Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Mechanisms of biological sex and the social consequences thereof

155 replies

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/11/2026 18:28

A placeholder thread so I don't continue to contribute to an active derail.

Will add content as it comes to me....

OP posts:
inkymoose · 04/11/2026 17:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ReTerf · 04/11/2026 17:41

No TIM ever had to deal with getting their first menstrual period in the middle of a lesson on their first day at a new school, and then be told by the teacher that they are not permitted to go to the loo until the end of the lesson. Nor were they ever told they were a slag for going out with lots of boys, or frigid if they didn’t go out with lots of boys. They were just boys. TIM’s have never been judged and insulted by a 60 year old doctor for accessing the morning after pill as a teenager. They have never been judged for being single mothers, or asked why on earth they are childless. Nor are they constantly told they are getting motherhood wrong—from conception onwards.
TIM’s do not experience the judgement that women face for their every decision, every moment of their lives, and the blame assigned to women for the actions of men.

TIM’s can dress up real pretty though.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 17:35

theilltemperedmonster · 04/11/2026 16:28

Biological sex is so straightforward that the Supreme Court didn't even need to define it. You can prove it with a birth certificate issued before age 18. Or later, if there was a clerical error/DSD, and a marginal correction had to be applied (a maybe 1 in 20,000 occurrence). EA2010 works perfectly smoothly with DSDs too. Certificates extracted from the gender recognition register are a completely different matter. I get so sick of explaining all this, with TRAs bleating about how complex it is. It's. Not. Complex.

You know this. I know this. They know this.

They IMO exhibit the same behaviour as the type of man who thinks if he can find a loophole to argue your rejection of his advances is not logically sound, you are bound to sleep with him. It's just so fucking icky, and so fucking relentless.

They can never win on honest terms. Bceause female people, of the boring, non-exceptional, non 1% of 1% of 1% DSD type, exist.

So either woman is the name for an adult human female, in which case male people have no right to and so no business in the rights, places and language that pertain to female people, or woman is not the name for an adult human female, in which case male people who identify as women still have no business in the rights, places and language that pertain to female people.

That literally is all that needs to be said. Female people matter enough to name.

So it's just gish gallop after gish gallop, refusal to acknowledge what they and we know they understand perfectly well as if somehow refusing to admit they know exactly what we mean will make us all decide we don't experience social and physical consequences because of the sex of our body after all.

OP posts:
inkymoose · 04/11/2026 17:32

Thehorticulturalhussie · 04/11/2026 15:32

@nicepotoftea I agree and think that we are analysing the phrases used commonly by men who believe that they can become women -
' I live as a woman now'
' I have always felt like a woman'
etc

We may or may not be tomboys when we're young but as puberty looms we become aware of attracting a certain type of attention from boys and men. I was a teen in the early 70s and we suddenly became responsible for not dressing in a way likely to make us seem 'easy', for not being in certain places at certain times, for being kind, for accepting that boys will be boys. Later we would become solely responsible for not getting pregnant.

We make some of the biggest and emotional decisions around our fertility - should I have a baby now or wait until I'm older and risk leaving it too late? Should I abort the unplanned baby I'm currently carrying (unable to anticipate the lifelong guilt and regret)? We are tied to our children for life. Many men do not feel that responsibility when the going gets tough.

At any age we feel fearful when walking down a road in the dark, hearing footsteps close behind. We feel a wave of relief to find that it's a woman who's simply in a hurry.

All of the above shape our lives because we are women and cannot be acquired by men wearing our clothes.

Very much so. Well put

theilltemperedmonster · 04/11/2026 16:28

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:52

From a legal point of view It's the sex registered at birth.

Biological sex is so straightforward that the Supreme Court didn't even need to define it. You can prove it with a birth certificate issued before age 18. Or later, if there was a clerical error/DSD, and a marginal correction had to be applied (a maybe 1 in 20,000 occurrence). EA2010 works perfectly smoothly with DSDs too. Certificates extracted from the gender recognition register are a completely different matter. I get so sick of explaining all this, with TRAs bleating about how complex it is. It's. Not. Complex.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 16:22

Going back to my thoughts in starting this thread,

I notice there's a Genderist narrative being attempted that runs alongside the lines of

People recognised "women" before they had any idea of what gametes were and some women don't even produce gametes ¹ so the use of gametes in any definition of a biological woman is wrong.

This is like claiming because we can't see a cause, we can't perceive an effect. A moment's thought shows how facile that suggestion is. We don't have to know the details of stellar fusion to understand the sun lights and heats the earth, nor to see it is a different body to the moon.

Women's bodies are what they are because of a myriad of process that start with our being conceived with a set of genetic instructions that have evolved to go one way rather than another.

Our self knowledge isn't formed separate to this but within it, a complex interplay of instrinsic capabilities, internal and external expectations, opportunities and disappointments, risks and wins. You cannot separate that from our cultural understanding of a female body. Pissing about pretending that until science discovered and named gametes we didn't observe both our sex and its consequences is simply insulting, as is mugging together unrelated concepts in the hope of creating some sort of theoretical deniability that sex isn't something we all know, see and understand.

The "argument" slides from side to side, now claiming that if (big if btw) some individuals can have a flawed body map that leads them to not appreciate their physical sex in some way, it must follow that no humans can recognise they have a certain body type in common with others. Then claiming other times that human recognition is exactly how we know our sex, but only from a limited set of social signals that align to the Genderist worldview. (The Genderist concept of non-reproductive social
sex being that apparently we can't be sure of sex but by God we all notice who has the right degree of head-tilt!🤣)

(¹ ofc they mean biological women here or their argument flops, but they can't say that because we aren't supposed to be able to perceive such a thing exists)

OP posts:
PassTheHanky · 04/11/2026 16:19

I'm retired now but when I worked (as an IT Project Manager ) I found big differences in men and women's behaviour at work, such as:

  • as an assertive confident woman I was sometimes accused of being aggressive at work yet the assertive confident men were not, their behaviour was admired;
  • in meetings men would hog the discussion, women were often talked down;
  • when women chatted they were 'gossiping', when men chatted they were 'networking';
  • when visiting male departmental heads for introductory meetings I often found that they assumed my male trainee was my boss;
Thehorticulturalhussie · 04/11/2026 15:54

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:50

Many men do not feel that responsibility when the going gets tough.

Any male mammal can simply leave before the baby is even born.

I agree, and many do, but I think that we grow up knowing that because of our biology having children is, for us, almost certainly, a lifelong and life changing commitment that shapes us as women.
Edited to add that the choice not to have children is a momentous one too.

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:52

Gerri1992 · 04/11/2026 08:46

One thing that keeps coming up in my work discussion is confusion of how biological sex is legally defined.
I think it is sex at birth, but I've also been told that it is what your birth certificate says and that birth certificates can be changed. Unclear what a workplace can do if someone is obviously trans but they won't admit it and their birth certificate agrees with the toilet they want to use.

From a legal point of view It's the sex registered at birth.

DrBlackbird · 04/11/2026 15:51

I was talking with my husband about locking the car as soon as I get in it and he was shocked. Why would I do that? It has never occurred to him to worry about being pulled from a car and sexually assaulted.

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:50

Thehorticulturalhussie · 04/11/2026 15:32

@nicepotoftea I agree and think that we are analysing the phrases used commonly by men who believe that they can become women -
' I live as a woman now'
' I have always felt like a woman'
etc

We may or may not be tomboys when we're young but as puberty looms we become aware of attracting a certain type of attention from boys and men. I was a teen in the early 70s and we suddenly became responsible for not dressing in a way likely to make us seem 'easy', for not being in certain places at certain times, for being kind, for accepting that boys will be boys. Later we would become solely responsible for not getting pregnant.

We make some of the biggest and emotional decisions around our fertility - should I have a baby now or wait until I'm older and risk leaving it too late? Should I abort the unplanned baby I'm currently carrying (unable to anticipate the lifelong guilt and regret)? We are tied to our children for life. Many men do not feel that responsibility when the going gets tough.

At any age we feel fearful when walking down a road in the dark, hearing footsteps close behind. We feel a wave of relief to find that it's a woman who's simply in a hurry.

All of the above shape our lives because we are women and cannot be acquired by men wearing our clothes.

Many men do not feel that responsibility when the going gets tough.

Any male mammal can simply leave before the baby is even born.

DrBlackbird · 04/11/2026 15:49

Really thorough and considered response @MarieDeGournay It won’t mean anything to the poster you were replying to but hopefully it gives lurkers food for thought.

flyingbuttress43 · 04/11/2026 15:46

Just an aside...I was a total tomboy as a kid. I did all the stereotypical boys stuff, hated anything to do with domesticity, wore trousers, had short hair etc. and was often greeted by people as 'sonny' because they thought I was a boy.

I have remained a tomboy as an adult even after marriage and children because it's essentially a personality trait and has precious little to do with this nebulous thing labelled gender.

Did I think when I was 7 that I was a boy or could become a boy? Nah. Why not? Because I wasn't stupid..

Thehorticulturalhussie · 04/11/2026 15:32

@nicepotoftea I agree and think that we are analysing the phrases used commonly by men who believe that they can become women -
' I live as a woman now'
' I have always felt like a woman'
etc

We may or may not be tomboys when we're young but as puberty looms we become aware of attracting a certain type of attention from boys and men. I was a teen in the early 70s and we suddenly became responsible for not dressing in a way likely to make us seem 'easy', for not being in certain places at certain times, for being kind, for accepting that boys will be boys. Later we would become solely responsible for not getting pregnant.

We make some of the biggest and emotional decisions around our fertility - should I have a baby now or wait until I'm older and risk leaving it too late? Should I abort the unplanned baby I'm currently carrying (unable to anticipate the lifelong guilt and regret)? We are tied to our children for life. Many men do not feel that responsibility when the going gets tough.

At any age we feel fearful when walking down a road in the dark, hearing footsteps close behind. We feel a wave of relief to find that it's a woman who's simply in a hurry.

All of the above shape our lives because we are women and cannot be acquired by men wearing our clothes.

theilltemperedmonster · 04/11/2026 15:09

Gerri1992 · 04/11/2026 13:50

My job has updated its policy, but is stuck on what to do when I say the person using the ladies is obviously trans and the other employee says you can't prove that. HR has been dithering for months and refuses to give advice on this situation, other to reiterate that trans women should use mens/disabled.

HR should get legal advice. It is not illegal sex discrimination to exclude from a women-only service a person who looks like a man, irrespective of their sex, because Schedule 3 removes liability for perceptive sex discrimination: and this must surely apply equally at work (that's the bit they need the lawyer for). Or, how about reporting them to the HSE or suing for indirect sex discrimination against women and muslims?

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:07

Living rurally surrounded by livestock, I find it useful to consider other species.

Because I am human I have rights that the livestock don't, but because I am female my life has been governed by my ability to control my fertility and other people's knowledge that I am the kind of human that gives birth.

Much as though I hated to admit this when I was younger, having a female body has also limited my ability to run fast and fight men.

This is why I need sex specific rights.

My identity/personality/character has not one jot of influence on any of this.

inkymoose · 04/11/2026 14:54

Thank you to @FlirtsWithRhinos for starting this thread, there's already plenty of food for thought here.

When I was a teenager, I considered myself to be a tomboy, because I liked playing outside, climbing trees, having adventures whatever they are, and wearing the kind of clothes that would allow me to do those things. I had a friend who looking back, I think was lesbian, who was quite influential when I was 12/13. I admired her and we were close friends for awhile, fighting off bullies, decrying anything frilly or girly, building dens (her mostly) and having big conversations about big things. I have a photo of her somewhere, wearing rugged shorts and a T-shirt, her haircut in a very short boyish style.

My friend's family emigrated to Canada when I was 13 and she 14, and although we wrote a few letters to each other we lost touch and I have never seen or heard from her since. After that, I changed schools because my family moved, only tens of miles rather than thousands, found it very difficult to make friends, was seen as an outsider, continued to reject stereotypical gender behaviour.

When we are children, other people make decisions, big ones small ones, life changing changes that we can do nothing about. I'm grateful that nobody ever suggested to me (not that they would've done) that I might not actually be a girl.

spannasaurus · 04/11/2026 13:54

Gerri1992 · 04/11/2026 13:50

My job has updated its policy, but is stuck on what to do when I say the person using the ladies is obviously trans and the other employee says you can't prove that. HR has been dithering for months and refuses to give advice on this situation, other to reiterate that trans women should use mens/disabled.

The female employees need to submit complaints to HR and tell them that they will raise an employment tribunal claim for harassment if they continue to allow men in the women's toilets. That might kick them into action.

Gerri1992 · 04/11/2026 13:50

Hedgehogforshort · 04/11/2026 10:50

Your employer is required under the Work Place (health welfare and safety) regulation 1992, to provide separate sex toilets, or single lockable self contained units, And must enforce this via their own policy.

If they do not lodge a grievance.

sex matters have resources on this matter.

My job has updated its policy, but is stuck on what to do when I say the person using the ladies is obviously trans and the other employee says you can't prove that. HR has been dithering for months and refuses to give advice on this situation, other to reiterate that trans women should use mens/disabled.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 11:10

midnight4 · 04/11/2026 11:02

@FlirtsWithRhinos I’m sorry for derailing your thread!

No worries :) I know how these things happen, quick asides get a life of their own

OP posts:
Seriestwo · 04/11/2026 11:08

What is the difference? My enormous male friend tells me when he goes into a room he scans it and thinks “I could take him, I could take him, etc” and then relaxes. I also scan a room but I look for the exits, the loo and constantly monitor all the men for potential threat. Including my lovely friend, who had no idea at all that women do that - precisely because he is lovely and would not want to harm a woman. Despite that, his sheer size means we will all subconsciously monitor him all of the time.

Pingponghavoc · 04/11/2026 11:07

The government and activist are trying to treat sex as if its similar to the words child/adult. When its more like age.

Governments can change the legal definitions of child and adult, but it can't change age. An 18 year old is still 18 whether they are defined as a adult or a child.

We can justify the child/adult definitions by average maturity, but that doesnt mean we say that mature 12 year olds are adults and immature 28 year olds are children. The same with any characteristics of adults and children.

Government cannot change sex. And research lets us understand sex more, but it doesnt change sex. Complications in development in others will not make a man have a period become pregnant or go through the menopause.

A man with a female birth certificate isnt the same as a woman with a female birth certificate. Because the word female and birth certificate are different definitiond for each person.

So as well as not having the same experience based on their sex, they dont even have the same birth certificate.

midnight4 · 04/11/2026 11:03

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 10:53

That's a question for the employers surely?

The first step is to make the policy itself clear and understood.

If the TIM person goes ahead anyway it can be dealt with as a disciplinary action, same as any other policy breach by an employee.

The focus on "But HOW???" is a distraction often intended to force the false conclusion that because enforcement may be hard or not 100% possible, the law must be changed to allow the desired act.

This is false logic - we don't demand 100% prevention of speeding to have a speed limit, nor 100% prevention of theft to agree theft is illegal.

The principle is clear. The person involved knows what is expected of them. Their choice to break the rule is a different question to whether the rule should exist.

Thank you for this.

midnight4 · 04/11/2026 11:02

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 10:57

And let's not turn this thread into discussing the practical minutae of khazis. There are thousands of posts about that already.

This is a big picture thread about the reality of being physically female and how that has social consequences. About there being a venn diagram where body and society overlap which means the social experience of womanhood is still a sexed experience that cannot be replicated by a man choosing to present as his conception of female.

@FlirtsWithRhinos I’m sorry for derailing your thread!

midnight4 · 04/11/2026 11:02

Hedgehogforshort · 04/11/2026 10:50

Your employer is required under the Work Place (health welfare and safety) regulation 1992, to provide separate sex toilets, or single lockable self contained units, And must enforce this via their own policy.

If they do not lodge a grievance.

sex matters have resources on this matter.

Thank you for this, it’s very helpful.