Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Australian documentary: Who decides?

158 replies

CassOle · 30/10/2026 19:37

https://whodecidesfilm.com/

"WHO DECIDES? is a feature documentary exploring the growing national conversation in Australia surrounding the participation of transgender women in female-only spaces, alongside broader questions relating to education, healthcare and public policy.

As these issues increasingly move from sporting fields and schools into courtrooms, government inquiries and parliamentary debate, the film looks beyond the headlines to examine how competing rights, public policy and lived experience intersect. Through interviews with people holding a range of perspectives, alongside those directly affected, experts, advocates, journalists, legal professionals and policymakers, WHO DECIDES? seeks to foster a thoughtful exploration of one of Australia's most contested public conversations."

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:47

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:36

“And what's absolutely galling is how this manufactured top down grievance that involves 0.5% of trans women”

I think you might find that the issue of excluding male people from female single sex provisions involves excluding 100% of those male people with transgender identities.

It would be absolutely pointless to think that the issue only involved 0.5% of them.

The point is the 100% is only 0.5% of the population.And for those very bad at maths means they barely exist.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:44

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:32

I see.

So you have no information and you are just slinging shit at the wall to see what sticks. You are just making assumptions based on your own prejudiced biases.

And howse that working? Because so far if you read back your posts are incoherent and I am wondering if you are ok.

The clip has mostly Rupert shillers who are regulars on sky channel shovelling the right wing agit prop. That you don't know who they are makes you 'unqualified' to comment.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:43

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:14

I don't have to the usual sky Rupert suspects on it speaks for it self.

“I don't have to the usual sky Rupert suspects on it speaks for it self.”

equals

this poster doesn’t have to have any evidence to spread misinformation. Meanwhile, the flurry of activity pushes this thread to appear in active so more women know that the film is coming.

Wishesandhorses · 31/10/2026 09:41

LouisTheYardTeacher · 31/10/2026 08:39

@Fairgo What we've had in the UK is a gradual process of the arguments for and against gender ideology being aired and publicly debated, and inevitably over time the GC side has gained support and the gender ideology side has lost it. I expect the same process will happen in Aus over the next few years.

This.

It's interesting that the pattern is always the same.

It begins with the belief that this is right and fine and will cause no problems.

It begins to break down as many difficulties and problems arise for women. Discussions such as this one start about 'balance of needs', and raising that the issues exist.

The court cases start where women's difficulties or experiences are so severe they have to once again fight for previously established rights because this has obviously not worked for all women, particularly less privileged and more vulnerable groups of women. The law recognises women's equality of need and impact which is not compatible with the wishes of men and activists. (Those wishes are always that those needs and impacts just be ignored and rejected with anger at incompatible issues for women even being mentioned. Spot the binary sexism present.)

The law and boundaries shift back to protecting women, and establish that men with gender identities can have their own resources and facilities and needs met, but cannot simply join the sex class of women in all things - because it effectively removes the needed provisions, safety and protections from the sex class of women. And it is reluctantly but definitely confirmed that in some things sex matters, and cannot be subordinated to gender.

Always the same flow.

The sad thing activists can never see, is that it started from their utopia, and good will, and their desired outcome being embraced and it didn't work. They would merely like the not working for women part to carry on without anyone minding about it or wanting equality or better outcomes for women.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:39

NowSober · 31/10/2026 09:30

Perhaps if you bothered to read my 'AI slop' or anything regarding Australian laws you would know there are no legitimate matters to raise since exemptions ALREADY EXIST for natal women. That female only networking apps don't qualify for an exemption understandably for anyone with a working brain which was Giggle's idiotic claim.

If exemptions ALREADY EXIST for natal women why don't they exist for lesbian networking apps?

Because 'app access' aren't considered a legitimate aim for obvious reasons.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:38

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 08:57

"There are plenty of women in your country raising the matters you're so concern with, but they're being hamper by the fact that there's no such category as women in Aus any more, thanks to the actions of Gillard when she was at the very TOP."

Perhaps if you bothered to read my 'AI slop' or anything regarding Australian laws you would know there are no legitimate matters to raise since exemptions ALREADY EXIST for natal women. That female only networking apps don't qualify for an exemption understandably for anyone with a working brain which was Giggle's idiotic claim.

And no, shouting 'genderwang' is not a substantive argument hence the gender critical movement not gaining any ground in Australia. But do keep up the 'gender wanging' defence its working a treat!

How’d that work out for the lesbian group?

If there was an ability to exclude male people, why did they have to go to court in the first place? And remind us again, did they win the ability to meet with out male people ?

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:38

AudHvamm · 31/10/2026 09:27

How do I get my GENUINE FEMINIST accreditation? Do I have to present evidence of years of service? Is there a written exam?

Clue:

Banging on incessantly about your personal hyper disgust sensitivities regarding 0.5% of the population as if they were an existential threat to civilisation as we know it ain't it.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:36

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:19

Because as a GENUINE FEMINIST I'm not stupid enough to fall for a manufactured astro turfed moral panic designed to enable the ascension of right wing governments who give buggar all about women's rights.

As for women's rights what rights? There are no rights at risk given special exemptions exist for natal women under the anti discrimination act.

And what's absolutely galling is how this manufactured top down grievance that involves 0.5% of trans women has centred itself as the women's right's calamity of our time that effectively silences via its media saturation REAL problems like the epidemic level of domestic & sexual violence women face in this country.

So don't think for one second the women of Australia are going to give this colonialist victorian clap trap a second thought because we live in the real world where trans people are the least of our problems hence ZERO interest in this beat up at the grass roots level regardless of the political funding.

“And what's absolutely galling is how this manufactured top down grievance that involves 0.5% of trans women”

I think you might find that the issue of excluding male people from female single sex provisions involves excluding 100% of those male people with transgender identities.

It would be absolutely pointless to think that the issue only involved 0.5% of them.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:35

PriOn1 · 31/10/2026 09:25

And why come on here to argue with (mostly) UK women if the whole thing is a non-event and not worth thinking about. Something doesn’t add up…

Why correct misinformation/disinformation that harms people? Seriously?

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:32

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:14

I don't have to the usual sky Rupert suspects on it speaks for it self.

I see.

So you have no information and you are just slinging shit at the wall to see what sticks. You are just making assumptions based on your own prejudiced biases.

And howse that working? Because so far if you read back your posts are incoherent and I am wondering if you are ok.

NowSober · 31/10/2026 09:30

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 08:57

"There are plenty of women in your country raising the matters you're so concern with, but they're being hamper by the fact that there's no such category as women in Aus any more, thanks to the actions of Gillard when she was at the very TOP."

Perhaps if you bothered to read my 'AI slop' or anything regarding Australian laws you would know there are no legitimate matters to raise since exemptions ALREADY EXIST for natal women. That female only networking apps don't qualify for an exemption understandably for anyone with a working brain which was Giggle's idiotic claim.

And no, shouting 'genderwang' is not a substantive argument hence the gender critical movement not gaining any ground in Australia. But do keep up the 'gender wanging' defence its working a treat!

Perhaps if you bothered to read my 'AI slop' or anything regarding Australian laws you would know there are no legitimate matters to raise since exemptions ALREADY EXIST for natal women. That female only networking apps don't qualify for an exemption understandably for anyone with a working brain which was Giggle's idiotic claim.

If exemptions ALREADY EXIST for natal women why don't they exist for lesbian networking apps?

Keeptoiletssafe · 31/10/2026 09:30

There’s a bit of confusion at the moment about new builds because it appears Canberra has stated 50% of toilets should be unisex. That will be a huge social experiment because self contained, private toilets aren’t as safe or healthy as standard designs of separate sex toilet washrooms.

I scanned over the Australian documents and there’s no realisation on the impact of how design affects the cost, cleanliness, number of pathogens, drug use and overdoses, vandalism, survival rate if someone collapses or sexual or other assault rate, closure rate due to misuse.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:30

AudHvamm · 31/10/2026 09:27

How do I get my GENUINE FEMINIST accreditation? Do I have to present evidence of years of service? Is there a written exam?

I think you need it printed on a shirt in huge letters.

Screamingabdabz · 31/10/2026 09:29

GENUINE FEMINIST

Wow. You just really can’t debate against such entrenched delusion and blindness.

AudHvamm · 31/10/2026 09:27

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:19

Because as a GENUINE FEMINIST I'm not stupid enough to fall for a manufactured astro turfed moral panic designed to enable the ascension of right wing governments who give buggar all about women's rights.

As for women's rights what rights? There are no rights at risk given special exemptions exist for natal women under the anti discrimination act.

And what's absolutely galling is how this manufactured top down grievance that involves 0.5% of trans women has centred itself as the women's right's calamity of our time that effectively silences via its media saturation REAL problems like the epidemic level of domestic & sexual violence women face in this country.

So don't think for one second the women of Australia are going to give this colonialist victorian clap trap a second thought because we live in the real world where trans people are the least of our problems hence ZERO interest in this beat up at the grass roots level regardless of the political funding.

How do I get my GENUINE FEMINIST accreditation? Do I have to present evidence of years of service? Is there a written exam?

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:27

Just in case anyone has missed this UK doco or wants to rewatch it in prep for next week‘s launch here is the link

https://adulthumanfemale.info/wp/

Of course, there are threads on MN about the protests that blocked the showing of the doco in Edinburgh at the Uni. How male people intimidated and blocked female people from watching it together.

https://archive.is/guKEW

All because feminists rejected that male people should be included in female single sex provisions and made a documentary about it.

No doubt, the Australian doco would be similarly protested if the location for the launch gets leaked.

ADH – My WordPress Blog

https://adulthumanfemale.info/wp/

PriOn1 · 31/10/2026 09:25

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 08:09

Then why the fear, why the aggression, apart from the fact that gender idiots are permanently set on the 'bullying and shout down' setting, why are you so afraid of one little film, paid for by the proverbial 'far-right', who no one pays annnny attention to.

And why come on here to argue with (mostly) UK women if the whole thing is a non-event and not worth thinking about. Something doesn’t add up…

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:22

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:12

Howse that argument about Sal Grover being a grifter working for you? Convincing many people?

The great thing about focusing on her is that people go and see for themselves what is happening. The Streisand effect is a bit of an own goal in that respect.

Howse it working in Australia? Its not & even grifter Grover will tell you that with her incessant crying that no one is listening. To be fair it must be frustrating to think your only meal ticket isn't being cashed in by the Australian public. Oh well maybe she can go back to Hollywood chasing fame & fortune there again with another bogus 'business model'.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:15

naffogato · 31/10/2026 09:07

For women Scotland are the grass roots organisation that brought the Scottish government to court to clarify the equality act. The fightback against gender ideology has been individual women coming together to fight.

A fringe group who got a favourable leg up by the courts is hardly a broad grass roots movement.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:14

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:07

“another Rupert project”

Great, you know who made it, please link us up with who has produced it?

I don't have to the usual sky Rupert suspects on it speaks for it self.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:12

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:05

Sal Grover has had her bogus grifting claims on blast on all the major media outlets in Australia for years now so that's hardly 'no debate'.

'No debate' is more in the realm of British billionaires who weaponise defamation law via law far a la Trump to censor legitimate criticism.

Howse that argument about Sal Grover being a grifter working for you? Convincing many people?

The great thing about focusing on her is that people go and see for themselves what is happening. The Streisand effect is a bit of an own goal in that respect.

naffogato · 31/10/2026 09:10

LouisTheYardTeacher · 31/10/2026 08:39

@Fairgo What we've had in the UK is a gradual process of the arguments for and against gender ideology being aired and publicly debated, and inevitably over time the GC side has gained support and the gender ideology side has lost it. I expect the same process will happen in Aus over the next few years.

Exactly. The gender ideology side know their nonsense does not stand up to any questioning which is why they try so hard to stop women speaking

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:08

Are all capitals the new italics now?

naffogato · 31/10/2026 09:07

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:01

Don't kid yourself. A favourable bogus court ruling is no broad grass roots campaign.

For women Scotland are the grass roots organisation that brought the Scottish government to court to clarify the equality act. The fightback against gender ideology has been individual women coming together to fight.

JellySaurus · 31/10/2026 09:07

SchoolOfCool · 31/10/2026 09:02

It is a view that basically admits that boundary violation is inherent to a trans identity. Which it isn't, but fuck knows the mainstream iteration of trans ideology likes to push that it is.

AGP? All those photos men take of themselves in women’s toilets? Male doctors on record saying they would perform intimate examinations in female patients who had requested a female doctor? Male teachers wearing massive fake breasts at work?