Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Obstetric violence is the last socially acceptable form of violence against women

141 replies

NibliaBiblia · 02/11/2026 14:03

Just what the title says.
I was physically forced onto my back in labour. Friend of mine had her waters broken without even being told they were about to do it and then was refused a ceasearean for hours after she said she needed one. One born every minute they just tell women what's going to happen and then do it. Another woman I know was verbally coerced into giving birth on her back in stirrups. Every time someone at work is pregnant somebody asks if they're "allowed" to do xyz.
And then things like cesareans without anaesthesia, cervical exams when the woman is saying to stop, episiotomy without warning, being belittled or spoken down to I haven't heard from women I know personally but definitely do happen.
And when a woman talks about feeling traumatised or violated there's always multiple people popping up to say that's normal, she should count her blessings, she should be grateful, etc.

OP posts:
PollyNomial · 04/11/2026 20:34

Koulibiak · 04/11/2026 20:18

another lie. The Amos review had a national remit, not just underperforming trusts. https://www.matneoinv.org.uk/

That review looked at 12 hospitals (<10%) and, declaration of interest, OH works in one of them in a service that supports maternity (not midwife or obstetrics) - these hospitals are all "failing" and it's not remotely a representative sample.

Koulibiak · 04/11/2026 20:18

PollyNomial · 04/11/2026 19:30

The reviews you speak of are into hospitals where maternity care is already known to be failing. It would be astonishing if they gave a glowing picture of the services.

Edited

another lie. The Amos review had a national remit, not just underperforming trusts. https://www.matneoinv.org.uk/

Home - National Maternity and Neonatal Investigation

The homepage for the National Maternity and Neonatal Investigation. Details the purpose of the Investigation, Chair and expert panel biographies.

https://www.matneoinv.org.uk/

Koulibiak · 04/11/2026 20:15

PollyNomial · 04/11/2026 19:26

The compensation payments in Canada are capped at less than $0.5m, which for a lifetime of adaptations to housing, additional care is insultingly small.

In the UK, these are uncapped (rightly IMO), which is why they are so much larger.

You are comparing chalk and cheese.

That is simply not true. The cap is only on pain and suffering, and doesn’t include other heads of damages, such as additional expenses, round the clock care or loss of earning potential. You don’t know what you are talking about.

PollyNomial · 04/11/2026 19:30

Koulibiak · 04/11/2026 18:22

@LiberteLynx nice bit of whataboutery.

The defining characteristic of maternity care in the U.K. is that it is midwife led. 99.5% of midwives are women. Multiple inquiries, investigations and reviews have repeatedly found midwives to be incompetent, uncaring, blinded by ideology and dangerous. I stand by what I wrote, which is that this is violence perpetrated by women on women.

The reviews you speak of are into hospitals where maternity care is already known to be failing. It would be astonishing if they gave a glowing picture of the services.

PollyNomial · 04/11/2026 19:26

Koulibiak · 03/11/2026 23:13

It’s Canada. Health care varies by province, but where I’m from, epidural rates are 77% (England: 22%), c section rates are 50% lower than England, and adverse outcomes are massively lower. 2% of the NHS budget is taken by negligence claims, as opposed to 0.1% in Canada.

And out of that 2% in England, maternity claims are by far the largest liability, i.e 60-68% of medical liability costs.

I guess it’s fine as long as it’s just numbers on a page. When it’s your child it might feel quite different.

@alphaI’m sorry this is not aimed at you, I understand your genuine concern.

Edited

The compensation payments in Canada are capped at less than $0.5m, which for a lifetime of adaptations to housing, additional care is insultingly small.

In the UK, these are uncapped (rightly IMO), which is why they are so much larger.

You are comparing chalk and cheese.

NibliaBiblia · 04/11/2026 19:24

Koulibiak · 04/11/2026 18:22

@LiberteLynx nice bit of whataboutery.

The defining characteristic of maternity care in the U.K. is that it is midwife led. 99.5% of midwives are women. Multiple inquiries, investigations and reviews have repeatedly found midwives to be incompetent, uncaring, blinded by ideology and dangerous. I stand by what I wrote, which is that this is violence perpetrated by women on women.

This is absolutely just as bad in other countries. In the USA they barely even pay lip service to the idea that women have a choice about what is done to them in labour, and it's 90% obstetricians over there.

OP posts:
Koulibiak · 04/11/2026 18:22

@LiberteLynx nice bit of whataboutery.

The defining characteristic of maternity care in the U.K. is that it is midwife led. 99.5% of midwives are women. Multiple inquiries, investigations and reviews have repeatedly found midwives to be incompetent, uncaring, blinded by ideology and dangerous. I stand by what I wrote, which is that this is violence perpetrated by women on women.

LiberteLynx · 04/11/2026 16:40

Koulibiak · 03/11/2026 22:37

What male obgyns? I had a very complex pregnancy, in a teaching hospital, and not once did I see a male obgyn.

Yes it is women on women violence. What did you think it was?

I don’t know what you are referring to as “the gods of medicine”. Reality is what it is - in this country, maternity care is overwhelmingly done by female midwives, and they are seriously getting things wrong. Hence the fact that each of us in England pays ten times as much for medical negligence, as taxpayers in Canada where they have obgyns (many of them women).

I know not all ob/gyns are female. Odd you are ok with the “woman on woman violence” as that dismisses it. Odd too that you would exclude the male ob/gyns who are no better and often worse.

NibliaBiblia · 04/11/2026 12:53

BusyExpert · 04/11/2026 12:47

I am a midwife…….

Well that's worrying.

OP posts:
BusyExpert · 04/11/2026 12:47

Koulibiak · 03/11/2026 22:00

How fucking rude. What are your credentials for this expert assessment? Or are you out there just looking for a fight

I am a midwife…….

RoyalCorgi · 04/11/2026 09:34

I'm quite surprised at some of the comments on here - there must be people who simply never read the news.

This story was widely covered a couple of days ago:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm9dzn8e737jo

It's about Danielle Brown, who was discharged from hospital at seven months of pregnancy despite having pre-eclampsia - and despite having been told her baby would be delivered by emergency c-section.

Because she still felt ill, she returned to the hospital and was told her baby was died. She was then told that, rather than giving birth that same day, she had to go home and make an appointment to deliver her baby. That turned out to be a week later. So that's a whole week of being pregnant with a baby you know has died.

You might not call that obstetric violence. You might decide instead that it's a combination of incompetence (discharging a woman who had pre-eclampsia) and callousness (not caring about a woman whose baby has died). But whatever you call it, I don't think you could describe it as doctors and midwives doing their best in a difficult situation, which is what several people have suggested.

Danielle Brown and Anthony Miller. Danielle on the left has straight blonde hair, tied back to leave a long fringe. She has a neutral expression. Anthony has short grey hair and looks stern or thoughtful. The pale and dark grey wallpaper behind them ha...

North Shields mother told to make appointment to give birth to baby who had died

Newcastle Hospitals NHS Trust apologises for care it says "fell short of the standards" expected.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm9dzn8e737jo

SomethingFun · 04/11/2026 08:51

See I think there is something mentally wrong with people when I say - my anaesthetic didn’t work and I told them and they ignored me til I was literally screaming down the theatre and then about 5 people leapt into action to sort it out, they reply medical professionals are doing their best is a second by second emergency situation. As that isn’t where we were. If it was a true emergency they would’ve knocked me out with a general anyway. Also to add they only gave me extra pain relief and anaesthetic once my baby was delivered - I don’t think I was the consideration at all.

Blackthornwickerwoman · 04/11/2026 08:35

Disturbia81 · 03/11/2026 19:11

This is why I had sections. I didn’t want to go through the chaos, brutality and long term consequences of vaginal birth.

Edited

Same

NibliaBiblia · 04/11/2026 07:40

@VoltaireMittyDream I'm so sorry that was done to you that is absolutely harrowing. And I'm so sorry that your baby has died. So sorry.

OP posts:
alphabetistic · 04/11/2026 00:24

Koulibiak · 03/11/2026 23:13

It’s Canada. Health care varies by province, but where I’m from, epidural rates are 77% (England: 22%), c section rates are 50% lower than England, and adverse outcomes are massively lower. 2% of the NHS budget is taken by negligence claims, as opposed to 0.1% in Canada.

And out of that 2% in England, maternity claims are by far the largest liability, i.e 60-68% of medical liability costs.

I guess it’s fine as long as it’s just numbers on a page. When it’s your child it might feel quite different.

@alphaI’m sorry this is not aimed at you, I understand your genuine concern.

Edited

Wow - those are stark differences. I knew we had a massive problem but I was under the impression things were pretty bad everywhere, even if not quite as bad as they are here. It's heartbreaking - I've read many stories over the years about women (and babies) let down by the system and every one has been very hard to read.

Koulibiak · 03/11/2026 23:13

alphabetistic · 03/11/2026 00:36

Can you share the country you're from where they're better at this? I was under the impression this was an issue the world over, even if it's possibly worse here than some places. I'm so so sorry you've suffered so badly - as I am about everyone else on the thread. I don't have kids myself but read about this issue as a teenager and it was one of the reasons I chose to remain child free (to be fair there were many other reasons too). My experience of health care professionals in general has been pretty terrible and I don't struggle to believe the stories at all. I'm horrified at some of the responses.

It’s Canada. Health care varies by province, but where I’m from, epidural rates are 77% (England: 22%), c section rates are 50% lower than England, and adverse outcomes are massively lower. 2% of the NHS budget is taken by negligence claims, as opposed to 0.1% in Canada.

And out of that 2% in England, maternity claims are by far the largest liability, i.e 60-68% of medical liability costs.

I guess it’s fine as long as it’s just numbers on a page. When it’s your child it might feel quite different.

@alphaI’m sorry this is not aimed at you, I understand your genuine concern.

Mumsgirls · 03/11/2026 23:10

Over 40 years ago a friend had a still birth at full term when sky high blood pressure for weeks did not result in action. Of course ‘ lessons will be learned’ It makes me so sad that uk still performs badly in maternity compared to other comparable countries. Perhaps it is indifference and arrogance rather than outright malice, but it HAS to change

Ohthatsabitshit · 03/11/2026 22:51

I think there are more instances of appalling treatment than most people realise or want to accept. Myself I’ve given birth 4 times in three different hospitals and I could recount very obvious ill treatment in all 4 births. Not minor upset, awful hard to get over treatment.

Koulibiak · 03/11/2026 22:43

LiberteLynx · 03/11/2026 22:07

Many medical processes and procedures are inherently violent. I agree that it can be traumatising to experience. I also agree there are some abuses or malpractice that happen in the medical establishment. I can even believe abuses of power to assault women might happen more commonly to women than men.

However, I disagree with your premise that it is a socially acceptable form of VAWG. You yourself called it medical battery and healthcare practitioners have been struck off, convicted and gone to prison in some cases. It is not socially acceptable.

VAWG is violence for no purpose other than domination and control.
Medical settings are very different. Have a look at how people who are involuntarily sectioned are treated, that can be very violent as well.

I’m interested in the parallel you want to draw between people who are sectioned, and pregnant women. Is it your position that birthing mothers are inapt and cannot give informed consent? If so, I would urge you to reframe your thinking. Pregnancy is not a mental illness. Mothers are not insane, they are not children to be patronised over.

Koulibiak · 03/11/2026 22:37

LiberteLynx · 03/11/2026 22:09

it has been established time and again that midwives have acted in cruel, negligent, malevolent ways towards women.

Slow clap. Why did you leave out the gods of medicine? Those male ob/gyns ?
It is woman on woman violence is it?

What male obgyns? I had a very complex pregnancy, in a teaching hospital, and not once did I see a male obgyn.

Yes it is women on women violence. What did you think it was?

I don’t know what you are referring to as “the gods of medicine”. Reality is what it is - in this country, maternity care is overwhelmingly done by female midwives, and they are seriously getting things wrong. Hence the fact that each of us in England pays ten times as much for medical negligence, as taxpayers in Canada where they have obgyns (many of them women).

NibliaBiblia · 03/11/2026 22:34

LiberteLynx · 03/11/2026 22:07

Many medical processes and procedures are inherently violent. I agree that it can be traumatising to experience. I also agree there are some abuses or malpractice that happen in the medical establishment. I can even believe abuses of power to assault women might happen more commonly to women than men.

However, I disagree with your premise that it is a socially acceptable form of VAWG. You yourself called it medical battery and healthcare practitioners have been struck off, convicted and gone to prison in some cases. It is not socially acceptable.

VAWG is violence for no purpose other than domination and control.
Medical settings are very different. Have a look at how people who are involuntarily sectioned are treated, that can be very violent as well.

I understand this perspective but in reality there is little to no accountability for routine violations of women's bodily autonomy.
Have you ever heard of a midwife or doctor being disciplined for carrying out a membrane sweep without consent? Or for continuing a vaginal exam when the woman said "stop"?
I reported my assault to the police but I had to write to them twice before they even recorded a crime, and they never even took a statement or interviewed anyone, even though it is clearly battery. If I had reported nearer the time my state of mind would have made it really difficult to push back - I don't believe I would have done so.

Thank you for your concern and your recommendation. I did find a counsellor through the BTA list of practitioners and it's been really helpful working through some of this with her.
I was really lucky to meet the midwife who looked after me antenatally with my second. She helped me so much. When I went for my booking appointment I was a bit of a wreck but by 28 weeks or so I felt like myself again. She just really listened and cared for me.

OP posts:
bababamama · 03/11/2026 22:25

insufficient anesthesia does happen across other operations too, nobody should be dismissing it as never happening but it rare, very rare. Other complications occur during childbirth and sometimes they have literally seconds to react, again rare but if it happens to you it’s very traumatic as stories here testify BUT if you are reading this pregnant or ttc do realise these are very rare cases and most births are pretty unremarkable medically speaking, mine weren’t even painful (didn’t have any pain relief, toothache is far worse). I’m not trying to downplay those affected but some context is needed so people are scared op

VoltaireMittyDream · 03/11/2026 22:17

MyKindHiker · 02/11/2026 14:55

Caesarian without anesthesia??? What Facebook madness have you been reading? The woman would die of clinical shock! This is very much not a medical practice in the UK.

I was given a c section a day and a half after my baby died during labour.

I had been telling all the midwives and the anaesthetist repeatedly for about 20 hours that the epidural had not been placed properly and I could feel everything. (I got a copy of my maternity notes which confirmed that I demonstrated being able to stand and walk).

They told me I was just in shock, epidurals were foolproof and it would be fine.

They cut into me and I was screaming and struggling and they had to hold me down and knock me out with gas to get the baby out.

The next day a group of male consultants stood over me as I lay there in the bereavement suite and told me that upon reviewing my notes they concluded that I had ‘felt sensation and misunderstood it as pain’.

Had I not been so fucking traumatised I would have sued the shit out of them.

I looked into this later in and it is way more common than you’d think that epidurals don’t work, women aren't believed, and they are given c sections with no pain relief whatsoever. This could all be avoided with a spinal block apparently, if anyone cared to believe that women can know when they are in pain or not.

NibliaBiblia · 03/11/2026 22:17

@SomethingFun I'm sorry I said this in reply to your story: "Like I said...". That was a really glib response and I shouldn't have written it.
I can't even imagine how awful what you went through must have been. I am so sorry.

OP posts:
LiberteLynx · 03/11/2026 22:13

NibliaBiblia · 03/11/2026 21:50

I'm okay now, but I really want to do everything I can to stop this being done to other women.

This is admirable, but you cannot take on this weight alone. Have you checked out the BTA? (Birth Trauma Assoc) they support survivors, family but also engage in activism and parliamentary enquiries to improve maternity care.