Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Kellie-Jay Keen (AKA Posie Parker) has been charged by the police under the Communications Act

503 replies

TERFandSWERF · 31/10/2026 15:02

https://x.com/wasacop/status/2116241544084619461?s=46&t=p6GESSn09HWHVXYgTLIbJg

“Kellie-Jay Keen has been charged under s.127 of the Communications Act 2003 over posts made between 23 and 25 June.

As ex-police, here's how it works:
• No victim needed
• No intent needed
• The offence is complete once the message is sent if a court finds it 'grossly offensive' (DPP v Collins [2006] UKHL 40)

That's a very low bar for a criminal charge over words.

But Chambers v DPP [2012] EWHC 2157 set a high bar for these cases, and Article 10 protects speech that offends, shocks or disturbs. A district judge decides on 4th December.

One to watch.”

WasAcop profile picture

WasAcop (@WasAcop) on X

Kellie-Jay Keen has been charged under s.127 of the Communications Act 2003 over posts made between 23 and 25 June. As ex-police, here's how it works: • No victim needed • No intent needed • The offence is complete once the message is sent if a court...

https://x.com/WasAcop/status/2116241544084619461?s=46&t=p6GESSn09HWHVXYgTLIbJg

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Manxexile · 14/11/2026 23:36

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/11/2026 20:35

To sum up my views, the behaviour of the Pakistani Muslim individuals who committed these horrific crimes, is not compatible with our culture in the UK.To deny this, is like putting the blinkers on, so if enough people deny it, then the problem will never be solved and countless other young girls will be abused.

As a 50+yo British woman who has worked with victims of CSA, trafficking and grooming gangs I know it is completely compatible with the misogynist culture in the UK. Religious men, politicians, teachers, social workers, coaches, police officers, paramilitaries, organised criminals have been torturing and raping women with relative impunity in the UK for centuries at least.

Newcomers to these isles haven't invented new depravity, they're profiting from our own, home grown, embedded, systemic misogyny.

To deny this is blinkered and does nothing to keep women and girls safe. We could empty the country of Pakistani (or even all Muslim) origin tomorrow. Women and girls will still be trafficked, abused, exploited and killed come tomorrow night.

Because of men. Just men.🤷‍♀️. All the different types of men. And society's attitude to women and girls.

I wouldn't be at all surprised to learn that some British men behave as badly towards women as some Pakistani men do.

But I'm not sure that that would explain why on pretty much all recognised international standards Pakistan is a far more dangerous place for women than the UK is.

Why do you think that might be? (And please don't just say "Because of men. Just men. All the different types of men")

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/11/2026 21:39

GarlicNothing · 14/11/2026 21:01

That's unarguably true, @TooBigForMyBoots. It still doesn't invalidate concerns about specific groupings of men, who may be more likely to offend and/or offend more severely.

The entertainment industry in general, and specifically the comedic branch, is currently admitting to a serious sexual abuse problem. Do you feel the people now speaking up are wrong to say "There's a problem with men in comedy" because there's a problem with men everywhere? Or do you believe the women's (and some men's) depictions of an abusive, misogynistic culture existing with singular intensity in comedy circles?

To me, it doesn't make sense to say it's men everywhere so who cares about those men.

As to who those men are, specifically, who abuse more women or abuse them more intensely? We only have observation and testimony to go on. I wish the Home Office would collate and publish classifying data. I can see the risks in doing so; I also see potential benefits.

But it is men everywhere. Can you tell me of any group of men who don't abuse women?

The solution is not to look at those men, or them men. The solution is to come down like a tonne of bricks on all men. No demons, no sacred castes.

We need to make our country so intolerant and punitive of male abusers that our boys, men and visitors to the country fear what will happen if they commit offences against women and girls.

ArabellaScott · 14/11/2026 21:03

Maybe so, TooBig.

But the problem of police and courts avoiding dealing with people for fear of being called racist is a problem heaped upon the existing problem.

Nobody should be above the law, and nobody should be getting away with abuse.

GarlicNothing · 14/11/2026 21:01

That's unarguably true, @TooBigForMyBoots. It still doesn't invalidate concerns about specific groupings of men, who may be more likely to offend and/or offend more severely.

The entertainment industry in general, and specifically the comedic branch, is currently admitting to a serious sexual abuse problem. Do you feel the people now speaking up are wrong to say "There's a problem with men in comedy" because there's a problem with men everywhere? Or do you believe the women's (and some men's) depictions of an abusive, misogynistic culture existing with singular intensity in comedy circles?

To me, it doesn't make sense to say it's men everywhere so who cares about those men.

As to who those men are, specifically, who abuse more women or abuse them more intensely? We only have observation and testimony to go on. I wish the Home Office would collate and publish classifying data. I can see the risks in doing so; I also see potential benefits.

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/11/2026 20:35

oldtiredcyclist · 14/11/2026 19:42

As someone who has been married to an Iranian woman for thirty six years, we have had a lot of discussions about the UK grooming gangs and the demographic most associated with the perpetrators. She has told me, that life, living on the Iranian borders with Pakistan and Afghanistan is very dangerous for young women and girls, particularly given that most Iranians are Shia and most Pakistanis and Afghans are Sunni. The cultures are totally different. We can see how the behaviour of men towards women, depends very much on where you grew up. The Mujahideen and the later Taliban all went to religious schools called Madrassas in Northern Pakistan. The place where Osama Bin Laden was discovered and killed, Abbotabad, is in North Eastern Pakistan, less than 200 kilometres from the Afghan border.
If anyone thinks that the regime in Iran is evil (which I do), then they should look at how women are treated in Afghanistan and Pakistan, they may then see, why so many Pakistani, Muslim men in this country were involved in grooming gangs, who targeted young, white British girls were doing so for a reason. Some independent reviews and reports noted that certain offenders operated under misogynistic or honor- and shame-based mindsets that viewed non-Muslim or white working-class girls as socially marginalized, unprotected, or of lesser value.
To sum up my views, the behaviour of the Pakistani Muslim individuals who committed these horrific crimes, is not compatible with our culture in the UK.
To deny this, is like putting the blinkers on, so if enough people deny it, then the problem will never be solved and countless other young girls will be abused.

To sum up my views, the behaviour of the Pakistani Muslim individuals who committed these horrific crimes, is not compatible with our culture in the UK.To deny this, is like putting the blinkers on, so if enough people deny it, then the problem will never be solved and countless other young girls will be abused.

As a 50+yo British woman who has worked with victims of CSA, trafficking and grooming gangs I know it is completely compatible with the misogynist culture in the UK. Religious men, politicians, teachers, social workers, coaches, police officers, paramilitaries, organised criminals have been torturing and raping women with relative impunity in the UK for centuries at least.

Newcomers to these isles haven't invented new depravity, they're profiting from our own, home grown, embedded, systemic misogyny.

To deny this is blinkered and does nothing to keep women and girls safe. We could empty the country of Pakistani (or even all Muslim) origin tomorrow. Women and girls will still be trafficked, abused, exploited and killed come tomorrow night.

Because of men. Just men.🤷‍♀️. All the different types of men. And society's attitude to women and girls.

oldtiredcyclist · 14/11/2026 19:42

Manxexile · 14/11/2026 17:53

"... but you're going to need to say what you think that specific problem is because so far the only suggestion has been that their ethnicity has a specific patriachal violence which doesn't actually add up when white British culture clearly also had a patriachal violence problem which people don't seem to want to look in the eye and deal with..."

I don't know if there is a specific problem or cause.

But my understanding is that if you look at those countries where women are most and least safe, than Pakistan regularly ranks as one of the least safe in the world whereas the UK tends to rank as one of the more safe.

Here for instance Pakistan ranks 169th out of 181 countries as being safe for women whereas the UK ranks 23rd. Women's Safety Index 2026: 181 Countries Ranked | Safety Index

I'm not convinced any attempted comparison between British patriarchal violence and that of an entirely different ethnicity is either useful or valid

As someone who has been married to an Iranian woman for thirty six years, we have had a lot of discussions about the UK grooming gangs and the demographic most associated with the perpetrators. She has told me, that life, living on the Iranian borders with Pakistan and Afghanistan is very dangerous for young women and girls, particularly given that most Iranians are Shia and most Pakistanis and Afghans are Sunni. The cultures are totally different. We can see how the behaviour of men towards women, depends very much on where you grew up. The Mujahideen and the later Taliban all went to religious schools called Madrassas in Northern Pakistan. The place where Osama Bin Laden was discovered and killed, Abbotabad, is in North Eastern Pakistan, less than 200 kilometres from the Afghan border.
If anyone thinks that the regime in Iran is evil (which I do), then they should look at how women are treated in Afghanistan and Pakistan, they may then see, why so many Pakistani, Muslim men in this country were involved in grooming gangs, who targeted young, white British girls were doing so for a reason. Some independent reviews and reports noted that certain offenders operated under misogynistic or honor- and shame-based mindsets that viewed non-Muslim or white working-class girls as socially marginalized, unprotected, or of lesser value.
To sum up my views, the behaviour of the Pakistani Muslim individuals who committed these horrific crimes, is not compatible with our culture in the UK.
To deny this, is like putting the blinkers on, so if enough people deny it, then the problem will never be solved and countless other young girls will be abused.

ArabellaScott · 14/11/2026 18:02

Walkden · 13/11/2026 15:22

"So? She didn’t make it up"

The trail was in 2007 and the retrial collapsed due to thr police hiding evidence. The Ipcc conducted an inquiry with numerous officers disciplined and the defendents conpensated.

Unfortunately the real killers are still at large

She knows there is no factual evidence/ proof for the claim the poor girl was butchered for kebabs but i guess it's good for engagement and rage baiting.

She's happy to propogate the rumour, regardless of how it might affect the girls surviving family members , if it gets her clicks, likes, revenue etc

Edited

It's a heartbreaking story. I wish someone would look into it further and try to do something to right the wrongs done to that poor child and her family.

Manxexile · 14/11/2026 17:53

Irkeddancer · 13/11/2026 15:22

Name it then, What's happened is people not wanting to say exactly what they think is the specific problem and cause of Muslim or Pakistani rapists Vs the majority that aren't. The difference is we are able to talk about and evidence the problems with the Catholic church because people can list and evidence the specifics that allowed, encouraged and covered up abuse in the Catholic church. You can talk all you want about th specific problem or Muslim rapists but you're going to need to say what you think that specific problem is because so far the only suggestion has been that their ethnicity has a specific patriachal violence which doesn't actually add up when white British culture clearly also had a patriachal violence problem which people don't seem to want to look in the eye and deal with. Could you name the specific problem causing Muslim rapists and how to deal with it?

"... but you're going to need to say what you think that specific problem is because so far the only suggestion has been that their ethnicity has a specific patriachal violence which doesn't actually add up when white British culture clearly also had a patriachal violence problem which people don't seem to want to look in the eye and deal with..."

I don't know if there is a specific problem or cause.

But my understanding is that if you look at those countries where women are most and least safe, than Pakistan regularly ranks as one of the least safe in the world whereas the UK tends to rank as one of the more safe.

Here for instance Pakistan ranks 169th out of 181 countries as being safe for women whereas the UK ranks 23rd. Women's Safety Index 2026: 181 Countries Ranked | Safety Index

I'm not convinced any attempted comparison between British patriarchal violence and that of an entirely different ethnicity is either useful or valid

Women's Safety Index 2026: How 181 Countries Rank for Women

Denmark ranks first and Afghanistan last. Explore the 2025/26 WPS Index on an interactive map, compare countries and see the 2026 global gender gap.

https://safetyindex.net/womensafetyindex.html

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/11/2026 23:44

LouisTheYardTeacher · 13/11/2026 16:58

I wouldn't argue vehemently that she was. I would just argue vehemently that no one should be arrested for saying she was.

Exactly. This is after all the point.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/11/2026 23:44

RoyalCorgi · 13/11/2026 16:52

You can talk all you want about th specific problem or Muslim rapists but you're going to need to say what you think that specific problem is

Why? Why is it my job? Why don't you ask the men themselves why they think it's OK to rape teenage girls?

Indeed.

Walkden · 13/11/2026 17:08

A local journatlist spent 3 years looking into this interviewing the family etc. she had to this to say about it

"She said: "If my investigation for this podcast achieves anything, I hope it brings an end to this false and damaging narrative. Not just because it's a lie, but because a missing 14-year-old girl, a victim of child sexual abuse, deserves more than being reduced to a piece of meat in a headline."

So im not sumpathetic to someone peddling this harmful narrative for clicks and engagement, which she most likely knows to be false, whilst claiming its because she cares about women and girls

LouisTheYardTeacher · 13/11/2026 16:58

Walkden · 13/11/2026 15:37

"Not engaging further with this because it’s pointless. It’s still quite plausible that Charlene was murdered"

I would go so far as to say its very probable she was murdered; just not necessarily by the men accused if doing so.

Its highly highly improbable that her body was used to make kebab

Its difficult to believe that people on this thread argue vehemently she was bit it just cant be proved.

I wouldn't argue vehemently that she was. I would just argue vehemently that no one should be arrested for saying she was.

RoyalCorgi · 13/11/2026 16:52

You can talk all you want about th specific problem or Muslim rapists but you're going to need to say what you think that specific problem is

Why? Why is it my job? Why don't you ask the men themselves why they think it's OK to rape teenage girls?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/11/2026 15:49

British comedy culture has a problem with sexual assault and harassment of women and girls? “Yeah, but there’s no point looking at the common factors because most rapists aren’t comedians.” That’s what you sound like.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/11/2026 15:45

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 17:10

I’m going to explain, again, for the benefit of the thread why I think it’s important to consider the common factors in the grooming gangs culture which was when gangs of mostly Pakistani men, who were often related to each other or who had clan links, preyed on vulnerable, mostly white girls. If this was the other way round, it’s quite likely it would meet the definition of racist hate crime.

As a common feature of these crimes, in a pattern which has endured for decades and across different mostly urban areas, and by all accounts is still ongoing, mostly working class teenage and often tween girls were groomed by young Pakistani men acting as “boyfriends”. They gave the girls presents, took them for drives in their cars (often taxis), and enabled them to smoke and drink alcohol, in exchange for sex.

Following this the girls were conditioned to accept and submit to greater levels of sexual brutality and exploitation, and trafficked to other often considerably much older men, including white men.

As vulnerable children lots of people in the public sector had a duty of care to these girls. A very few tried to help. Some likely actively colluded. Most turned a blind eye. The fact that the men were Pakistani and the girls were considered no better than they should be, ie white slags, by all concerned including the rapists themselves, the police, social services, teachers and council officials, meant that no one was going to risk their salary or pension to put their neck on the line, even if they cared, which most of these people did not. And so thousands of girls were brutally raped, otherwise assaulted, evidence suggests that some were trafficked abroad even, and a few were murdered. And these crimes all had certain commonalities that no one really thought should be discussed, so it was largely handwaved away or disappeared into the wider statistics for years. Which I think is a bad thing. Other people presumably see it differently.

So that’s why I would like to put those girls first, not some misguided sense of political correctness that it’s an inconvenient conversation. That sense is fuelling the far right, and it’s not helping. These conversations need to be had, without prejudice and with full scrutiny of how this was allowed to happen, and covered up for so long.

For anyone who wants to understand, I recommend the recent Casey report, the one she carried out in 2015 into Rotherham Council, and the work of Maggie Oliver. I’d also recommend reading some survivor stories to understand the level of brutality against children we are talking about, because many people aren’t particularly well informed about this issue, which is hardly surprising when people insinuate that you’re a racist or far right just for wanting to discuss it.

Obviously needs bumping again because I certainly did point out why I thought the Pakistani grooming/rape gangs flourished without getting in to which race is more likely to rape. So I don’t need to engage with anyone’s straw men.

Walkden · 13/11/2026 15:37

"Not engaging further with this because it’s pointless. It’s still quite plausible that Charlene was murdered"

I would go so far as to say its very probable she was murdered; just not necessarily by the men accused if doing so.

Its highly highly improbable that her body was used to make kebab

Its difficult to believe that people on this thread argue vehemently she was bit it just cant be proved.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/11/2026 15:34

Irkeddancer · 13/11/2026 15:22

Name it then, What's happened is people not wanting to say exactly what they think is the specific problem and cause of Muslim or Pakistani rapists Vs the majority that aren't. The difference is we are able to talk about and evidence the problems with the Catholic church because people can list and evidence the specifics that allowed, encouraged and covered up abuse in the Catholic church. You can talk all you want about th specific problem or Muslim rapists but you're going to need to say what you think that specific problem is because so far the only suggestion has been that their ethnicity has a specific patriachal violence which doesn't actually add up when white British culture clearly also had a patriachal violence problem which people don't seem to want to look in the eye and deal with. Could you name the specific problem causing Muslim rapists and how to deal with it?

No one needs to say this because as repeatedly pointed out, it’s your straw man. People are allowed to talk about this specific crime phenomenon as a pattern of crime. The end.

MyAmpleSheep · 13/11/2026 15:33

Irkeddancer · 13/11/2026 15:22

Name it then, What's happened is people not wanting to say exactly what they think is the specific problem and cause of Muslim or Pakistani rapists Vs the majority that aren't. The difference is we are able to talk about and evidence the problems with the Catholic church because people can list and evidence the specifics that allowed, encouraged and covered up abuse in the Catholic church. You can talk all you want about th specific problem or Muslim rapists but you're going to need to say what you think that specific problem is because so far the only suggestion has been that their ethnicity has a specific patriachal violence which doesn't actually add up when white British culture clearly also had a patriachal violence problem which people don't seem to want to look in the eye and deal with. Could you name the specific problem causing Muslim rapists and how to deal with it?

Am I wrong to think that some strands of Islam (and Islamic jurisprudence) - some strands, clearly not all - have a very different standard of bodily autonomy and consent for women than modern "British" culture?

I don't think this causes rape, but is it possibly a factor to consider?

Walkden · 13/11/2026 15:32

"A confession, the recordings about knowing where the grave is then combined with the attitude expressed in the joke is all evidence"

Pwrhaps i should refer you to what lancashire police's position is.:

"The evidence around the covert material that was relied upon in court has been fatally undermined and is not accurate, is not truthful," senior investigating officer Det Supt Gareth Willis told Thorp. "We all acknowledge evidence does not exist. It's been reviewed independently, and what was documented as being fact is, in fact, not true."

Courts

Read every news story, live report, and update on Courts. Stay up to date with full coverage from Lancs Live.

https://www.lancs.live/all-about/courts

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/11/2026 15:30

Not engaging further with this because it’s pointless. It’s still quite plausible that Charlene was murdered.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/11/2026 15:28

The case collapsed because the police were shite. There is evidence, as pp pointed out.

Walkden · 13/11/2026 15:22

"So? She didn’t make it up"

The trail was in 2007 and the retrial collapsed due to thr police hiding evidence. The Ipcc conducted an inquiry with numerous officers disciplined and the defendents conpensated.

Unfortunately the real killers are still at large

She knows there is no factual evidence/ proof for the claim the poor girl was butchered for kebabs but i guess it's good for engagement and rage baiting.

She's happy to propogate the rumour, regardless of how it might affect the girls surviving family members , if it gets her clicks, likes, revenue etc

Irkeddancer · 13/11/2026 15:22

RoyalCorgi · 13/11/2026 10:04

When we talk about crime, it's important to be able to talk about demography. Imagine, for example, if we weren't allowed to point out that 98% of sexual offences against children are committed by men.

Or imagine if we couldn't mention that football hooliganism (a huge problem a few decades ago) was largely, though not exclusively, the preserve of young white working-class men.

Or take another example from a few years ago: Catholic priests abusing children. Abuse of children by religious leaders wasn't, and isn't, unique to the Catholic Church, but the scale of the abuse over a number of years, and the extent of the cover-up, did demonstrate that the Catholic Church had a particular problem in this regard. If we couldn't have mentioned that the Catholic Church had a worse record than other churches, how could we ever have hoped to tackle the problem?

People who are anti-racist like to deflect from the grooming gang problem by pointing out that plenty of child abusers are white males, and sometimes those males form their own gangs. That is true. But by refusing to acknowledge the specific problem of gangs from Muslim communities raping and torturing young girls, they are doing an enormous disservice to those girls. To address a problem, you have to be able to look it squarely in the eye and name it.

Name it then, What's happened is people not wanting to say exactly what they think is the specific problem and cause of Muslim or Pakistani rapists Vs the majority that aren't. The difference is we are able to talk about and evidence the problems with the Catholic church because people can list and evidence the specifics that allowed, encouraged and covered up abuse in the Catholic church. You can talk all you want about th specific problem or Muslim rapists but you're going to need to say what you think that specific problem is because so far the only suggestion has been that their ethnicity has a specific patriachal violence which doesn't actually add up when white British culture clearly also had a patriachal violence problem which people don't seem to want to look in the eye and deal with. Could you name the specific problem causing Muslim rapists and how to deal with it?

Thisistyresome · 13/11/2026 15:17

Walkden · 13/11/2026 14:53

"Again you don't understand the English language."

I say again there is no Credible evidence.

A statement that someone was allegedly joking about someone being turned into kebabs is evidence that his humour has extremely poor taste.

It is not credible evidence that he actually butchered someone and turned their body into kebab meat, and wasnt wden credible evidence that they killed her at all

Edited

Funny how you skip most of the evidence and focus on the joke.

A confession, the recordings about knowing where the grave is then combined with the attitude expressed in the joke is all evidence. It is not proof to the criminal standard but that is not the same as the evidence not being credible.