Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Obstetric violence is the last socially acceptable form of violence against women

141 replies

NibliaBiblia · 02/11/2026 14:03

Just what the title says.
I was physically forced onto my back in labour. Friend of mine had her waters broken without even being told they were about to do it and then was refused a ceasearean for hours after she said she needed one. One born every minute they just tell women what's going to happen and then do it. Another woman I know was verbally coerced into giving birth on her back in stirrups. Every time someone at work is pregnant somebody asks if they're "allowed" to do xyz.
And then things like cesareans without anaesthesia, cervical exams when the woman is saying to stop, episiotomy without warning, being belittled or spoken down to I haven't heard from women I know personally but definitely do happen.
And when a woman talks about feeling traumatised or violated there's always multiple people popping up to say that's normal, she should count her blessings, she should be grateful, etc.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NibliaBiblia · 06/11/2026 11:06

AnotherVice · 06/11/2026 09:27

Sadly It seems as if a large number of women on this thread have subscribed to the same ‘doctrine of necessity’ that a lot of so-called medical professionals have, ie, if they feel it is necessary, then they can totally disregard a woman’s autonomy and completely undermine the principles of informed consent. This is illegal, unethical and so, so damaging to women’s mental and physical health. A foetus does not exist in law until born. Obstetric violence is very real, frighteningly common and as OP says, happening in plain sight and accepted by so many. I wrote my dissertation on this so have done a lot of research on it.

Is it publicly available? I'd be interested to read it. I can't find a lot of information about this in the uk other than the best uk study which i don't think is published yet and the durham university blog
Edited to add obviously there's lots of information available but not much that specifically names obstetric violence

OP posts:
potterypieces · 06/11/2026 09:47

True.

AnotherVice · 06/11/2026 09:32

FunPartyIdeas · 06/11/2026 09:30

And I would add that a considerable numbers of interventions are not medically necessary, but done to speed up the natural process of labour, which, by its very nature, can be long.
A bit like a conveyor belt.

Edited

Totally agree!

FunPartyIdeas · 06/11/2026 09:30

AnotherVice · 06/11/2026 09:27

Sadly It seems as if a large number of women on this thread have subscribed to the same ‘doctrine of necessity’ that a lot of so-called medical professionals have, ie, if they feel it is necessary, then they can totally disregard a woman’s autonomy and completely undermine the principles of informed consent. This is illegal, unethical and so, so damaging to women’s mental and physical health. A foetus does not exist in law until born. Obstetric violence is very real, frighteningly common and as OP says, happening in plain sight and accepted by so many. I wrote my dissertation on this so have done a lot of research on it.

And I would add that a considerable numbers of interventions are not medically necessary, but done to speed up the natural process of labour, which, by its very nature, can be long.
A bit like a conveyor belt.

AnotherVice · 06/11/2026 09:27

Sadly It seems as if a large number of women on this thread have subscribed to the same ‘doctrine of necessity’ that a lot of so-called medical professionals have, ie, if they feel it is necessary, then they can totally disregard a woman’s autonomy and completely undermine the principles of informed consent. This is illegal, unethical and so, so damaging to women’s mental and physical health. A foetus does not exist in law until born. Obstetric violence is very real, frighteningly common and as OP says, happening in plain sight and accepted by so many. I wrote my dissertation on this so have done a lot of research on it.

RoyalCorgi · 06/11/2026 09:15

I agree with SomethingFun that there are women working in maternity (both midwives and obstetricians) who appear to have no fellow-feeling or sympathy towards the women they're caring for. And I don't think that is wholly because they are overworked or stressed.

You can see the same attitude at work in the responses of some women to the Russell Brand case. Lots of "why didn't she come forward earlier" and even "I went out with Russell Brand and he didn't rape me" kind of comments.

I hesitate to say that women are their own worst enemy, but a lot of them really don't help.

BunionOnion · 06/11/2026 08:13

SomethingFun · 06/11/2026 07:36

I’ve only had c sections from female surgeons and the vast majority of theatre staff I encountered were women alongside all the midwives who were generally vile. I’d liken it to the handmaid’s tale where women are quite happy to be horrific towards other women, particularly the childbearing ones as it gives them a feeling of power and status. Feel free to disagree with me, but I would wager that the midwives and female nhs staff I encountered when I was in maternity would never speak to or treat me the way they did there if we were in a Tescos or something. I don’t think it is normal behaviour from women towards heavily pregnant women but it’s definitely normalised when on maternity wards and you work there.

It’s on this thread to be fair - women expecting sunshine and rainbows, women expecting calmness and clarity in ‘emergency’ situations, women expecting pain free births and that all these expectations are from unreasonable princesses who just need to do as they are told otherwise they or their babies will die. But we do all those things and sadly women and babies die anyway, often from medical negligence, and the ones that survive are often traumatised physically and emotionally from this behaviour and attitude towards them when giving birth.

I do think maternity staff are overstretched and I can see this leads to burnout but assuming you are a competent professional and a decent human being - if you find yourself so lacking in empathy for a woman in the throes of labour that you can deny her easily available pain relief, put your hands on and inside her without consent, perform medical procedures without consent and speak to her like she’s a piece of shit whilst you are doing those things then it is on you to admit defeat with your career and go and do another job.

Perfectly said @SomethingFun 👏

SomethingFun · 06/11/2026 07:36

I’ve only had c sections from female surgeons and the vast majority of theatre staff I encountered were women alongside all the midwives who were generally vile. I’d liken it to the handmaid’s tale where women are quite happy to be horrific towards other women, particularly the childbearing ones as it gives them a feeling of power and status. Feel free to disagree with me, but I would wager that the midwives and female nhs staff I encountered when I was in maternity would never speak to or treat me the way they did there if we were in a Tescos or something. I don’t think it is normal behaviour from women towards heavily pregnant women but it’s definitely normalised when on maternity wards and you work there.

It’s on this thread to be fair - women expecting sunshine and rainbows, women expecting calmness and clarity in ‘emergency’ situations, women expecting pain free births and that all these expectations are from unreasonable princesses who just need to do as they are told otherwise they or their babies will die. But we do all those things and sadly women and babies die anyway, often from medical negligence, and the ones that survive are often traumatised physically and emotionally from this behaviour and attitude towards them when giving birth.

I do think maternity staff are overstretched and I can see this leads to burnout but assuming you are a competent professional and a decent human being - if you find yourself so lacking in empathy for a woman in the throes of labour that you can deny her easily available pain relief, put your hands on and inside her without consent, perform medical procedures without consent and speak to her like she’s a piece of shit whilst you are doing those things then it is on you to admit defeat with your career and go and do another job.

Koulibiak · 06/11/2026 00:00

LiberteLynx · 05/11/2026 10:16

Thank you for clarifying you are only considering British women with low risk pregnancies who give birth vaginally in the UK. Last I looked, a midwife cannot perform a c-section.

You are holding midwives wholly accountable for implementing the RCOG and NICE rules and pathways largely written by men.

You are also ignoring the progressive defunding and destaffing of maternity care by mostly male NHS managers.

Easy to blame the frontline (female) worker for not having enough beds or staff or pain relief medication or for rules they did not write but are required to follow.

I am not saying the blame lies only with men. I am saying it is not as simple as ‘woman on woman’ violence with midwives wholly to blame.

Edited

oh just stop digging. I didn’t encounter any male ob/gyns in my pregnancies, so I’m certainly not going to report on male on female violence in maternity services.

I have been in contact with plenty of incompetent and dangerous midwives.

You claiming “but I didn’t write them rules” is just pathetic.

On this thread we’ve had midwives who have called women cuckoo and self entitled fantasists, who have likened pregnant women to sectioned patients, and who have misrepresented the Amos review and clinical negligence damages in Canada. So no, I’m not going to yield over because you said so.

My personal opinion, backed by my experience, is that midwives seem to think they know everything, when in fact they are largely ignorant (and blinded by ideology) and that ignorance puts mothers and babies at risk. Baroness Amos and Donna Ockenden came to the same conclusion. Feel free to bury your head in the sand. Res ipsa loquitur.

FunPartyIdeas · 05/11/2026 22:41

GettingFestiveNow · 05/11/2026 22:21

People who think this doesn't happen need to read some of Donna Ockenden's reviews of NHS maternity services. This is all in the public domain and reported on in the national press at the time. It's not supposition, it's fact, but nothing fucking changes.

March 2022 - review of Shrewsbury and Telford - examined 1,592 cases and identified failures in care across a period spanning more than two decades.

Nottingham 2026 - reviewed 2500 cases - women systematically denied pain relief and subjected to procedures without their consent.

Agreed.
I didn't trust the NHS Maternity Serivces in 2020 - no chance I would in 2026!

GettingFestiveNow · 05/11/2026 22:21

People who think this doesn't happen need to read some of Donna Ockenden's reviews of NHS maternity services. This is all in the public domain and reported on in the national press at the time. It's not supposition, it's fact, but nothing fucking changes.

March 2022 - review of Shrewsbury and Telford - examined 1,592 cases and identified failures in care across a period spanning more than two decades.

Nottingham 2026 - reviewed 2500 cases - women systematically denied pain relief and subjected to procedures without their consent.

BunionOnion · 05/11/2026 21:52

NibliaBiblia · 05/11/2026 08:17

I wish I'd had my mum with me. Your DD is very wise.
I'm sorry for how you were treated.

Thank you 🙏

FunPartyIdeas · 05/11/2026 21:18

Blackthornwickerwoman · 04/11/2026 08:35

Same

I had a home birth with my last baby. None of these featured.

AmnesiacDream · 05/11/2026 16:40

dairydebris · 02/11/2026 14:05

I resent your suggestion that Healthcare providers are commiting intentional violence and the implicit suggestion this is at all comparable to other forms of violence against women.

After the multiple scandals at hospitals and the findings in the recent maternity report by Baroness Valerie Amos, your post just makes you look complicit in criminal treatment of women on maternity wards in the UK.

NibliaBiblia · 05/11/2026 10:52

LiberteLynx · 05/11/2026 10:16

Thank you for clarifying you are only considering British women with low risk pregnancies who give birth vaginally in the UK. Last I looked, a midwife cannot perform a c-section.

You are holding midwives wholly accountable for implementing the RCOG and NICE rules and pathways largely written by men.

You are also ignoring the progressive defunding and destaffing of maternity care by mostly male NHS managers.

Easy to blame the frontline (female) worker for not having enough beds or staff or pain relief medication or for rules they did not write but are required to follow.

I am not saying the blame lies only with men. I am saying it is not as simple as ‘woman on woman’ violence with midwives wholly to blame.

Edited

Good point. 45% of births are cesareans and 10-15% are instrumental/assisted so at minimum 55%+ in the UK involve an obstetrician at some stage.

OP posts:
LiberteLynx · 05/11/2026 10:16

Koulibiak · 04/11/2026 18:22

@LiberteLynx nice bit of whataboutery.

The defining characteristic of maternity care in the U.K. is that it is midwife led. 99.5% of midwives are women. Multiple inquiries, investigations and reviews have repeatedly found midwives to be incompetent, uncaring, blinded by ideology and dangerous. I stand by what I wrote, which is that this is violence perpetrated by women on women.

Thank you for clarifying you are only considering British women with low risk pregnancies who give birth vaginally in the UK. Last I looked, a midwife cannot perform a c-section.

You are holding midwives wholly accountable for implementing the RCOG and NICE rules and pathways largely written by men.

You are also ignoring the progressive defunding and destaffing of maternity care by mostly male NHS managers.

Easy to blame the frontline (female) worker for not having enough beds or staff or pain relief medication or for rules they did not write but are required to follow.

I am not saying the blame lies only with men. I am saying it is not as simple as ‘woman on woman’ violence with midwives wholly to blame.

NibliaBiblia · 05/11/2026 08:17

BunionOnion · 04/11/2026 22:32

I’ve given birth four times. First time I nearly died, last time my baby nearly died. I had some lovely midwives and some midwives who were just - frankly - brutal and shouldn’t have been allowed anywhere near a woman at her
most vulnerable. The bad midwives made me feel stupid, ignored me for hours on end, dismissed my pain and tried to send me home when I was in agony. I am nearly 60 now and still remember how awful those births were. One of my DDs is now pregnant and has asked me to be there with her when she gives birth. If anyone tries to treat my girl like they treated me I will raise hell.

I wish I'd had my mum with me. Your DD is very wise.
I'm sorry for how you were treated.

OP posts:
NibliaBiblia · 05/11/2026 08:16

BusyExpert · 04/11/2026 21:58

Not for me it’s not, I am not an over entitled fantasist.

I do feel entitled to decide who is allowed to touch me. I feel entitled to decide whether or not medical procedures are performed on me.
You call me "cuckoo" and a "fantasist". In your professional opinion as a midwife, is it just me who is lying? Or do you think all the rest of the women on this thread are also lying about the mistreatment, violation and abuse that they were subjected to?

OP posts:
BunionOnion · 04/11/2026 22:32

I’ve given birth four times. First time I nearly died, last time my baby nearly died. I had some lovely midwives and some midwives who were just - frankly - brutal and shouldn’t have been allowed anywhere near a woman at her
most vulnerable. The bad midwives made me feel stupid, ignored me for hours on end, dismissed my pain and tried to send me home when I was in agony. I am nearly 60 now and still remember how awful those births were. One of my DDs is now pregnant and has asked me to be there with her when she gives birth. If anyone tries to treat my girl like they treated me I will raise hell.

Koulibiak · 04/11/2026 22:11

BusyExpert · 04/11/2026 12:47

I am a midwife…….

That explains a lot. Your ilk have killed hundreds of mothers and babies. It must be hard to get exposed for what you are. But your victims are not “cuckoo”, they are voicing what experts have recognised as systemic failure, toxic culture and incompetence.

ElanaohElana · 04/11/2026 22:00

I would fully agree that this was my experience of birth too. There is a horrific culture where there is not informed consent.

BusyExpert · 04/11/2026 21:58

NibliaBiblia · 04/11/2026 12:53

Well that's worrying.

Not for me it’s not, I am not an over entitled fantasist.

Koulibiak · 04/11/2026 21:00

PollyNomial · 04/11/2026 20:34

That review looked at 12 hospitals (<10%) and, declaration of interest, OH works in one of them in a service that supports maternity (not midwife or obstetrics) - these hospitals are all "failing" and it's not remotely a representative sample.

The methodology on selecting hospitals is at page 107. I will take Amos at her word, rather than yours.

https://www.matneoinv.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/NMNI-Final-Report-and-Recommendations.pdf

PollyNomial · 04/11/2026 20:59

NibliaBiblia · 04/11/2026 20:37

Does it have to be representative to be a problem? Those twelve hospitals are going to be serving, and failing, a lot of women.

If a review only looks at <bad things>, it will have generally bad findings just as surely as if a review only looks at <good things>, it will have generally good findings.

So, yes, it really does matter if a review has an unrepresentative sample and you want to draw national conclusions from it.

NibliaBiblia · 04/11/2026 20:37

PollyNomial · 04/11/2026 20:34

That review looked at 12 hospitals (<10%) and, declaration of interest, OH works in one of them in a service that supports maternity (not midwife or obstetrics) - these hospitals are all "failing" and it's not remotely a representative sample.

Does it have to be representative to be a problem? Those twelve hospitals are going to be serving, and failing, a lot of women.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread