Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Kellie-Jay Keen (AKA Posie Parker) has been charged by the police under the Communications Act

503 replies

TERFandSWERF · 31/10/2026 15:02

https://x.com/wasacop/status/2116241544084619461?s=46&t=p6GESSn09HWHVXYgTLIbJg

“Kellie-Jay Keen has been charged under s.127 of the Communications Act 2003 over posts made between 23 and 25 June.

As ex-police, here's how it works:
• No victim needed
• No intent needed
• The offence is complete once the message is sent if a court finds it 'grossly offensive' (DPP v Collins [2006] UKHL 40)

That's a very low bar for a criminal charge over words.

But Chambers v DPP [2012] EWHC 2157 set a high bar for these cases, and Article 10 protects speech that offends, shocks or disturbs. A district judge decides on 4th December.

One to watch.”

WasAcop profile picture

WasAcop (@WasAcop) on X

Kellie-Jay Keen has been charged under s.127 of the Communications Act 2003 over posts made between 23 and 25 June. As ex-police, here's how it works: • No victim needed • No intent needed • The offence is complete once the message is sent if a court...

https://x.com/WasAcop/status/2116241544084619461?s=46&t=p6GESSn09HWHVXYgTLIbJg

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 14:26

Irkeddancer · 03/11/2026 14:24

Id rather you didn't tbh as you haven't made a single coherent point.

Suits me perfectly. I’ve made plenty of coherent points that other people have managed to parse, so that’s maybe something you can reflect on.

Irkeddancer · 03/11/2026 14:28

MyAmpleSheep · 03/11/2026 14:03

Regardless of whether it's a causal factor, cultural aspects can (and I'm sure are) still of benefit to detect and prevent this type of crime (and others.)

You don't have to be concerned whether CSA inside a church organisation is more or less common than anywhere else to for knowledge of the power structures inside the church to be helpful in fighting it.

Yes but if you had for example Protestant churches and catholic churches having high levels of CSE then wouldn't it be helpful to see which cultural aspect overlap as causal factors than someone trying to pinpoint it as more exclusive to catholic churches when th data doesn't show that?

Irkeddancer · 03/11/2026 14:31

Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 08:56

The data on perpetrator ethnicity is mostly not reliable either way. “The home office” has been involved in covering up the extent of these gangs for decades. And the population of the country is majority white, so it needs to be looked at as a per capita figure to make any kind of good faith argument. It’s not really all that relevant to recognising that thousands of vulnerable girls were brutalised by organised gangs in a particular pattern of offending.

This is where you decided to start making a point apparently but then you don't wanna provide any actual data for that point while resorting to likening me to an abuser simply for pointing out where people use words like disproportionate and overrepresented incorrectly. Someone's very keen to minimise discussion, and it isn't me or anyone else being factual.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 14:33

Hedgehogforshort · 03/11/2026 14:02

Because populations and ethnic groups are not spread out like butter, some minority groups cluster in specific areas of the country

Indeed. For eg Rotherham is a large town and it’s had a long lasting effect there. It’s highly relevant to people in those towns and cities where there was a disproportionate amount of offending of this nature.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 14:36

Irkeddancer · 03/11/2026 14:31

This is where you decided to start making a point apparently but then you don't wanna provide any actual data for that point while resorting to likening me to an abuser simply for pointing out where people use words like disproportionate and overrepresented incorrectly. Someone's very keen to minimise discussion, and it isn't me or anyone else being factual.

I didn’t at any point “liken you to an abuser”. I said you had an agenda. I’m sure you think you’re doing the right thing by obfuscating the discussion around this specific criminal phenomenon over many decades.

MyAmpleSheep · 03/11/2026 14:37

Irkeddancer · 03/11/2026 14:28

Yes but if you had for example Protestant churches and catholic churches having high levels of CSE then wouldn't it be helpful to see which cultural aspect overlap as causal factors than someone trying to pinpoint it as more exclusive to catholic churches when th data doesn't show that?

Who am "I" in your question and what's my role?

"someone trying to pinpoint it as more exclusive to catholic churches when th data doesn't show that?"

That's not a neutrally worded question, so I suspect you're trying to set a trap there.

Hedgehogforshort · 03/11/2026 14:38

Irkeddancer · 03/11/2026 14:26

purely because they bring their cultural values and behaviours with them.

I'm asking someone who makes tis point to tell me what the cultural values and behaviours of British society are that causes white British men to commit the majority of CSE and sexual crimes. If we're gonna talk about cultural values, surely it's helpful to see where British culture has this and where they overlap?

The same (or similar) values or attitudes to women, are shared between most perps. regardless of ethnicity.

The point is some incoming groups, do not know the laws that are supposed to protect women in the first place, and protections that do not exist in their country of origin.

Hence the leaflets handed out to “boat people” explaining what they cannot do with regards to women. Evidence in of itself, that authorities recognise this issue.

And as for some groups of men they only target white vulnerable girls, because they are seen as, “slags” of no consequence.

Irkeddancer · 03/11/2026 14:42

Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 14:33

Indeed. For eg Rotherham is a large town and it’s had a long lasting effect there. It’s highly relevant to people in those towns and cities where there was a disproportionate amount of offending of this nature.

You.Cannot.Take. Data. From. Localized. Clusters.And Mathematically. Extrapolate. It. To. Make. National per-capita statements about an entire ethnic demographic across the whole country. That's all and it's not that hard and I don't get why you are defending people making statistically unevidenced claims?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 14:56

Irkeddancer · 03/11/2026 14:42

You.Cannot.Take. Data. From. Localized. Clusters.And Mathematically. Extrapolate. It. To. Make. National per-capita statements about an entire ethnic demographic across the whole country. That's all and it's not that hard and I don't get why you are defending people making statistically unevidenced claims?

I have simply said that per capita is the only good faith way to examine the statistics. I don’t consider your claim that 70-80% of CSE is committed by white men overall to give much insight in a majority white country. Even less so in particular pockets of the country.

I’ve also been clear that the data available isn’t reliable as much of the perpetrator ethnicity information isn’t available. And I’m unmoved by your appeal to authority of “home office data”.

With all that said, I am not interested in the exact numbers, because you seem to think I’m making a claim I am not. I don’t know, or think it is necessarily relevant to the discussion whether per capita more rapists or CSE gangs are white, Pakistani, black or Somali.

I simply want to be free to discuss this specific criminal phenomenon in detail because I believe it’s important and it’s relevant to this specific thread, and most people don’t actually have that much knowledge about it, they’ve bought into left wing misinformation that there is nothing to see at all. It’s not a moral panic, it devastated and ruined the lives of thousands of vulnerable girls, many of whom have never had justice, and lots of people who were supposed to protect them colluded in brushing it under the carpet for a very long time, which is fucking shameful. It’s not the most important CSE, or the only important CSE. I didn’t make any claim that it was, but I still think it is something worth talking about without “but all men rape” whataboutery every five seconds.

hope that helps.

Hedgehogforshort · 03/11/2026 15:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Thisistyresome · 03/11/2026 15:17

It is a political prosecution. The government are trying to gat an "islamophobia" definition in as policy so this allows a test case.

The problem here is that the CPS believe there is (or should be) an Islamic blasphemy law, the courts keep telling them that this is not the case but they keep trying to establish one. This will be another attempt to get a win to create one. They will be facing an uphill struggle because the more the CPS try and do it the more the judiciary will get annoyed. The courts will want a change in law (which is what the government are trying to get the new definition to do).

GarlicNothing · 03/11/2026 15:19

Irkeddancer · 03/11/2026 13:04

No you linked headlines, I'm asking you to back up the stat you claimed that Pakistani men commit 10% or grooming crimes. It's a pretty firm stat so you would surely have evidence to it ? I've quoted the actual only data we have, which is evidenced.

I clicked each link in @oldtiredcyclist's 'headlines' post. They listed the names of convicted grooming gang members.

It was an eye-opener for me. I knew they were mostly Pakistani men, but hadn't realised quite what a huge majority were. The names are overwhelmingly SE Asian, with prevalence in Pakistan/Punjab.

These gangs abused hundreds of girls, thousands over the years. The men they were sold to did include white British men, and white men have dominated the CSA scandals related to religious and educational establishments. But it looks like the collaborative, systematic recruitment, rape and commercial sex trafficking of school-age girls is led by men of Pakistani heritage in the UK.

About 70% of British Pakistanis can trace their origin to the Mirpur district of Azad Kashmir (N. Pakistan), a self-governing, prosperous state whose violently patriarchal traditions persist among rural clans.

Shedmistress · 03/11/2026 15:20

Irkeddancer · 03/11/2026 14:42

You.Cannot.Take. Data. From. Localized. Clusters.And Mathematically. Extrapolate. It. To. Make. National per-capita statements about an entire ethnic demographic across the whole country. That's all and it's not that hard and I don't get why you are defending people making statistically unevidenced claims?

What if that data has been multiplied over say around 50 different large towns and cities? And was specific to these areas? And the actions of the councils, social workers and police also mapped across to those same towns and cities?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 15:27

Shedmistress · 03/11/2026 15:20

What if that data has been multiplied over say around 50 different large towns and cities? And was specific to these areas? And the actions of the councils, social workers and police also mapped across to those same towns and cities?

Well quite.

Irkeddancer · 05/11/2026 13:48

Shedmistress · 03/11/2026 15:20

What if that data has been multiplied over say around 50 different large towns and cities? And was specific to these areas? And the actions of the councils, social workers and police also mapped across to those same towns and cities?

Even if you aggregate 50 selected towns, that is still a targeted sample, not a national census or a comprehensive dataset. I thought women on here appreciated stats and research? I'm confused why many on this thread are anti data accuracy?

Irkeddancer · 05/11/2026 13:57

GarlicNothing · 03/11/2026 15:19

I clicked each link in @oldtiredcyclist's 'headlines' post. They listed the names of convicted grooming gang members.

It was an eye-opener for me. I knew they were mostly Pakistani men, but hadn't realised quite what a huge majority were. The names are overwhelmingly SE Asian, with prevalence in Pakistan/Punjab.

These gangs abused hundreds of girls, thousands over the years. The men they were sold to did include white British men, and white men have dominated the CSA scandals related to religious and educational establishments. But it looks like the collaborative, systematic recruitment, rape and commercial sex trafficking of school-age girls is led by men of Pakistani heritage in the UK.

About 70% of British Pakistanis can trace their origin to the Mirpur district of Azad Kashmir (N. Pakistan), a self-governing, prosperous state whose violently patriarchal traditions persist among rural clans.

A list of headlines isn't national per capita math though.Acknowledging high-profile cases isn't the issue here it's using them to make unevidenced demographic claims is. It's perfectly possible to say there are high profile cases without making a false point that Pakistani I mean are disproportionately represented per capita. If you're going to attribute abuse by Pakistani men to their regional ancestry, what is your cultural explanation for the majority of CSE offenders who are white men? Demanding structural explanations for one group while treating the majority as individual bad actors is a classic double standard, I'm not saying you're doing that but so far no on has answered my question for what the causal factor is for these crimes and whether they believe it's different for white men. I'm genuinely interested to hear. I think it's all patriachal violence because I don't think that's exclusive to one ethnicity.

Irkeddancer · 05/11/2026 14:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Data and statistics isn't trolling. Accusing someone of being a troll is against MN rules as well. I'm a long term poster of this board and have as much right to share my position as anyone else. Simply supplying facts has had be accused of :

  • darvo (which as a CSA survivor is quite alarming that facts makes me an abuser)
  • bare faced denial even though I'm literally talking about CSE as a whole and not denying any of its existence
  • now a troll and unpleasant

Despite no one actually being able to say why I'm wrong to point out people shouldn't post data misinformation. If someone's going to confidently claim something is overrepresented per capita, that's allowed to be corrected.

Irkeddancer · 05/11/2026 14:22

Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 14:36

I didn’t at any point “liken you to an abuser”. I said you had an agenda. I’m sure you think you’re doing the right thing by obfuscating the discussion around this specific criminal phenomenon over many decades.

You're well aware of the accusations you made and why MN deleted it. Shameful to resort to calling someone an abuser rather than engaging in the data if you take such an issue with people talking facts.

Irkeddancer · 05/11/2026 14:25

Hedgehogforshort · 03/11/2026 14:38

The same (or similar) values or attitudes to women, are shared between most perps. regardless of ethnicity.

The point is some incoming groups, do not know the laws that are supposed to protect women in the first place, and protections that do not exist in their country of origin.

Hence the leaflets handed out to “boat people” explaining what they cannot do with regards to women. Evidence in of itself, that authorities recognise this issue.

And as for some groups of men they only target white vulnerable girls, because they are seen as, “slags” of no consequence.

You missed then when the same advise was issued by the government to British men before being added to the leaflet for asylum seekers given. I also think your answer minimises how complex the evidence on these grooming gangs was, again it's not solely how these girls were viewed through a Pakistani ethnic lense, we have had a long existing problem in British culture where working class poor girls have also been viewed this way, hence are rarely protected by British peers either. It's not just because they're white, it's because we as a British society do not value or protect young girls especially not poor ones.

GarlicNothing · 05/11/2026 14:42

Irkeddancer · 05/11/2026 13:57

A list of headlines isn't national per capita math though.Acknowledging high-profile cases isn't the issue here it's using them to make unevidenced demographic claims is. It's perfectly possible to say there are high profile cases without making a false point that Pakistani I mean are disproportionately represented per capita. If you're going to attribute abuse by Pakistani men to their regional ancestry, what is your cultural explanation for the majority of CSE offenders who are white men? Demanding structural explanations for one group while treating the majority as individual bad actors is a classic double standard, I'm not saying you're doing that but so far no on has answered my question for what the causal factor is for these crimes and whether they believe it's different for white men. I'm genuinely interested to hear. I think it's all patriachal violence because I don't think that's exclusive to one ethnicity.

I think it's all patriarchal violence ...

Agreed.

I don't think that's exclusive to one ethnicity

Definitely not. The depth, breadth and intensity of expression varies by culture, though - or would you say Afghani and Finnish men share the same patriarchal values & behaviours, as a cultural generality?

It's a fallacy bordering on stupidity to ignore statistical trends and pattern recognition. Life cannot be lived on a purely case by case basis.

  • We teach girls to take more precautions against predatory men than we teach boys. This is because we know which groups (classes) of people pose a greater danger to whom.
  • The UK applies tight restrictions to male immigrants from Albania because we've got a problem with Albanian organised crime expansion.
  • If we're wise, we notice when men show excessive interest in children and are unusually tactile with them. This is because we recognise a pattern as indicative of potential risk.
  • We do this in all kinds of relationships, hence 'red flags'.
I'm not here to explore the types & causes of CSA with you, it's a big subject. Of course there are trends and patterns there as well.

I would say that, when men grow up in a society which devalues girls and women, legally favours the male, normalises the marriage of underage girls to much older men and despises people of a different religion, those men are more likely to rape girls of a different religion and to feel justified in doing so.

Not very long ago, upper class English men raped lower class English girls and boys quite freely. Society accepted this as their informal right - if anyone were to be blamed, the blame fell squarely on their victims. You can't ignore the effects of prevailing culture on the people within that culture.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 14:46

Irkeddancer · 05/11/2026 14:22

You're well aware of the accusations you made and why MN deleted it. Shameful to resort to calling someone an abuser rather than engaging in the data if you take such an issue with people talking facts.

You haven’t been the one talking facts, you’ve been repeating government spin.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 14:47

GarlicNothing · 05/11/2026 14:42

I think it's all patriarchal violence ...

Agreed.

I don't think that's exclusive to one ethnicity

Definitely not. The depth, breadth and intensity of expression varies by culture, though - or would you say Afghani and Finnish men share the same patriarchal values & behaviours, as a cultural generality?

It's a fallacy bordering on stupidity to ignore statistical trends and pattern recognition. Life cannot be lived on a purely case by case basis.

  • We teach girls to take more precautions against predatory men than we teach boys. This is because we know which groups (classes) of people pose a greater danger to whom.
  • The UK applies tight restrictions to male immigrants from Albania because we've got a problem with Albanian organised crime expansion.
  • If we're wise, we notice when men show excessive interest in children and are unusually tactile with them. This is because we recognise a pattern as indicative of potential risk.
  • We do this in all kinds of relationships, hence 'red flags'.
I'm not here to explore the types & causes of CSA with you, it's a big subject. Of course there are trends and patterns there as well.

I would say that, when men grow up in a society which devalues girls and women, legally favours the male, normalises the marriage of underage girls to much older men and despises people of a different religion, those men are more likely to rape girls of a different religion and to feel justified in doing so.

Not very long ago, upper class English men raped lower class English girls and boys quite freely. Society accepted this as their informal right - if anyone were to be blamed, the blame fell squarely on their victims. You can't ignore the effects of prevailing culture on the people within that culture.

Thank you, very well reasoned post.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 14:49

Irkeddancer · 05/11/2026 14:25

You missed then when the same advise was issued by the government to British men before being added to the leaflet for asylum seekers given. I also think your answer minimises how complex the evidence on these grooming gangs was, again it's not solely how these girls were viewed through a Pakistani ethnic lense, we have had a long existing problem in British culture where working class poor girls have also been viewed this way, hence are rarely protected by British peers either. It's not just because they're white, it's because we as a British society do not value or protect young girls especially not poor ones.

No one said it was “solely”. Stop putting words into people’s mouths.

NumberTheory · 05/11/2026 15:09

Irkeddancer · 05/11/2026 14:25

You missed then when the same advise was issued by the government to British men before being added to the leaflet for asylum seekers given. I also think your answer minimises how complex the evidence on these grooming gangs was, again it's not solely how these girls were viewed through a Pakistani ethnic lense, we have had a long existing problem in British culture where working class poor girls have also been viewed this way, hence are rarely protected by British peers either. It's not just because they're white, it's because we as a British society do not value or protect young girls especially not poor ones.

You missed then when the same advise was issued by the government to British men before being added to the leaflet for asylum seekers given.

I certainly missed this. When and how did that happen?

Irkeddancer · 05/11/2026 16:13

GarlicNothing · 05/11/2026 14:42

I think it's all patriarchal violence ...

Agreed.

I don't think that's exclusive to one ethnicity

Definitely not. The depth, breadth and intensity of expression varies by culture, though - or would you say Afghani and Finnish men share the same patriarchal values & behaviours, as a cultural generality?

It's a fallacy bordering on stupidity to ignore statistical trends and pattern recognition. Life cannot be lived on a purely case by case basis.

  • We teach girls to take more precautions against predatory men than we teach boys. This is because we know which groups (classes) of people pose a greater danger to whom.
  • The UK applies tight restrictions to male immigrants from Albania because we've got a problem with Albanian organised crime expansion.
  • If we're wise, we notice when men show excessive interest in children and are unusually tactile with them. This is because we recognise a pattern as indicative of potential risk.
  • We do this in all kinds of relationships, hence 'red flags'.
I'm not here to explore the types & causes of CSA with you, it's a big subject. Of course there are trends and patterns there as well.

I would say that, when men grow up in a society which devalues girls and women, legally favours the male, normalises the marriage of underage girls to much older men and despises people of a different religion, those men are more likely to rape girls of a different religion and to feel justified in doing so.

Not very long ago, upper class English men raped lower class English girls and boys quite freely. Society accepted this as their informal right - if anyone were to be blamed, the blame fell squarely on their victims. You can't ignore the effects of prevailing culture on the people within that culture.

I didn't say I'm ignoring it though I'm saying if we're looking at CSE then surely the helpful thing to focus on is the causal factors across all instances rather than focusing on ethnicity when none of the facts show ethnicity is a driving factor as you say yourself Britain has a long standing class, misogyny and rape culture problem, so why then is hyper focusing on the ethnicity of some offenders and then falsely stating they're disproportionately offenders (which is positioning their ethnicity as a causal factor) when actually it seems the patriachal cause behind abuse from all offenders is the same? And why is that a fallacy bordering on stupidity rather than you engaging in good faith instead of being insulting?

ETA: the reports into the cases many are referring to on this thread also made this exact point that it was also a largely classist and misogynist British culture that saw these girls as fair game and did not protect them hence the importance of talking about all the causes rather than pretending Pakistani and other ethnicities are bringing misogyny and rape culture here where it's existed for quote a long time.