Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Stonewall CEO attempting to adopt a more moderate position

208 replies

ItsCoolForCats · 01/11/2026 11:16

He wants to "turn down the heat" 🙄

I can't imagine this going down well amongst the TQ++++.....

"Stonewall was not, Blake stressed, aiming to overturn the supreme court ruling.* *“We understand that this is the law. But we also want to ensure that trans people are protected and, along with other organisations, we are looking at what that would look like.”

Article in the Guardian today

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/01/progress-takes-time-stonewall-ceo-on-turning-down-the-heat-on-the-trans-debate?shem=dsdf,sharefoc,agadiscoversdl,,sh/x/discover/m1/4

‘Progress takes time’: Stonewall CEO on turning down the heat on the trans debate

Leader is charting a course through troubled waters as a new survey finds trans people feel more pessimistic about social acceptance after combative decade

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/01/progress-takes-time-stonewall-ceo-on-turning-down-the-heat-on-the-trans-debate?shem=dsdf%2Csharefoc%2Cagadiscoversdl%2C%2Csh%2Fx%2Fdiscover%2Fm1%2F4

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 02/11/2026 08:35

MrsOvertonsWindow · 02/11/2026 08:29

I see Cool is now on version 12,345 on why women have no rights to single sex changing rooms, hospital wards, sports, toilets away from men. - oh and are responsible for the last decade + of transactivists repeatedly demonstrating male power, bullying, threats and intimidation.

Tough luck mate. You lot decided on #nodebate from the outset. Now whining that you didn't really mean anyone could change sex, that men don't really want access to undressed women while incoherently swerving to "There's also no law saying trans people can't use the public toilet of their choice"

It's a dizzying and incoherent ride you lot have taken society on. It would be funny if it hadn't been so damaging to so many, especially the young.

Maybe time for a period of quiet reflection along with a cup of chamomile tea as you work out how to accept that the bullying all came from transactivists?

Waste of energy you trying to coerce women into thinking we're the problem. The gig's up mate. Time to come to terms with it.

Edited

Well, Cool seems to have been up all night In The Cause, so perhaps getting some sleep would be in order? It must be exhausting trying to keep coming up with new ways to say the same wrong stuff.

Who cares, anyway? They can say whatever they like. Doesn't make it true, and none of it will hold up in court. Hence the wheedling, near begging, coming from Stonewall now. It's a just a distraction tactic.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 02/11/2026 08:29

I see Cool is now on version 12,345 on why women have no rights to single sex changing rooms, hospital wards, sports, toilets away from men. - oh and are responsible for the last decade + of transactivists repeatedly demonstrating male power, bullying, threats and intimidation.

Tough luck mate. You lot decided on #nodebate from the outset. Now whining that you didn't really mean anyone could change sex, that men don't really want access to undressed women while incoherently swerving to "There's also no law saying trans people can't use the public toilet of their choice"

It's a dizzying and incoherent ride you lot have taken society on. It would be funny if it hadn't been so damaging to so many, especially the young.

Maybe time for a period of quiet reflection along with a cup of chamomile tea as you work out how to accept that the bullying all came from transactivists?

Waste of energy you trying to coerce women into thinking we're the problem. The gig's up mate. Time to come to terms with it.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 07:23

Mountainlarch · 02/11/2026 07:11

Exemptions have always existed but we're never applied because of "Stonewall law". The application of the real law had to be gained again tribunal by tribunal, up to the Supreme Court. It's not done yet in its practical applications. Once we're back to respecting the law, then we can start discussing.

Its not done yet because there's no specific case law yet in terms of toilets exclusion other than employment law. Until there is there's going to be 'different interpretations' rather than disrespect of the law because the law is vague as it stands & service providers can be sued for indirect discrimination either way. There's also no law saying trans people can't use the public toilet of their choice outside of employment law because the law only applies to service providers.

In any case the point is space exclusion is still available in law so acknowledging identity is irrelevant.

Pingponghavoc · 02/11/2026 07:18

The term 'Cis woman' makes no sense if woman is an undefined series of traits.

People either identify into the group, or they dont.

Mountainlarch · 02/11/2026 07:11

Exemptions have always existed but we're never applied because of "Stonewall law". The application of the real law had to be gained again tribunal by tribunal, up to the Supreme Court. It's not done yet in its practical applications. Once we're back to respecting the law, then we can start discussing.

Pingponghavoc · 02/11/2026 07:08

"They are claiming they have more in common with the typical inclinations & interests of women as a group & therefore are more like them categorically than men as a group. That's not the same as claiming women & men exclusively have a distinct set of inclinations & interests."

We're back to "Men are whatever men say they are and women are whatever men say they are".

An individual man can define what a woman is to him, and therefore become one. Women cannot ask questions or challenge their assumptions because that is denying the mans existence.

Women do not get to define ourselves, men do. Our existence is always defined by men, so we cannot claim the discrepancies in these definitions means our existence is being denied.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 06:59

AlexandraLeaving · 02/11/2026 06:47

I’m interested in this reference to using shared words. I think that is a significant part of the problem.

If, instead of adopting “man” and “woman”, transpeople had identified new labels - say, feminina and masculino - that would have avoided the overlap, but still signified the link to traditional/stereotyped behaviour/hobbies/interests that you say is important. Non-binary could have been included as the gender identity equivalent of agnostic.

Society could then have had a discussion about whether femininas and/or masculinos or non-binaries needed particular adjustments or protections. That could have included the provision of fourth spaces in toilet/changing rooms etc etc. It could, in fact, have had the debate that @MyAmpleSheep tried to start with this thread https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5592833-for-which-services-is-seperated-by-gender-appropriate?page=1

But instead, the activists used words that already had meanings and sought to change those meanings. That caused confusion, and left the traditionally disadvantaged group of people formerly known as “women” without an unambiguous label for their sex-class. It also opened the door for those who wished to to colonise previously single-sex spaces, claiming they were intended to be single-gender spaces. It also reinforced gender stereotypes because of the insistence that liking dolls/pink/make-up were attributes or identifiers of “women”.

And that’s all before we get to the (many) nut jobs who argue they have “literally” changed sex.

You act as if exemptions from anti discrimination law for cis/natal women don't exist & they do so shared words (that involve prefix distinctions mind you) is irrelevant to what it actually takes to justify the protection of spaces.

But I appreciate that the use of shared words is a sore point regardless of prefix distinction & rights already being protected regardless so I'm open to any reasonable ideas that might help alleviate the conflict. Its an interesting proposal because its still directly representative of the phenomena itself without the added baggage of stereotypical associations to sex & certainly worth pursuing. Well done!

But here's the rub, there can be no united 'trouble shooting' until both parties are willing to acknowledge the others humanity & concerns.

JellySaurus · 02/11/2026 06:57

MyAmpleSheep · 01/11/2026 21:05

Over the years, the meaning of that slogan has been intentionally misappropriated to suggest that trans people and their allies were refusing to collaborate, compromise or discuss policy affecting trans people.

That's obviously not true, and a convenient retcon for stonewall.

Like their retcon that the Stonewall riots were started by a TIM.

’Post-truth’?

AlexandraLeaving · 02/11/2026 06:47

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 00:41

Part of not gender critical feminists not being able to reckon with gender is they confuse it with sex. They are not the same thing so there is no shared identity being proposed in terms of reproductive sex. The shared identity is the sociologically constructed associations with cis/natal women as in gendered associations - a completely different concept to sex.

Therefore, clearly the real source of friction is the shared usage of words rather than the concepts themselves. But I don't know how you can reasonably get around the fact that women & men have both gendered associations tied to them hence the shared usage of words.

And what's disingenuous about this resistance to shared words 'because it confusing' is prefixes as in 'trans' & 'cis' solve this confusion….& yet its still not enough.

You can't expect to be considered to be entering a negotiation or even a debate in good faith where there is no possibility of rational discussion.

Edited

I’m interested in this reference to using shared words. I think that is a significant part of the problem.

If, instead of adopting “man” and “woman”, transpeople had identified new labels - say, feminina and masculino - that would have avoided the overlap, but still signified the link to traditional/stereotyped behaviour/hobbies/interests that you say is important. Non-binary could have been included as the gender identity equivalent of agnostic.

Society could then have had a discussion about whether femininas and/or masculinos or non-binaries needed particular adjustments or protections. That could have included the provision of fourth spaces in toilet/changing rooms etc etc. It could, in fact, have had the debate that @MyAmpleSheep tried to start with this thread https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5592833-for-which-services-is-seperated-by-gender-appropriate?page=1

But instead, the activists used words that already had meanings and sought to change those meanings. That caused confusion, and left the traditionally disadvantaged group of people formerly known as “women” without an unambiguous label for their sex-class. It also opened the door for those who wished to to colonise previously single-sex spaces, claiming they were intended to be single-gender spaces. It also reinforced gender stereotypes because of the insistence that liking dolls/pink/make-up were attributes or identifiers of “women”.

And that’s all before we get to the (many) nut jobs who argue they have “literally” changed sex.

For which services is separate by "gender" appropriate? | Mumsnet

Assuming it to be compliant with all relevant legislation (which is another discussion), which public services make more (or enough) sense to separate...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5592833-for-which-services-is-seperated-by-gender-appropriate?page=1

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 06:26

WatchingFellini · 02/11/2026 05:53

See, I don’t think “woman” is a gender. It’s the word for an adult human female. Why can’t people who identify with more stereotypically feminine stuff use their own word for that gender? It’s muddying the waters if men call themselves women, isn’t it? They’re using their identity as transwomen to gain access to spaces they have no right being in.

"See, I don’t think “woman” is a gender. It’s the word for an adult human female. Why can’t people who identify with more stereotypically feminine stuff use their own word for that gender"

But gender (typical inclinations & interests) comes into being because of adult human male/female expression. Gender identity is a result of being male or female. The two are inextricably linked. Gender of what? Gender of a human adult female or male also known as man/woman.

There is no other word that represents the phenomena being described.

They’re using their identity as transwomen to gain access to spaces they have no right being in.

Word labels have no bearing on access to spaces. Special exemptions for cis women specifically require a legitimate aim justification so word labelling doesn't come into it.

WatchingFellini · 02/11/2026 05:53

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 05:28

They are claiming they have more in common with the typical inclinations & interests of women as a group & therefore are more like them categorically than men as a group. That's not the same as claiming women & men exclusively have a distinct set of inclinations & interests.

What bothers me about the concern regarding perpetuating stereotypes is its like a denial that typical behaviours exist when they clearly do that are already socially categorised. Trans people aren't responsible for these social categories existing, they already exist by virtue of socially constructed categorisations of typical behaviours.

As an example I'm a cis woman, if I had to categorise my 'gender' it would sit in the 'woman' category because I have more in common with the typical interests & inclinations of women as a group. The gender identity of man/woman isn't exclusive to trans people we all have one or we have neither in the case where many people are a mixed bag of both male/female typical behaviours & as such are 'non binary'.

See, I don’t think “woman” is a gender. It’s the word for an adult human female. Why can’t people who identify with more stereotypically feminine stuff use their own word for that gender? It’s muddying the waters if men call themselves women, isn’t it? They’re using their identity as transwomen to gain access to spaces they have no right being in.

StealthTroublemaker · 02/11/2026 05:45

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 05:28

They are claiming they have more in common with the typical inclinations & interests of women as a group & therefore are more like them categorically than men as a group. That's not the same as claiming women & men exclusively have a distinct set of inclinations & interests.

What bothers me about the concern regarding perpetuating stereotypes is its like a denial that typical behaviours exist when they clearly do that are already socially categorised. Trans people aren't responsible for these social categories existing, they already exist by virtue of socially constructed categorisations of typical behaviours.

As an example I'm a cis woman, if I had to categorise my 'gender' it would sit in the 'woman' category because I have more in common with the typical interests & inclinations of women as a group. The gender identity of man/woman isn't exclusive to trans people we all have one or we have neither in the case where many people are a mixed bag of both male/female typical behaviours & as such are 'non binary'.

So if you like knitting and are kind you’re a woman? What is a list of these “gender stereotypes”? Just so I can check l’m really à woman. I mean, I think I’m a woman as I’m female but you seem to think it’s not biology that makes you a woman but your hobbies and interests.

StealthTroublemaker · 02/11/2026 05:43

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:58

I’m not sure I agree because I think gender identity pushes harmful gender stereotypes

At its essence gender identity is just another form of expressing gender non conformity within one's sex which is the opposite of 'pushing' sex stereotypes.

Well no, if say a man wore dresses, and adopted a lot of the sexist gubbins you call “gender stereotypes” that society has deemed belong to women, and still claimed to be a man, he would be widening the bandwidth of what it is to be a man and be GNC. If a man does the same but claims that adopting these stereotypes makes him a woman, he is pushing the gender stereotypes that anyone who does these things must be a woman.

Patriarchy - only women wear dresses
GC feminists - anyone can wear a dress
Gender Ideologists - anyone wearing a dress is a woman

hope this helps.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 05:28

WatchingFellini · 02/11/2026 05:00

Again, not sure I agree because they’re claiming to be women because they like stereotypically feminine things instead of saying they’re men who like those things, and to me that is very much pushing gender stereotypes.

Edited

They are claiming they have more in common with the typical inclinations & interests of women as a group & therefore are more like them categorically than men as a group. That's not the same as claiming women & men exclusively have a distinct set of inclinations & interests.

What bothers me about the concern regarding perpetuating stereotypes is its like a denial that typical behaviours exist when they clearly do that are already socially categorised. Trans people aren't responsible for these social categories existing, they already exist by virtue of socially constructed categorisations of typical behaviours.

As an example I'm a cis woman, if I had to categorise my 'gender' it would sit in the 'woman' category because I have more in common with the typical interests & inclinations of women as a group. The gender identity of man/woman isn't exclusive to trans people we all have one or we have neither in the case where many people are a mixed bag of both male/female typical behaviours & as such are 'non binary'.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 05:06

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 05:00

I'm not assuming anything about children, or anyone else. I'm asking about men who come to transness in middle age. Don't deflect.

I asked "What percentage of middle-aged men donning dresses and wigs do so for sexual gratification, do you think?"

You're completely unable to answer because any honest answer destroys your claim that there's no link between fetishism and trans status.

I'm not assuming anything about children, or anyone else. I'm asking about men who come to transness in middle age. Don't deflect.

How do you know they only "came to transness in middle age"? You only know they came out at that time…not the same thing.

I asked "What percentage of middle-aged men donning dresses and wigs do so for sexual gratification, do you think?"

And I answered your irrelevant nonsensical question.

WatchingFellini · 02/11/2026 05:00

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:58

I’m not sure I agree because I think gender identity pushes harmful gender stereotypes

At its essence gender identity is just another form of expressing gender non conformity within one's sex which is the opposite of 'pushing' sex stereotypes.

Again, not sure I agree because they’re claiming to be women because they like stereotypically feminine things instead of saying they’re men who like those things, and to me that is very much pushing gender stereotypes.

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 05:00

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:55

By this logic are you assuming children suffering from gender dysphoria are fetishising too?

Sorry, I don't operate on 'guesswork' or personal biases. Get back to me when you have credible data on the matter.

I'm not assuming anything about children, or anyone else. I'm asking about men who come to transness in middle age. Don't deflect.

I asked "What percentage of middle-aged men donning dresses and wigs do so for sexual gratification, do you think?"

You're completely unable to answer because any honest answer destroys your claim that there's no link between fetishism and trans status.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:58

WatchingFellini · 02/11/2026 04:54

I’m not sure I agree because I think gender identity pushes harmful gender stereotypes - it just does it in a different way -but as I say, I don’t really care how people choose to frame their identities as long as they don’t use them to harm others which is all too common with transpeople these days, I’m afraid.

I’m not sure I agree because I think gender identity pushes harmful gender stereotypes

At its essence gender identity is just another form of expressing gender non conformity within one's sex which is the opposite of 'pushing' sex stereotypes.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:55

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 04:49

What percentage of middle-aged men donning dresses and wigs do so for sexual gratification, do you think?

Give us your best guess.

By this logic are you assuming children suffering from gender dysphoria are fetishising too?

Sorry, I don't operate on 'guesswork' or personal biases. Get back to me when you have credible data on the matter.

WatchingFellini · 02/11/2026 04:54

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:45

No, some of them literally do claim to be women with cervixes and periods somehow whole shebang

Yep & some religious nutters claim they are Jesus Christ but we don't go around claiming all religious people are nutters because of it.

I only have a problem

Sure, plenty of people limit their critique of trans people to conflicting rights, I'm one of them. But it's clearly not the case for many as demonstrated on this forum where they routinely assume all matter of perversion & delusion to their motivations rather than accept gender identity is just another form of living as gender non conforming.

I’m not sure I agree because I think gender identity pushes harmful gender stereotypes - it just does it in a different way -but as I say, I don’t really care how people choose to frame their identities as long as they don’t use them to harm others which is all too common with transpeople these days, I’m afraid.

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 04:49

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:45

No, some of them literally do claim to be women with cervixes and periods somehow whole shebang

Yep & some religious nutters claim they are Jesus Christ but we don't go around claiming all religious people are nutters because of it.

I only have a problem

Sure, plenty of people limit their critique of trans people to conflicting rights, I'm one of them. But it's clearly not the case for many as demonstrated on this forum where they routinely assume all matter of perversion & delusion to their motivations rather than accept gender identity is just another form of living as gender non conforming.

What percentage of middle-aged men donning dresses and wigs do so for sexual gratification, do you think?

Give us your best guess.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:45

WatchingFellini · 02/11/2026 04:31

No, some of them literally do claim to be women with cervixes and periods somehow whole shebang.

I honestly have no problem with people being whatever gender they feel like because I personally think gender is bullshit in the same way religion is and people can believe what they want. I only have a problem when it affects women and children, so if transwomen could just accept that their gender identities do not grant them access to female sports and spaces, there’d be no issue for me and most GC people I know.

No, some of them literally do claim to be women with cervixes and periods somehow whole shebang

Yep & some religious nutters claim they are Jesus Christ but we don't go around claiming all religious people are nutters because of it.

I only have a problem

Sure, plenty of people limit their critique of trans people to conflicting rights, I'm one of them. But it's clearly not the case for many as demonstrated on this forum where they routinely assume all matter of perversion & delusion to their motivations rather than accept gender identity is just another form of living as gender non conforming.

WatchingFellini · 02/11/2026 04:31

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:21

Changing sex traits like morphology from hormones or surgery isn't the same as changing gametes. Trans people aren't claiming their gametes changed.

it begs the a question whey they think their gender should entitle them to opposite-sex spaces, sports and opportunities.

I never said it did. If an exemption from anti discrimination is justified under the grounds of a legitimate aim they are not.

No, some of them literally do claim to be women with cervixes and periods somehow whole shebang.

I honestly have no problem with people being whatever gender they feel like because I personally think gender is bullshit in the same way religion is and people can believe what they want. I only have a problem when it affects women and children, so if transwomen could just accept that their gender identities do not grant them access to female sports and spaces, there’d be no issue for me and most GC people I know.

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 04:26

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:11

You seem to have missed this bit:

"Nice try but individual instances don't speak for the majority."

In other words, what this individual's motivation is irrelevant.

It's not the individual that's significant. It's that you're standing behind him. You, and the majority of trans supporters who stand by those few individuals, are the real issue.

99.9999% of Muslims aren't terrorists. And 99.99% of Muslims call out those who are. Nobody - bupkes, zero, nada, not a single person in the trans community calls out the fetishists. You don't dare to, you can't afford to, you're structurally unable to. That's a problem. Prove me wrong. And when 99% of trans-identifying people do the same, we can talk.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:21

WatchingFellini · 02/11/2026 04:16

That’s not true of them all though, is it? Some of them literally do claim to have changed sex.

And of course, if you are correct, it begs the a question whey they think their gender should entitle them to opposite-sex spaces, sports and opportunities.

Changing sex traits like morphology from hormones or surgery isn't the same as changing gametes. Trans people aren't claiming their gametes changed.

it begs the a question whey they think their gender should entitle them to opposite-sex spaces, sports and opportunities.

I never said it did. If an exemption from anti discrimination is justified under the grounds of a legitimate aim they are not.