Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Mr Menno examines Hunter Schafer and passing

58 replies

mardirousse · 02/11/2026 00:49

I love Mr Menno. This one is exceptionally insightful. He looks into "the prettiest girl in the world", the phenomenon of "passing" , gender reassignment surgery, and the sick, twisted porn fueled ideas Hunter himself has about women, femininity and rape.

It's really well researched and put together. Shows the complicity of the fashion world and Hollywood. And that wonderful Germaine Greer clip separating feminity (fake) from female (real)

In Hunter's own words, his sexuality is not gay, straight, bi or pan. "It's attraction to misogyny". Just like the other sick hateful transwomen such as Juno Dawson and Andrea whatshisface. But we don't expect it from "the prettiest girl in the world"

Anyone who feels there are some transwomen who pass so well they deserve to be accepted as women should watch this and then discuss.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/8yxev3CHiWE?is=o7hH6Mnal-S1zBon

OP posts:
CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 02/11/2026 21:44

Thanks for sharing that video. I do have some sympathy for HS, the bullying and rigid sex based roles in his school s d family have clearly led him down this path.

I am also totally shocked at his age and found his demeanour, aggressive language and looks to be unmistakably male. He really doesn’t pass.

His emotional growth has obviously been stunted and who knows what health problems he’s got on the horizon. Kim Petras is ahead of him I think and appears to be suffering already.

This whole industry exploitative and evil - fetishistic men and profiteers benefit.

Seriestwo · 03/11/2026 01:03

He doesn’t pass. Maybe in a still, filtered posed photo with only him in it - but see him move and it’s obvious.

it’s cruel to lie to these men.

2021x · 03/11/2026 02:29

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 02/11/2026 17:49

Ugh, that guy Menno is such a creep.

Hunter S has done nothing whatsoever to anyone, and 'examining' her is...yeah, creepy as hell. When cis men do this to any woman, believe them the first time.

When all this dies down, and moderation comes back in- what do you think will happen to these young men who have been castrated?

Helleofabore · 03/11/2026 06:02

I do think though that Hunter Schafer being labelled using descriptions referencing female sex based terms signals that this person is the ultimate reference point in ‘passing’. Some people obviously believe that he fits the category of passing as a female person.

It is enlightening to see this. Because to me it is just another example of the ‘near enough is good enough’ approach that some people on MN have indicated is what then gives them acceptance to use female language for themselves. Because they purchased either hormones or surgery to develop breast tissue primarily.

To me it is also an indication of how many people either are or pretend to be incapable of detecting male sex category cues on male bodies. It is also an indication as to the extremes some peoole will go to be considered true supporters of a philosophical belief.

There are several young male people with transgender identities that are featured by media coverage over the past two years who have been reported as having early pubertal hormonal intervention. Those male people are still recognisably male people.

I think we are seeing some people desperately attempting to persuade others that there early pubertal hormonal treatments produce results that mean these male people ‘pass’. However, I think we are seeing the proof that early treatment doesn’t produce the results as claimed.

After all, if Hunter Schafer, a renown model doesn’t ’pass’ after early puberty hormonal treatment what chance is there for others. Therefore there seems to be concerted effort to describe this man as achieving the ultimate acclaim of being a beautiful woman indistinguishable from other women when the reality is clear to so many- this model is very much a male person.

Helleofabore · 03/11/2026 06:10

What ‘harm’ has Hunter Schafer done ?

He has accepted nomination for actress awards. Meaning he has accepted a place that should have gone to a female person for recognition of excellence. Female actors have a very obvious current and historical need to be recognised for their talent.

There is also a situation where he has described himself using female reference terms. He may feel he has no option now after the decisions he and his family made in his youth. However, he is now an adult and has responsibility for his own decisions. He uses female language for himself when he is a male person. There is harm in this, particularly as a role model for young girls who may not understand that he is male.

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 03/11/2026 06:14

Datun · 02/11/2026 13:27

God, that is absolutely tragic.

He became aroused and attracted to misogyny, and like a lot of these men, only felt validated if he was abused. He even went as far as wanting to be consumed by men, almost literally, with drawings of teeth and mouths.

He said he can't feel like a real woman until he's raped. Ffs.

And then bizarrely says that the reason he wanted to be a woman is because he didn't like the things that men did, macho stuff.

And his parents saying they were worried he liked girly things, and God made you as you are, so, obviously, homosexuality was definitely off the fucking table.

Now he's being feted and held up as a beauty, sought after by porn addled men.

He can't perform sex, he wants his penis cut off, and, I was absolutely gobsmacked that he's 28. He sounded like a 15-year-old kid.

And as Menno pointed out, his desire to flee the macho world of maleness has resulted in his embodiment of male domination, claiming that to feel like a woman he needs to be abused and raped.

It's all so fucked up.

A 28-year-old man completely stunted in his mental and physical development using misogyny and misandry as his only currency.

I fucking hate this ideology.

A thought literally just occurred to me, I wonder if motivation for some trans identified men to have 'bottom surgery' is because they don't actually want or enjoy anal sex and they think having a pseudo vagina would be more comfortable or convenient. I wonder if they find themselves so 'niche' in terms of partners they attract that they feel they have no choice. Especially ones like Hunter who have gone way past the point of no return in terms of having any kind of normal male sexual response or of being able to attract sexual partners who don't want/expect/fetishise the opportunity to penetrate them.

2021x · 03/11/2026 07:34

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 03/11/2026 06:14

A thought literally just occurred to me, I wonder if motivation for some trans identified men to have 'bottom surgery' is because they don't actually want or enjoy anal sex and they think having a pseudo vagina would be more comfortable or convenient. I wonder if they find themselves so 'niche' in terms of partners they attract that they feel they have no choice. Especially ones like Hunter who have gone way past the point of no return in terms of having any kind of normal male sexual response or of being able to attract sexual partners who don't want/expect/fetishise the opportunity to penetrate them.

It could be many things all crashing down at once.; I have thought that, for gay men, part of the motivation is because they are attracted to what they consider to be "typically" straight men.

For example, the type of men who loudly objectify women and are very specific about wanting women to be a certain way- body hair-less, long, luxurious hair and fat in very specific places, i.e. on the chest.

Those who run the fashion and entertainment industry. The Dr Frankensteins and Pygmalions in the cosmetic surgery circles who want to be seen as legends, and all the tentacles and dollars going from these groups of people into the legislation,

The people who it's not benefiting are the confused and insecure teenage boys being told they could be someone worthy if they just completely fuck their body up for the comfort of homophobes and pleasure of creeps.

Datun · 03/11/2026 07:48

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 03/11/2026 06:14

A thought literally just occurred to me, I wonder if motivation for some trans identified men to have 'bottom surgery' is because they don't actually want or enjoy anal sex and they think having a pseudo vagina would be more comfortable or convenient. I wonder if they find themselves so 'niche' in terms of partners they attract that they feel they have no choice. Especially ones like Hunter who have gone way past the point of no return in terms of having any kind of normal male sexual response or of being able to attract sexual partners who don't want/expect/fetishise the opportunity to penetrate them.

Presumably Hunter has few if any sexual feelings. Like Jazz Jennings. It seemed from the video that it was more about him having a bulge. It was getting in the way of his career.

If he never went through puberty, and didn't develop, he'll still have the sexuality of a child.

And yes, i'm sure men fetishise him horribly. It's so disturbing, all of it.

I have thought that, for gay men, part of the motivation is because they are attracted to what they consider to be "typically" straight men.

Ray Blanchard who came up with the two types of trans identified men, AGP, and HSTS (homosexual transsexual), claims that yes, this is indeed the case.

Some form of internal homophobia making gay men wanting to attract straight men, not gay ones. It's a strong fantasy.

See India Willoughby on Big Brother absolutely outraged that one of the straight men wouldn't kiss him. Also Juno Dawson, who claims the man he lives with is straight. That they are a heterosexual couple.

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 03/11/2026 07:56

Datun · 03/11/2026 07:48

Presumably Hunter has few if any sexual feelings. Like Jazz Jennings. It seemed from the video that it was more about him having a bulge. It was getting in the way of his career.

If he never went through puberty, and didn't develop, he'll still have the sexuality of a child.

And yes, i'm sure men fetishise him horribly. It's so disturbing, all of it.

I have thought that, for gay men, part of the motivation is because they are attracted to what they consider to be "typically" straight men.

Ray Blanchard who came up with the two types of trans identified men, AGP, and HSTS (homosexual transsexual), claims that yes, this is indeed the case.

Some form of internal homophobia making gay men wanting to attract straight men, not gay ones. It's a strong fantasy.

See India Willoughby on Big Brother absolutely outraged that one of the straight men wouldn't kiss him. Also Juno Dawson, who claims the man he lives with is straight. That they are a heterosexual couple.

Edited

No indeed. So the passive sexual role that men like this adopt in sexual relationships can't be fulfilling in any way other than as a source of affection and validation.

2021x · 03/11/2026 08:02

Datun · 03/11/2026 07:48

Presumably Hunter has few if any sexual feelings. Like Jazz Jennings. It seemed from the video that it was more about him having a bulge. It was getting in the way of his career.

If he never went through puberty, and didn't develop, he'll still have the sexuality of a child.

And yes, i'm sure men fetishise him horribly. It's so disturbing, all of it.

I have thought that, for gay men, part of the motivation is because they are attracted to what they consider to be "typically" straight men.

Ray Blanchard who came up with the two types of trans identified men, AGP, and HSTS (homosexual transsexual), claims that yes, this is indeed the case.

Some form of internal homophobia making gay men wanting to attract straight men, not gay ones. It's a strong fantasy.

See India Willoughby on Big Brother absolutely outraged that one of the straight men wouldn't kiss him. Also Juno Dawson, who claims the man he lives with is straight. That they are a heterosexual couple.

Edited

Right… it's almost like their definition of a male has to include the bog-standard misogynistic behaviour that also includes intense homophobia.

I can see how they could convince themselves, in their misery, that this is how to get what they want. It's incredibly sad that HS wasn't given the chance to grow up and then make that decision.

As abhorrent and narcissistic as HS's inner thoughts about women appear to me, Menno's video helped me understand that women, i.e the lesser being, are just a proxy for his own identity. He isn't worthy of being the man that he is - or that he thinks his family will love him to be- therefore, it's better to be a woman instead.

Datun · 03/11/2026 08:11

2021x · 03/11/2026 08:02

Right… it's almost like their definition of a male has to include the bog-standard misogynistic behaviour that also includes intense homophobia.

I can see how they could convince themselves, in their misery, that this is how to get what they want. It's incredibly sad that HS wasn't given the chance to grow up and then make that decision.

As abhorrent and narcissistic as HS's inner thoughts about women appear to me, Menno's video helped me understand that women, i.e the lesser being, are just a proxy for his own identity. He isn't worthy of being the man that he is - or that he thinks his family will love him to be- therefore, it's better to be a woman instead.

He isn't worthy of being the man that he is - or that he thinks his family will love him to be- therefore, it's better to be a woman instead.

Yes. That's why, to me certainly, it's all so sexist. There's no part of him that actually wants to be a woman, he just doesn't want to be a man, so the concept of woman is the means to do it.

We are a resource.

Hence the overwhelming lack of affinity for actual women. And the outrage that they can't use all our provision.

Datun · 03/11/2026 08:14

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 03/11/2026 07:56

No indeed. So the passive sexual role that men like this adopt in sexual relationships can't be fulfilling in any way other than as a source of affection and validation.

it's incredibly sad. I feel the same about Jazz Jennings. Their lives are utterly curtailed. This ideology is criminal.

2021x · 03/11/2026 08:17

Datun · 03/11/2026 08:11

He isn't worthy of being the man that he is - or that he thinks his family will love him to be- therefore, it's better to be a woman instead.

Yes. That's why, to me certainly, it's all so sexist. There's no part of him that actually wants to be a woman, he just doesn't want to be a man, so the concept of woman is the means to do it.

We are a resource.

Hence the overwhelming lack of affinity for actual women. And the outrage that they can't use all our provision.

Edited

Of course, it's the same with Alexis Blake; the narcissism isn't overt like India W and RuPaul-type characters; it's covert. They don't empathise with what it means for women, because they physically cannot think about anything but themselves and their pain.

Thats why I think a lot of gay men think they aren't a threat to women and therefore women are just being transphobic. It is easier for a gay man to understand the single sex space as discrimination from a gay protectionist perspective rather than the female one. I am very interested in the upcoming interview Menno teased with the gay therapist in the US. I have been watching his content, and he has a very male-oriented approach without being misogynistic. He has even changed his mind on a few things in the comments.

SylvanMoon · 03/11/2026 09:40

Datun · 03/11/2026 08:11

He isn't worthy of being the man that he is - or that he thinks his family will love him to be- therefore, it's better to be a woman instead.

Yes. That's why, to me certainly, it's all so sexist. There's no part of him that actually wants to be a woman, he just doesn't want to be a man, so the concept of woman is the means to do it.

We are a resource.

Hence the overwhelming lack of affinity for actual women. And the outrage that they can't use all our provision.

Edited

This discussion is interesting, because it's highlighting that these men are very clear that there aren't a smorgasbord of genders that they can choose from: it's either male or female. If one isn't working for them, then the other one might.

Datun · 03/11/2026 09:53

This discussion is interesting, because it's highlighting that these men are very clear that there aren't a smorgasbord of genders that they can choose from: it's either male or female. If one isn't working for them, then the other one might.

Yes. Casting about to try and find the stereotypes that fit, and finding none of them do, because they're negative. Whereas feminism wants to eliminate them altogether, because they're negative.

In another universe these two attitudes are almost aligned.

CassOle · 03/11/2026 10:26

There is another group of men who are having vaginoplasty, and it is interesting to compare and contrast the two groups.

  1. men who identify as women (for whatever reason).
  2. men who are in dom/sub 'pup-play' homosexual relationship.

You have guessed it, it is always the 'sub' that has the vaginoplasty in scenario number 2.

PassTheHanky · 03/11/2026 12:03

Do we know whether puberty blockers totally block ALL male development?

I know PBs inhibit the development of secondary sex characteristics but their male bodies are still rammed full of XY chromosomes so what effect do they have?
Some young males are almost able pass as women in large part due to the freshness of youth but the bodies of men and women age differently so as TIMs get older I wonder if their XY chromosomes make them look more and more male and drive them to take more and more actions to try and regain their youthful "femaleness"?

Catsanfan · 03/11/2026 12:05

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 02/11/2026 17:49

Ugh, that guy Menno is such a creep.

Hunter S has done nothing whatsoever to anyone, and 'examining' her is...yeah, creepy as hell. When cis men do this to any woman, believe them the first time.

In what way is he a creep? I've met him a few times, he's lovely

FrippEnos · 03/11/2026 12:29

Catsanfan · 03/11/2026 12:05

In what way is he a creep? I've met him a few times, he's lovely

That's an easy one to answer

For TRAs he is a creep because he uses his platfrom to tell the truth and not fawn over trans people. He asks questions that very few people are prepared to ask.

I am amazed that he stays as cool as he does when he interviews trans people and their allies.

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2026 12:40

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 02/11/2026 17:49

Ugh, that guy Menno is such a creep.

Hunter S has done nothing whatsoever to anyone, and 'examining' her is...yeah, creepy as hell. When cis men do this to any woman, believe them the first time.

HS is a man pretending to be a woman - that needs calling out just like Blackface does.

solerolover · 03/11/2026 12:52

I remember seeing a picture of Hunter posing with his sister on social media and instantly clocking him despite the fact that he's turned to the side
https://x.com/schaferfiles/status/1896875759136113094
Even when you can only see a portion of his face full on, there's no doubt that he's a man

Mr Menno examines Hunter Schafer and passing
solerolover · 03/11/2026 13:01

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 02/11/2026 17:49

Ugh, that guy Menno is such a creep.

Hunter S has done nothing whatsoever to anyone, and 'examining' her is...yeah, creepy as hell. When cis men do this to any woman, believe them the first time.

Hunter is a man who literally gets off on misogyny and sexual violence towards women, he has said so himself. He is utterly repugnant and the actual creep here, keep seal clapping for him though.

Sensitive content
Mr Menno examines Hunter Schafer and passing
NibliaBiblia · 03/11/2026 13:11

I have thought that, for gay men, part of the motivation is because they are attracted to what they consider to be "typically" straight men.

As Woody Allen (I think) says: I wouldn't want to join a club that would have someone like me as a member.

ChequerToRed · 03/11/2026 14:38

PassTheHanky · 03/11/2026 12:03

Do we know whether puberty blockers totally block ALL male development?

I know PBs inhibit the development of secondary sex characteristics but their male bodies are still rammed full of XY chromosomes so what effect do they have?
Some young males are almost able pass as women in large part due to the freshness of youth but the bodies of men and women age differently so as TIMs get older I wonder if their XY chromosomes make them look more and more male and drive them to take more and more actions to try and regain their youthful "femaleness"?

This is a part of the PB debate that gets very little airing, probably because it throws up some raw truths that don’t support the narrative. The biggest proponents of giving PBs to children are adult men who wail and lament about ridiculous notions such as being ‘poisoned by testosterone’ and having a body ‘destroyed by puberty’. It’s just magical thinking that doesn’t stack up when looking at the evidence. The few transwomen who we know have taken PBs when younger still don't pass. HS doesn’t pass except in artfully selected photos, pap shots just make him look like a gawky young man with long hair, that Dutch makeup tutorial YouTuber (can’t remember his name) is huge and doesn’t pass, the poor son of that awful women from Mermaids doesn’t pass, Jazz Jennings doesn’t pass and struggles with his weight. What PBs do to a male body seems to be, unsurprisingly, very similar to examples we can look at through history. Take the castrati singers so popular in the 17th and 18th century who had their puberty blocked through castration, they tended to be very tall (it prevents bone growth plates closing) and to easily put on weight. Sure, they didn’t grow facial hair, but they still looked unmistakably male. Adding in some oestrogen doesn’t seem to get rid of this, it may sometimes, but obviously not always, prevent the tall stature, and grows them some boobs, but it certainly doesn’t give them the impossibility of a female puberty or erase male features.
Basically, we already know the results of stopping male puberty, we’ve known for hundreds, maybe thousands of years, but all that gets thrown under a bus because some guy who transitioned age 42 is upset that he can't transform in the cute little uwu anime girl of his fantasies, so a drug with some really nasty side effects and results that don’t match up to the hype are given to healthy children, some of whom would probably just grow up gay if left alone.

GriseldaandMike · 03/11/2026 16:55

NibliaBiblia · 03/11/2026 13:11

I have thought that, for gay men, part of the motivation is because they are attracted to what they consider to be "typically" straight men.

As Woody Allen (I think) says: I wouldn't want to join a club that would have someone like me as a member.

“I refuse to join any club that would have me as a member.” — Groucho Marx

Swipe left for the next trending thread