Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

News about Sarah Summers and Phoenix Publications

310 replies

ProfJoPhoenix · 02/11/2026 18:13

Dear all

It gives me ENORMOUS pleasure to let you know that early in 2027, Phoenix Publications will be publishing Sarah Summers memoir (called Being a girl and other dangerous things).

@iamsarah has had an extraordinary life and write beautifully.

Please spread the word far and wide and please visit Phoenix Publications Ltd website for updates and news of how to pre-order.

The book is a blinder!

Best
Jo Phoenix

OP posts:
BucketBoots · 03/11/2026 19:39

I was at the WPUK meeting which @IamSarah attended as a TRA reporter. She and her friends sniggered at the back and I think she may have also asked a question. They left before the end of the meeting.

She reported at the time either on here or on her blog (it was a really long time ago so I can’t remember details) that she was spat at or similar.

It was an egregious lie. And she was posting on here under multiple accounts.

Many women were banned or sanctioned for questioning this over the years and most of us have kept publicly kept our mouths shut. We’ve heard about the crowdfund for a case that never went to trial, the business venture which has been repeatedly advertised on MN explicitly against the rules (and yes, I know they’re supposed to be about healing women but it is still a business), and now the book.

I’ll probably be banned for this post but I don’t care. If ‘Sarah’ is really coming clean, then she needs to own all the damage she has done properly. ‘I was a TRA and now I’ve seen the light’ doesn’t cut it. Especially not when your wife is still fully on board.

poppsocks · 03/11/2026 19:37

I am slightly concerned at the idea that posters can find out others' email addresses.

TinselAngel · 03/11/2026 19:35

IamSarah · 03/11/2026 19:25

I love a good conspiracy theory but I really haven’t had the time to bash anyone full time, let alone change usernames to do it.

Posie Parker has publicly criticised my campaign to secure women’s rape crisis therapy in Brighton. I have been critical of some of the things she has said and done when using my old Mumsnet username. I don’t think either of us lose any sleep over it.

It’s hardly a conspiracy theory.

Hedgehogforshort · 03/11/2026 19:29

I believe our well known long timers who don’t change their name. Why wouldn't I.

none of them have ever been nasty or bullied people, by
Sarah’s own admissions.

lots of people (including myself) come on here with er????, be kind, eh what??? show me, explain to me. I went and read. But no abuse.

someone who abuses other people and gets them banned is someone who has a deep problem, not resolved by “switching teams”

i have seen some recent activity from a name changer who does not operate collectively, does not watch others backs, or offer support. Just rants and raves, and picked on me.

it is more than not nice. Given the hostilities IRL especially in the past on here.

glad you saw the truth Sarah but trust is something you earn try doing that.

Dragonasaurus · 03/11/2026 19:26

I supported Sarah - we are all Sarah - and I’m also pleased to hear that donations can’t be traced back

i am somewhat surprised/concerned that posters’ different usernames and email addresses seem to be so easily verifiable by Tinsel, Helle and others. Like many others, I change my username to try to ensure personal details can’t be collated across different posts. Are you suggesting that this kind of anonymity isn’t possible here?

IamSarah · 03/11/2026 19:25

TinselAngel · 03/11/2026 19:03

And virtually full time bashing of Posie and any women who supported her at one time, unless you’ve used different email addresses.

I love a good conspiracy theory but I really haven’t had the time to bash anyone full time, let alone change usernames to do it.

Posie Parker has publicly criticised my campaign to secure women’s rape crisis therapy in Brighton. I have been critical of some of the things she has said and done when using my old Mumsnet username. I don’t think either of us lose any sleep over it.

Helleofabore · 03/11/2026 19:15

I know some posters came very close to outing Sarah’s other main user name and didn’t even disclose what they knew while pointing out the hypocrisy of the posting by the established user name.

Again, posters are not mistaken about what has been posted in the past. Particularly not Tinsel.

Helleofabore · 03/11/2026 19:08

I don’t believe that posters are mistaking the user name the Sarah has used in the past to berate women on this board. And we have not disclosed this while knowing.

Please do not accuse us of not knowing the history of posting from Sarah, because those making the accusation would be incorrect in that assumption.

TinselAngel · 03/11/2026 19:03

IamSarah · 03/11/2026 17:15

Scrutinise away. As I said before I’m very happy to DM anyone my list of previous usernames.

You might find some triggering threads about rape but you will mainly find me discussing endometriosis, knee pain, peri menopause and when Sarah Lancashire is next on the telly. Knock yourselves out.

And virtually full time bashing of Posie and any women who supported her at one time, unless you’ve used different email addresses.

IamSarah · 03/11/2026 18:59

poppsocks · 03/11/2026 18:23

I don't know who Sarah posted as previously (I could have a wild guess but not confident it's correct) but I am genuinely heartened that she has re-evaluated her position to the point of fighting this awful battle.

I would be interested to hear more about her thought processes, but completely understand why no-one wants to expose usernames that might be used to dox etc.

My thought process was basically this:
We’re all one big happy LGBTQ family
Trans women are women
my pronouns are she / her
Gosh a lot of lesbians are identifying as men
What is all this cis and queer business?
Men wouldn’t pretend to be lesbians, why would they?
Just be kind.
Non-binary is valid
Gosh there are a lot of lesbians who were born male
Why are these lesbians born male obsessed with wearing their mum’s underwear?
No man would pretend to be female to access women’s spaces.
Some men are predatory
AGP is a thing
No man would try and use a woman’s rape crisis service.
Nobody would cross that boundary. That just wouldn’t happen.
Oh.
Those posters on Mumsnet were right.

poppsocks · 03/11/2026 18:23

I don't know who Sarah posted as previously (I could have a wild guess but not confident it's correct) but I am genuinely heartened that she has re-evaluated her position to the point of fighting this awful battle.

I would be interested to hear more about her thought processes, but completely understand why no-one wants to expose usernames that might be used to dox etc.

IamSarah · 03/11/2026 17:32

SerafinasGoose · 03/11/2026 17:12

I don't recall being berated, so can't speak from that position other than to say that I agree Tinsel was right to raise it. There's no reason why concerns like this should be censored, even in the context of a sensitive discussion.

I'm a fairly sporadic poster but have been here long enough to know what an agressively censorious environment the FWR boards have been because of the TRA, when the boards split, the introduction of the 'three strikes' rule, and when people and posts were summarily banned for stating the bleeding obvious.

I did crowd-fund Sarah. I would still do so now, knowing what I know in retrospect, and because taking on Sussex in those circumstances required a huge amount of courage. I know that's easy for me to say when to the best of my knowledge I wasn't on the receiving end. But there are women here who have done a great deal of good for other women - including Tinsel - and Sarah's case against Sussex did contribute to fighting against the wholesale assault on women's rights that many of us here oppose.

I'm pleased to know from @IamSarah that donations are not traceable back to their donors. If I'd thought they were, this would have affected my decision to donate.

Thank you Serafinas for contributing to the crowd fund 🌺

I can recall berating women on here prior to 2021 which I am very embarrassed about and for which I apologise. I acknowledged the error of my ways then and I do now.

I admit I’m like one of those annoying ex-smokers who go on about how dreadful smoking is. I’m certainly not perfect, in fact I’m extremely flawed.

I’m not duplicitous though. I will admit if I’ve done something wrong but I haven’t posted on here simultaneously using multiple names. I certainly haven’t berated women using one name and asked them to contribute to a crowd funder using another. That is just not true.

IamSarah · 03/11/2026 17:15

Scrutinise away. As I said before I’m very happy to DM anyone my list of previous usernames.

You might find some triggering threads about rape but you will mainly find me discussing endometriosis, knee pain, peri menopause and when Sarah Lancashire is next on the telly. Knock yourselves out.

SerafinasGoose · 03/11/2026 17:12

I don't recall being berated, so can't speak from that position other than to say that I agree Tinsel was right to raise it. There's no reason why concerns like this should be censored, even in the context of a sensitive discussion.

I'm a fairly sporadic poster but have been here long enough to know what an agressively censorious environment the FWR boards have been because of the TRA, when the boards split, the introduction of the 'three strikes' rule, and when people and posts were summarily banned for stating the bleeding obvious.

I did crowd-fund Sarah. I would still do so now, knowing what I know in retrospect, and because taking on Sussex in those circumstances required a huge amount of courage. I know that's easy for me to say when to the best of my knowledge I wasn't on the receiving end. But there are women here who have done a great deal of good for other women - including Tinsel - and Sarah's case against Sussex did contribute to fighting against the wholesale assault on women's rights that many of us here oppose.

I'm pleased to know from @IamSarah that donations are not traceable back to their donors. If I'd thought they were, this would have affected my decision to donate.

Hermiaxx · 03/11/2026 16:58

It’s also very cheeky to be mistaken and fail to acknowledge this as a possibility. I always understand I may be wrong but agree with Jo and perhaps it’s best to read the book of a survivor first before casting the first stone! But hey enjoy your continued perfection x

Shedmistress · 03/11/2026 16:45

Hermiaxx · 03/11/2026 16:11

Please stop and think before you continue to attack someone you don’t know - please keep your anger directed at male attackers and have some empathy here! The real truth is never pure and rarely simple! I stand with @IamSarahxx

It is very fucking cheeky to advertise a new book including the people you used to berate, to the people you used to berate!

But those of us that used to be berated now need to shut up about it?

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 03/11/2026 16:42

TinselAngel · 03/11/2026 16:16

If nobody is allowed to criticise people they don’t know, mumsnet will grind to a halt.

Indeed.

And anyone who publishes a book should be prepared for scrutiny.

As Lang used to say "no sacred castes."

TinselAngel · 03/11/2026 16:16

Hermiaxx · 03/11/2026 16:11

Please stop and think before you continue to attack someone you don’t know - please keep your anger directed at male attackers and have some empathy here! The real truth is never pure and rarely simple! I stand with @IamSarahxx

If nobody is allowed to criticise people they don’t know, mumsnet will grind to a halt.

Hermiaxx · 03/11/2026 16:11

Please stop and think before you continue to attack someone you don’t know - please keep your anger directed at male attackers and have some empathy here! The real truth is never pure and rarely simple! I stand with @IamSarahxx

Shedmistress · 03/11/2026 15:52

The issue is the duplicity not publishing a book anonymously.

TinselAngel · 03/11/2026 15:48

ProfJoPhoenix · 03/11/2026 15:39

Wow. Look away for 5 minutes and look what erupts.

As her publisher, I am going to wade in with 2 comments. There are many reasons for publishing a memoir anonymously. The poiny of a memoir is not a celebration or otherwise of an individual, it is that the story speaks to wider context and to many other people.

But more than anything else I know the contents and I would strongly encourage all of you to buy the book once it is out and make up your own minds.

Anyhow that is all from me.

Jo

We understand the need for the memoir to be published anonymously.

Dragonasaurus · 03/11/2026 15:41

Jo, will I be able to order the book through my local independent bookshop? I always like the opportunity to highlight the potential demand for GC books to them - plus they run the local literature festival…..

ProfJoPhoenix · 03/11/2026 15:39

Wow. Look away for 5 minutes and look what erupts.

As her publisher, I am going to wade in with 2 comments. There are many reasons for publishing a memoir anonymously. The poiny of a memoir is not a celebration or otherwise of an individual, it is that the story speaks to wider context and to many other people.

But more than anything else I know the contents and I would strongly encourage all of you to buy the book once it is out and make up your own minds.

Anyhow that is all from me.

Jo

OP posts:
SuperLux · 03/11/2026 15:18

I had no idea about this controversy and have happily supported Sarah's cause in the past. I don't know who the previous persona was & I'm not particularly interested.

Perhaps, armed with the facts, I might have still donated because it is still important to campaign for SSS and I do think there's no stronger advocate than a convert.

But I am a big fan of making informed choices. It appears that wasn't allowed to happen here. Certainly there was a lack of transparency.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 15:09

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 03/11/2026 13:59

I think what I struggle with isn't just that you were pretty awful to many posters here and also about women involved in the various "GC" groups, but that when you changed your mind, you didn't own it under your previous persona, you just developed a new one. And when you created your new persona, you invited women you had previously denigrated (sometimes in quite unpleasant ways) to support you.

I'm glad you changed your mind. However, I think it's unfortunate that you failed to recognise the stories of other women who had been excluded from, or were avoiding, services and provisions that included trans identifying men in their definitions of women, and only shifted position when it directly affected you. Prior to that, you did not care about other women's experiences, but after shifting position you expected other women to care about yours, to the extend that you fundraised and elicited support from the very women you had dismissed as evil transphobes.

Very well said.