Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Australian documentary: Who decides?

158 replies

CassOle · 30/10/2026 19:37

https://whodecidesfilm.com/

"WHO DECIDES? is a feature documentary exploring the growing national conversation in Australia surrounding the participation of transgender women in female-only spaces, alongside broader questions relating to education, healthcare and public policy.

As these issues increasingly move from sporting fields and schools into courtrooms, government inquiries and parliamentary debate, the film looks beyond the headlines to examine how competing rights, public policy and lived experience intersect. Through interviews with people holding a range of perspectives, alongside those directly affected, experts, advocates, journalists, legal professionals and policymakers, WHO DECIDES? seeks to foster a thoughtful exploration of one of Australia's most contested public conversations."

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:07

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:53

Why don't you wait until you see the film before you pass judgement.

The clips said it all. And mark my words, no major TV stations will touch it when they see its just another Rupert project.

The right know the they have zero credibility when it comes to affordability in this country that's why they have to rely on scapegoating immigrants, women, trans & indigenous people to get any motion with what remains of their only hope: ignorant bigots.

“another Rupert project”

Great, you know who made it, please link us up with who has produced it?

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:05

JellySaurus · 31/10/2026 08:44

Since when does ‘egalitarian’ mean not being allowed to ask questions or consider other perspectives?

Egalitarian =/= No Debate

Sal Grover has had her bogus grifting claims on blast on all the major media outlets in Australia for years now so that's hardly 'no debate'.

'No debate' is more in the realm of British billionaires who weaponise defamation law via law far a la Trump to censor legitimate criticism.

JellySaurus · 31/10/2026 09:04

teawamutu · 31/10/2026 08:52

A brand new MNer! Let's have a game to celebrate.

You’ve omitted Whataboutery, Women haven’t lost any rights, Outdated, Never Happens, Nobody Cares, and Introduce Irrelevancies. Most of which our new TRA has already ticked.

naffogato · 31/10/2026 09:03

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:19

Because as a GENUINE FEMINIST I'm not stupid enough to fall for a manufactured astro turfed moral panic designed to enable the ascension of right wing governments who give buggar all about women's rights.

As for women's rights what rights? There are no rights at risk given special exemptions exist for natal women under the anti discrimination act.

And what's absolutely galling is how this manufactured top down grievance that involves 0.5% of trans women has centred itself as the women's right's calamity of our time that effectively silences via its media saturation REAL problems like the epidemic level of domestic & sexual violence women face in this country.

So don't think for one second the women of Australia are going to give this colonialist victorian clap trap a second thought because we live in the real world where trans people are the least of our problems hence ZERO interest in this beat up at the grass roots level regardless of the political funding.

No. You are not a feminist if you cede what belongs to women to men masquerading as us. Putting it in caps doesn’t make it true.

women had to fight long and hard for our rights. Men still get 95% of the funding and sponsorship for sports. Why should women give what little we have gained to mediocre cheating men?

transwomen are part of the epidemic of male sexual violence against women. It’s the same issue. Incarceration rates in prisons show that 70% of transwomen in prison are there for sexual offences. A rate that is many times higher than their fellow men. Allowing transwomen into female spaces makes the sexual assault epidemic worse for women.

SchoolOfCool · 31/10/2026 09:02

StealthTroublemaker · 31/10/2026 06:48

It does look very interesting. I do think it’s odd how women saying no to mixed sex spaces is considered “anti-trans”. Surely that would suggest there is a clash of demands at the very least.

It is a view that basically admits that boundary violation is inherent to a trans identity. Which it isn't, but fuck knows the mainstream iteration of trans ideology likes to push that it is.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:01

LouisTheYardTeacher · 31/10/2026 08:39

@Fairgo What we've had in the UK is a gradual process of the arguments for and against gender ideology being aired and publicly debated, and inevitably over time the GC side has gained support and the gender ideology side has lost it. I expect the same process will happen in Aus over the next few years.

Don't kid yourself. A favourable bogus court ruling is no broad grass roots campaign.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 08:57

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 08:26

@Fairgo - I didn't say anger, I said fear, and I didn't pay attention to your AI slop post.

There are plenty of women in your country raising the matters you're so concern with, but they're being hamper by the fact that there's no such category as women in Aus any more, thanks to the actions of Gillard when she was at the very TOP.

This thread isn't about VAWAG, your whataboutery is just an attempt to deflect from the topic at hand because you have no arguments to back up the genderwang you're so devoted too.

Edited

"There are plenty of women in your country raising the matters you're so concern with, but they're being hamper by the fact that there's no such category as women in Aus any more, thanks to the actions of Gillard when she was at the very TOP."

Perhaps if you bothered to read my 'AI slop' or anything regarding Australian laws you would know there are no legitimate matters to raise since exemptions ALREADY EXIST for natal women. That female only networking apps don't qualify for an exemption understandably for anyone with a working brain which was Giggle's idiotic claim.

And no, shouting 'genderwang' is not a substantive argument hence the gender critical movement not gaining any ground in Australia. But do keep up the 'gender wanging' defence its working a treat!

teawamutu · 31/10/2026 08:52

A brand new MNer! Let's have a game to celebrate.

Australian documentary: Who decides?
sanluca · 31/10/2026 08:51

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:47

Well they already have in Europe, Scandinavia, Canada, Asia, half of the US states & Australia with their not giving a shit energy.

No grass roots, no change.

Sorry to burst your bubble but in Europe the TWAW is certainly not a done deal. The focus is less on toilets though, and more on sports, healthcare, prisons and changing rooms.

My government still tries to treat it as isolated incidents, led by a gay prime minister who is very 'protect the dolls' and is 'expecting' a baby by surrogacy. That alone probably says enough

JellySaurus · 31/10/2026 08:44

Fairgo · 30/10/2026 22:08

You can tell from the promo this is a heavily biased video masquerading as 'just asking questions' given that 99% of the clips are pushing an anti trans narrative.

Looks like the latest desperate attempt to get a grass roots anti trans movement going in Australia where none exists despite their many well funded media campaigns to do so. It will be forever a lost cause in Australia as we don't have the same anti egalitarian cultural influences as the UK does.

Since when does ‘egalitarian’ mean not being allowed to ask questions or consider other perspectives?

Egalitarian =/= No Debate

LouisTheYardTeacher · 31/10/2026 08:39

@Fairgo What we've had in the UK is a gradual process of the arguments for and against gender ideology being aired and publicly debated, and inevitably over time the GC side has gained support and the gender ideology side has lost it. I expect the same process will happen in Aus over the next few years.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 08:26

@Fairgo - I didn't say anger, I said fear, and I didn't pay attention to your AI slop post.

There are plenty of women in your country raising the matters you're so concern with, but they're being hamper by the fact that there's no such category as women in Aus any more, thanks to the actions of Gillard when she was at the very TOP.

This thread isn't about VAWAG, your whataboutery is just an attempt to deflect from the topic at hand because you have no arguments to back up the genderwang you're so devoted too.

StealthTroublemaker · 31/10/2026 08:24

So @fairgo, we have women saying letting males into their spaces makes them uncomfortable and unsafe. You say they’re overreacting. Can you explain how making all spaces mixed sex makes women safer and what material benefit women receive from doing so? You seem very sure that women asserting their rights to single sex spaces is “anti-trans”, but then that shows there is a conflict. Why do you believe the feelings and wishes of a TIM to access a female space trump the feelings and wishes of a woman who needs a single sex space?

do you believe that TIF should not use any female space but only male spaces? Will this be safe for them? You seem to not mention them at all….

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 08:15

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 08:09

Then why the fear, why the aggression, apart from the fact that gender idiots are permanently set on the 'bullying and shout down' setting, why are you so afraid of one little film, paid for by the proverbial 'far-right', who no one pays annnny attention to.

Why the anger? Why ask something that you aren't interested in? I already told you:

"And what's absolutely galling is how this manufactured top down grievance that involves 0.5% of trans women has centred itself as the women's right's calamity of our time that effectively silences via its media saturation REAL problems like the epidemic level of domestic & sexual violence women face in this country."

That you don't believe domestic & sexual violence epidemics is anything to be 'angry' about shows exactly the sincerity with which your interest in women's rights are.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 31/10/2026 08:10

Another men's rights activist on MN berating women for not privileging men performing female stereotypes ahead of actual women

how original!

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 08:09

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:47

Well they already have in Europe, Scandinavia, Canada, Asia, half of the US states & Australia with their not giving a shit energy.

No grass roots, no change.

Then why the fear, why the aggression, apart from the fact that gender idiots are permanently set on the 'bullying and shout down' setting, why are you so afraid of one little film, paid for by the proverbial 'far-right', who no one pays annnny attention to.

BusyExpert · 31/10/2026 08:08

That rather stupid response demonstrates the enormous chip on your shoulder says everything I need to know about your ability to think and the fantasy world you live in

sad

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:55

BusyExpert · 31/10/2026 07:52

No sweetheart they haven’t decided. In the UK trans”women” are being firmly put back in their box. Any woman that supports this rubbish cannot call themselves a feminist.

Sorry to blow your British supremacy bubble but that ship where anyone gave a shit what an empire in steep regression thinks sailed long ago.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:53

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 07:43

Oh look another AI Garbageteer, it started with Nietzsche - German, it was misappropriated by Foucault - French and then spewed forth by Butler - American. Aus has been re-colonised by stealth, you're now part of the Post-Modern Global blob, there nothing authentic about you and the 'anti-women feminist's' of Aus.
Why don't you wait until you see the film before you pass judgement.

Why don't you wait until you see the film before you pass judgement.

The clips said it all. And mark my words, no major TV stations will touch it when they see its just another Rupert project.

The right know the they have zero credibility when it comes to affordability in this country that's why they have to rely on scapegoating immigrants, women, trans & indigenous people to get any motion with what remains of their only hope: ignorant bigots.

BusyExpert · 31/10/2026 07:52

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:47

Well they already have in Europe, Scandinavia, Canada, Asia, half of the US states & Australia with their not giving a shit energy.

No grass roots, no change.

No sweetheart they haven’t decided. In the UK trans”women” are being firmly put back in their box. Any woman that supports this rubbish cannot call themselves a feminist.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:47

BusyExpert · 31/10/2026 07:44

Pointless discussion. There is only one group that can decide about the inclusion of men in frocks to a woman’s arena and that is women.

and the majority don’t want them

Well they already have in Europe, Scandinavia, Canada, Asia, half of the US states & Australia with their not giving a shit energy.

No grass roots, no change.

BusyExpert · 31/10/2026 07:44

Pointless discussion. There is only one group that can decide about the inclusion of men in frocks to a woman’s arena and that is women.

and the majority don’t want them

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 07:43

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:19

Because as a GENUINE FEMINIST I'm not stupid enough to fall for a manufactured astro turfed moral panic designed to enable the ascension of right wing governments who give buggar all about women's rights.

As for women's rights what rights? There are no rights at risk given special exemptions exist for natal women under the anti discrimination act.

And what's absolutely galling is how this manufactured top down grievance that involves 0.5% of trans women has centred itself as the women's right's calamity of our time that effectively silences via its media saturation REAL problems like the epidemic level of domestic & sexual violence women face in this country.

So don't think for one second the women of Australia are going to give this colonialist victorian clap trap a second thought because we live in the real world where trans people are the least of our problems hence ZERO interest in this beat up at the grass roots level regardless of the political funding.

Oh look another AI Garbageteer, it started with Nietzsche - German, it was misappropriated by Foucault - French and then spewed forth by Butler - American. Aus has been re-colonised by stealth, you're now part of the Post-Modern Global blob, there nothing authentic about you and the 'anti-women feminist's' of Aus.
Why don't you wait until you see the film before you pass judgement.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:36

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 07:30

You can tell from the promo this is a heavily biased video masquerading as 'just asking questions' given that 99% of the clips are pushing an anti trans narrative.

The first person on the clip is a 'trans', there was footage of Tickle and the narration referred to him as 'she' so any suggestion that it's 'anti-trans' is hysterical hyperbole. The remarks sounds like a last disparate attempt to keep 'No Debate' alive, it may turn out in the full version that the 'trans' narrative falls apart but that's not because it's biased, it's because the 'trans' narrative is a load of shite. As Kevin said the Overton Window has moved and it's shifted back to where it should be.

Men are not women, and sorry Kev but you're not a man.

I was also wondering if it was going to be shown nationwide on TV or is just going to be on line.

It's only one token trans woman with the rest being the usual Murdoch right wing shill suspects in the clip. Maybe if you knew anything about Australian politics you would know that, Grahaaam.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 07:30

You can tell from the promo this is a heavily biased video masquerading as 'just asking questions' given that 99% of the clips are pushing an anti trans narrative.

The first person on the clip is a 'trans', there was footage of Tickle and the narration referred to him as 'she' so any suggestion that it's 'anti-trans' is hysterical hyperbole. The remarks sounds like a last disparate attempt to keep 'No Debate' alive, it may turn out in the full version that the 'trans' narrative falls apart but that's not because it's biased, it's because the 'trans' narrative is a load of shite. As Kevin said the Overton Window has moved and it's shifted back to where it should be.

Men are not women, and sorry Kev but you're not a man.

I was also wondering if it was going to be shown nationwide on TV or is just going to be on line.