well Of Loneliness. Maggie reads it and it has a significant impact on her.

I found the social history interesting and don't worry, it's fairly light in tone and not as weary as The Well Of Loneliness. Apologies to those who love it, I read it too young and wanted better outcomes for Stephen. I was too young to really appreciate the context in which it was written. But it very much made an impression of me and I'd sought it out because of the issues around publication and the theme. I thought there may be others on here who had done likewise and would be interested.

I know nothing about McCollum but in her "author's note" she speaks of how she thinks the book is about the present as well as past - current oppression, repression, male violence, homophbia, racism and what she sees as a new era of censorship, "with speech and literature about and by lesbians particularly under attack". She appears to have done a lot of research and tried to stay faithful to facts.

https://www.hilarymccollum.com/As-a-Lover-1/

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Scout2016 · 05/11/2026 20:16

BeMoreBear · 05/11/2026 08:06

Interesting, thanks for this, haven't read The Well of Loneliness in decades. I'll see if I can get McCollum's book through the library.

I'm tempted reread and see what I make of it 30 years on, knowing what to expect this time...I did think I might try one of her other books and looked up Adam's Breed. It won awards but appears to be even more gloomy.

OP posts:
BeMoreBear · 05/11/2026 08:06

Interesting, thanks for this, haven't read The Well of Loneliness in decades. I'll see if I can get McCollum's book through the library.

Grammarnut · 04/11/2026 22:19

Thank you. I will look for it.

MarieDeGournay · 04/11/2026 01:27

Thanks for letting us know about this, Scout2016, it looks interesting, and I've got to the stage where anything that says 'lesbian' and means 'woman' is a pleasant surprise!😏